Why should Bush be impeached?

  • Thread starter Thread starter NotWorthy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
estesbob:
It appears you have backed away from Bush is violating the consitutiton to he is chipping away at it. What does that mean?
Violating the constitution is legal. Chipping away at it is a capital offence. Off with Dubya’s head!
 
estesbob said:
1. He is a republican
2. He opposes abortion
3. He takes his Faith Seriously
4. He opposew homosexual marriage
5. He vigorously defends our country
6. He believes the United States is a great country

For Democrats all of those are impeachable offenses

AMEN!!!
 
Heres the latest spin form the Demcorats, Per harry reid and Chuckie Schumer

They not quite sure exactly what it is Bush did that is illegal but are sure he did something illegal

They want to quickly pass a law to make whatever it is he did that was illegal legal.

In short another “silver bullet” that the Left was sure was going to bring Bush down has blown up in their faces. The biggest thing Bush has going for him is his enemies.
 
It sadly speaks volumes for the Democrats who put party politics and bickering ahead of everything else.

It’s kind of like the sweeping generality made here about spying on US citizens. Sounds real ominous. When you accurately describe it as eavesdropping on telephone conversations between suspected terrorist contacts abroad and people in the US, it doesn’t play nearly so bad.
 
From today press conference with Dick Durbin:

QUESTION: I don’t think I’ve heard any Democrats say that, though this program, in your view appears to be unconstitutional, maybe unlawful, why not say, Halt it now, and come to Congress and ask for the changes, but halt it now? I’ve not heard any Democrat say: Stop the program.

DURBIN: Well, I have to say, candidly, there are very few members of Congress who know exactly what this program’s all about. Other than press descriptions, we don’t honestly know what is being done in the name of this program.
 
40.png
estesbob:
A little history is in order. Both Lincoln and Davis had the telegraphs tapped during the Civil War. Both Wilson and Roosevelt had EVERY overseas Cable during World War I and World War II monitored.
And the Opposition opposed these Presidents vehemently. How did history paint the opposition? Not in a good light. I wonder how Kennedy and Kerry are going to like that…and Gore…and Daschle…and Pelosi… (rats, I only have 5000 word limit).

Notworthy
 
40.png
NotWorthy:
And the Opposition opposed these Presidents vehemently. How did history paint the opposition? Not in a good light. I wonder how Kennedy and Kerry are going to like that…and Gore…and Daschle…and Pelosi… (rats, I only have 5000 word limit).

Notworthy
How many times was the NY Times with the opposition? (hint: more than you might think).
 
40.png
geezerbob:
It sadly speaks volumes for the Democrats who put party politics and bickering ahead of everything else.

It’s kind of like the sweeping generality made here about spying on US citizens. Sounds real ominous. When you accurately describe it as eavesdropping on telephone conversations between suspected terrorist contacts abroad and people in the US, it doesn’t play nearly so bad.
The NYT Polls show the same thing. When you ask “Is it lawful to spy on Americans” you get majority “No”.

When you ask “Is it lawful to spy on suspected terrorists calling Americans”, you get overwhelming majority “Yes”.

The problem is the NYT only publicizes the first poll and says "Americans are against President Bush’s actions.

Notworthy
 
40.png
gilliam:
How many times was the NY Times with the opposition? (hint: more than you might think).
Correction: How many times did the NY Times lead the opposition? (hint: more than you might think).🙂

Notworthy
 
40.png
estesbob:
It appears you have backed away from Bush is violating the consitutiton to he is chipping away at it. What does that mean?
Oh no. To my knowledge I haven’t backed away from anything. I still believe that warrantless domestic spying is a violation of the Constitution of the United States. I also think that the president, who is supposed to be upholding the law, is willfully violating the FISA law enacted by Congress.

The “chipping away” part had more to do with interfering with a free press; our ability to receive information that the government has not tampered with.
 
40.png
Thekla:
Oh no. To my knowledge I haven’t backed away from anything. I still believe that warrantless domestic spying is a violation of the Constitution of the United States. I also think that the president, who is supposed to be upholding the law, is willfully violating the FISA law enacted by Congress.

The “chipping away” part had more to do with interfering with a free press; our ability to receive information that the government has not tampered with.
Listening in on al-Qaeda in foreign countries talking to people in the US is not domestic spying.
 
40.png
gilliam:
Who would you replace him with?
On this thread, I’ve never argued for impeachment. I’ve generally tried to answer the original posters question about why Mr. Bush is so disliked and I’ve always said it’s a matter of policy. From what I’ve seen, this Republican Congress would never to vote for impeachment, so it’s really a moot point. However, if I had absolute power and could replace him with anyone I wanted to, I’d pick Warren Buffet.
 
40.png
gilliam:
Listening in on al-Qaeda in foreign countries talking to people in the US is not domestic spying.
I heard Scott McClellan trying to make that dog hunt. If you are in the US talking to al Qaeda and they are spying on you, the spying is domestic even if the phone call requires more numbers. Just like if a US citizen commits a terrorist act within the country after making an international call, it’s still domestic terrorism; meaning a terrorist act perpetrated by a US citizen. The phone call doesn’t make it international terrorism.

It’s location, location, location.
 
40.png
Thekla:
I heard Scott McClellan trying to make that dog hunt. If you are in the US talking to al Qaeda and they are spying on you, the spying is domestic even if the phone call requires more numbers. Just like if a US citizen commits a terrorist act within the country after making an international call, it’s still domestic terrorism; meaning a terrorist act perpetrated by a US citizen. The phone call doesn’t make it international terrorism.

It’s location, location, location.
Nope it is your dog that won’t. If one of the callers is outside the US than it is international in nature therefore international spying. Simple definition. Both parties have to be in the US for it to be domestic in nature.

Think of it as you would inter-State commerce… it might help… or a network. An intranet has both nodes within the same company whereas an internet has at least one node outside the company.
 
40.png
gilliam:
Interesting choice.
Admit it. You thought I’d pick Oprah.😃 But seriously, Warren Buffet is one of the smartest, most sensible people in the country. There’s good reason for him to be called the “Oracle from Omaha.” And he always uses his secretary, not himself, as the example for his views on fiscal policy. I love that guy.
 
40.png
gilliam:
Nope it is your dog that won’t. If one of the callers is outside the US than it is international in nature therefore international spying. Simple definition. Both parties have to be in the US for it to be domestic in nature.

Think of it as you would inter-State commerce… it might help… or a network. An intranet has both nodes within the same company whereas an internet has at least one node outside the company.
Correct.
 
40.png
gilliam:
Nope it is your dog that won’t. If one of the callers is outside the US than it is international in nature therefore international spying. Simple definition. Both parties have to be in the US for it to be domestic in nature.

Think of it as you would inter-State commerce… it might help… or a network. An intranet has both nodes within the same company whereas an internet has at least one node outside the company.
“I’ll take olympic caliber word parsing for $800, Alex.”

I agree that the administration says it’s international spying, but we don’t agree. You are not an airplane flying from one country to another or a phone call transmitting from one country to the next. You are in the United States and you are the one being surveilled. An airplane doesn’t have rights, but you do.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top