Who will pay for the wall?

  • Thread starter Thread starter HCTC
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I don’t think they fell for it, they had no qualms about us paying for it.
I think it was aimed more at the Dems
 
But arguing that Mexico needs to send us a check for the money or Trump was lying is disingenuous. It is simply taking advantage of the basic ignorance of most Democrats to paint a picture that casts Trump as a liar.
Well, in reality Trump did TRY to get Mexico to pay for the wall, and he failed - remember? So maybe he’s more of a loser than a liar when it comes to Mexico paying for the wall.



WASHINGTON — Throughout the campaign, Donald Trump revved up supporters with a vow to build a border wall and force Mexico to pay for it. The promise deeply offended Mexicans, and in a testy phone call shortly after taking office, Trump all but begged his Mexican counterpart to stop embarrassing him by publicly refusing to give in to the demand.
“I have to have Mexico pay for the wall — I have to,” the president told President Enrique Peña Nieto. “I have been talking about it for a two-year period.”

The Washington Post obtained transcripts of that Jan. 27 call and another friction-filled conversation the next day between Trump and Australian Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull. The Post published the bombshells Thursday morning.

Peña Nieto: "My position has been and will continue to be very firm saying that Mexico cannot pay for that wall."Trump: “But you cannot say that to the press. … I cannot live with that.”
 
Last edited:
I know he modified what he said.
He didn’t modify it. He explained the actual policy agenda that would achieve the slogan.

Now admittedly I kust skimmed the speech, but as far as I can tell, this is the only mention of the wall:
I would build a great wall, and nobody builds walls better than me, believe me, and I’ll build them very inexpensively, I will build a great, great wall on our southern border. And I will have Mexico pay for that wall.
Nowhere did he say that Mexico was going to send us a check for the cost of the wall. In fact, earlier in the speech he said this:
But I wouldn’t even waste my time with this one. I would call up the head of Ford, who I know. If I was president, I’d say, “Congratulations. I understand that you’re building a nice $2.5 billion car factory in Mexico and that you’re going to take your cars and sell them to the United States zero tax, just flow them across the border.”

And you say to yourself, “How does that help us,” right? “How does that help us? Where is that good”? It’s not.

So I would say, “Congratulations. That’s the good news. Let me give you the bad news. Every car and every truck and every part manufactured in this plant that comes across the border, we’re going to charge you a 35-percent tax, and that tax is going to be paid simultaneously with the transaction, and that’s it.
Which seems to lend credence to the idea that the wall would be ‘paid for’ by policy changes. This was later confirmed during one of the GOP primary debates when Trump explained it would be paid for using means including tariffs, trade deals, and possibly confiscating remittances. In fact, he explicitly said Mexico would probably not send us a check, so we’d get it from them another way.

It is taking advantage of 1) Democrats who don’t know what he actually said, and 2) Low information voters who don’t understand the complicated plan.

At no point did Trump ever say or imply that Mexico would willingly fund the wall with straight cash.
 
Last edited:
Well, in reality Trump did TRY to get Mexico to pay for the wall, and he failed - remember?
No, I don’t remember that because that isn’t what happened.
  1. You have a transcript that was already accused of being doctored.
  2. At no point is he even alleged to have said: I’m not going to get Mexico to pay for the wall. At best you have an allegation that he asked the Mexican President to stop saying he wasn’t going to pay for it.
  3. Like I said before, this is simply taking advantage of basic ignorance. It’s very dishonest.
 
It is taking advantage of 1) Democrats who don’t know what he actually said, and 2) Low information voters who don’t understand the complicated plan.

At no point did Trump ever say or imply that Mexico would willingly fund the wall with straight cash.
It’s a wedge issue, they can’t let it go no matter the actual circumstances. They will just continue to push a soundbite and call him a liar.

