C
chevalier
Guest
As the Grand Master of the Most Brooding and Grumpy Order of Old Bachelors, I feel the duty incumbent on me to offer a sound volume of succinct clarification.
So here it goes.
Standing by your feelings, including the unrequited ones, is an important part of your human experience and it seems to me everyone has the right to have his feelings respected. From this follows that a woman should have this right of hers respected as well and shouldn’t be deny it. I think if she wants to take the chance and pronounce her feelings, aware of the consequences, everyone should respect it.
In a normal situation, however, I’m not a fan of the idea of women chasing men and it doesn’t sit well with me. I don’t like the idea of a woman asking a man out and trying to wear the breeches.
However, similarly as in #1, I don’t believe that a woman should not be allowed to pay for herself if she insists. Paying for a date is kindness, it is not a matter of justice and women cannot expect it as their due. This is the beautiful part of courtesy and chivalry: doing things which are honourable and which justice inspires and suggests, but no law mandates. This generally means that it should always be taken as a kindness and never as the payment of a rightful debt, which among other results means a “thank you” is generally due unless extreme courtesy is taken as a matter-of-course (in a given situation not saying “thank you” is equal to implying “I would expect no less of you” and speaks volumes in its silence). Here it follows that should a way show some exceptional kindness or favour, it should be respected.
It is generally plainly rude to make a scene about who pays, anyway. Being a gentleman does not allow making scenes.
One of the beautiful points of etiquette is all the things you do with it once you know how and once you, well, do. Examples include, “so are you going to ask me to dance or not?” said in a gentle and slightly amused (in a good way) tone. This is not mandatory, of course, because courage is required more of men than of women, and in the case of a woman, this takes a slightly heroic overtone. Eowyn would be proud.
I’ve seen tons of examples in literature and even in real life, how favour can be shown in a dignified way. For example if a lady took your glass and poured your drink, it spoke volumes about affection or some form of respect and yet it wasn’t demeaning to her and didn’t imply romance, strictly speaking, either. An example I remember from real life, was a young girl taking a sip from her friend’s cup. Just don’t take it any perverted way.
Initiating a conversation could be both well taken and well understood. And no, it is not demeaning to a self-respecting woman. It is only demeaning if it has other reasons to be unflattering. Showing genuine interest in meeting up is not demeaning either. In fact, it’s quite refreshing and is probably taken much better than haughty indifference by the reasonable men.
Also, very much of the appreciation is shown by appreciation of certain specific acts of kindness a man does, especially those which are not popular, no longer done, which put particularly a young and a shy man at risk of being regarded as not quite normal by his peers. I’ve seen some examples and it needs to be said that appreciating an act of kindness has never demeaned anybody. A gentleman may even be motivated by lack of appreciation because it creates a certain “against everything” reflex, but no one likes being treated badly. At this point I heartily recommend to aspiring ladies and gentlemen reading Schiller’s *The Glove *(poetry-archive.com/s/the_glove.html).
Obviously, revenge is always bad, even if it limits itself to sulking, but there are limits to what one can take.
This said, I reiterate the initial statement that the man should do the pursuing. It is somewhat unbecoming of a woman to do it the way some men do (which seems fine for them), but this doesn’t mean that it’s unbecoming in each and every case. It depends how it’s done. However, encouragement would be a better instrument, I suppose, although I also stand by the other initial statement that being true to oneself is a right and should be respected. If a woman wants to take some flak for staying true to her feelings, possibly shaming a guy or two in the process, at some point you’ve got to allow her.
So here it goes.
Standing by your feelings, including the unrequited ones, is an important part of your human experience and it seems to me everyone has the right to have his feelings respected. From this follows that a woman should have this right of hers respected as well and shouldn’t be deny it. I think if she wants to take the chance and pronounce her feelings, aware of the consequences, everyone should respect it.
In a normal situation, however, I’m not a fan of the idea of women chasing men and it doesn’t sit well with me. I don’t like the idea of a woman asking a man out and trying to wear the breeches.
However, similarly as in #1, I don’t believe that a woman should not be allowed to pay for herself if she insists. Paying for a date is kindness, it is not a matter of justice and women cannot expect it as their due. This is the beautiful part of courtesy and chivalry: doing things which are honourable and which justice inspires and suggests, but no law mandates. This generally means that it should always be taken as a kindness and never as the payment of a rightful debt, which among other results means a “thank you” is generally due unless extreme courtesy is taken as a matter-of-course (in a given situation not saying “thank you” is equal to implying “I would expect no less of you” and speaks volumes in its silence). Here it follows that should a way show some exceptional kindness or favour, it should be respected.
It is generally plainly rude to make a scene about who pays, anyway. Being a gentleman does not allow making scenes.
One of the beautiful points of etiquette is all the things you do with it once you know how and once you, well, do. Examples include, “so are you going to ask me to dance or not?” said in a gentle and slightly amused (in a good way) tone. This is not mandatory, of course, because courage is required more of men than of women, and in the case of a woman, this takes a slightly heroic overtone. Eowyn would be proud.
I’ve seen tons of examples in literature and even in real life, how favour can be shown in a dignified way. For example if a lady took your glass and poured your drink, it spoke volumes about affection or some form of respect and yet it wasn’t demeaning to her and didn’t imply romance, strictly speaking, either. An example I remember from real life, was a young girl taking a sip from her friend’s cup. Just don’t take it any perverted way.
Initiating a conversation could be both well taken and well understood. And no, it is not demeaning to a self-respecting woman. It is only demeaning if it has other reasons to be unflattering. Showing genuine interest in meeting up is not demeaning either. In fact, it’s quite refreshing and is probably taken much better than haughty indifference by the reasonable men.
Also, very much of the appreciation is shown by appreciation of certain specific acts of kindness a man does, especially those which are not popular, no longer done, which put particularly a young and a shy man at risk of being regarded as not quite normal by his peers. I’ve seen some examples and it needs to be said that appreciating an act of kindness has never demeaned anybody. A gentleman may even be motivated by lack of appreciation because it creates a certain “against everything” reflex, but no one likes being treated badly. At this point I heartily recommend to aspiring ladies and gentlemen reading Schiller’s *The Glove *(poetry-archive.com/s/the_glove.html).
This said, I reiterate the initial statement that the man should do the pursuing. It is somewhat unbecoming of a woman to do it the way some men do (which seems fine for them), but this doesn’t mean that it’s unbecoming in each and every case. It depends how it’s done. However, encouragement would be a better instrument, I suppose, although I also stand by the other initial statement that being true to oneself is a right and should be respected. If a woman wants to take some flak for staying true to her feelings, possibly shaming a guy or two in the process, at some point you’ve got to allow her.