Why do some traditional Catholics reject the Luminous Mysteries of the Rosary?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Holly3278
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It is basically just a traditional way of praying the psalms, and has very ancient roots. It is much easier to learn with a companion who already knows the ropes. I think it is best done in company, as a communal effort, but all to often people (for one reason or another) pray alone.

There is also the the possibility of joining an Oblate program at a nearby Benedictine monastery (should there be one in your city). It would offer you the opportunity to get involved and do some good, come for prayer times with the community as you are able plus get good spiritual direction and also fellowship with the other oblates and the brothers.

The house would have it’s own form of the LOTH, and from my experience they are probably going to be very happy to have you and pray with you.
Absolutly NO offence meant whatsoever, but this is exactly what I was referring to in my other post. This sounds…, well for lack of better words, … complicated! I wish I could tell you the number of times I have looked at learning the LOTH and approached it with loads of zeal, which was suddenly squashed as soon as I actually read and tried to figure it all out! :banghead:
In the end I just say, (sighs) “I think I’ll stick to the Rosary!” :whistle:
 
Absolutly NO offence meant whatsoever, but this is exactly what I was referring to in my other post. This sounds…, well for lack of better words, … complicated! I wish I could tell you the number of times I have looked at learning the LOTH and approached it with loads of zeal, which was suddenly squashed as soon as I actually read and tried to figure it all out! :banghead:
In the end I just say, (sighs) “I think I’ll stick to the Rosary!” :whistle:
There is a wonderful book by the Dummies Series called Liturgy of the Hours for Dummies. For those who are interested in the simple Roman Rite, it’s perfect. It walks you step by step through the Roman Rite. Once you get Morning Prayer, Evening Prayer follows the exact same pattern. Those are the two hinges.

Later, you may want to add Night Prayer to your schedule. I never suggest that any layman or diocesan priest pray more than Morning, Evening and Office of Readings. The other hours follow a different pattern and to tell the truth, people who live in the world, don’t have the luxury of a four-hour work day that consecrated people do. One has to be realistic.

Fraternally,

Br. JR, FFV 🙂
 
figs,
I know first-hand how daunting the LOTH can seem,
but really, after about a week, it becomes second nature.

My best advice, find a priest or deacon, who will “show” you what to do. How to use the ‘ordo’ and then find the proper readings, etc.

The LOTH is not part of my regular prayer rountine anymore, however, when I do pray it, I may fumble around at first, but the rhythm comes right back,
it’s kind of like riding a bike! 😉

Another thing to remember, the laity are not “bound” to pray the LOTH, so you can pray any or all of the office, at anytime. I have a really crazy schedule, so when I pray them this is the schedule I keep
Morning prayer sometime between 6am-10am.
I try to do the Office of Readings at lunchtime,
which can be anywhere between 11am-3pm.
Evening prayer is usually between 6pm-8pm, and night prayer around Midnight.
What I love is that, because the LOTH is the universal prayer of the Church, no matter what time it is where I am, somewhere, someone else is praying the same hour.
It makes me feel connected to something “bigger”. 🙂
Absolutly NO offence meant whatsoever, but this is exactly what I was referring to in my other post. This sounds…, well for lack of better words, … complicated! I wish I could tell you the number of times I have looked at learning the LOTH and approached it with loads of zeal, which was suddenly squashed as soon as I actually read and tried to figure it all out! :banghead:
In the end I just say, (sighs) “I think I’ll stick to the Rosary!” :whistle:
 
I’ve said the Luminous Mysteries with a group in church, on occasion, but I’ve never said them on my own. It’s just not part of my prayer life and I feel the rosary is already complete.
 
On-line Divine Office-org will help also. They use the same book “I believe” that Michael mentioned above. Which in truth you could probly order used on-line in very good condition also. Solid on-line information also. Don’t know if it was mentioned since my last visit here.

The Christian Religious books I have purchased used on-line are rarely opened. Often the way to save a few bucks is to exceed the S+H limit, being the books are usually $1-2 dollars, I put a $25 dollar list together. This is what I do anyway.

I agree with JReducation above about the mysteries. Really has much to do with when an individual started to recite the Rosary. Many souls out here today who have been reciting the Rosary a very long time, long before Bl John Paul II. Thus they have been following a constant path a very long time. May the Lord be pleased with them.

To me it was just natural progression in practice, since the mysteries swim in my mind, yet the addition really just highlighted the others. I also fell within this period of time so many factors made this transition natural.

“They don’t understand that it’s custom that has evolved and will continue to evolve. We just won’t be around to see the next stage.” Yes, past, present and future is a truth here.

