Why do JW fear Jesus in scripture

  • Thread starter Thread starter twb1621
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Jehovah’s Witnesses teach that the word SWMA (body) here is the body of Christ as in the elect in him.
NAB John 2:21 But he was speaking about the temple of his body.
Compare with 1Co 3:16:
NAB 1 Corinthians 3:16 Do you not know that you are the temple of God, and that the Spirit of God dwells in you?
Actually the word is NAOS nah-os’} temple not body

So in John 2:21 Jesus is speaking about the temple of his body the place where the Spirit of God dwells.

And we are taught that our body is the temple of God. Here it means our body is the living temple of God. This is what Jesus is referring to when He talks about the temple of his body and not the collective elect.

The word is the same in 1 Cor. 3:16 so it has the same meaning. Our individual body is the temple of God. --You are the temple of God and the Spirit of God dwells in you?

Jeanne
 
Actually the word is NAOS [nah-os’} temple not body

So in John 2:21 Jesus is speaking about the temple of his body the place where the Spirit of God dwells.

And we are taught that our body is the temple of God. Here it means our body is the living temple of God. This is what Jesus is referring to when He talks about the temple of his body and not the collective elect.

The word is the same in 1 Cor. 3:16 so it has the same meaning. Our individual body is the temple of God. --You are the temple of God and the Spirit of God dwells in you?

Jeanne
Amen sister…
[/quote]
 
JeanneH:
Actually the word is NAOS [nah-os’} temple not body

**Dan:
The Greek is NAOS TOU SWMATOS which is temple of his body. The word SWMA is body in the nominative case and SWMATOS is genitive. Both words are in the verse, and as I indicated where you see the word body there, the word is SWMA.

JeanneH:
So in John 2:21 Jesus is speaking about the temple of his body the place where the Spirit of God dwells.

Dan:
Since the word SWMA is there (contra your original statement) then you no longer have an argument.

JeanneH:
And we are taught that our body is the temple of God. Here it means our body is the living temple of God. This is what Jesus is referring to when He talks about the temple of his body and not the collective elect.

The word is the same in 1 Cor. 3:16 so it has the same meaning. Our individual body is the temple of God. --You are the temple of God and the Spirit of God dwells in you?

Jeanne

Dan:
I have taken the liberty of capitalizing YOU in that verse where it is found in the plural. It is being used collectively.

DRA 1 Corinthians 3:16 Know YOU not that YOU are the temple of God and that the Spirit of God dwelleth in YOU?

Dan:
If you don’t want to take my word for this, take Justin Martyr’s comments. I am being told by Catholics that Justin received his doctrine from the apostles. However this view as well as his view that the Son was not the Creator is actually closer to JW theology.

Justin links 1Co 3:16 and John 2:19 and says our bodies (plural) are a temple (singular). He says those bodies are members of Christ. He says explicitly that “the temple of God” is “the members of Christ” and “our bodies” are “the temple of Christ.” He does this in the context of John 2:19.

Justin Martyr - John 2:19
newadvent.org/fathers/0103506.htm
Against Heresies (Book V, Chapter 6)
  1. Whence also he says, that this handiwork is “the temple of God,” thus declaring: “Do you not know that you are the temple of God, and that the Spirit of God dwells in you? If any man, therefore, will defile the temple of God, him will God destroy: for the temple of God is holy, which [temple] you are.” 1 Corinthians 3:16 Here he manifestly declares the body to be the temple in which the Spirit dwells. As also the Lord speaks in reference to Himself, “Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up. He spoke this, however,” it is said, “of the temple of His body.”** John 2:19-21** And not only does he (the apostle) acknowledge our bodies to be a temple, but even** the temple of Christ**, saying thus to the Corinthians, “Do you not know that your bodies are members of Christ? Shall I then take the members of Christ, and make them the members of an harlot?” 1 Corinthians 3:17 He speaks these things, not in reference to some other spiritual man; for a being of such a nature could have nothing to do with an harlot: but he declares “our body,” that is, the flesh which continues in sanctity and purity, to be “the members of Christ;” but that when it becomes one with an harlot, it becomes the members of an harlot. And for this reason he said, “If any man defile the temple of God, him will God destroy.” How then is it not the utmost blasphemy to allege, that** the temple of God**, in which the Spirit of the Father dwells, and the members of Christ, do not partake of salvation, but are reduced to perdition? Also, that our bodies are raised not from their own substance, but by the power of God, he says to the Corinthians, “Now the body is not for fornication, but for the Lord, and the Lord for the body. But God has both raised up the Lord, and shall raise us up by His own power.” 1 Corinthians 6:13-14
 
According to Scripture, “If Christ has not been raised, your faith is in vain, and you are still in your sins” (1 Cor. 15:17). Jesus makes clear, even before death, that it is his body that will be raised up. He promises to raise up the temple once it is destroyed. “He was speaking about the temple of his body” (John 2:21).

