Why did God decree Death?

  • Thread starter Thread starter SalamKhan
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Indeed so, which is why we do not move from initial obscurity to pretended clarity…
Jesus literally employs a parable about reaping & harvesting. Call him foolish, why don’t you?

Just because you a unable to understand, does not make wisdom foolish.
 
The root word appears 95 times,
but scroll down to see whatever context you want it in.
Forgive me for not wanting to visit the site…
I mean, if I ask the question, I should have the decency to look at the answer, yes?

So I went there, and the English word “love” in translation does not always appear, even though it does appear, at least in the root form, in the Arabic - hababa… It looked like 53 times… So thank you for the reference - That is a pretty extensive translation site for the Quran…

So in the present indicative 3rd person singular does the Quran ever write that God loves man?

geo
 
Jesus literally employs a parable about reaping & harvesting.
Actually, it is about sowing and reaping, saying that as one sows, so also shall one reap… That forms a summary of the teachings of loving God and neighbored doing good… And the counterparts of not so doing…

The conversation does not begin with sowing and reaping, except it is well known in agricultural cultures…

Jalal does not seem to have such a purpose…
Call him foolish, why don’t you?
He did not begin with obscurity…
Just because you a unable to understand, does not make wisdom foolish.
He may be wise to those who agree with him, but to someone like me he sounds like gibberish and filled with guile… His words seem tightly crafted and not seeking clarification in his readers, but rather presuming it…

Just my take - I mean, you did ask…

My take and $5 will get you no change back at Starbuck’s!

geo
 
Without death, we would be like a field that never gets reaped & harvested.
Christianity teaches that the harvest occurs in this life in an earnest…

But it only occurs when we turn from this life to God…

We regard death as the failure of Adam in us, and the final result of it…

Death is our enemy…

Jalal seems to see it as his friend…

geo
 
He did not begin with obscurity…
What obscurity? Try reading it yourself:
Thank-you…

Starting from the end of that beautiful poem one cannot infer the beginning…
But emerging from the beginning the end forms the jewell…

The end accounts the beginning, you see…
Without the beginning, it is but pretense…

Thank-you for sharing this lovely work…

So now I am in your debt…

May I soon return your kindness…

geo
 
Last edited:
Why did God decree Death?
Is this what you mean by DECREE death?

[Gen 2:17]
But of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil,
thou shalt not eat of it:
for in the day that thou eatest thereof
thou shalt surely die.


For this sounds more like a warning than a decree…

How do you understand the term “decree”?

geo
 
How do you understand the term “decree”?
He willed that it should exist. In a previous comment, I replied to someone that vegetation and animals preceded humanity, and they perished. Death is part of this world and not a punishment.
 
Death is part of this world and not a punishment.
If you believe Genesis, this world is fallen…

Death came into the cosmos through Adam’s fall…

Death is a consequence of turning from God…

Are you arguing that God decreed that His creation should turn away from Him?

geo
 
If you believe Genesis, this world is fallen…

Death came into the cosmos through Adam’s fall…
Adam was in paradise, where there was no death, and then was sent to earth, where there is death.
Are you arguing that God decreed that His creation should turn away from Him?
It was God’s decree that humanity should be on earth (Genesis 1:27-28, & Surah 2:30), and so Adam being sent to earth was not punishment.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top