Why should Bush be impeached?

  • Thread starter Thread starter NotWorthy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
rlg94086:
Are you sure? If someone sues the government for being wiretapped illegally, wouldn’t it eventually end up in the Supreme Court? Otherwise, why do the lawyers talk about previous court decisions? Are they talking about the House?
I’ll go back and look at your other point, but one of the problems with suing the government for illegal wiretaps is that right now, who gets to sue? Who knows that they are being illegally wiretapped? This was the fundamental purpose of the FISA courts; to provide oversight.
 
40.png
estesbob:
Congress can not pass a law limiting the Constitutional powers of the Presdident. Bush was under no obligation to follow FISA law when dealing in a National security issues concering foreign nationals. The courts has repeatedly ruled the Presdient has this authority.
Nobody is arguing the case for foreign nationals; it’s the spying on US citizens that is at issue. Please don’t mix the two together as though there is no difference. There is a difference and to mix the two causes confusion.

As for the Congress not being able to pass a law limiting the president, they most certainly can. As a matter of fact that is precisely what they did when they originally passed the FISA law and for precisely this reason; the POTUS was using the government to spy on US citizens in the name of national security. And the “inherent” authority of the president is actually at it’s weakest when the Congress has spoken on the issue.
 
I am still confused as to why there is confusion.

The activities do NOT include wiretaps.

The activities involve listening in to cell phone conversations.

When we find an al Qaeda cell phone we check the numbers and see which ones are to phone numbers in the United States. We monitor CELL PHONE also known as WIRELESS) calls from overseas to U.S. numbers.

ANYBODY can listen in to wireless communications. It is no more difficult than listening to a conversation that someone yells from one cubicle to another.

Ya just need a receiver. Shortwave radio fans do this ALL THE TIME. That’s why important stuff gets encrypted. Or is transmitted in code. Or in burst mode. [You DO know what burst mode is, right?]

No magic. No wiretaps.

Now, of course, that the New York Times has blown the whole operation, one wonders whether the listening program will continue to work… one would suspect that al Qaeda would change their M.O. that’s an abbreviation for modus operandi. That’s Latin.]
 
Al Masetti:
You DO know what burst mode is, right?
I don’t know what burst code is.
Al Masetti:
one would suspect that al Qaeda would change their M.O. that’s an abbreviation for modus operandi. That’s Latin.]
I’m glad you spelled it correctly. Some people go into raptures of joy over spelling errors. :confused:
 
40.png
rlg94086:
As I have no idea, I will gladly give you that point…now what about the John Schmidt quote and the point made in the Univ. of Chicago blog, I originally referenced. Do wish to argue with these attorneys who are directly addressing the Bush issue?

Personally, I’m not convinced either way. I’m hearing very strong, valid arguments from attorneys on both sides, so I’m always amazed when other non-legally trained people are so sure of the legality/illegality of Bush’s actions.
I tried to acces the Tribune article in the link, but am not signed up and can’t get to it. I’d really need to read the whole thing and parts were missing in the blog thing. However, my first question would be how does Congress passing FISA in 1978 impact the statement from the SC in 1972? Also, I believe that the FISA law has gone before the SC and is a “legal” law. Therefore, what they said in '72 doesn’t carry the same weight as it did before FISA.
 
Al Masetti:
I am still confused as to why there is confusion.

The activities do NOT include wiretaps.

The activities involve listening in to cell phone conversations.
Who knows? That’s the purpose of oversight, so that the courts can determine the legality of what is being done.
 
Since there is an argument about whether FISA itself is constitutional, that question may also be moot. 😃

Edited - oops, sorry didn’t see the SC comment. According to the Univ of Chicago site, this is not the case. (btw that would be “constitutional” law. I think all laws are “legal” by definition.)
40.png
Thekla:
I tried to acces the Tribune article in the link, but am not signed up and can’t get to it. I’d really need to read the whole thing and parts were missing in the blog thing. However, my first question would be how does Congress passing FISA in 1978 impact the statement from the SC in 1972? Also, I believe that the FISA law has gone before the SC and is a “legal” law. Therefore, what they said in '72 doesn’t carry the same weight as it did before FISA.
 
40.png
rlg94086:
Since there is an argument about whether FISA itself is constitutional, that question may also be moot. 😃
Is that true? I’ll look, but I thought that FISA has been before the SC in the past 25 years.
 
40.png
rlg94086:
Not if the “expert” is wrong. The president is not acting without counsel, you know. I’m certain they have their constitutional lawyers who have a case laid out for the wiretapping - as previous presidents have done.

Now, if it was clearly illegal, and the president said “I’m going to do it anyway”, then he would be breaking the law and therefore have committed an impeachable offense.
But the President did have council. He did NOT act on his own. He consulted the Foreign Intelligence Committees of both houses, made up of Republican’s and Democrat’s.

How can you say he did this in private.

