Great! Maybe we can make some progress,then.
The difference is that I’m using sound hermeneutic principles while you’ve already admitted that “the majority of Catholics don’t know the basic principles of hermeneutics. I think the majority of them would not be able to give an interpretation of the word.”
Well, please take into account that this characterization, while accurate, does not apply to Catholics on THIS Board!
it is arrogant of you to claim that yours is the only church, while we are not a part of the church.
I suppose it would be, if I had. However, I have only represented to you the Catholic teaching, which is that there is only One Church, and all who are Christians are part of it. I never said anything about “we are not a part of the church”. I don’t even know which “we” you are talking about!
And the Bible says otherwise. As usual, I’m going to have to go with God’s word over yours.
Ok, please give me a scripture that states there is more than one church.
What you believe Roman Catholics wrote and what Roman Catholicism commonly teaches are not the same thing.
I would dearly love it if you would stop using that word “Roman” with me. Are you saying you don’t believe the Catholic Church wrote the Bible?
Are you saying that you believe Catholicism teaches something contrary to the bible? On the contrary, I think you do not understand how you got the canon, or what the Catholic Church teaches.
I’ve been studying the scriptures for twenty years and not one person has ever pointed out anything I’ve taught that is wrong. Likewise, I aced (and am acing) my seminary classes.
Congratulations! You are about to enter a whole new era in your education.
Now, if you’re going to say that I don’t understand Roman Catholic teaching, then that is to admit that this organization you claim is infallible, is God’s own mouthpiece, was incompetent to teach me in all of the years they had me.
Ahh, and ex Catholic! Many things are becoming more clear suddenly! I agree that the catechesis needs improvement. I left the church too, for the same reason, and went to protestant seminary for the same reason.
I don’t. Like I’ve explained to you many times now, our doctrine isn’t based on what others believe, but on what the Bible says.
Then I challenge you to account for the Orthodox beliefs, since they produced that Bible you claim you believe.
I’ve already addressed this.
Oh! I must have missed some posts. Can you say it again? Why did Jesus give His apostles the power to forgive sins?
Then why do you follow a priesthood based on the priesthood that you admit that Jesus did away with?
Not so! Jesus did away with the Levitical priesthood,a nd established one after the order of Melchizedeck.
I see. So then, you believe that your priests are God?
We believe that they are channels of God’s grace.
I don’t believe that, but it’s certainly more plausible that believing that a wafer is God or that you keep Christ’s physical body in a “tabernacle”.
Again, therein lies the difference. You go to the priest believing you go to Christ. We go to Christ.
These are matters for a different thread. For the purpose of this thread, suffice to say that we recognize the face of Christ in the priest, when he acts in the name of Jesus.