Actually, you sort of make my point. Compared to his peers (world leaders in the 30s and 40s: Mussolini, Hitler, Franco, the Japanese Emperor), FDR was a far better choice. But it was unfortunate that the world came to the pass where such a choice was even necessary. FDR was necessary because the previous generation of leaders brought the world to such a pass.
My argument is not that Bush is or is not FDR. Rather, the analogy is that we are in the equivalent of the pre-FDR position. I see Bush pushing us toward a world where an FDR - with the gigantic expansion of executive power - will be unavoidable. I don’t want that world to come to pass, where we must choose among the most benevolent of the dictators.
We were relatively lucky with FDR. What if next time around, we get a Pinochet?