After he had risen, he gives the same testimony, “See my hands and my feet, that it is I myself; feel me and see, because a spirit does not have flesh and bones just as you behold that I have. Do you have something there to eat?” (Luke 24:39, 41).

Jesus insists that Thomas place his finger into his wounded side, so as to prove that he had indeed risen from the dead (John 20:27). There is no question that Jesus had truly risen from the dead.

The assertion that Jesus was invisibly raised while God the Father dissolved his natural body is ludicrous and to my knowledge is a belief that only JW’s hold . Such a presumption is without historical or scriptural warrant, and the “proof is in the pudding”

Show me a Scripture verse or verses which backs up the your assertion about God disposing of Jesus’ body.
 
JeanneH:
Actually the word is NAOS [nah-os’} temple not body

**Dan:
The Greek is NAOS TOU SWMATOS which is temple of his body. The word SWMA is body in the nominative case and SWMATOS is genitive. Both words are in the verse, and as I indicated where you see the word body there, the word is SWMA.

JeanneH:
So in John 2:21 Jesus is speaking about the temple of his body the place where the Spirit of God dwells.

Dan:
Since the word SWMA is there (contra your original statement) then you no longer have an argument.

JeanneH:
And we are taught that our body is the temple of God. Here it means our body is the living temple of God. This is what Jesus is referring to when He talks about the temple of his body and not the collective elect.

The word is the same in 1 Cor. 3:16 so it has the same meaning. Our individual body is the temple of God. --You are the temple of God and the Spirit of God dwells in you?

Jeanne

Dan:
I have taken the liberty of capitalizing YOU in that verse where it is found in the plural. It is being used collectively.
DRA 1 Corinthians 3:16 Know YOU not that YOU are the temple of God and that the Spirit of God dwelleth in YOU?
Dan:
If you don’t want to take my word for this, take Justin Martyr’s comments. I am being told by Catholics that Justin received his doctrine from the apostles. However this view as well as his view that the Son was not the Creator is actually closer to JW theology.

Justin links 1Co 3:16 and John 2:19 and says our bodies (plural) are a temple (singular). He says those bodies are members of Christ. He says explicitly that “the temple of God” is “the members of Christ” and “our bodies” are “the temple of Christ.” He does this in the context of John 2:19.

Justin Martyr - John 2:19
newadvent.org/fathers/0103506.htm
Against Heresies (Book V, Chapter 6)
2. Whence also he says, that this handiwork is “the temple of God,” thus declaring: “Do you not know that you are the temple of God, and that the Spirit of God dwells in you? If any man, therefore, will defile the temple of God, him will God destroy: for the temple of God is holy, which [temple] you are.” 1 Corinthians 3:16 Here he manifestly declares the body to be the temple in which the Spirit dwells. As also the Lord speaks in reference to Himself, “Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up. He spoke this, however,” it is said, “of the temple of His body.”** John 2:19-21** And not only does he (the apostle) acknowledge our bodies to be a temple, but even** the temple of Christ**, saying thus to the Corinthians, “Do you not know that your bodies are members of Christ? Shall I then take the members of Christ, and make them the members of an harlot?” 1 Corinthians 3:17 He speaks these things, not in reference to some other spiritual man; for a being of such a nature could have nothing to do with an harlot: but he declares “our body,” that is, the flesh which continues in sanctity and purity, to be “the members of Christ;” but that when it becomes one with an harlot, it becomes the members of an harlot. And for this reason he said, “If any man defile the temple of God, him will God destroy.” How then is it not the utmost blasphemy to allege, that** the temple of God**, in which the Spirit of the Father dwells, and the members of Christ, do not partake of salvation, but are reduced to perdition? Also, that our bodies are raised not from their own substance, but by the power of God, he says to the Corinthians, “Now the body is not for fornication, but for the Lord, and the Lord for the body. But God has both raised up the Lord, and shall raise us up by His own power.” 1 Corinthians 6:13-14

Dan, we who are of the Catholic Faith as the Body of the Bride of Christ defend the Word of God in faith through His word in Scripture and Sacred Traditional teachings as they have been protected by His Church throughout all Christianity. With our presentation of faith we provide scriptural support with its lineage dating back 2000 years and much further attesting to the authenticity of what we provide.