If any of these people had reservations, why didn’t they voice them? Why? Because they knew the value of the intelligence!!! It was only after the public firestorm, er, I meant media storm (the public is not firestorming) that these democrats decided to voice their objections (But I’m sure that was just a coincidence, right?).

Notworthy
 
Everyone realizes that during a time of war, no Supreme Court nor Congress will find a president of the United States guilty of a crime in trying to protect the American public, right?

They didn’t do it to Lincoln, they didn’t do it to Roosevelt, they won’t do it to Bush.
 
40.png
NotWorthy:
But the President did have council. He did NOT act on his own. He consulted the Foreign Intelligence Committees of both houses, made up of Republican’s and Democrat’s.
Notworthy
I don’t think that’s quite right. First of all, Daschle is on the record as saying that at the time of war authorization (or whatever it was) the president asked for this spying stuff and was told “no.” So I wonder why, if he thought he had the authority, he had to ask? Second of all, people on the committee were told they couldn’t talk about it under penalty of law. They couldn’t even consult with attorneys.

Telling congresspeople what you are doing and that they can’t talk about it is not “consultation.” Rockefeller is also on the record as saying he had objections but couldn’t consult an attorney. My hunch is that the Republicans just blew kisses:love: and said “Do whatever you want.”
 
40.png
gilliam:
Everyone realizes that during a time of war, no Supreme Court nor Congress will find a president of the United States guilty of a crime in trying to protect the American public, right?

They didn’t do it to Lincoln, they didn’t do it to Roosevelt, they won’t do it to Bush.
How convenient, then, for the Executive branch to be able to declare a war without bothering with a Congressional declaration of war, and with no specifiic objective, no metric for judging success, and no criteria for determining when the war is over. Kind of a “get out of the constitution free” card.
 
Philip P:
How convenient, then, for the Executive branch to be able to declare a war without bothering with a Congressional declaration of war, and with no specifiic objective, no metric for judging success, and no criteria for determining when the war is over. Kind of a “get out of the constitution free” card.
Hey, you don’t like what the Congress does, you complain to them.
As for the President, the Congress gave him the authority to act.
 
40.png
Thekla:
I don’t think that’s quite right. First of all, Daschle is on the record as saying that at the time of war authorization (or whatever it was) the president asked for this spying stuff and was told “no.” So I wonder why, if he thought he had the authority, he had to ask? Second of all, people on the committee were told they couldn’t talk about it under penalty of law. They couldn’t even consult with attorneys.

Telling congresspeople what you are doing and that they can’t talk about it is not “consultation.” Rockefeller is also on the record as saying he had objections but couldn’t consult an attorney. My hunch is that the Republicans just blew kisses:love: and said “Do whatever you want.”
If the President wanted to break the law, would he have briefed Congress on what he was doing???
 
40.png
gilliam:
As for the President, the Congress gave him the authority to act.
That’s precisely the question, isn’t it? The WH claims the authority was implicit…a significant number of congress members disagree.

Also, this imbalance of powers is a bigger deal than just this specific president and this specific congress. Your point that congress and the SC not challenging is, sadly, probably accurate. IMO, Congress and the Courts have done the country a disservice by abdicating so much power to the Executive over the last few decades (a process which seems to me to be only increasing)
 
Al Masetti:
If the President wanted to break the law, would he have briefed Congress on what he was doing???
Interesting question. It does make him able to later say that they were in on it too. Which is exactly what the administration is now saying. I think it’s one of those things they have to tell about or the law-breaking would be crystal clear. I’ll ask my brother.
 
Philip P:
That’s precisely the question, isn’t it? The WH claims the authority was implicit…a significant number of congress members disagree.
Only on listening in on suspected al-Qaeda phone calls coming into the US. You really think a US Congress will seriously impeach a president of the United States over this? Come on, wake up and smell the Kansas Beef!
 
40.png
gilliam:
Hey, you don’t like what the Congress does, you complain to them.
As for the President, the Congress gave him the authority to act.
It just staggers me how some people just persist in insupportable fictions. How many times have we posted that Congress gave Bush the authority. I betcha the same posters still haven’t read the Resolution.
 
40.png
Thekla:
I don’t think that’s quite right. First of all, Daschle is on the record as saying that at the time of war authorization (or whatever it was) the president asked for this spying stuff and was told “no.” So I wonder why, if he thought he had the authority, he had to ask? Second of all, people on the committee were told they couldn’t talk about it under penalty of law. They couldn’t even consult with attorneys.

Telling congresspeople what you are doing and that they can’t talk about it is not “consultation.” Rockefeller is also on the record as saying he had objections but couldn’t consult an attorney. My hunch is that the Republicans just blew kisses:love: and said “Do whatever you want.”
These are the same Senators that tend to leak information like a sieve??? No, your reasoning doesn’t add up, Thekla. With “unidentified sources” the rage of the day, they would have got Bob Woodward involved in a heartbeat.

Notworthy
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top