Why must we be forgiven by a priest?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DrewC
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
So you say. I’m afraid I’m going to have to take the Bible’s word over yours.
The Bible says, in 2 Corinthians 2:9-11 (Written by Paul, an apostle of Jesus Christ) For to this end also did I write, that I might have proof from you, whether ye be obedient in all things.
10To whom ye forgive anything, I forgive also; for if I forgave anything, to whom I forgave it,** I forgave it for your sakes in the person of Christ**,
11lest Satan should get an advantage over us. For we are not ignorant of his devices.
Forgiving someone “in the person of Christ” is totally Biblical.
 
Jesus gave the Apostles the authority to forgive or retain sins. This authority which is in the Person of Christ is handed down to the Bishops. The priest through ordination get the authority from the Bishop.

We are a very Physical Body of Christ. We take Christ physically into our bodies and we physically confes to a person who has authority for forgive or retain sins on behave/in the Person of Christ. I once ask a priest to hear my confession over the phone. It was a friend so he just laughed at me and explained that both him and I need to be physically present. As a Body of Christ we are connected in a hyerarchy and should not forget this.
 
Actually, the only thing they’ve quoted for me is a bunch of prooftexts.

So you say. I’m afraid I’m going to have to take the Bible’s word over yours.

So then, you believe there’s a chance that the passage I cited for you might be wrong? Good to know you have such a high view of God’s word.
I wasn’t addressing this to you, I was addressing it to the OP. I’m not going to sit and argue with someone who obviously thinks he is infallible (but isn’t). But I will pray for you :crossrc:
 
It proves that even a Roman Catholic has to admit that Roman Catholics don’t understand basic hermeneutic principles. Thus, their interpretations are suspect.
:rolleyes:

There’s very little to explain when the passages are as clear as in this case.

That’s why the passage in John 20:21-23 is so important.
“21 He said therefore to them again: Peace be to you. As the Father hath sent me, I also send you. 22 When he had said this, he breathed on them; and he said to them: Receive ye the Holy Ghost. 23 Whose sins you shall forgive, they are forgiven them; and whose sins you shall retain, they are retained.”

My thinking is that if our Lord had not intended to make the Sacrament of Reconciliation a means of grace unto salvation, then why in the world would He have made this statement and given both this power and command to the presbyters of His church?

James 5:16 & 1st John 1:9 also offer us more insight into this doctrine.

James 5: 14 Is any man sick among you? Let him bring in the priests of the church, and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord. 15 And the prayer of faith shall save the sick man: and the Lord shall raise him up: and if he be in sins, they shall be forgiven him. 16 Confess therefore your sins one to another: and pray one for another, that you may be saved. For the continual prayer of a just man availeth much.

1st John 1:9 If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just, to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us from all iniquity.

All these passages expressly speak of confession of sins and so I have to ask, then just how will those outside the Catholic Church explain the obvious link between these passages.

Here is a further outline for study on this sacrament courtesy of John Martignoni and his Bible Christian Society
Confession
A. Confess your sins to men
~ Leviticus 5:5-6 (“All scripture…”: 2 Tim 3:16)
(Law is a shadow: Hebrews 10:1)
~ 1 John 1:9
~ James 5:16
B. Can men forgive sins?
~ Only God has the power to forgive sins but He exercises this power through men.
~ Mark 2:7
~ Matthew 9:1-8
When the crowds saw it, they were afraid , and the glorified God, who had given such authority to men.
  • Matthew 9:8
To me, the scriptures are clear, and I can’t help but praise and thank God for His wisdom and mercy that (knowing the weaknesses of mankind) equipped His church with the means to help His children overcome our weaknesses and sins.
 
Me quoting doesn’t last long but you having a CAF forum member signature without consent maybe against forum policy.
Not to mention when you quote someone in a forum, you do it in context of the discussion, whereas a signature is carried from discussion to discussion without that context, something protestants tend to do alot: quote out of context.
 
