Why are Traditional leaning guys so weird (insecure?) around women!

  • Thread starter Thread starter Malon101
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Malon101

Guest
I’ve just noticed this after moving to the south that guys do not know how to act around women who don’t follow the more Traditional ‘mother with babies’ mold. Are women SUPPOSED to be stupid/ditsy/obsessed with fashion/makeup/looks in order to be a woman? I’m beginning to feel that that is the definition of what makes a woman sometimes, by being around these type of men. When you don’t act like that they give you weird looks, and think you’re being ‘rebellious’. It’s not fair for women to have to lower their IQ by 40 points to be ‘normal’. It seems I can’t smile and be friendly to a guy without them thinking you’re hitting on them, never mind being congenial - they refuse to acknowledge you at the same level. I only find this with traditional leaning, perhaps Southern guys. Guys from the north or more liberal seem to be fine interacting with girls like me. Even international students don’t act like this… What do you do with these type of guys???
 
Hmm, what kind of guys do you meet?

I’ve met a lot of Southern conservative type guys and none of them had that weird insecurity.

I don’t think there is anything you can do about how they behave but you can start picking and choosing who you want to spend your time with. But even if meeting these types of guys is inevitable, such as in the workplace, you can choose to not let this type of foolishness to affect you. I know, easier said than done.
 
I’ve just noticed this after moving to the south that guys do not know how to act around women who don’t follow the more Traditional ‘mother with babies’ mold. Are women SUPPOSED to be stupid/ditsy/obsessed with fashion/makeup/looks in order to be a woman? I’m beginning to feel that that is the definition of what makes a woman sometimes, by being around these type of men. When you don’t act like that they give you weird looks, and think you’re being ‘rebellious’. It’s not fair for women to have to lower their IQ by 40 points to be ‘normal’. It seems I can’t smile and be friendly to a guy without them thinking you’re hitting on them, never mind being congenial - they refuse to acknowledge you at the same level. I only find this with traditional leaning, perhaps Southern guys. Guys from the north or more liberal seem to be fine interacting with girls like me. Even international students don’t act like this… What do you do with these type of guys???
Never have noticed what you seem to classify all Traditional guys having in personality traits.🤷 Perhaps you need to broaden your scope.
 
I grew up in the south. I fell in love with a typical southern fraternity guy and I never had these problems that you speak of. Most Yankees that I have been around, men and women, usually just assume I’m stupid because I’m from the south. 🤷
 
I’ve just noticed this after moving to the south that guys do not know how to act around women who don’t follow the more Traditional ‘mother with babies’ mold. Are women SUPPOSED to be stupid/ditsy/obsessed with fashion/makeup/looks in order to be a woman? I’m beginning to feel that that is the definition of what makes a woman sometimes, by being around these type of men. When you don’t act like that they give you weird looks, and think you’re being ‘rebellious’. It’s not fair for women to have to lower their IQ by 40 points to be ‘normal’. It seems I can’t smile and be friendly to a guy without them thinking you’re hitting on them, never mind being congenial - they refuse to acknowledge you at the same level. I only find this with traditional leaning, perhaps Southern guys. Guys from the north or more liberal seem to be fine interacting with girls like me. Even international students don’t act like this… What do you do with these type of guys???
Hmmm, depends on your definition of “traditional.”

If by “traditional” you mean traditional Catholic men who are closely associated with the Tridentine Mass, the answer is different–let me know and I’ll answer that question. I assume you mean more Southern guys in general, though.

I moved to the South when I was 18. I actually had to have a manager sit down and explain this to me because I honestly didn’t understand it. Yankee (I use the term fondly) customs are different. 😉

It’s not the intelligence or the career. There’s a tradition here of women being charming, friendly, and bubbly, at least by yankee standards. Yankee introverts like yours’ truly ahem have an even harder time with this. 😉

In my normal interactions, I was polite–almost too formally so by Southern standards–but I didn’t smile very often or very warmly. Why? Because the way I had been brought up was to be somewhat more reserved, which is typical, especially on the northeast coast. There, smiling and being as engaging as the “typical” southern woman is is seen as socially pushy, and kind of boundary-crossing. (This is very hard to describe to someone who hasn’t lived in both places, but I’m taking a stab at it.) As a result, a lot of my coworkers assumed that I had a very bad attitude all the time, even though I didn’t and I generally liked them. I had to learn to smile more and be more effusive in order to work better with customers, and this translated over to life in general.

Again, it really isn’t the career or your intelligence, at least not for most of the guys. It’s that not acting a certain way isn’t expected, and is like you’re speaking a foreign language, except it’s a body language rather than a verbal one.

