Why is the mantilla (specifically) so popular among US traditional Catholics?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DarkLight
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I often fantasize about switching to all black clothes with just different colored cardigans. But then I remember how much I love earth tones.

I do consider a black lace mantilla to essentially be neutral. Or at least it’s different enough that I don’t feel like I need to match it to my outfit.
 
Who is talking about “lace” people have used other materials to cover their heads.
Which is what the purpose of the “mantilla” is.

Peace!
 
Who is talking about “lace” people have used other materials to cover their heads.
The whole thread? The topic here is the cultural phenomenon of the triangular lace mantilla as the dominant head covering in the USA, not the idea of head covering in general.
 
I specifically remember my grandmother purchasing veils for all the females in my family and giving them to us on Christmas Eve, 1963. She was a great admirer of Jacquie Kennedy. I do think the former 1st Lady inspired Catholic style as well as secular style. My other grandmother, however, continued to wear hats.
Compared with hats, veils are certainly easier to store in one’s car, to carry in a purse or pocket, less expensive, doesn’t matter if they get sat on, are child-friendly, more generally available, easy to make. In the winter, I wear a beret for warmth and leave it on for Mass. In warmer weather, I wear a veil like 98% of the women and girls.
Truly, the Spanish ‘mantilla’ has become a worldwide favorite.
 
Oh, that one probably came from Andalusia in Spain. It was mostly worn when you’re attending a ceremony, for example when you’re having an audience with the Holy Father you’ll wear black and white whenever you’ll have a wedding. It was though commonly worn whenever you visit the Pope and when you celebrate the Holy Week but it can also be worn when you attend a formal celebration that has nothing to do with the Mass. But I don’t have idea why women in U.S. wore that.
 
Last edited:
a certain part of Spain.
The Spanish Mantilla is a very different thing from the “normal” kind. My wife, who is Spanish, has one. It is about a foot wide and at least five feet long. It is supported on an elaborate comb, which in turn is supported on the hair (you need long, thick hair). You also need a hairdresseer to fix it all up. Fewer and fewer know how to do this but in the cities where the great annual processions take place you can still find plenty of wearers.

 
Last edited:
I wear the infinity veil from Veils by Lily in a color called “latte” (it’s kind of a taupe/dark beige color) which is very neutral and goes with everything. They come with the option of having a small comb sewn into them, but I opted to not have the comb since it would create a mess if I got the veil caught on something got pulled.
(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)

I have thought of buying one in a dark purple shade to wear for Lent and Advent (it’s called “merlot” on the website.) My husband sees me ending up having a veil organizer in my closet, with different ones to match different outfits!
(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
 
I can only speak for myself - mantillas feel pretty! Prettier and more fun in my view than hats.
 
40.png
Tis_Bearself:
I live next door to an African-American Protestant Church and the ladies there all wear hats to services every Sunday.
In the African-American culture (expecially among Protestant African-Americans), hats in church are definitely much more of a Thing than among white American Protestants. Every Sunday is an Easter parade.
Truer words were never spoken. When you drive by an AA church on Sunday, well, that’s something to see. Everyone looks very sharp!
I wear the infinity veil from Veils by Lily in a color called “latte” (it’s kind of a taupe/dark beige color) which is very neutral and goes with everything. They come with the option of having a small comb sewn into them, but I opted to not have the comb since it would create a mess if I got the veil caught on something got pulled.

(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
The very fetching-looking young lady in this post would immediately be noticed by every single traditionalist-oriented Catholic young man in the parish. If a woman seeks to attract that kind of man (one who will actually help her get to heaven instead of hinder her — never have figured out why some Catholic women marry men who force them to do all the “heavy lifting” where the Faith in the home is concerned), she will get herself a mantilla like this, and she will wear it.

The mantilla is also about as counter-cultural as it gets, and for some of us, “counter-cultural” is a good thing.
 