I am still waiting for Bro Sam to say anything of substance to back up his claims………So for all he has done is to sling mud….He is acting like a childish thug……point in case his signature….He is preaching bully theology. That’s it. He does not want to dialog. I guess he is just here to poke fun and pick a fight. Don’t know why but that is all I have seen in his posts. 🤷
 
Not to mention when you quote someone in a forum, you do it in context of the discussion, whereas a signature is carried from discussion to discussion without that context, something protestants tend to do alot: quote out of context.
I pm Guanophore to check if brosam did had her permission to be used as a signature.
 
He is acting like a childish thug……point in case his signature….He is preaching bully theology.
Troll

I saw one person on the forums and I liked it.

Lets take a look at this statistics:
Join Date: Sep 17, '07
Posts
Total Posts: 330 (**106.11 **posts per day)
Maybe he should stop talking and start listening?

“A fool’s mouth is his undoing, and his lips are a snare to his soul. The words of a gossip are like choice morsels; they go down to a man’s inmost parts” (Proverbs 18:7-8).
 
Great! Maybe we can make some progress,then.
The difference is that I’m using sound hermeneutic principles while you’ve already admitted that “the majority of Catholics don’t know the basic principles of hermeneutics. I think the majority of them would not be able to give an interpretation of the word.”
Well, please take into account that this characterization, while accurate, does not apply to Catholics on THIS Board! 👍
it is arrogant of you to claim that yours is the only church, while we are not a part of the church.
I suppose it would be, if I had. However, I have only represented to you the Catholic teaching, which is that there is only One Church, and all who are Christians are part of it. I never said anything about “we are not a part of the church”. I don’t even know which “we” you are talking about!
And the Bible says otherwise. As usual, I’m going to have to go with God’s word over yours.
Ok, please give me a scripture that states there is more than one church.
What you believe Roman Catholics wrote and what Roman Catholicism commonly teaches are not the same thing.
I would dearly love it if you would stop using that word “Roman” with me. Are you saying you don’t believe the Catholic Church wrote the Bible?

Are you saying that you believe Catholicism teaches something contrary to the bible? On the contrary, I think you do not understand how you got the canon, or what the Catholic Church teaches.
I’ve been studying the scriptures for twenty years and not one person has ever pointed out anything I’ve taught that is wrong. Likewise, I aced (and am acing) my seminary classes.
Congratulations! You are about to enter a whole new era in your education. 👍
Now, if you’re going to say that I don’t understand Roman Catholic teaching, then that is to admit that this organization you claim is infallible, is God’s own mouthpiece, was incompetent to teach me in all of the years they had me.
Ahh, and ex Catholic! Many things are becoming more clear suddenly! I agree that the catechesis needs improvement. I left the church too, for the same reason, and went to protestant seminary for the same reason.
I don’t. Like I’ve explained to you many times now, our doctrine isn’t based on what others believe, but on what the Bible says.
Then I challenge you to account for the Orthodox beliefs, since they produced that Bible you claim you believe.
I’ve already addressed this.
Oh! I must have missed some posts. Can you say it again? Why did Jesus give His apostles the power to forgive sins?
Then why do you follow a priesthood based on the priesthood that you admit that Jesus did away with?
Not so! Jesus did away with the Levitical priesthood,a nd established one after the order of Melchizedeck.
I see. So then, you believe that your priests are God?
We believe that they are channels of God’s grace.
I don’t believe that, but it’s certainly more plausible that believing that a wafer is God or that you keep Christ’s physical body in a “tabernacle”.

Again, therein lies the difference. You go to the priest believing you go to Christ. We go to Christ.
These are matters for a different thread. For the purpose of this thread, suffice to say that we recognize the face of Christ in the priest, when he acts in the name of Jesus.
 
No he wasn’t. However, he also insisted that his followers should depend on him to tell them what the scriptures say because they couldn’t understand them.
Glad you admit the Jim Jones analogy doesn’t apply.

Good thing the Catholic Church produced your Bible so you know what Scripture says, huh?

As for what it means, salvation is rather too important to leave to the merely literate.