PS–Also, my accent didn’t help. Because I spoke more formally, with fairly precise northeast-coast diction and without the Southern vowels or contractions, I appeared even more “snooty,” for lack of a better term, when that was combined with my body language. Eventually my accent has softened a bit, plus I learned how better to interact with people here, and those who I worked with for any length of time eventually learned that I didn’t mean to sound or act at all snobby, but that I’d grown up a certain way and was still learning how to integrate a bit more into the South. 😉

PPS–None of this is to sound denigrating to either culture; I love both! I’m just trying to explain my experiences with this and why the OP might be picking up the vibes that she’s getting.
 
I’ve just noticed this after moving to the south that guys do not know how to act around women who don’t follow the more Traditional ‘mother with babies’ mold. Are women SUPPOSED to be stupid/ditsy/obsessed with fashion/makeup/looks in order to be a woman? I’m beginning to feel that that is the definition of what makes a woman sometimes, by being around these type of men. When you don’t act like that they give you weird looks, and think you’re being ‘rebellious’. It’s not fair for women to have to lower their IQ by 40 points to be ‘normal’. It seems I can’t smile and be friendly to a guy without them thinking you’re hitting on them, never mind being congenial - they refuse to acknowledge you at the same level. I only find this with traditional leaning, perhaps Southern guys. Guys from the north or more liberal seem to be fine interacting with girls like me. Even international students don’t act like this… What do you do with these type of guys???
What do you mean by " traditional? " Your scenario seems to be a little off since Southern men marry at least as often as Nothern men. I think you are just moving in the wrong circles.

Pax
Linus2nd
 
I’ve just noticed this after moving to the south that guys do not know how to act around women who don’t follow the more Traditional ‘mother with babies’ mold. Are women SUPPOSED to be stupid/ditsy/obsessed with fashion/makeup/looks in order to be a woman? I’m beginning to feel that that is the definition of what makes a woman sometimes, by being around these type of men. When you don’t act like that they give you weird looks, and think you’re being ‘rebellious’. It’s not fair for women to have to lower their IQ by 40 points to be ‘normal’. It seems I can’t smile and be friendly to a guy without them thinking you’re hitting on them, never mind being congenial - they refuse to acknowledge you at the same level. I only find this with traditional leaning, perhaps Southern guys. Guys from the north or more liberal seem to be fine interacting with girls like me. Even international students don’t act like this… What do you do with these type of guys???
That does seem odd. Do they actually use the term ‘rebellious’? Against what would you be rebelling, exactly?
 
There’s a tradition here of women being charming, friendly, and bubbly, at least by yankee standards. Yankee introverts like yours’ truly ahem have an even harder time with this. ;).
What’s so hard about being called ‘doll baby’, sugar and/or honey’? I moved from NY to the south. It sure didn’t take me long to get used to that!
 
What’s so hard about being called ‘doll baby’, sugar and/or honey’? I moved from NY to the south. It sure didn’t take me long to get used to that!
It’s not just that. It’s going from being a naturally very reserved person in a reserved, formal culture to a person who’s still naturally reserved but living in a very outgoing, friendly, warm culture. By northeast standards, at least those in the area I grew up in, those nicknames would be considered rather rude unless you were very close to the person calling you that. Did it bother me to be called “honey” after meeting someone twice? No! But it didn’t occur to me until it was explained that not responding at least as warmly, even without the nicknames, would be seen as rude and cold by someone used to the warmer southern mannerisms. Does that clarify things a bit?

Short version: it wasn’t them at all, it was me–or rather, the public image of “me” that I had. When I was called into that manager’s office and told that persons X, Y, and Z thought I hated working with them, I was genuinely shocked! I liked all of them quite well as coworkers, and never thought I’d given any impression to the contrary.
 
Heh. Exactly. I don’t mind it (it was a bit off-putting at first), but this is exactly what I mean. In many areas of the US, that kind of thing just isn’t normal. 🙂 😉 I love living in the south, but it did take some getting used to.
 
I’ve just noticed this after moving to the south that guys do not know how to act around women who don’t follow the more Traditional ‘mother with babies’ mold. Are women SUPPOSED to be stupid/ditsy/obsessed with fashion/makeup/looks in order to be a woman? I’m beginning to feel that that is the definition of what makes a woman sometimes, by being around these type of men. When you don’t act like that they give you weird looks, and think you’re being ‘rebellious’. It’s not fair for women to have to lower their IQ by 40 points to be ‘normal’. It seems I can’t smile and be friendly to a guy without them thinking you’re hitting on them, never mind being congenial - they refuse to acknowledge you at the same level. I only find this with traditional leaning, perhaps Southern guys. Guys from the north or more liberal seem to be fine interacting with girls like me. Even international students don’t act like this… What do you do with these type of guys???
I think you need to meet better people.

I am a Northerner living in a Southern state (and a stereotypically hyper-macho one) and I don’t encounter any of the problems you seem to be encountering. (Of course, I also live in a college town and I have an upper middle class peer group through the kids’ private school, which makes a difference.)

