Why should Bush be impeached?

  • Thread starter Thread starter NotWorthy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Trying to be as objective as I can about this. IMHO: At a time of war it would be extremely hard to impeach a President who was over zealous in trying to protect the lives of Americans. No matter what youre political leanings were.

Now after the war would be a different story altogether.
 
40.png
gilliam:
Now after the war would be a different story altogether.
How fortunate that he’s constructed an artificial war that has no end then.

‘I don’t think you can win it.’ (President Bush, August 2004)

Mike
 
40.png
MikeWM:
How fortunate that he’s constructed an artificial war that has no end then.
“Artifical”? :rotfl:Non-sensical.
‘I don’t think you can win it.’ (President Bush, August 2004)
Way to take one sentence out of context, in addition to making a fallacious argument.
Lauer: “You said to me a second ago, one of the things you’ll lay out in your vision for the next four years is how to go about winning the war on terror. That phrase strikes me a little bit. Do you really think we can win this war on terror in the next four years?”

President Bush: “I have never said we can win it in four years.”

Lauer: “So I’m just saying can we win it? Do you see that?”

President Bush: “I don’t think you can win it. But I think you can create conditions so that those who use terror as a tool are less acceptable in parts of the world –- let’s put it that way. I have a two pronged strategy. On the one hand is to find them before they hurt us, and that’s necessary. I’m telling you it’s necessary. The country must never yield, must never show weakness [and] must continue to lead. To find al-Qaida affiliates who are hiding around the world and … harm us and bring ‘em to justice –- we’re doing a good job of it. I mean we are dismantling the al-Qaidaas we knew it. The long-term strategy is to spread freedom and liberty, and that’s really kind of an interesting debate. You know there’s some who say well, ‘You know certain people can’t self govern and accept, you know, a former democracy.’ I just strongly disagree with that. I believe that democracy can take hold in parts of the world that are now non-democratic and I think it’s necessary in order to defeat the ideologies of hate. History has shown that it can work, that spreading liberty does work. After all, Japan is our close ally and my dad fought against the Japanese. Prime Minister Koizumi, is one of the closest collaborators I have in working to make the world a more peaceful place.”
 
40.png
MikeWM:
How fortunate that he’s constructed an artificial war that has no end then.
He didn’t attack us on 9/11, he didn’t attack the USS Cole.
‘I don’t think you can win it.’ (President Bush, August 2004)
Now that’s not fair, and I think you know it. He said that once, and almost immediately clarified it. He has said we will win this war thousands of times. I hope no one takes one of your sentances from this forum and does that to you. It is bad form.
 
40.png
gilliam:
He didn’t attack us on 9/11, he didn’t attack the USS Cole.
But he did come up with the ‘War on Terror’. He said ‘you’re with us or against us’.
Now that’s not fair, and I think you know it. He said that once, and almost immediately clarified it.
Actually, I think it is very fair. I take it in the context that he said it - as stickman has kindly reproduced above. (I don’t mean it to imply that we are ‘losing’ somehow, just that it can’t be ‘won’ in the way we understand a war). The ‘war’ is not winnable, not least because it isn’t a war. It could only be ‘won’ by the world being perfect, which isn’t going to happen. I think he is being straightforward here in saying that we shouldn’t expect the standard things of a war - the declaration of victory, the marches, the abrupt change from war to peace. I’m very glad that he understands that and is trying to explain it. The only problem left is that he called it a ‘war’ in the first place.

I’m glad Bush said that. It is a rare example of politicians trying to explain that things aren’t black and white, and that things can be (and usually are) more complicated.

