I have to agree that it would easier for me to list who is still Catholic than who is not. Let’s see: In our current family group, my husband, adult daughter, 2 grandkids, and me.
My aunt, who takes the function of my mother for a variety of reasons, was baptized Catholic, is petrified of the thought that I make frequent use of the Sacrament of Reconciliation (she only went once, to her first confession, where the priest asked her to stay after. She didn’t, and never went back), and currently believes in a sort of reincarnation that resembles more best practices for garbage recycling. Her husband is a lapsed Lutheran but great guy and avid golfer (I’ve heard some consider golfing a faith). My cousin-sisters are lapsed. One is a widow who had her now teenager baptized, but did nothing about it. One simply allowed her children to grow so they could choose their faith later, with the usual results from that.
As for my family of birth- My mother practices a form of Catholicism where her method is the only right method, but it changes with her whims. For decades, my father made fun of her insistence we attend Catholic school, missed our sacraments, etc. (You do NOT want to hear the tale of my Confirmation!) He has since returned to the Church. The two of them now seem to use the Church as a stick to beat people, usually their siblings and children, grandchildren, etc. For example, I do not fit Mom’s definition of a good Catholic. I obtained a divorce after marrying a man with Mom pushing me. I also obtained an anullment, and married a wonderful man who adopted my two children and raised them as his own. He is partially of Italian extraction, and I did not, at age 32, ask my father’s permission to marry. She gets upset when I go to a family ceremony involving Mass and receive our Lord, as I am allegedly a “fallen” woman. This does not apply to my thrice-divorced and yet married again younger sister. (See, I told you it was their own form.) It took me a long time to realize that there was more methodology of Catholic than the various rites, as in Byzantine and Latin, and Mom’s was not the only Latin rite.
I have six sibs. All were raised Catholic. One is Lutheran, and seems to be the only sincere Christian in the bunch. The rest are Catholic when they have milestones in their lives.
I figure, we’re it. We are what people see as Catholic. Fortunately, the two types of Catholic, the censuring and what I humbly hope is the loving, show up in sharp contrast. Aside from praying and setting a good example without being a shrew about it, I don’t know what else I can do or want to do, except be ready for the possible time when questions are asked. And those questions get asked every so often. I hope my answers are soft enough but yet informative.