To add to the discussion on Bush, impeachment and FISA,
… these are complex issues, so unhappily, some homework is needed. Hope you’re not intimidated by the word “homework”.
I put together a few sources.
Please read this January 19, 2006 article by Victoria Toensing. It appeared as an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal.
digenovatoensing.com/inthenews/terrorists%20on%20tap.htm
Excerpts:
The author has…” … extensive experience with the consequences of government bungling due to over-strict interpretations of FISA. As chief counsel for the Senate Intelligence Committee from 1981 to 1984, I participated in oversight of FISA in the first years after its passage. When I subsequently became deputy assistant attorney general in the Reagan administration, one of my responsibilities was the terrorism portfolio, which included working with FISA.”
“There are other valid reasons for the president not to ask Congress for a legislative fix. To have public debate informs terrorists how we monitor them, harming our intelligence-gathering to an even greater extent than the New York Times revelation about the NSA program. Asking Congress for legislation would also weaken the legal argument, cited by every administration since 1978, that the president has constitutional authority beyond FISA to conduct warrantless wiretaps to acquire foreign intelligence information.”
Justice Department career lawyers told me that the FISA statute defined its “primary purpose” as foreign intelligence gathering. Because crimes were taking place, the FBI had to shut down the wire.
FISA’s “primary purpose” became the basis for the “wall” in 1995, when the Clinton-Gore Justice Department prohibited those on the intelligence side from even communicating with those doing law enforcement. The Patriot Act corrected this problem and the FISA appeals court upheld the constitutionality of that amendment, characterizing the rigid interpretation as “puzzling.” The court cited an FBI agent’s testimony that efforts to investigate two of the Sept. 11 hijackers were blocked by senior FBI officials, concerned about the FISA rule requiring separation.
Today, FISA remains ill-equipped to deal with ever-changing terrorist threats. It was never envisioned to be a speedy collector of information to prevent an imminent attack on our soil. And the reasons the president might decide to bypass FISA courts are readily understandable, as it is easy to conjure up scenarios like the TWA hijacking, where strict adherence to FISA would jeopardize American lives.
Regarding NSA and the kind of work it does; It’s not as secret as the media makes out… So readers need to review some other material:
www.ftva.org which is a Web page for alumni of the Air Force “wing” of the National Security Agency.
www.nsa.gov especially the sections on the National Cryptologic Museum, the National Crypotolgic Museum Foundation, and the Center for Cryptologic History.
There is a lot more stuff available than one might assume.
Also review the NSA Museum and library site for Venona, which was declassified and there is TONS of information available on how the NSA worked that case.
Haynes & Klehr and Romerstein & Breindel have written detailed analyses of Venona, which can be purchased through Amazon.
Tart & Keefe have written “The Price of Vigilance” which details all the NSA aircraft that have been shot down in the line of duty.
Visit the NSA museum. The library even has free stuff on declassified cases.
OR, call the NSA gift shop, give them your credit card and ask for one of each book.
There is a lot of really good information available without relying on the MSM that insists on using expressions such as “domestic wiretaps” when the situation is actually “foreign radio monitoring”.