Mike
 
40.png
MikeWM:
But he did come up with the ‘War on Terror’.
As you know, that is a term to describe a situation we found ourselves in.
He said ‘you’re with us or against us’.
As you also know, I agree with that statement. There is no such thing in my mind as being kinda with us and kinda with the terrorists. If you want to aid the terrorists, you are not on our side.
Actually, I think it is very fair. I take it in the context that he said it - as stickman has kindly reproduced above. (I don’t mean it to imply that we are ‘losing’ somehow, just that it can’t be ‘won’ in the way we understand a war). The ‘war’ is not winnable, not least because it isn’t a war. It could only be ‘won’ by the world being perfect, which isn’t going to happen. I think he is being straightforward here in saying that we shouldn’t expect the standard things of a war - the declaration of victory, the marches, the abrupt change from war to peace. I’m very glad that he understands that and is trying to explain it. The only problem left is that he called it a ‘war’ in the first place.
There will be a time when the Islamo-fascists will no longer be strong enough to cause much harm and can be handled with policing. When that point comes, the “war” will be over.
I’m glad Bush said that. It is a rare example of politicians trying to explain that things aren’t black and white, and that things can be (and usually are) more complicated.

Mike
 
Philip P:
I think he deserves to be impeached…
Wow.

Why… do you “… think he DESERVES to be impeached…”?

Specifically.

What evidence is there of crimes and misdemeanors?
 
40.png
Thekla:
… warrantless wiretapping inside of the United States…

Thekla:)
Is there a difference between “warrantless wiretapping inside of the United States” and

evesdropping on wireless electronic emissions outside the United States?

Hint: LINEWIRE wire taps versus WIRELESS listening in ?]
 
Al Masetti:
Wow.

Why… do you “… think he DESERVES to be impeached…”?

Specifically.

What evidence is there of crimes and misdemeanors?
I think the purpose of the presidency (and indeed of government in general) is to, well, “establish justice, insure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty.” I do not believe the president’s actions have furthered this – in fact I think they have hindered progress here.

Specifically:
  • I believe his decision to invade Iraq has increased the threat of terrorism and tied us into a counterproductive and intensely draining military commitment. Not only has our presence their failed to defend us from terror, but it has also left us less flexibility in dealing with more conventional threats such as North Korea or Iran.
  • I believe his spending priorities have imperiled our economic future, priming us for a severe economic crisis in the not-to-distant future. The undermining of our economic base will make it harder to sustain programs such as medicare, medicade, social security, federal aid for college funding, affordable housing initiatives, etc., which are essential for reducing poverty and enabling upward income mobility into the middle and higher socio-economic classes.
  • The executive power has gained too much power viz. the other branches of government, a trend this administration has exacerbated. I believe the president is establishing legal precedents that undermine safeguards against tyranny. When social instability increases as a result of the social inequality which will result from this administration’s actions, the country’s institutions may not be able to protect us.
Let me put it in the starkest terms possible. In the 30’s, most of the world was going far left (communist) or far right (fascist). The roots for that lay in the previous generation of leaders (the 20s and 10s). The US escaped this fate because FDR led us down the middle way. I believe Bush is behaving as recklessly as the leaders of the 10s and 20s. To avoid catastrophe, we will need a new FDR, and I’m not at all certain one will arise.
 
40.png
Thekla:
Mike,
Thanks for chiming in, but you are right, I’m perfectly capable of answering questions that I think merit them.
Thekla

gilliam,

I’ve been real clear about Iraq so no one should ever question where I stand on it. But I am an American so I put the Constitution of the United States far ahead of support for politicians. I have contempt for attempts to confuse, fool, or frighten the American people into willingly giving up their rights.
The you should be pleased to know that everything Bush has done is Constitutional. I have contempt for those who weaken out Country’s ability to defend itself in order to take cheap political shots at the President.

There has not been one itoa of evidence presented that what Bush did is illegal and of course no evidence whatsoever that anything he has done is an impeachable offense-its not like he LIED to a federal grand jury!
 
PhilipP,

FDR? That’s what you’re going with? You do know that FDR did warrantless wiretaps of any European-US communication during WWII, right? The same FDR who “packed the court” and interred Japanese-American citizens. That FDR? Yeah, he’s a great example of restraint in the use of executive power. :rolleyes:
 
40.png
rlg94086:
PhilipP,

FDR? That’s what you’re going with? You do know that FDR did warrantless wiretaps of any European-US communication during WWII, right? The same FDR who “packed the court” and interred Japanese-American citizens. That FDR? Yeah, he’s a great example of restraint in the use of executive power. :rolleyes:
A little history is in order. Both Lincoln and Davis had the telegraphs tapped during the Civil War. Both Wilson and Roosevelt had EVERY overseas Cable during World War I and World War II monitored. No warrant was issued or required for these actions. No warrant is required for the monitoring Bush ordered either.

