Why Isn't There a Palestinian State?

  • Thread starter Thread starter upant
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The Palestinians were turned into pawns by the surrounding Arab nations who refused to allow them to go into those lands as immigrants. Instead, the Palestinians were heavily restricted by their brother Moslems as to where they could go and what they could do.

The Palestinians did have something to give: their agreement and commitment to live in peace. They chose instead to remain the pawns of the ME powers-that-be so as to continue their proxy war against Israel.

The water the Palestinians have is from Israel. How can the Palestinians control it?

Had the territories in question become a separate state, the Israelis would have had a hard time defending settlements in a sovereignty entity, no? But the Palestinians have turned down all two-state proposals as not good enough. Odd, if the Palestinian terrorists were to continue their activities from a separate nation, their actions would be an act of war…

The reason the Jewish refugees had a place to go was that the tiny nation of Israel was willing to allow them to properly immigrate. The Palestinians remained refugees because none of the Arab states, large or small, was willing to do the same. This is one reason I see the Palestinians to be pawns of the ME powers.
 
No, I’m just not into blind patriotism and blind alliances.

Jim
 
OH wait, most Americans think Palestinians are Muslims and fair game.
No, I’m just not into blind patriotism and blind alliances.
I’m thinking the first quote more accurately represents your feelings about “most Americans”. The second is just cover. Kind of link trying to make a distinction between antisemitism and anti-Zionism. Whatever minor difference there is between them, they both tend to end up with a lot of dead Jews and neither ideology minds that.
 
Last edited:
Blind patriotism is how Hitler and the Nazi’s caused world havoc, and how Bush got us into the unjust war in Iraq.

Blind alliances is how Israel could bomb Palestinians in Gaza while claiming they were merely responding to Hamas rocket attacks.

The problem is, Hamas was not in the areas the Israeli’s bombed, just innocent Palestinians who don’t support Hamas, but are caught between them and the Israeli’s.

Pope’s John Paul II, Pope Benedict XVI and Pope Francis, all opposed the war in Iraq and the indiscriminate bombing of Palestinians by the Israeli’s.

I side with our Pope’s, you apparently don’t,

Jim
 
Last edited:
Turning a blind eye to the injustice to support Israel,
yet you turn a blind eye to the treatment of the palestinian arabs by the rest of the arabs in the middle east.

why isn’t the gaza egytian border an open border? why isn’t humanitarian aid flowing through it?

you don’t seem interested in the total picture. i won’t deny israel takes advantage of the situation, but the arabs make it easy for them.

the arabs toss a few bombs at israel and you expect israel not to retaliate? what intel do you have that hamas was not in the area? they are notorious for hiding behind the skirts of women and children

the west bank would not be under israeli control if the arabs hadn’t gone to war against them. as a spoil of war they can do what they want with the territory. international law didn’t stop the invasion.

those who abandoned their property to make it easier for the arab army to wage total destruction on the israeli’s have no claim to any property. they aided and abetted the enemy and are traitors to the state. would you let isis fighters back in the country knowing they have not changed their ways?
 
You’re asking these questions for what purpose ?

Is it to justify injustices committed by the Israeli government ?

You can’t point at other unjust acts committed by others, in this case the Arab nations, in order to justify the one’s committed by the group you align yourself with, the Jewish State of Israel,

Just as truth is truth, regardless of where or who follows it, so too is evil evil, regardless of where and who follows it.

Jim
 
You can’t point at other unjust acts committed by others, in this case the Arab nations, in order to justify the one’s committed by the group you align yourself with, the Jewish State of Israel,
yes, you can when you are fighting from a defensive position.

the arabs are the attackers. israeli is just defending itself. we would do worse. look what we did just to punish saddam.

hamas fire the rockets first?

arabs invade israel in late 1940’s and the late 1960’s.

the arabs have the three no’s
Is it to justify injustices committed by the Israeli government ?
i don’t really have a dog in the fight, i just don’t like revisionist history.
You’re asking these questions for what purpose ?
to develop the truth of the situation. to show it isn’t only israel blockading and not assisting the palestinians. but you ignore the treatment of arabs on arabs to focus on israel.
 
Arabs aren’t bombing innocent people in Gaza as Israel has done.

Arabs aren’t the one’s who drove the Palestinians into exiled refugee camps

Arabs aren’t the one’s bulldozing Palestinians homes to the ground in the West Bank, in order to make room for immigrating Arabs.

Sure, Arab nation’s haven’t been all that helpful to Palestinians, but their lack of help doesn’t justify atrocities committed by the Israeli government,

Jim
 
why won’t egypt or the rest of the arab world help these people.
Egypt, like Israel, receives money from the U.S. The blood spilled by war crimes against the Palestinians stains our hands as it does Israel’s and Egypt’s.
 
The reason you being this up is that you have nothing more recent.
So you are unaware of the Israeli blockade of Gaza that started in 2007 and the massive harm it has done to residents and the economy?
 
To Jim, Imachone, and others who rebuke Israel…

If Israel gave back everything and returned to the 1949 borders…do you think that would result in peace?
 
If Israel gave back everything and returned to the 1949 borders…do you think that would result in peace?
Don’t have to go back that far, 1967 would do. I don’t know if it would immediately result in peace, there are lots of children growing up now who will hold grudges against Israel for the deaths of their parents, but if Palestinians could control their own affairs it would weaken Hamas’ influence in Gaza.
 
So you think if Israel went back to 1967 borders then Hamas would change their charter which calls for their extermination?
 
My comment was in response to his bringing up the bombing of the USS Liberty 50 years ago.
 
Hamas’ rhetoric would be less successful at the polls and have less popular support without the continued Israeli abuses.
 
Agreed.

But would returning to 1967 boundaries result in peace? Would Hamas (et al) accept the presence of a Jewish state?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top