I was born in ‘53 and I don’t recall ever seeing a mantilla in our church (Eastern Canada) until it became a fashion accessory in the mid ‘60s. Women in our parish wore hats or kerchiefs. In winter fur hats or other winter headgear. I’ve posted a picture here before of a Confirmation celebration in our parish around 1966. The only veils in sight are on the two Sisters and a few of the girls being confirmed. Lots of hats and kerchiefs though.

One thing about the mantilla is that it was easy to fold, slip into its plastic case, and tuck into your purse or the glove compartment so it was readily available should you need it.
 
By the time you got to the mid-20th century, Catholic women weren’t always putting on a head covering or a hat to go out (especially if they were just doing some errand like grocery store)
Well, there was the trusty kerchief to cover the curlers…😃
 
@Phemie, I am a few years younger, but that is the same thing I experienced. We always wore the little round veils to church with a Bobby pin. Then I remember my sister started to wear a navy blue mantilla type veil. (She was older than me.) I don’t remember them being as long an “drippy” looking as the ones I see pics of now. The round one were certainly easy to carry in your purse!

I always wonder why the mantilla is the choice and not the round one for those that wear veils to mass. It would seem that it is a fashion statement although many vehemently deny that is the case.
 
Last edited:
@Phemie, I am a few years younger, but that is the same thing I experienced. We always wore the little round veils to church with a Bobby pin. Then I remember my sister started to wear a navy blue mantilla type veil. (She was older than me.) I don’t remember them being as long an “drippy” looking as the ones I see pics of now. The round one were certainly easy to carry in your purse!

I always wonder why the mantilla is the choice and not the round one for those that wear veils to mass. It would seem that it is a fashion statement although many vehemently deny that is the case.
Because they take veil literally? And the little round things don’t cut it?
 
I don’t know. Maybe because we only thought of it as “covering our head in church” and not ‘veiling”?!

Moi, all ready to accompany my aunt & uncle to Mass some time in the early 60s.

image|531x500
 
Last edited:
I always wonder why the mantilla is the choice and not the round one for those that wear veils to mass. It would seem that it is a fashion statement although many vehemently deny that is the case.
I prefer the mantilla over the chapel cap (“the round one”) because it’s easier for me to use. I can lay a mantilla on my head as I walk into the church and it will remain there until I remove it after I leave. A chapel cap won’t stay in place unless I secure it on my head with a bobby pin (and then I’d either have to put it on at home or bring a mirror to assist with this preparation because there are no public restrooms at either of the churches where I’d be wearing a mantilla, but that problem is particular to my situation and may not reflect that of most American women).
 
It would seem that it is a fashion statement although many vehemently deny that is the case.
I think for some ladies it may be a case of what’s easiest to put on your particular head/ hair and have it stay on. I have poofy hair and have tried wearing the doily-with-bobby-pins because it was the handiest thing to grab. It didn’t work very well. The longer veils stay on me better and can be tied or wrapped round the neck in a manner that makes them stay. I have also in an emergency used the “Leopard Spotted Headscarf from Urban Drugstore Across from the Church”.

A lot of the older ladies still use the short little chapel veil because they’re easy to buy in Catholic stores and tuck easily into your purse.
 
Maybe there’s a Continuum – round chapel veils at the frumpy end of the continuum, and longer veils of French lace at the full-on glamorous end of the spectrum. Bonus glamour points if the wearer is young and lovely.
 
I always wonder why the mantilla is the choice and not the round one for those that wear veils to mass. It would seem that it is a fashion statement although many vehemently deny that is the case.
I never quite got the denial either, honestly. Us ladies tend to like pretty things, you know? If you’re going to wear a head covering, I never saw much issue with wearing one that you like. And in this era it’s hardly like lace is particularly ostentatious or out of reach for most women.

I ordered a black and gold one recently that’s very nice, in the infinity scarf style. I think it’ll look nice for sundays. Been using a plain ivory kerchief for everyday though.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top