Hello, Radical,
Your analogy is interesting.
thanks….(I’ll assume interesting is a good thing)
But Bob seems to be hated by quite a variety of people! Not just by his neighbors (non-Catholic Christians) over their disagreements about the right way to run the neighborhood/ or the correct neighborhood by-laws & traditions about which they think Bob is wrong (though they can’t seem to agree themselves on what exactly is the true/correct position- only that Bob is definitely wrong) while he insists that he’s right; but he’s also particularly hated even by the rival neighborhood who diss all the traditions & customs of the first neighborhood without flinching but appear to single Bob out as the embodiment of the first neighborhood and its ridiculous customs and focus disproportionate hate on him!
In the Canadian neighbourhood I don’t think Bob is singled out any more than other conservative Christians…all of which are fair game for criticism. The contrast here is how criticism of conservative Christianity is quite acceptable, but criticism of conservative Islam is often avoided. If you want to understand those outside of the neighbourhood better, I would suggest that you watch this debate from
Intelligence Squared where the subject is: The CC is a force for good in the world. When I first came across this, I thought it would be such an easy win for the affirmative b/c of all the good the CC does….but that is not the way it played out with the audience. When you watch it, avoid any desire to try and justify the CC and just try and understand the other side’s point of view….They view homosexuality as being every bit as legitimate as heterosexuality and therefore, the CC is oppressive wrt its position on homosexuality. They view women as being equal in every way with men and therefore, the CC is oppressive wrt its position on women priests. They see nothing wrong with birth control and therefore, they see the CC position WRT birth control as needlessly contributing to disease and poverty.
I guess my question is, the neighbors think Bob is dead wrong, Bob is convinced he’s right regardless, why is he thoroughly disliked while himself not seeming to dislike the others (whom he is convinced are wrong just as they are of him), but only maintaining that he’s right?
A couple of things in response: First, I think you have neglected Bob’s rather recent past. Sure Bob has cleaned up his act lately, but it wasn’t that long ago that he was quite the nasty bully in the neighbourhood (ie burning people at the stake, inquisitions etc.)…Bob clearly disliked his neighbours and went on record that every other neighbour was damned to hell. Recently Bob has “clarified” that statement and has kinda reversed himself. The other thing is that Bob has let little Joey do a lot of his dirty work (ie St Bartholomew’s day massacre), but when the neighbours complain about the damage that Joey has done, Bob merely says, “Well, it wasn’t me. I never told him to do that. I’ll give Joey a stern talking to.” The neighbours think Bob should take more responsibility for Joey’s actions.
Second, (and now I’ll break from the analogy) consider how the CC comes across with its official statements. According to the CC, Protestant Churches aren’t real churches. Instead, they are merely ecclesiastical communities. Further, Protestants are called “separated brethren” b/c they are separated from the one true Church…they are separated doctrinally from the Truth. Compared to where the CC has been in the past, this is a very conciliatory position. Nevertheless, consider how you would feel if a Protestant Church approached your local Catholic Church as with this official statement:
*Hello Catholic Ecclesiastical Community of X. We would like to extend to you our hands in friendship and brotherhood. We treasure the fact that we worship the same Lord, however, we feel obliged to clarify our position so that there can be no misunderstanding and so that truth is proclaimed. You will note that we refer to you as our “unreformed brethren” b/c your doctrine is unreformed and still contains considerable error (and we know that those errors need to be eliminated before you can enjoy the fullness of the truth). We also don’t call your community a “church” b/c your priest and sacraments are not legitimate. Through friendship and interaction with us, we hope that your walk will become closer to the truth. In any event, we rejoice in the fact that, notwithstanding the deficiencies in your Ecclesiastical Community, it is possible for (some of) you to still be saved through a spiritual membership in our Church, the One True Church *
Tell me, what percentage of your congregation would find that arrogant and offensive?..keeping in mind that all I have really done is put the shoe on the other foot and have the Protestant Church saying about the CC what the CC says about Protestant Churches.
Peace.