Why should Bush be impeached?

  • Thread starter Thread starter NotWorthy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
estesbob:
The courts disagree with you. They have held repeatedly that the President had this power.
You may well be right, but I’ve not seen this yet. When have the courts said he can do this, independent of FISA?
Congress can not pass a law limiting the consitutional powers of the President.
Indeed, and rightly so.

Mike
 
40.png
MikeWM:
You may well be right, but I’ve not seen this yet. When have the courts said he can do this, independent of FISA?

Indeed, and rightly so.

Mike
I believe earlier in this thread we had the pertinent court cases cited, FISA is irelevant-if the courts agreed he had the power congress can not pass a law taking it away from him.

Even the Democrats are backpedalling furiously in this. now they agree it needs to be done-they just want Bush to say “mother may i” before he does it.

Much has been made out of the fact that there is bi-partisan agreement that this needs to be investigated. well of course there is. This is a classic turf battle between the exectuive and legislative branch-the kind of battle that has being going on since the Constitution was ratified. It is such tension between the branches of Govt that makes out Country great.

At any rate one thing is clear-after much intiial exhuberence on the Democrats part it it apparent that this is not the long awaited “silver bullet” to bring down the Bush presdidency.In fact as with most of the so called Bush “abuses” (remember Fitzmass?)this one has blown up in the Democrats faces.
 
40.png
gilliam:
Thekla,

When the call originates from a suspected al-Qaeda operative off-shore, it is not a domestic spying program. I’m shocked that you would use such a term. 😉
When you say “the” call, what call are you talking about?

A domestic spying program means spying on US citizens in the US. Like everybody else, I don’t care who we spy on outside of the country. However, after listening to Gonzalez yesterday, I’m now convinced that they are willfully breaking the law.
 
40.png
estesbob:
I believe earlier in this thread we had the pertinent court cases cited, FISA is irelevant-if the courts agreed he had the power congress can not pass a law taking it away from him.
Really? There is a court case in this thread that says the president doesn’t have to follow the FISA law? Please cite it and be specific because to my knowledge the FISA law has never been struck done and has been to the SC.

And you are wrong about the Congress being unable to limit the administration. Those “inherent” powers are at their weakest level when the Congress has spoken on a subject; FISA, for example.

So again. Please cite the case that deems FISA “irrelevant.”
 
40.png
Thekla:
When you say “the” call, what call are you talking about?

A domestic spying program means spying on US citizens in the US. Like everybody else, I don’t care who we spy on outside of the country. However, after listening to Gonzalez yesterday, I’m now convinced that they are willfully breaking the law.
I tried to change this but missed the time limit. BTW - I wanted to thank you for the compliment of the shock at my possibly not knowing what I am talking about. Let me put you at ease and tell you that I do. I need to amend domestic spying to include both citizens and non-citizens.
 
40.png
thestickman:
The whine and moan of the left regarding the wiretaping of Al-Qeada calls coming from outside the nation to numbers inside America won’t change the reality either.
You know for a fact that the administration is wiretapping al-queda, do you? Well you must have a special direct link to the president, then, because that’s more than the administration has felt it needs to tell the court. In fact, the administration has felt that it has to tell the court nothing.

See, that’s exactly why this is a big issue. The FISA court exists to ensure that the eavesdropping is directed at a legitimate target (Al Queda, for instance). The reason the law exists in the first place is that the executive branch has targeted illegitimate targets in the past.

Tell me, what safeguard is there against misuse of power if you remove the FISA court?
 
Philip P:
You know for a fact that the administration is wiretapping al-queda, do you? Well you must have a special direct link to the president, then, because that’s more than the administration has felt it needs to tell the court. In fact, the administration has felt that it has to tell the court nothing.

See, that’s exactly why this is a big issue. The FISA court exists to ensure that the eavesdropping is directed at a legitimate target (Al Queda, for instance). The reason the law exists in the first place is that the executive branch has targeted illegitimate targets in the past.