Peace
 
Brother,
Thank you for that book title! I never thought to check the ‘for dummies’ stuff! I will give the LOTH another look. Who knows, I might ‘get it’ yet! 👍

Oneofthewomen,
Thank you for your advise of learning the LOTH.
The clergy in our parish are overwhelmed and I would really think twice before I bothered them. I tend to be one of those that likes to try to figure things out on my own because I end up praying on my own.
Thank you once again, at least I don’t feel like I’m the only one that looks at the LOTH and :bigyikes:
 
Brother,
Thank you for that book title! I never thought to check the ‘for dummies’ stuff! I will give the LOTH another look. Who knows, I might ‘get it’ yet! 👍

Oneofthewomen,
Thank you for your advise of learning the LOTH.
The clergy in our parish are overwhelmed and I would really think twice before I bothered them. I tend to be one of those that likes to try to figure things out on my own because I end up praying on my own.
Thank you once again, at least I don’t feel like I’m the only one that looks at the LOTH and :bigyikes:
One of the first things that you’re taught when you become a postulant in the Franciscan family is the LOTH. If you really want confusion, think Franciscan. We have eight books. For each season there are two books, one has the Roman edition of the Divine Office and the other book has the Franciscan edition of the Divine Office. The Franciscan edition takes precedence. You always have to check the Franciscan edition to make sure that there is no Franciscan feast that day. If there isn’t, then you pray from the Roman Breviary. If there is a Franciscan feast, you ignore the Roman Breviary and use the Franciscan edition. The ordo, which is a little pamphlet like a calendar, gives you tons of numbers for the different pages, but it does not tell you which book. It’s not user friendly.

Once you figure out how to juggle these books around with ten fingers, five ribbons and six holy cards to keep your place, the next thing is to figure out whether you’re to stand, sit, bow or do a jib and when to do it. 😃

You have to picture this. We pray Matins, Lauds, Vespers and Compline in common. The little hours we pray individually. For about three months, you feel like a complete idiot. Until you go through an entire cycle, you don’t get it.

You’re in very good company. The LOTH has made many saints. It teaches patience.

Fraternally,

Br. JR, FFV 🙂
 
One of the first things that you’re taught when you become a postulant in the Franciscan family is the LOTH. If you really want confusion, think Franciscan. We have eight books. For each season there are two books, one has the Roman edition of the Divine Office and the other book has the Franciscan edition of the Divine Office. The Franciscan edition takes precedence. You always have to check the Franciscan edition to make sure that there is no Franciscan feast that day. If there isn’t, then you pray from the Roman Breviary. If there is a Franciscan feast, you ignore the Roman Breviary and use the Franciscan edition. The ordo, which is a little pamphlet like a calendar, gives you tons of numbers for the different pages, but it does not tell you which book. It’s not user friendly.

Once you figure out how to juggle these books around with ten fingers, five ribbons and six holy cards to keep your place, the next thing is to figure out whether you’re to stand, sit, bow or do a jib and when to do it. 😃

You have to picture this. We pray Matins, Lauds, Vespers and Compline in common. The little hours we pray individually. For about three months, you feel like a complete idiot. Until you go through an entire cycle, you don’t get it.
No!
See… now if I were to confront that kind of nightmare :takethat: I’m afraid I would be doing overtime some place slightly warm!! LOL
 
No!
See… now if I were to confront that kind of nightmare :takethat: I’m afraid I would be doing overtime some place slightly warm!! LOL
:rotfl:

If an illiterate country bumpkin like me can get it, anyone can get it. Patience is a sign of a soul at peace with God.

Fraternally,

Br. JR, FFV 🙂
 
:rotfl:

If an illiterate country bumpkin like me can get it, anyone can get it. Patience is a sign of a soul at peace with God.

Fraternally,

Br. JR, FFV 🙂
Brother, what time does your Franciscan community pray Matins? I’ve spent some time at two Benedictine monasteries and we sung Matins at 3:30 AM (1961 Divine Office – nice and long!). Despite initial difficulty, I began to really appreciate the Night Office. Maybe it’s the added penance of being up early, or maybe it’s the actuality of praying at all hours, but Matins became quite special.

I do remember one of the monastery’s dogs chasing a skunk into the cloister one Matins, though… that was quite eventful! And a new type of incense, too 🙂
  • PAX
 
No!
See… now if I were to confront that kind of nightmare :takethat: I’m afraid I would be doing overtime some place slightly warm!! LOL
The reason it seems so complicated is that it is the traditional prayer of the church, which means it evolved. The roots are in a recitation of the psalms, plain and simple.

You do not have to follow the practice of any house closely unless you want to.

You could just buy a book of psalms and take off on your own from there!