I suspect next the Left is going demand we send a precess server to find Bib Laden in some cave so we can formally notify we are attempting to monitor his communications.
 
40.png
rlg94086:
PhilipP,

FDR? That’s what you’re going with? You do know that FDR did warrantless wiretaps of any European-US communication during WWII, right? The same FDR who “packed the court” and interred Japanese-American citizens. That FDR? Yeah, he’s a great example of restraint in the use of executive power. :rolleyes:
Actually, you sort of make my point. Compared to his peers (world leaders in the 30s and 40s: Mussolini, Hitler, Franco, the Japanese Emperor), FDR was a far better choice. But it was unfortunate that the world came to the pass where such a choice was even necessary. FDR was necessary because the previous generation of leaders brought the world to such a pass.

My argument is not that Bush is or is not FDR. Rather, the analogy is that we are in the equivalent of the pre-FDR position. I see Bush pushing us toward a world where an FDR - with the gigantic expansion of executive power - will be unavoidable. I don’t want that world to come to pass, where we must choose among the most benevolent of the dictators.

We were relatively lucky with FDR. What if next time around, we get a Pinochet?
 
Philip P:
Actually, you sort of make my point. Compared to his peers (world leaders in the 30s and 40s: Mussolini, Hitler, Franco, the Japanese Emperor), FDR was a far better choice. But it was unfortunate that the world came to the pass where such a choice was even necessary. FDR was necessary because the previous generation of leaders brought the world to such a pass.

My argument is not that Bush is or is not FDR. Rather, the analogy is that we are in the equivalent of the pre-FDR position. I see Bush pushing us toward a world where an FDR - with the gigantic expansion of executive power - will be unavoidable. I don’t want that world to come to pass, where we must choose among the most benevolent of the dictators.

We were relatively lucky with FDR. What if next time around, we get a Pinochet?
You get a vote in the matter… but these are not grounds for impeachment
 
So, you want someone even more powerful than Bush, as long as they are a benevolent dictator? No thanks.
Philip P:
Actually, you sort of make my point. Compared to his peers (world leaders in the 30s and 40s: Mussolini, Hitler, Franco, the Japanese Emperor), FDR was a far better choice. But it was unfortunate that the world came to the pass where such a choice was even necessary. FDR was necessary because the previous generation of leaders brought the world to such a pass.

My argument is not that Bush is or is not FDR. Rather, the analogy is that we are in the equivalent of the pre-FDR position. I see Bush pushing us toward a world where an FDR - with the gigantic expansion of executive power - will be unavoidable. I don’t want that world to come to pass, where we must choose among the most benevolent of the dictators.

We were relatively lucky with FDR. What if next time around, we get a Pinochet?
 
40.png
rlg94086:
So, you want someone even more powerful than Bush, as long as they are a benevolent dictator? No thanks.
No, I don’t want to have to make that choice. Bush is pushing us to a world where we will have to make it.
 
I guess we’ll have to disagree on that. I think Bush is exactly what we needed at this time in history.
Philip P:
No, I don’t want to have to make that choice. Bush is pushing us to a world where we will have to make it.
 
40.png
estesbob:
I suspect next the Left is going demand we send a precess server to find Bib Laden in some cave so we can formally notify we are attempting to monitor his communications.
A precess server? Can we do that? Who do you think we should send? :cool:

By the way is anyone interested in presenting evidence for treason, bribery, high crime or misdemeanour on the part of Dubya and connecting that evidence to the requirements for impeachment? That’s what this thread is about, isn’t it? Why should Bush be impeached?
 
Philip P:
No, I don’t want to have to make that choice. Bush is pushing us to a world where we will have to make it.
The cow jumped over the moon too:)
 
The reality remains: After 299 posts no one has offered any valid evidence to warrant the impeachment of President Bush.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top