Conversely, his supports would call him a liar if border security is not radically enhanced, be it by fence, brick, or drone (they don’t care about the construction materials, they understand Dems will fight funding options)
 
It’s a wedge issue, they can’t let it go no matter the actual circumstances. They will just continue to push a soundbite and call him a liar.
What part of “And Mexico is going to pay for it” is difficult to understand?
 
What part of “And Mexico is going to pay for it” is difficult to understand?
The verbal gymnastics being used here by Trump supporters to say he meant something different is worthy of an Olympic event.
 
The verbal gymnastics being used here by Trump supporters to say he meant something different is worthy of an Olympic event.
If you distill it down, he said he would strengthen border security and reduce illegal immigration. While he should be dinged for not following all his strategy points, he will fundamentally be measured against the main objective.
 
If you distill it down, he said he would strengthen border security and reduce illegal immigration. While he should be dinged for not following all his strategy points, he will fundamentally be measured against the main objective.
What do I need to distill down? He said that he would build a wall and Mexico would pay for it. There is nothing about that to be distilled down.
 
40.png
Jig_Saw:
The verbal gymnastics being used here by Trump supporters to say he meant something different is worthy of an Olympic event.
If you distill it down, he said he would strengthen border security and reduce illegal immigration. While he should be dinged for not following all his strategy points, he will fundamentally be measured against the main objective.
By “distill”, you mean pretty much ignore his actual words and come up with new ones that aren’t quite so absurd.
 
By “distill”, you mean pretty much ignore his actual words and come up with new ones that aren’t quite so absurd.
Well, that and then claim that’s what he meant all along and anyone who didn’t see it that way from day one clearly is being stupid.
 
I find it easy to spot the people here who have spent their career in the public sector, where technicalities matter more than getting actual results.
 
What part of “And Mexico is going to pay for it” is difficult to understand?
They will pay for it. Trump never said it would be paid for with a check from Mexico
The verbal gymnastics being used here by Trump supporters to say he meant something different is worthy of an Olympic event.
Except he literally said this was how he was going to pay for it before he even became the Republican nominee. No interpretation required.
 
Well, that and then claim that’s what he meant all along and anyone who didn’t see it that way from day one clearly is being stupid.
Trump is a master of obfuscation - “the obscuring of the intended meaning of communication by making the message difficult to understand, usually with confusing and ambiguous language.” What’s truly sad is that now members of Congress are adapting to Trump by becoming skilled in obfuscation themselves so as to be able to maneuver the meaning of anything they say in order to survive the shifting political sands at the WH.

That being said - “I’m gonna build a big, beautiful wall, and Mexico is going to pay for it” is crystal clear.
 
I find it easy to spot the people here who have spent their career in the public sector, where technicalities matter more than getting actual results.
I wouldn’t call who is paying for a multi-billion dollar project a mere technicality. If a business offers me something for free and then tries to make me pay for it, then that is not a technicality, that is fraud.
 
In his tweets today he keeps capitalizing the word “Wall”. I kept thinking I was seeing a reference to Pink Floyd.
 
Last edited:
He didn’t modify it. He explained the actual policy agenda that would achieve the slogan.
Tomato, Tomah-to. Saying something different is the very definition of modifying.

Besides, the idea that Mexico (not Mexican companies) will pay for it is deception. Furthermore, the idea that these companies will be the source of the revenue because if he decides to start a tariff war, is flat out ignorant. There is a reason we do not engage in unfair trade practices and tariff wars. The consumer always ends up paying, the cost of living goes up, and standard of living goes down.

Even most kids know there is no such thing as a free lunch. The magic wall fairy will not avail us.
 
I find it easy to spot the people here who have spent their career in the public sector, where technicalities matter more than getting actual results.
By technicalities, do you mean language? Yes, I prefer intelligence over ignorance. I found it gets better results more often. And no, results are not everything. That is utilitarianism. A dishonest business man can, and usually does, “get results” though his workers and investors my suffer, when he cheats them, doesn’t pay them, have failed businesses, etc.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top