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_dlJNiXm9HfY/TTHDLHs4puI/AAAAAAAAAv4/twJTBrT1ZII/s1600/grail_psalms.jpg PAGE NOT FOUND

But then eventually you would realize that there may be certain psalms which to your mind are more appropriate for certain times of day, or certain big events and even certain seasons.

Then you might say to yourself “I always pray psalm 140 at the beginning of nightfall, it seems so appropriate!” This is what the monks of holy church had done for centuries. You are tapping in to the accumulated spirituality and wisdom of of the catholic Christian faith of 2000 years and the worship of Jesus Christ and the Jewish people for hundreds of years more.

… This Psalm is spoken in the person of our Lord Jesus Christ, both head and members. He is the head, we are the members. Not without good reason then, His voice is ours and our voice is also His. Let us, therefore, listen to the Psalm and recognize in it the voice of Christ…
St Augustine of Hippo - notes on psalm 41
 
You are tapping in to the accumulated spirituality and wisdom of of the catholic Christian faith of 2000 years and the worship of Jesus Christ and the Jewish people for hundreds of years more.
This is one of the great beauties and powers of praying the Breviary. Well put.
  • PAX
 
If you want to have a very simple office, I recommend Anglican Use Book of Divine Worship.
The Schema is simple, lots of freedom matching up the hymns, there are 2 schema of Psalms distribution you can choose one suit you best.
And since it is one of public liturgy approved by the Church, you can rest assured you pray with the whole Church.
 
The reason it seems so complicated is that it is the traditional prayer of the church, which means it evolved. The roots are in a recitation of the psalms, plain and simple.

Then you might say to yourself “I always pray psalm 140 at the beginning of nightfall, it seems so appropriate!” This is what the monks of holy church had done for centuries. You are tapping in to the accumulated spirituality and wisdom of of the catholic Christian faith of 2000 years and the worship of Jesus Christ and the Jewish people for hundreds of years more.
I agree, this is a fine post and well put.

The early monastics had little experience to build on. Certainly they had no commentaries, devotionals or guides, but walked blindly into the desert and followed those who advanced in holiness, imitating them in prayer and work. They saw what worked to make people holy and what didn’t, and they imitated the men who advanced in holiness.

It’s a great advantage to us, to be able to tap into the accumulated experience of so many men and women who groped about in the desert looking for an invisible God.

-Tim-
 
You are tapping in to the accumulated spirituality and wisdom of of the catholic Christian faith of 2000 years and the worship of Jesus Christ and the Jewish people for hundreds of years more.
This. Not only are you praying with the church today, you are praying with the church throughout the ages.
 
The reason it seems so complicated is that it is the traditional prayer of the church, which means it evolved. The roots are in a recitation of the psalms, plain and simple.

You do not have to follow the practice of any house closely unless you want to.

You could just buy a book of psalms and take off on your own from there!

But then eventually you would realize that there may be certain psalms which to your mind are more appropriate for certain times of day, or certain big events and even certain seasons.

Then you might say to yourself “I always pray psalm 140 at the beginning of nightfall, it seems so appropriate!” This is what the monks of holy church had done for centuries. You are tapping in to the accumulated spirituality and wisdom of of the catholic Christian faith of 2000 years and the worship of Jesus Christ and the Jewish people for hundreds of years more.
Thanks 🙂
 
Brother, what time does your Franciscan community pray Matins? I’ve spent some time at two Benedictine monasteries and we sung Matins at 3:30 AM (1961 Divine Office – nice and long!). Despite initial difficulty, I began to really appreciate the Night Office. Maybe it’s the added penance of being up early, or maybe it’s the actuality of praying at all hours, but Matins became quite special.

I do remember one of the monastery’s dogs chasing a skunk into the cloister one Matins, though… that was quite eventful! And a new type of incense, too 🙂
  • PAX
We pray Matins at 5;00 and then we go from there. Monastic communities can do it in the middle of the night, because they go to be very early. We can’t go to bed before 11:00. The rule requires certain things that monastics don’t do. We have to eat three meals together. We must have an hour or two of community recreation. We must put in an hour of manual labor around the house. And we have apostolic duties. Even though most of our brothers are not priests, we don’t have lay brothers, which monasteries do have. The lay brothers take care of all the housekeeping, grocery shopping, car washing, laundry, cooking, setting tables, picking up after meals, doing dishes, etc etc. In our community everyone does these things, whether you’re ordained or not.

Also, in monastic communities, the lay brothers are relieved of certain hours of the office, so they have more time for manual labor or to go shopping for food, etc. In our community, everyone is bound to the same number of hours of the Divine Office. We do them all, but we do Office of Readings, Morning Prayer, Evening Prayer and Night Prayer in common. The daytime prayers we do individually.
The reason it seems so complicated is that it is the traditional prayer of the church, which means it evolved. The roots are in a recitation of the psalms, plain and simple.