Tell me, what safeguard is there against misuse of power if you remove the FISA court?
That is the entire issue. It is suspected al-Qaeda operatives trying to call into the US that is the question. Should the US listen in on their calls without a court warrent. That is all the Administration is asking for. From yesterday’s speech from the President:

First, I made the decision to do the following things because there’s an enemy that still wants to harm the American people. What I’m talking about is the intercept of certain communications emanating between somebody inside the United States and outside the United States;** and one of the numbers would be reasonably suspected to be an al Qaeda link or affiliate**. In other words, we have ways to determine whether or not someone can be an al Qaeda affiliate or al Qaeda. And if they’re making a phone call in the United States, it seems like to me we want to know why.

This is a – I repeat to you, even though you hear words, “domestic spying,” these are not phone calls within the United States. It’s a phone call of an al Qaeda, known al Qaeda suspect, making a phone call into the United States. I’m mindful of your civil liberties, and so I had all kinds of lawyers review the process. We briefed members of the United States Congress, one of whom was Senator Pat Roberts, about this program. You know, it’s amazing, when people say to me, well, he was just breaking the law – if I wanted to break the law, why was I briefing Congress? (Laughter and applause.) Federal courts have consistently ruled that a President has authority under the Constitution to conduct foreign intelligence surveillance against our enemies.

Predecessors of mine have used that same constitutional authority. Recently there was a Supreme Court case called the Hamdi case. It ruled the authorization for the use of military force passed by the Congress in 2001 – in other words, Congress passed this piece of legislation. And the Court ruled, the Supreme Court ruled that it gave the President additional authority to use what it called “the fundamental incidents of waging war” against al Qaeda.

whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2006/01/20060123-4.html

You all really should listen to the whole speech:

President Discusses Global War on Terror at Kansas State University
 
Philip P:
You know for a fact that the administration is wiretapping al-queda, do you?
At least as much you do they weren’t.
Well you must have a special direct link to the president, then, because that’s more than the administration has felt it needs to tell the court. In fact, the administration has felt that it has to tell the court nothing.
:rotfl:Yeah, I love it. He had the audacity to use the authority given to him by Congress. Then he really freaked the leftists out by have the nerve to let members of Congress know what he was up to.
See, that’s exactly why this is a big issue.
IMO, it’s only a big deal the to liberals and leftists who’re seeing their stanglehold on the judiciary coming to an end. Oh, and to those who need/want to see Bush and/or America fail against terrorism.
The FISA court exists to ensure that the eavesdropping is directed at a legitimate target (Al Queda, for instance). The reason the law exists in the first place is that the executive branch has targeted illegitimate targets in the past.
The cool thing is, neither you nor I get to decide these sorts of things. The President, as CIC has the authority to decide who’s a legitimate target–not FISA because Congress has given the President this authority. Read it as many times as ya need to:)

Tell me, what safeguard is there against misuse of power if you remove the FISA court?

Since Bush didn’t remove the FISA court, your question is non-sensical. Keep ignoring the reality of President Bush informing members of Congress of the wiretaps of calls coming from outside the US by suspected Al-Qeada and you’ll continue making the same fallacious argument over and over again.

Philip, you amaze me. On one hand you write as if your certain you don’t trust the federal government not to misuse it’s power–yet, you also write as if you think the governent can handle our tax dollars appropriately as a matter of the moral good.

Would make a great topic for another thread:)

As I stated earlier, whine and moan of the left regarding the wiretaping of Al-Qeada calls coming from outside the nation to numbers inside America won’t change the reality either.

“Authorization for Use of Military Force - Authorizes the President to use all necessary and appropriate force against those nations, organizations, or persons he determines planned, authorized, committed, or aided the terrorist attacks that occurred on September 11, 2001, or harbored such organizations or persons, in order to prevent any future acts of international terrorism against the United States by such nations, organizations, or persons. States that this Act is intended to constitute specific statutory authorization within the meaning of the War Powers Resolution.”
 