Dan, I for one have seen your methods and your manipulation within this forum and feel its reasonable to ask a couple questions that have yet to be answered by you in any thread you’ve taken part in and in fact that you have refused to respond to at all.

I recognize the use of your manipulated and extremely limited Greek interpretations as a smoke screen created and used in an attempt to keep others busy and away from presenting scriptural proof refuting what you wish to promote through your deceptions. Perhaps if you won’t provide answers to my questions others here may begin insisting on responses to their scriptural defenses to require your sources so everyone can see the root of your intentions.

I have to ask again,

What credible sources with there lineage do you refer to beyond what the JW has provided you?
What degrees in ancient languages, ancient civilizations, and ancient writing forms do you hold to claim legitimacy in any of your personal interpretations of any Greek or Hebrew text and if those interpretations are not yours, what do you refer to as a credible reference?

Finally, why do you avoid scripture in both Old and New Testament that shows as evident the beliefs you are promoting are deceitful?
 
For those who may not be aware, in interpreting ancient Greek and Hebrew, one word can not be taken out of context with its adjoining word structure as each word can have 5 or 15 or several more uses and its meaning changes based on the adjoining word or words. You can also change one word to another by adding or subtracting only one character so unless a person provides the quoted full sentence structure being referred to and it can be verified by historic documentation of its legitimacy and scholarly interpretation, it is often used as a method to confuse and distort interpretation by cults and one should not be deceived by this tactic.

Additionally, one can compare many quotes of Russell’s (founder of JW) from some of their own web sites proving the distorted and erroneous interpretations he presented against scripture itself. These should not be ignored when scripture is called into question by JW.
 
I googled the Jehovah’s Witness website and this is what I found

watchtower.org/e/bh/article_04.htm

“Jesus is Jehovah’s most precious Son—and for good reason. He is called “the firstborn of all creation,” for he was God’s first creation.# (Colossians 1:15) There is something else that makes this Son special. He is the “only-begotten Son.” (John 3:16) This means that Jesus is the only one directly created by God. Jesus is also the only one whom God used when He created all other things. (Colossians 1:16) Then, too, Jesus is called “the Word.” (John 1:14) This tells us that he spoke for God, no doubt delivering messages and instructions to the Father’s other sons, both spirit and human.”
 
JeanneH:
Actually the word is NAOS [nah-os’} temple not body

**Dan:
The Greek is NAOS TOU SWMATOS which is temple of his body. The word SWMA is body in the nominative case and SWMATOS is genitive. Both words are in the verse, and as I indicated where you see the word body there, the word is SWMA.

JeanneH:
So in John 2:21 Jesus is speaking about the temple of his body the place where the Spirit of God dwells.

Dan:
Since the word SWMA is there (contra your original statement) then you no longer have an argument.
Jeanne:
Temple and body are mentioned each once in this verse. I still stand by my understanding that our human bodies are the temple of the Holy Spirit.

JeanneH:
And we are taught that our body is the temple of God. Here it means our body is the living temple of God. This is what Jesus is referring to when He talks about the temple of his body and not the collective elect.

The word is the same in 1 Cor. 3:16 so it has the same meaning. Our individual body is the temple of God. --You are the temple of God and the Spirit of God dwells in you?

Jeanne

Dan:
I have taken the liberty of capitalizing YOU in that verse where it is found in the plural. It is being used collectively.
DRA 1 Corinthians 3:16 Know YOU not that YOU are the temple of God and that the Spirit of God dwelleth in YOU?
Jeanne:
If you start reading 1 Cor.3 :1 and following you will see that Paul is addressing the" Brothers" a community. It is my understanding that when some one is addressing a group and says JB: 1Cor 3:16 Didn’t YOU realize that YOU were God’s temple and that the Spirit of God was living among YOU? he is talking about the individual you. Paul didn’t want the followers of Christ to fall into an incomplete teaching that Apollos was offering

Dan:
If you don’t want to take my word for this, take Justin Martyr’s comments. I am being told by Catholics that Justin received his doctrine from the apostles.