After all, your small community is so because so few agree with your particular interpretation of Scripture, which is at odds with some 30,000 other Protestant interpretations of the same.
 
Jesus gave the Apostles the authority to forgive or retain sins. This authority which is in the Person of Christ is handed down to the Bishops. The priest through ordination get the authority from the Bishop.

We are a very Physical Body of Christ. We take Christ physically into our bodies and we physically confes to a person who has authority for forgive or retain sins on behave/in the Person of Christ. I once ask a priest to hear my confession over the phone. It was a friend so he just laughed at me and explained that both him and I need to be physically present. As a Body of Christ we are connected in a hyerarchy and should not forget this.
I haven’t read recently of any drive-up confessional either.:getholy:
 
Do you have my permission to quote me?
When one posts on the forum, brosam, permission is implied, because there is a 'quote" button given as an option to reply. However, one’s personal signature can contain many things not posted on the forum, and is understood to be representative of the posters personal affectations and values. It appear that your value is to use this quote, taken out of context, as a way of further insulting Catholics on this board. You insult me personally by using it without my permission, you insult the posters by insinuating that it applies to them (which is does not) and you insult me by misrepresenting my Catholic tradition.

If you did go to school, then you should have learned that quoting people out of context is inappropriate, and that authors will often take offense to being misrepresented in public, which is a form of libel.

If someone here is guilty of libelling you, as you have done to me, then I suggest you report to the mods. 👍
 
When one posts on the forum, brosam, permission is implied, because there is a 'quote" button given as an option to reply. However, one’s personal signature can contain many things not posted on the forum, and is understood to be representative of the posters personal affectations and values. It appear that your value is to use this quote, taken out of context, as a way of further insulting Catholics on this board. You insult me personally by using it without my permission, you insult the posters by insinuating that it applies to them (which is does not) and you insult me by misrepresenting my Catholic tradition.

If you did go to school, then you should have learned that quoting people out of context is inappropriate, and that authors will often take offense to being misrepresented in public, which is a form of libel.

If someone here is guilty of libelling you, as you have done to me, then I suggest you report to the mods. 👍
If I were feeling uncharitable, I could put in my siggy line that brosam, “insisted that his followers should depend on him to tell them what the scriptures say because they couldn’t understand them” since it’s something that he said in this thread. It’d be horribly out of context but other posters in other threads wouldn’t know that. 🤷
 
I have often heard this question from my Protestant friends, and my response is, if indeed a Priest is a just a man,

“Why do you insist on being married by a Minister?”

“Why do you insist on having your children baptized by a minsiter?”

They choose electively which practicies they want to take issue with because of the three I mentioned, confession is the most “awkward” for them. They never have a good answer for these questions, they simply want to go after a sacrament they don’t recognize.
 
I have often heard this question from my Protestant friends, and my response is, if indeed a Priest is a just a man,

“Why do you insist on being married by a Minister?”

“Why do you insist on having your children baptized by a minsiter?”

They choose electively which practicies they want to take issue with because of the three I mentioned, confession is the most “awkward” for them. They never have a good answer for these questions, they simply want to go after a sacrament they don’t recognize.
“When I admonish a person to go to confession it is to make him a better Christian.”–Martin Luther as quoted by Boenhoeffer.
 
I have often heard this question from my Protestant friends, and my response is, if indeed a Priest is a just a man,

“Why do you insist on being married by a Minister?”

“Why do you insist on having your children baptized by a minsiter?”

They choose electively which practicies they want to take issue with because of the three I mentioned, confession is the most “awkward” for them. They never have a good answer for these questions, they simply want to go after a sacrament they don’t recognize.
The difference, of course, is that we’re not claiming that ministers have the authority to forgive sin that the Bible tells us belongs only to God.
 
The difference, of course, is that we’re not claiming that ministers have the authority to forgive sin that the Bible tells us belongs only to God.
So “binding and loosing” authority in your intepretation, whoops, hermeneutic is confined to tying one’s shoes?

This is why we Catholics insist upon understanding Scripture as a whole, not playing “Bible Bingo.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top