Philip P:
That’s precisely the question, isn’t it? The WH claims the authority was implicit…a significant number of congress members disagree.
:rotfl:Really? How many = “a significant number”?
Also, this imbalance of powers is a bigger deal than just this specific president and this specific congress. Your point that congress and the SC not challenging is, sadly, probably accurate. IMO, Congress and the Courts have done the country a disservice by abdicating so much power to the Executive over the last few decades (a process which seems to me to be only increasing)
Time for you and like-minded folks to work to vote in new folks to the Congress then:)

Till then, you can’t make this go away: Authorization for Use of Military Force - Authorizes the President to use all necessary and appropriate force against those nations, organizations, or persons he determines planned, authorized, committed, or aided the terrorist attacks that occurred on September 11, 2001, or harbored such organizations or persons, in order to prevent any future acts of international terrorism against the United States by such nations, organizations, or persons. States that this Act is intended to constitute specific statutory authorization within the meaning of the War Powers Resolution."
 
gilliam said:

gilliam,

I am unable to listen to him (it’s not a computer problem) but I did read the text of the speech. But I have to say, “So what?” You keep saying that these are not domestic calls; calls within the US. But the president says this, “And if they’re making** a phone call in the United States**, it seems like to me we want to know why.” Is he misspeaking or muddying things?

Then you quote the president saying it again. He said, “certain communications emanating between somebody inside the United States and outside the United States.” Emanating means originating. So again, he’s either misspeaking, muddying the waters, or accidentally telling the truth. The point is that we don’t know and I don’t trust them.

Thekla
 
40.png
gilliam:
That is the entire issue. It is suspected al-Qaeda operatives trying to call into the US that is the question. Should the US listen in on their calls without a court warrent. That is all the Administration is asking for. From yesterday’s speech from the President:

First, I made the decision to do the following things because there’s an enemy that still wants to harm the American people. What I’m talking about is the intercept of certain communications emanating between somebody inside the United States and outside the United States;** and one of the numbers would be reasonably suspected to be an al Qaeda link or affiliate**. In other words, we have ways to determine whether or not someone can be an al Qaeda affiliate or al Qaeda. And if they’re making a phone call in the United States, it seems like to me we want to know why.

This is a – I repeat to you, even though you hear words, “domestic spying,” these are not phone calls within the United States. It’s a phone call of an al Qaeda, known al Qaeda suspect, making a phone call into the United States. I’m mindful of your civil liberties, and so I had all kinds of lawyers review the process. We briefed members of the United States Congress, one of whom was Senator Pat Roberts, about this program. You know, it’s amazing, when people say to me, well, he was just breaking the law – if I wanted to break the law, why was I briefing Congress? (Laughter and applause.) Federal courts have consistently ruled that a President has authority under the Constitution to conduct foreign intelligence surveillance against our enemies.

Predecessors of mine have used that same constitutional authority. Recently there was a Supreme Court case called the Hamdi case. It ruled the authorization for the use of military force passed by the Congress in 2001 – in other words, Congress passed this piece of legislation. And the Court ruled, the Supreme Court ruled that it gave the President additional authority to use what it called “the fundamental incidents of waging war” against al Qaeda.

whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2006/01/20060123-4.html

You all really should listen to the whole speech:

President Discusses Global War on Terror at Kansas State University
The courts make sure that the president is saying what he says he is.

Unquestioned trust in the executive is a feature of monarchy, not representative democracy. I’ll stick with the framers on this one.
 
Philip P:
See, that’s exactly why this is a big issue. The FISA court exists to ensure that the eavesdropping is directed at a legitimate target (Al Queda, for instance). The reason the law exists in the first place is that the executive branch has targeted illegitimate targets in the past.

Tell me, what safeguard is there against misuse of power if you remove the FISA court?
The FISA court exists to regulate DOMESTIC wiretapping. Bush has the Consitutional authority to do what he believes is necessary on foreign intelligence activities are concerned.

As far as FISA being some almighty safeguard against misuse of power-we did fine without it for 200 plus years. I suspect we could muddle on without it for another 200 years.
 
Philip P:
The courts make sure that the president is saying what he says he is.

Unquestioned trust in the executive is a feature of monarchy, not representative democracy. I’ll stick with the framers on this one.
And the framers gave the President power over foreign policy and extended powers in time of war. Given the admirable way Bush has protected this country since 9-11 I would say the framers would be pleased with how Bush has excercised this power.