Justin links 1Co 3:16 and John 2:19 and says our bodies (plural) are a temple (singular). He says those bodies are members of Christ. He says explicitly that “the temple of God” is “the members of Christ” and “our bodies” are “the temple of Christ.” He does this in the context of John 2:19.

Jeanne
I agree. All of our personal bodies(plural) your body, my body are a temple of God in which the Holy Spirit dwells. Yes all of the Christian bodies do make up the temple of God. Yes all of our individual bodies are individual members of Christ’s body. Jesus is the Saviour of the individual and the collective.

I guess I just have a different understanding of Justin.

Justin Martyr - John 2:19
newadvent.org/fathers/0103506.htm
Against Heresies (Book V, Chapter 6)
2. Whence also he says, that this handiwork is “the temple of God,” thus declaring: “Do you not know that you are the temple of God, and that the Spirit of God dwells in you? If any man, therefore, will defile the temple of God, him will God destroy: for the temple of God is holy, which [temple] you are.” 1 Corinthians 3:16 Here he manifestly declares the body to be the temple in which the Spirit dwells. As also the Lord speaks in reference to Himself, “Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up. He spoke this, however,” it is said, “of the temple of His body.”** John 2:19-21** And not only does he (the apostle) acknowledge our bodies to be a temple, but even** the temple of Christ**, saying thus to the Corinthians, “Do you not know that your bodies are members of Christ? Shall I then take the members of Christ, and make them the members of an harlot?” 1 Corinthians 3:17 He speaks these things, not in reference to some other spiritual man; for a being of such a nature could have nothing to do with an harlot: but he declares “our body,” that is, the flesh which continues in sanctity and purity, to be “the members of Christ;” but that when it becomes one with an harlot, it becomes the members of an harlot. And for this reason he said, “If any man defile the temple of God, him will God destroy.” How then is it not the utmost blasphemy to allege, that** the temple of God**, in which the Spirit of the Father dwells, and the members of Christ, do not partake of salvation, but are reduced to perdition? Also, that our bodies are raised not from their own substance, but by the power of God, he says to the Corinthians, “Now the body is not for fornication, but for the Lord, and the Lord for the body. But God has both raised up the Lord, and shall raise us up by His own power.” 1 Corinthians 6:13-14
Dan:
However this view as well as his view that the Son was not the Creator is actually closer to JW theology.

Jeanne
Where did this come from. I thought we were talking about the temple of God.

In the beginning was the Word(Jesus) and the Word(Jesus) was with God…
He (the Word Jesus) was with God in the beginning. Through Him all things came to be…

How do you separate God’s word from God. How can you separate a mans word from man. Man is his word.
This topic has been discussed too many times already and the Catholic and the JW will never agree on this. We will have to agree to disagree.

Jeanne

PS I need to learn how to make my post easier to read like you do yours. How do you do it?
 
Greetings,

I would like to open a discussion on JW belief in the resurrection or lack of it.

JW say that after Jesus’s death His body remained here while His spirit went to Heaven. Jesus was the firstfruits of the dead which we all know, including the JW, this refers to the resurrection which is when the bodies of the dead will be made alive again. So how could the JW maintain they believe in a resurrection if His body remained here?
Of all the many perfections of the soul of Christ a few words must be written, namely about his miraculous power. It is commonplace with the Fathers to speak of the humanity of Christ as the “organ,” or the instrument of his divinity. The principle author of miracles, evidently, is God, who alone is able by his omnipotence to supercede the forces of nature. But history attests that o many occassions God has used instruments to bring about these marvels, either to authenticate a message to mankind or to manifesy the sanctity of the miracle worker. Greatest of all wonder workers, however, is Christ, both by reason of the number of his miracles and their extraordinary and varied character, and by reason of the permanence of this miraculous power in his human nature. I say that this power was habitual in him, not in the sense that it was a property of his human nature but that, unlike others whom God has from time to time used as the instruments of his omnipotence, Christ was able, in virtue of the power constantly communicated to his human nature by God, to work a miracle whenever he wished. As to its extent St. Thomas thus expresses the traditional view: “He had power to bring about any miraculous change which might be directed to the end of the Incarnation, which is to renew all things in heaven or on earth.” Summa Theo. III, Q.13, art. 2

To this miraculous power also belongs the complete control that Christ possessed over his own life. He died because he willed to die; not only in the sense that he offered himself voluntarily to his executioners, but that, even when his physical weakness had reached the stage at which naturally he must have died, he was able, had he so willed, to keep himself in life. “I lay down my life that I may take it again. No man taketh it away from me; but I lay it down of myself, and I have power to take it up again” (John 10:17-18). Hence also Christ as man was the instrumental cause of his own Resurrection, although the principal author was his divinity. Thus we read in Scriptures both that God raised Christ from the dead (e.g. 1 Corinthians 15:15) and also that Christ raised himself (John 2:19).

