Why do non-Catholic Christians gather on sunday?

  • Thread starter Thread starter TEPO
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Offense taken,
Nothing like a predjicial sterotype to ‘win’ the debate. In my lifetime I have never, NEVER, met a Catholic who thinks like this. Please produce one that does.
Sorry for the offense, wasn’t trying to “win” anything just making an observation of my years of walking with Christ, living/working with many who call themselves christians…
There’s bad fruit everywhere Christ is lifted up…
 
Good answer
Believe it or not, Christians of whatever denomination, can gather whenever! Most gather only on Sunday, to fellowship, celebrate Communion(weekly in our case), worship, and hear the Word of God! We know that there are many who meet out of a sense of duty or obligation, fueled by rituals and tradition!👍
 
There is good/bad fruits EVERYWHERE Christ is lifted up…That’s what I am trying to say,
It’s the individuals not the name on the church building that says where God’s working …The Spirit blows like the wind…The whole OP just smacked of just we have God’s “real presence” why should any other believers gather…
It just reminded me of John telling Jesus " Hey there working in Your name but there not part of our Group…What did Jesus tell Him ?

You need to spend some time here and in third world countries working together in ministry with other christians that are not Catholic and see Christ’s presence reflected in their words,deeds, thoughts, attitudes and actions…
I never said that believers should’nt gather. I just wanted to know why so many do, especially if it is not necessary in the grand scheme of salvation.

Also, I never said that Jesus wasnt with other Christian faiths… Geez. 🤷
 
Believe it or not, Christians of whatever denomination, can gather whenever! Most gather only on Sunday, to fellowship, celebrate Communion(weekly in our case), worship, and hear the Word of God! We know that there are many who meet out of a sense of duty or obligation, fueled by rituals and tradition!👍
Geeeez… 🤷
 
Could you please provide the details of your ‘observation’?
Living one way Sunday and party/hearty worldy the rest of the week…Happens in all christian groups…I just happened to live /work in an high Italian/Catholic town…Remember a name does not a christian make…It’s a lifestyle that shows it…You can put any church name there…I just happened to be around alot that called themselves Catholic…We have plenty of high profiled that carry a christian name banner, their lifestyle/actions shows a different story.
 
We are not long rangers and growth is a process…Some villages may only have 2/3 believers you don’t think Christ is among them since there not Roman Catholic.
It starts with the person having a conversion experience…There are churches underground that aren’t Catholic, You don’t think Christ is among them…People chose to follow Christ every day…Our church has missionaries around the world sharing the message of Christ to villages around the world…It’s a relationship that grows…Gathering with fellow believers is part of that.We are called to spread the gospel message…You seem to think that your eucharist is the only place that Jesus is present…Jesus is present to more believers than you realize…Christ is present when my wife and I have devotions and prayer…You believe the way you do because of faith…What your church teaches…When we commune at church Jesus said this I my body…I believe that by faith…Our whole relationship is built on faith…Our communion is open to all who profess Christ…He sees the hearts and knows the faith, He knows who love Him with passion and those who will be spewed for being luke warm…I mean this with no offense but I live in a large Italian Catholic area…If it is a you say that you only have Jesus present you should have the most godly spiritually mature christians in the world…I have/had Catholic neighbors/co workers who were the most heavily drinking cussing partiers I ever knew…Comments like I"m born anew every week with my eucharist and I just confess and partake and their back to their wild lifestyles Monday…It’s a heart change not showing up in the correct “church building” every week…Christ KNOWS who are His every where His name is lifted up…You can show up in church every day and not have the sacred scriptures change you…God is way bigger that the box you seem to fit Him in…You have no idea where His presence is or isn’t…
There are a lot of valid statements in this post! Jesus is EVERYWHERE and cannot be restricted to the eucharist; although we do not fault our catholic brothers and sisters for holding to this belief! Jesus did not say that we could only commune with Him in the eucharist in catholic churches, He pretty much said He would meet you where you were. I meet Him EVERY morning, not just Sunday! Christians of every denomination are guilty at times of debauchery and overindulgence, so we should not point fingers at one denomination or the other! Remember paul said,“because of grace, should you keep on sinning? No!” If catholics made statements like that, they would be mocking Christ; doing what they please, and trusting the eucharist to make them ne"new"!
 
Living one way Sunday and party/hearty worldy the rest of the week…Happens in all christian groups…I just happened to live /work in an high Italian/Catholic town…Remember a name does not a christian make…It’s a lifestyle that shows it…You can put any church name there…I just happened to be around alot that called themselves Catholic…We have plenty of high profiled that carry a christian name banner, their lifestyle/actions shows a different story.
Okay…you are not in the pulpit right now.
Would you (pretty please with sugar on top) answer the question?
 