If anybody tells you you’re being “rebellious,” tell them with a big smile, “You’re not my daddy or my husband!”
 
OP, it’s interesting that you equate “Traditional ‘mother with babies’ mold” with “stupid/ditsy/obsessed with fashion/makeup/looks.”
 
OP, it’s interesting that you equate “Traditional ‘mother with babies’ mold” with “stupid/ditsy/obsessed with fashion/makeup/looks.”
You know, I noticed that too. Or even that stupid or ditsy is equivalent to being “obsessed” with fashion. I’m thinking of one woman I know in particular who is into fashion as a hobby, and she’s brilliant.

I think the OP needs to re-evaluate where her own perceptions are coming from, and perhaps find some new people. I like UbiCaritas’s post - it reminds me of some of what my mom went through when we lived in the South for three years growing up. My mom is one of the sweetest, nicest women who ever lived, but she’s also quiet and keeps to herself. I think living there was the only time people ever thought she was “mean.”

(Though she also went to Finland one time visiting a family friend, and people there thought she and my grandma were crazy because they smiled too much and dared to laugh in public. Cultural expectations, on all sides, do a lot to inform how we perceive and are perceived by others.)
 
You know, I noticed that too. Or even that stupid or ditsy is equivalent to being “obsessed” with fashion. I’m thinking of one woman I know in particular who is into fashion as a hobby, and she’s brilliant.

I think the OP needs to re-evaluate where her own perceptions are coming from, and perhaps find some new people.
Yes.
 
OP, it’s interesting that you equate “Traditional ‘mother with babies’ mold” with “stupid/ditsy/obsessed with fashion/makeup/looks.”
In the OP’s defense, I have met people who think that women should not bother their pretty little heads on such weighty matters as science, philosophy and theology. They should bother their pretty little heads with beauty, homemaking and child care so they can be good wives and mothers someday. And if a woman does not limit her interest to beauty, fashion and homemaking she is labeled as rebellious.

These people do exist. I have met them. However the type of people I have met who do think that way are surprisingly usually women.

I wish I could tell you otherwise.
 
In the OP’s defense, I have met people who think that women should not bother their pretty little heads on such weighty matters as science, philosophy and theology. They should bother their pretty little heads with beauty, homemaking and child care so they can be good wives and mothers someday. And if a woman does not limit her interest to beauty, fashion and homemaking she is labeled as rebellious.

These people do exist. I have met them. However the type of people I have met who do think that way are surprisingly usually women.

I wish I could tell you otherwise.
I’ve never been south except for Florida but I will say that I have met both Southern men and women and I think this might be more of an upper class phenomenon. I think there’s a lot of the whole ideal of the Southern gentleman and southern women who are impeccable looking homemakers who raise kids and still look pretty while the men are off doing their man stuff.

Maybe you need to hang around more working or middle class types who might be a little more open to different roles and ideas about family. I guess in my midwestern mindset I don’t see anything wrong with women being intelligent and actually prefer it.

Also people have mentioned the whole politeness thing. For some reason I hate it and being from the midwest I also hate the whole Minnesota nice thing. Not that i’m super blunt by any means but I guess i’m a little more emotional and say whats on my mind. For me politeness seems kind of fake and I guess i’m more appreciative of people being truly friendly.

That being said people are different everywhere you go, so try to find different folks. Where do you meet these men anyways?
 
In the OP’s defense, I have met people who think that women should not bother their pretty little heads on such weighty matters as science, philosophy and theology. They should bother their pretty little heads with beauty, homemaking and child care so they can be good wives and mothers someday. And if a woman does not limit her interest to beauty, fashion and homemaking she is labeled as rebellious.

These people do exist. I have met them. However the type of people I have met who do think that way are surprisingly usually women.

I wish I could tell you otherwise.
I refuse to believe anyone under the age of 50 believes that at all. Except perhaps in foreign cultures.

My wife is a scientist. There is rarely any overt sexism in her field. There are some cultural things every once in a while. There was a married Chinese couple where the woman was by far and away the better scientist, As brilliant as she was, he was horrible. The company would have fired him many times but they knew she would leave. So they kept him on to keep her on. But they (the couple) requested that he be given the larger salary. Because of their families and culture. But it was the couple that requested this, not the company doing it on purpose.
 
I’ve done business in the South when I was living elsewhere and I lived in the South for a couple of years in the last decade. It is different, let me add my voice to the chorus about that. That Southern women tend to be more extroverted and sociable than other women should never be mistaken for, they’re dumber, as the OP seems to think. I dunno what circles the OP travels in, but that was definitely not my impression. Being both socially graceful and feminine the way Southern women usually are is attractive to men and there is nothing wrong with that.

Further, the OP could reexamine her assumption that women (and Southern women in particular) who think first about being a wife and mother ahead of having a career are less smart than those like her who choose careers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top