This is just one more proof in the New Testament that Jesus is the God-Man, the Second Person of the Blessed Trinity.
cont.
 
Greetings,

I would like to open a discussion on JW belief in the resurrection or lack of it.

JW say that after Jesus’s death His body remained here while His spirit went to Heaven. Jesus was the firstfruits of the dead which we all know, including the JW, this refers to the resurrection which is when the bodies of the dead will be made alive again. So how could the JW maintain they believe in a resurrection if His body remained here?
The bible clearly states that Jesus went to heaven in a flesh and blood body, since it says in I Corinthians 15:50. " “Flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God. “ Thus Jesus clearly went to heaven in the same flesh and blood body he died in.

Also, the fact that the disciples didn’t recognise him is evident that the body he died in (and was ressurected in) was the same only so ravaged by the tortures of his execution that he was unrecognisable. Mary and others that had spent countless hours with him were shocked by the state of his body and thus though he was someone else (a gardener that had been tortured for example). Remember Jesus had been severely beaten and lashed, so he must have been covered in bruises, not only were the holes for the nails evident but the torn flesh and open wounds from his torture.

Thus it is very clear that Jesus went to heaven in his flesh and blood body and appeared before the heavenly hosts in thus in evidence of his suffering.
 
For those who may not be aware, in interpreting ancient Greek and Hebrew, one word can not be taken out of context with its adjoining word structure as each word can have 5 or 15 or several more uses and its meaning changes based on the adjoining word or words. You can also change one word to another by adding or subtracting only one character so unless a person provides the quoted full sentence structure being referred to and it can be verified by historic documentation of its legitimacy and scholarly interpretation, it is often used as a method to confuse and distort interpretation by cults and one should not be deceived by this tactic.

Additionally, one can compare many quotes of Russell’s (founder of JW) from some of their own web sites proving the distorted and erroneous interpretations he presented against scripture itself. These should not be ignored when scripture is called into question by JW.
👍
 
The bible clearly states that Jesus went to heaven in a flesh and blood body, since it says in I Corinthians 15:50. " “Flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God. “ Thus Jesus clearly went to heaven in the same flesh and blood body he died in.

Also, the fact that the disciples didn’t recognise him is evident that the body he died in (and was ressurected in) was the same only so ravaged by the tortures of his execution that he was unrecognisable. Mary and others that had spent countless hours with him were shocked by the state of his body and thus though he was someone else (a gardener that had been tortured for example). Remember Jesus had been severely beaten and lashed, so he must have been covered in bruises, not only were the holes for the nails evident but the torn flesh and open wounds from his torture.

Thus it is very clear that Jesus went to heaven in his flesh and blood body and appeared before the heavenly hosts in thus in evidence of his suffering.
 
The bible clearly states that Jesus went to heaven in a flesh and blood body, since it says in I Corinthians 15:50. " “Flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God. “ Thus Jesus clearly went to heaven in the same flesh and blood body he died in.

Also, the fact that the disciples didn’t recognise him is evident that the body he died in (and was ressurected in) was the same only so ravaged by the tortures of his execution that he was unrecognisable. Mary and others that had spent countless hours with him were shocked by the state of his body and thus though he was someone else (a gardener that had been tortured for example). Remember Jesus had been severely beaten and lashed, so he must have been covered in bruises, not only were the holes for the nails evident but the torn flesh and open wounds from his torture.

Thus it is very clear that Jesus went to heaven in his flesh and blood body and appeared before the heavenly hosts in thus in evidence of his suffering.
One of the most touching post-Resurrection scenes, for me anyway, is when, after His Resurrection, He appeared to His brethren on the shore and had breakfast with them. Oh, happy day!

Imagine that! The Risen Lord actually eating some fresh, grilled fish with His chosen disciples.
 
The bible clearly states that Jesus went to heaven in a flesh and blood body, since it says in I Corinthians 15:50. " “Flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God. “ Thus Jesus clearly went to heaven in the same flesh and blood body he died in.

Jeanne;
Not clear to me at all.