You do not have to follow the practice of any house closely unless you want to.

You could just buy a book of psalms and take off on your own from there!

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_dlJNiXm9HfY/TTHDLHs4puI/AAAAAAAAAv4/twJTBrT1ZII/s1600/grail_psalms.jpg PAGE NOT FOUND

But then eventually you would realize that there may be certain psalms which to your mind are more appropriate for certain times of day, or certain big events and even certain seasons.

Then you might say to yourself “I always pray psalm 140 at the beginning of nightfall, it seems so appropriate!” This is what the monks of holy church had done for centuries. You are tapping in to the accumulated spirituality and wisdom of of the catholic Christian faith of 2000 years and the worship of Jesus Christ and the Jewish people for hundreds of years more.

… This Psalm is spoken in the person of our Lord Jesus Christ, both head and members. He is the head, we are the members. Not without good reason then, His voice is ours and our voice is also His. Let us, therefore, listen to the Psalm and recognize in it the voice of Christ…
St Augustine of Hippo - notes on psalm 41
Actually that would not meet the requirements for liturgy. The requirements for the Liturgy of the Hours are set by the Sacred Congregation for Divine Worship. Even when a religious community alters the breviary, which happens all the time, the changes must be approved or the Divine Office is considered invalid. You’re praying and it’s valid prayer; but you are not praying with the Church.

To pray with the Church means to pray as the Church authorizes you to pray. This is true for the East and the West.

The best thing to do is to pick up one of the approved editions of the LOTH. The one volume Christian Prayer is easy to use and even easier is the shorter Christian Prayer. The shorter one does not have the propers for the holy days.

The LOTH must be in sync with the missal. That’s why you can’t just pick up the bible and pray the psalms. There are three things that must coordinate: Lectionary, Missal and Breviary.

Fraternally,

Br.JR, FFV 🙂
 
Absolutly NO offence meant whatsoever, but this is exactly what I was referring to in my other post. This sounds…, well for lack of better words, … complicated! I wish I could tell you the number of times I have looked at learning the LOTH and approached it with loads of zeal, which was suddenly squashed as soon as I actually read and tried to figure it all out! :banghead:
In the end I just say, (sighs) “I think I’ll stick to the Rosary!” :whistle:
If you are interested in a simpler form of liturgical prayer, I recommend the Little Office of the Blessed Virgin Mary. It is prayed at the same hours as the LOTH but only a subset of psalms is used rather than rotating through the entire Psalter.
 
If you are interested in a simpler form of liturgical prayer, I recommend the Little Office of the Blessed Virgin Mary. It is prayed at the same hours as the LOTH but only a subset of psalms is used rather than rotating through the entire Psalter.
The Little Office of the Virgin Mary is beautiful; but it’s not liturgy. It’s private prayer. It was denied by the CDW around 1985 when people noticed that it was not included in Canon Law. People asked. The answer was that the CDW did not consider it a liturgical prayer of the Church, but a devotional prayer.

There is a breviary that has only two hours, Morning and Evening Prayer. It’s a great beginner. Though I still encourage people to buy LOTH for Dummies. It’s the best book I’ve seen on it. It’s actually more user friendly than the rubrics in the breviary. The CDW should take lessons from the Dummies publisher.

Fraternally,

Br.JR, FFV 🙂
 
The LOTH must be in sync with the missal. That’s why you can’t just pick up the bible and pray the psalms. There are three things that must coordinate: Lectionary, Missal and Breviary.
Forgive my tangent, but this is the main thing that is holding me back from becoming a Third Order Carmelite right now. I pray the Divine Office 1962 edition, currently from DivinumOfficium.com but soon to be praying from the Baronius Press edition. I pray the Lauds, Vespers and Compline per the current Constitution of the OCDS’s, but I pray the hours that correspond to the liturgy in which I attend, the Extraordinary Form.

I’ve been told by multiple people that I will be flat-out told I have to pray the LOTH to abide by the precepts of the OCDS constitutions, but I simply adore praying the Divine Office in Latin, and in the form used in 1962 and approved for liturgical use by the Summorum Pontificum issued by Pope Benedict XVI. Since I feel so called to a vocation that centers around prayer for the Church, I find it important to pray the Hours that are truly Liturgical (i.e. Latin) and not just a personal devotion (i.e. English). It takes a while for me to pray the Hours, since I am glancing at the English translation as I read, but I’ve quickly gotten used to the back-and-forth between the Latin and English, and I’m actually picking up quite a bit of Latin in the progress. To pray LOTH would not only be off-kilter from my liturgy, but it would also be off-kilter with my ordo.

This isn’t a request for a solution or even a question, just a bit of venting, I guess. 😊
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top