Of course the framers also gave us the ultimate check on the Presidents power-the ability to vote him out after 4 years. Given the results of the last election it appears the people liked what they saw.
 
40.png
thestickman:
Philip, you amaze me. On one hand you write as if your certain you don’t trust the federal government not to misuse it’s power–yet, you also write as if you think the governent can handle our tax dollars appropriately as a matter of the moral good.

Would make a great topic for another thread:)
It would. Feel free to start one. For now I’ll sum up my position this way:
  1. I believe government can be a powerful tool for the common good
  2. Because I believe in giving the government great power, I also believe in keeping it accountable. Checks and balances, and government transparency, are absolutely essential.
That’s my attitude toward government in a nutshell. Applied to the topic at hand, it would look like this:
  1. The government should be actively using all information available to track, locate, and capture terrorists
  2. Because this gives the government a great deal of power, it is absolutely essential that the government has a strong check on this power (in this case Congress by passing FISA, and the Judiciary by having the power to approve or deny requests for electronic eavesdropping).
 
40.png
Thekla:
gilliam,

I am unable to listen to him (it’s not a computer problem) but I did read the text of the speech. But I have to say, “So what?” You keep saying that these are not domestic calls; calls within the US. But the president says this, “And if they’re making** a phone call in the United States**, it seems like to me we want to know why.” Is he misspeaking or muddying things?

Then you quote the president saying it again. He said, “certain communications emanating between somebody inside the United States and outside the United States.” Emanating means originating. So again, he’s either misspeaking, muddying the waters, or accidentally telling the truth. The point is that we don’t know and I don’t trust them.

Thekla
Speeches (even if you don’t agree with the person speaking) are meant to be listened to, not read.

The President is talking about suspected al-Qaeda outside the US talking with someone inside the US. Personally, I would hope the US government is listening to such conversations, wouldn’t you? Who placed the call is the least of my worries. That is only a concern a lawyer would have. And frankly, in the middle of a war, lawyers can argue with themselves forever for all I care. We are at war, and some people want the other side to win. Are you with us or against us? ( I think I have asked that before)…
 
40.png
estesbob:
As far as FISA being some almighty safeguard against misuse of power-we did fine without it for 200 plus years. I suspect we could muddle on without it for another 200 years.
FISA came about specifically because we were not doing all right without it. President Nixon was spying on anti-Vietnam activists, Civil Rights activists, and other groups he considered to be a political threat.
 
Philip P:
FISA came about specifically because we were not doing all right without it. President Nixon was spying on anti-Vietnam activists, Civil Rights activists, and other groups he considered to be a political threat.
FISA was a reaction to Nixon??? So why did they wait almost 25 years after he left office to pass it?

FISA has nothing to do with the issue at hand. Bush needs no approval from congress or the courts to do what he has been doing. Neither, BTW, did Clinton when he was doing it. As I have said numerous tmes Congress has no power to pass a law restricting the powers given the Presdident by the Constitution.
 
40.png
estesbob:
FISA was a reaction to Nixon??? So why did they wait almost 25 years after he left office to pass it?

FISA has nothing to do with the issue at hand. Bush needs no approval from congress or the courts to do what he has been doing. Neither, BTW, did Clinton when he was doing it. As I have said numerous tmes Congress has no power to pass a law restricting the powers given the Presdident by the Constitution.
Check you math. FISA was passed in 1978. Nixon served until 1974.
 
40.png
estesbob:
FISA was a reaction to Nixon??? So why did they wait almost 25 years after he left office to pass it?
What are you talking about? The FISA law was passed by Congress in 1978. :tsktsk:
 
40.png
gilliam:
Speeches (even if you don’t agree with the person speaking) are meant to be listened to, not read.

The President is talking about suspected al-Qaeda outside the US talking with someone inside the US.
I told you before that I am unable to listen to him. And you keep talking as if everything is crystal clear yet when I bring up the president saying things contrary to your point, they are ignored. What you are saying the president said and what he actually said are not the same things.

And the “Are you with us or against us” question is an insult and, quite frankly, it’s not worthy of my response.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top