Cashue
Also, the fact that the disciples didn’t recognise him is evident that the body he died in (and was ressurected in) was the same only so ravaged by the tortures of his execution that he was unrecognisable. Mary and others that had spent countless hours with him were shocked by the state of his body and thus though he was someone else (a gardener that had been tortured for example). Remember Jesus had been severely beaten and lashed, so he must have been covered in bruises, not only were the holes for the nails evident but the torn flesh and open wounds from his torture.

Jeanne:
I think they didn’t recognize him because he was in his glorious body. Also, He did just die. Put your self in their place. Would you have recognized him immediately after just seeing him die? I don’t think the apostles fully believed until they finally realized that Jesus actually did raise from the dead.

Cashue
Thus it is very clear that Jesus went to heaven in his flesh and blood body and appeared before the heavenly hosts in thus in evidence of his suffering

Jeanne:
Still not clear to me. Flesh and blood can mean a person who lives a carnal life. They cannot inherit an incorruptible body.

Jeanne
 
I googled the Jehovah’s Witness website and this is what I found

watchtower.org/e/bh/article_04.htm

“Jesus is Jehovah’s most precious Son—and for good reason. He is called “the firstborn of all creation,” for he was God’s first creation.# (Colossians 1:15) There is something else that makes this Son special. He is the “only-begotten Son.” (John 3:16) This means that Jesus is the only one directly created by God. Jesus is also the only one whom God used when He created all other things. (Colossians 1:16) Then, too, Jesus is called “the Word.” (John 1:14) This tells us that he spoke for God, no doubt delivering messages and instructions to the Father’s other sons, both spirit and human.”
Amazing… So they say Jesus is the Son of God, refute Jesus proclamation He is God which would say they believe Him a liar or deceitful, acknowledge there is but one God, then recognize Him as some sort of a mini-god even though they dismiss His claim of being God as false and know there to be one God. But they mock the Blessed Trinity…

To Dan,

As far as Justin Martyr, Dan, just in case you peek at those posters you have placed on your ignore list for inability to respond to their scriptural references…

*Justin explains his position that the Son of God was God of the Father’s will. Justin also stands on his conclusion that Jesus as God and of His Father, both of whom came to be together before the creation, were together during the creation and supports his conclusion with those words shared between the Father and the Son such as “Let us make man in our image…”, which reflects a cooperative. With the Trinity, these things are recognized, for God the Son was not “born” or even begotten of the soil of the earth as man but rather begotten of the will of God and shared in that divine knowledge and existence. God the Father cannot be separated from His will therefore both are one. The Son was there and shared in the experience of creation. God our Father Himself declared there is only one God yet He acknowledges His Son through the prophets in scripture and the Son is specifically referred to as God in Scripture. If there is only one God as we know there to be, the Son of God is therefore one with the Father, one of Three in one God. Now, if you are going to refer to Justin as someone we should believe in without doubt, there is a great deal more you need to accept from his writings in order to show yourself credible. *
*Deny this with justification Dan. *
 
yes, they do not believe in the divinity of Christ. There is something about Saint Michael the Archangel in their beliefs. They do not celebrate Christmas or Easter. I am not sure what their religion stands for. I do not think they call themselves Christians. They do believe in God the Father though. Carlan
They believe Jesus was originally Michael the Archangel, then returned to heaven after His earthly life as Michael the Archangel again.
 
Amazing… So they say Jesus is the Son of God, refute Jesus proclamation He is God which would say they believe Him a liar or deceitful, acknowledge there is but one God, then recognize Him as some sort of a mini-god even though they dismiss His claim of being God as false and know there to be one God. But they mock the Blessed Trinity…
.
Exactly, clearly when Jesus said he was God’s son it was as you said his proclaimation that he was God. This is a clear and undeniable fact in scripture: Jesus said on many, many occassion “I AM ALMIGHTY GOD.”

I think their confusion comes from the one or two times Jesus seemed to suggest he was God’s son, but this clearly means he is God (just God in flesh) as he said, “I am God in the flesh”. Jesus was not lying when he said that he is God Almighty and that explained to his disciples he was God in the flesh.

Looking over the Jehovah’s Witness sight I even found this
watchtower.org/e/ti/article_03.htm

Where they seem to be denying the power of the Holy church to reveal truths not as yet contained in scripture. Still they do admit:

"He had a prehuman existence as the only-begotten Son of God. What then was the will of the One who sent him to earth? “God loved the world so much that he gave his only-begotten Son,” says John, one of the Gospel writers, “in order that everyone exercising faith in him might not be destroyed but have everlasting life.” (John 3:16) "
watchtower.org/e/19990701/article_02.htm

We must pray for their souls.
 