Geeeez… 🤷
Geeeeez, Louise, do you think that people really enjoy doing something out of duty, or obligation, rather than desire, or joy? Like serving Christ; if you do it out of a feeling of obligation rather than tremendous joy, then you are an oppressed servant, and of no use to anyone! Geeeeez!:rolleyes:
 
I guess since HisKids green ‘online’ light is off, I am not going to get an answer.
Don’t feel bad. When I young I also used to speak hastlily too. Fortunately I had people around me who would always challenge me, and as I aged I learned to pepper my words carefully.
Now, here is truth of the matter HK, you and I have NEVER met anyone who goes to confession friday night so they can raise Cain Saturday night, The Catholics who sin willfully, I can guarentee never darken a confessional booth let alone a Church.
 
Geeeeez, Louise, do you think that people really enjoy doing something out of duty, or obligation, rather than desire, or joy? Like serving Christ; if you do it out of a feeling of obligation rather than tremendous joy, then you are an oppressed servant, and of no use to anyone! Geeeeez!:rolleyes:
The people you’re talking about also happen to be the people you’re talking to. Really, how do you think this is going to work out?
 
We drunken Irish can’t wait get out the door so we can get to the pub across the street.
😉
 
Hi

a quote from Heinrich Bullinger, a reformator from Switzerland and one of the “Church Fathers” of the reformed-Evangelicals (Presbyterians) in answer to the question of the OP.

From the 2nd Helvetic Confession:

“**WHAT OUGHT TO BE DONE IN MEETINGS FOR WORSHIP. **
Although it is permitted all men to read the Holy Scriptures privately at home, and by instruction to edify one another in the true religion, yet in order that the Word of God may be properly preached to the people, and prayers and supplication publicly made, also that the sacraments [edit by Esdra: Baptism and Holy Supper] may be rightly administered, and that collections may be made for the poor and to pay the cost of all the Church’s expenses, and in order to maintain social intercourse, it is most necessary that religious or Church gatherings be held. For it is certain that in the apostolic and primitive Church, there were such assemblies frequented by all the godly.” [CHAPTER XXII -
Of Religious and Ecclesiastical Meetings].

and

CEREMONIES AND RITES.
Unto the ancient people were given at one time certain ceremonies, as a kind of instruction for those who were kept under the law, as under a schoolmaster or tutor. But when Christ, the Deliverer, came and the law was abolished, we who believe are no more under the law (Rom. 6:14), and the ceremonies have disappeared; hence the apostles did not want to retain or to restore them in Christ’s Church to such a degree that they openly testified that they did not wish to impose any burden upon the Church. Therefore, we would seem to be bringing in and restoring Judaism if we were to increase ceremonies and rites in Christ’s Church according to the custom in the ancient Church. Hence, we by no means approve of the opinion of those who think that the Church of Christ must be held in check by many different rites, as if by some kind of training. For if the apostles did not want to impose upon Christian people ceremonies or rites which were appointed by God, who, I pray, in his right mind would obtrude upon them the inventions devised by man? The more the mass of rites is increased in the Church, the more is detracted not only from Christian liberty, but also from Christ, and from faith in him, as long as the people seek those things in ceremonies which they should seek in the only Son of God, Jesus Christ, through faith. Wherefore a few moderate and simple rites, that are not contrary to the Word of God, are sufficient for the godly.”[CHAPTER XXVII Of Rites, Ceremonies and Things Indifferent]

Finally: for the interested the Heidelberg Catechism.

Esdra
 
Just wondering, do you see anything wrong with kneeling?

And as you said, since He is present at every service, don’t you think you should at least do some kneeling as a sign of reverence or humility in God’s presence?
I don’t see anything wrong with kneeling. I just don’t see kneeling to be that important. I believe the main way to show reverence to God, to honor God is to go to his house (church) and worship him. When you give your life to God, when you let him take over your life, when you let him be incharge of your life , when you submit to God, that is showing God humility. See there are different way to show reverence and humility besides kneeling.
 
If it was asked by a SDA, it would have more credibility, but catholics gather on Sunday too, so it is essentially apointless question! Does it really matter what day anyone gathers to worship our KIng? And sir, your response is not a whit better, either!😛
 
The problem with this, is that obligations are for the most part man made! Some believe, and even promote that the more you do, the better your riches in Heaven will be! But, if your heart is not in it, then you are spinning your wheels! I serve out of thankfulness and a desire to see others smile, knowing that in some small way, I have shown them the love of Christ! Did Jesus oblige us to serve, or suggest it? I know He said, “If you love Me, you will keep My Commandments!” But, I believe that even those who don’t serve, will enter the Kingdom of God!
 
I hav never hinted that anyone is presenting arguments in an offensive or insulting manner, simply that it is a question which has no logical or correct answer! Some people meet on Thursday; the SDA on Saturday. So, what I’m saying is, who cares why non-catholics or catholics for that matter gather? Do you really believe God is keeping score?:rolleyes:
 
I am not; simply speaking of people I know, who say things like,“Well, I guess I have to go help with this or that,” or I really don’t want to, but Jesus said,“For even I the Son of Man, came not to be served but to serve!” Some don’t serv at all! Why do you serve?
 
But, if this thread was started by a catholic, then it is a pointless question! And I meet many an ‘oppressed servant’ in my travels!:cool:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top