Jeanne:
Temple and body are mentioned each once in this verse. I still stand by my understanding that our human bodies are the temple of the Holy Spirit.

Dan:
John 2:19 in Greek is literally “the temple of his body.” There are ways in Greek to make it explicit that the temple was his body. Since this was your proof-text that the Son was raised in a physical body, your proof has now disappeared. You are welcome to believe as you like, but this text may not be used to prove the point which you were making.

JeanneH:
And we are taught that our body is the temple of God. Here it means our body is the living temple of God. This is what Jesus is referring to when He talks about the temple of his body and not the collective elect.

Dan:
I understand what you were taught. But the passage in John 2:19 does not teach this. You are welcome to your interpretation.

JeanneH:
The word is the same in 1 Cor. 3:16 so it has the same meaning. Our individual body is the temple of God. --You are the temple of God and the Spirit of God dwells in you?
Jeanne

Dan:
Yes, but that begs the question as to whether or not Christians together make up one temple or are each their own temple. In that verse temple is singular and those that make up that single temple are referred to in the plural.

Dan:
I have taken the liberty of capitalizing YOU in that verse where it is found in the plural. It is being used collectively.DRA 1 Corinthians 3:16 Know YOU not that YOU are the temple of God and that the Spirit of God dwelleth in YOU?

Jeanne:
If you start reading 1 Cor.3 :1 and following you will see that Paul is addressing the" Brothers" a community. It is my understanding that when some one is addressing a group and says JB: 1Cor 3:16 Didn’t YOU realize that YOU were God’s temple and that the Spirit of God was living among YOU? he is talking about the individual you. Paul didn’t want the followers of Christ to fall into an incomplete teaching that Apollos was offering

** Dan:**
There are ways in Greek to make it explicit that while one is addressing a group something applies to the individual. For example a verse just a few verses earlier:

NJB 1 Corinthians 3:13 but each person’s handiwork will be shown for what **it **is. The Day which dawns in fire will make it clear and the fire itself will test the quality of each person’s work.

If you look at the Greek you will see singular nouns, verbs and articles, etc. This is what you need in 1Co 3:16 to prove that a single individual is in view as a temple. Remember, this is the same context to which you appealed where Paul is addressing the brothers as a community.

Dan:
If you don’t want to take my word for this, take Justin Martyr’s comments. I am being told by Catholics that Justin received his doctrine from the apostles.

​
Justin links 1Co 3:16 and John 2:19 and says our bodies (plural) are a temple (singular). He says those bodies are members of Christ. He says explicitly that “the temple of God” is “the members of Christ” and “our bodies” are “the temple of Christ.” He does this in the context of John 2:19.

**Jeanne **
I agree. All of our personal bodies(plural) your body, my body are a temple of God in which the Holy Spirit dwells. Yes all of the Christian bodies do make up the temple of God. Yes all of our individual bodies are individual members of Christ’s body. Jesus is the Saviour of the individual and the collective.

Dan:
The technical term “body” of Christ is a term whereby individual members make up the singular body of Christ.

**Jeanne **
I guess I just have a different understanding of Justin.

Dan:
It appears that we do. Justin equates “the temple of God” with “the members of Christ.” In this context the members are a composite body. He discusses this while explicitly mentioning John 2:19.

You no longer argue that John 2:19 is a proof-text for the resurrection of the physical body of Christ any longer, which is good, because that text cannot prove your original premise.

Dan:
However this view as well as his view that the Son was not the Creator is actually closer to JW theology.

Jeanne
Where did this come from. I thought we were talking about the temple of God.

Dan:
I am working on a theory that the farther back one gets to the apostles the closer one gets to JW theology. So far the evidence supports the theory very well.

Jeanne
In the beginning was the Word(Jesus) and the Word(Jesus) was with God…
He (the Word Jesus) was with God in the beginning. Through Him all things came to be…

How do you separate God’s word from God. How can you separate a mans word from man. Man is his word.

Dan:
Does Justin make this argument?

Jeanne
PS I need to learn how to make my post easier to read like you do yours. How do you do it?

Dan:
You have a choice of tools in the editor. I find that when one uses the indent instead of the quote, when one replies it comes across in the reply. The other tools like formatting and links are also in that bar.
 
Cashue:
Exactly, clearly when Jesus said he was God’s son it was as you said his proclaimation that he was God. This is a clear and undeniable fact in scripture: Jesus said on many, many occassion “I AM ALMIGHTY GOD.”

Dan:
Jesus never said even one time “I AM ALMIGHTY GOD.” There are verses where some Catholics might appeal to the effect that he meant this by using other words, but that is not the same thing. Jesus used the words “I am” to say a great many things such as “I am the bread of life,” “I am the light of the world,” and “I am the gate of the sheepfold.”

Cashue:
I think their confusion comes from the one or two times Jesus seemed to suggest he was God’s son, but this clearly means he is God (just God in flesh) as he said, “I am God in the flesh”. Jesus was not lying when he said that he is God Almighty and that explained to his disciples he was God in the flesh.

Dan:
One or two times he seems to suggest he is God’s Son? That does not sound like a very Catholic statement to me. It certainly is not Scriptural:

NAB Matthew 16:15 He said to them, “But who do you say that I am?” 16 (1 Simon Peter said in reply, “You are the Messiah, the Son of the living God.” 17 Jesus said to him in reply, "Blessed are you, Simon son of Jonah. For flesh and blood has not revealed this to you, but my heavenly Father.

Note that Jesus uses the words "I am" to identify himself as the Son and the Messiah. That is what he means when he uses the words.
 
.

Dan:
Yes, but that begs the question as to whether or not Christians together make up one temple or are each their own temple. In that verse temple is singular and those that make up that single temple are referred to in the plural.

Jeanne:
Both. Each Christian is A temple of God because the Holy Spirit lives in us and together we make up THE temple of God

Dan:
There are ways in Greek to make it explicit that while one is addressing a group something applies to the individual. For example a verse just a few verses earlier:
NJB 1 Corinthians 3:13 but each person’s handiwork will be shown for what **it **is. The Day which dawns in fire will make it clear and the fire itself will test the quality of each person’s work.
If you look at the Greek you will see singular nouns, verbs and articles, etc. This is what you need in 1Co 3:16 to prove that a single individual is in view as a temple. Remember, this is the same context to which you appealed where Paul is addressing the brothers as a community.

Jeanne:
I am not a Greek scholar, I am just reading my bible as the Greek and Hebrew scholars translated it and am trusting that they did it right.
Yes and the community consists of individuals.

Dan:
If you don’t want to take my word for this, take Justin Martyr’s comments. I am being told by Catholics that Justin received his doctrine from the apostles.

​
Justin links 1Co 3:16 and John 2:19 and says our bodies (plural) are a temple (singular). He says those bodies are members of Christ. He says explicitly that “the temple of God” is “the members of Christ” and “our bodies” are “the temple of Christ.” He does this in the context of John 2:19.

**Jeanne **
I agree. All of our personal bodies(plural) your body, my body are a temple of God in which the Holy Spirit dwells. Yes all of the Christian bodies do make up the temple of God. Yes all of our individual bodies are individual members of Christ’s body. Jesus is the Saviour of the individual and the collective.

Dan:
You no longer argue that John 2:19 is a proof-text for the resurrection of the physical body of Christ any longer, which is good, because that text cannot prove your original premise.

Jeanne:

I did not give up on my premise but on the circular discussion.

Dan:
However this view as well as his view that the Son was not the Creator is actually closer to JW theology.

Jeanne
Where did this come from. I thought we were talking about the temple of God.

Dan:
I am working on a theory that the farther back one gets to the apostles the closer one gets to JW theology. So far the evidence supports the theory very well.

Jeanne:
What evidence? JW theology originated with Mr. Russell and continues with what the current Governing Body deems as true for now until they are enlightened again… I will continue to go with what the Catholic church teaches because it has not changed its teaching from the beginning.

Jeanne
In the beginning was the Word(Jesus) and the Word(Jesus) was with God…
He (the Word Jesus) was with God in the beginning. Through Him all things came to be…

How do you separate God’s word from God. How can you separate a mans word from man. Man is his word.

Dan:
Does Justin make this argument?

Jeanne:
I don’t know what arguments Justin makes.
You didn’t answer the question.

Jeanne
PS I need to learn how to make my post easier to read like you do yours. How do you do it?

Dan:
You have a choice of tools in the editor. I find that when one uses the indent instead of the quote, when one replies it comes across in the reply. The other tools like formatting and links are also in that bar

Jeanne:
I don’t see the editor until my message is sent.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top