Why should Bush be impeached?

  • Thread starter Thread starter NotWorthy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
thestickman:
The reality remains: After 299 posts no one has offered any valid evidence to warrant the impeachment of President Bush.
In the worldview where inconvenient things are ignored, perhaps. Or in the world where you think it would be ‘warranted’, which I wonder if it exists whatever Bush might do or have done.

Mike
 
40.png
MikeWM:
In the worldview where inconvenient things are ignored, perhaps. Or in the world where you think it would be ‘warranted’, which I wonder if it exists whatever Bush might do or have done.

Mike
Mike,

In the US impeachment is governed by the US Constitution and certain criteria have to be met. We don’t just vote a government out of office before their term is up.
 
40.png
gilliam:
Mike,

In the US impeachment is governed by the US Constitution and certain criteria have to be met. We don’t just vote a government out of office before their term is up.
Well, I remain to be persuaded that he should be impeached, but I think it is clear there might be enough there to try if the political will was there. I’d be amazed if it was tried though, unless some bigger ‘bad thing’ Bush had done was found.

Mike
 
40.png
MikeWM:
Well, I remain to be persuaded that he should be impeached, but I think it is clear there might be enough there to try if the political will was there. I’d be amazed if it was tried though, unless some bigger ‘bad thing’ Bush had done was found.
There is always the danger of trivializing impeachment proceedures, which the Congress is very reluctant to do. It is a big club that should be used sparingly on the Executive Branch.
 
40.png
MikeWM:
In the worldview where inconvenient things are ignored, perhaps. Or in the world where you think it would be ‘warranted’, which I wonder if it exists whatever Bush might do or have done.

Mike
If Bush committed any high crime or misdmeanor I would 100% support his Impeachment as I would should any president be so foolish.

To the best of my knowledge he has not done so and based on what I read and know of the man, he won’t:)
 
Philip P:
I think the purpose of the presidency (and indeed of government in general) is to, well, “establish justice, insure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty.” I do not believe the president’s actions have furthered this – in fact I think they have hindered progress here.

Specifically:
  • I believe his decision to invade Iraq has increased the threat of terrorism and tied us into a counterproductive and intensely draining military commitment. Not only has our presence their failed to defend us from terror, but it has also left us less flexibility in dealing with more conventional threats such as North Korea or Iran.
  • I believe his spending priorities have imperiled our economic future, priming us for a severe economic crisis in the not-to-distant future. The undermining of our economic base will make it harder to sustain programs such as medicare, medicade, social security, federal aid for college funding, affordable housing initiatives, etc., which are essential for reducing poverty and enabling upward income mobility into the middle and higher socio-economic classes.
  • The executive power has gained too much power viz. the other branches of government, a trend this administration has exacerbated. I believe the president is establishing legal precedents that undermine safeguards against tyranny. When social instability increases as a result of the social inequality which will result from this administration’s actions, the country’s institutions may not be able to protect us.
Let me put it in the starkest terms possible. In the 30’s, most of the world was going far left (communist) or far right (fascist). The roots for that lay in the previous generation of leaders (the 20s and 10s). The US escaped this fate because FDR led us down the middle way. I believe Bush is behaving as recklessly as the leaders of the 10s and 20s. To avoid catastrophe, we will need a new FDR, and I’m not at all certain one will arise.
It appears to me that what you are calling for is a switch from the Bicameral/ three branch/ Federal system of government that the United States now has …

… to a Parliamentary system, which we do not have.
 
Al Masetti:
It appears to me that what you are calling for is a switch from the Bicameral/ three branch/ Federal system of government that the United States now has …

… to a Parliamentary system, which we do not have.
…and our Founding Fathers rejected…
 
40.png
MikeWM:
In the worldview where inconvenient things are ignored, perhaps. Or in the world where you think it would be ‘warranted’, which I wonder if it exists whatever Bush might do or have done.

Mike
Mike,

It appears to me that you are mixing features of the parliamentary system with the Bicameral / Three branch / Federal system that has been in operation in the United States.

They are two totally different systems and practices from one just don’t apply to the other.

A vote of no-confidence in a parliamentary system has no counterpart (such as impeachment) in the U.S. system.

In the U.S. there are national elections every two years in which the entire House of Representatives and 1/3 of the Senate are up for re-election. Every four years, the same plus the head of the Executive Branch.

If the electorate is upset with the way the government is being run, then at the two year point, they can literally change the government by a dramatic change in the composition of the House of Representatives. And it has happened.
 
40.png
thestickman:
The reality remains: After 299 posts no one has offered any valid evidence to warrant the impeachment of President Bush.
Correct.

Disliking Dubya or even disliking his policies does not equate to possessing evidence of treason, bribery, high crime, or misdemeanour on the part of Dubya.

What evidence exists for treason, bribery, high crime or misdemeanour on the part of Dubya?

Evidence not polemic.

If anyone has the necessary evidence, then does that evidence meet the criteria for impeachment?

Criteria not wishful thinking.

Why have so many of you completely evaded the question asked in the original post? Any good reason or just throwing around a bit of rambling prose, hoping it still stick?
 
Ani Ibi:
Correct.

Disliking Dubya or even disliking his policies does not equate to possessing evidence of treason, bribery, high crime, or misdemeanour on the part of Dubya.

What evidence exists for treason, bribery, high crime or misdemeanour on the part of Dubya?

Evidence not polemic.

If anyone has the necessary evidence, then does that evidence meet the criteria for impeachment?

Criteria not wishful thinking.

Why have so many of you completely evaded the question asked in the original post? Any good reason or just throwing around a bit of rambling prose, hoping it still stick?
Despite your use of gigantic-sized font, I’m not sure what you want/expect. There are currently no impeachment proceding being brought against the president, so any talk of impeachment is hypothetical. People have given what they believe may constitute grounds in such a hypothetical situation - the most likely being violation of FISA. The only way to see if the evidence brought would stick would be to actually have a trial - short of that, any evidence is as hypothetical as the trial itself.

Maybe you could give an example of what kind of evidence you are looking for. It might be more productive than playing with you font sizes.
 
Al Masetti:
It appears to me that what you are calling for is a switch from the Bicameral/ three branch/ Federal system of government that the United States now has …

… to a Parliamentary system, which we do not have.
How so?
 
Ani Ibi:
A precess server? Can we do that? Who do you think we should send? :cool:
Either Cindy Sheehan or Ted Kennedy. Kennedy would probably be best just in case Osam asks for a ride…
 
40.png
estesbob:
Either Cindy Sheehan or Ted Kennedy. Kennedy would probably be best just in case Osam asks for a ride…
Yes, I like those two. You’ll need Jane for the photo op, though, to prove that the papers have been served. And Michael at the camcorder. Perfect.
 
To add to the discussion on Bush, impeachment and FISA,

… these are complex issues, so unhappily, some homework is needed. Hope you’re not intimidated by the word “homework”.

I put together a few sources.

Please read this January 19, 2006 article by Victoria Toensing. It appeared as an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal.

digenovatoensing.com/inthenews/terrorists%20on%20tap.htm

Excerpts:

The author has…” … extensive experience with the consequences of government bungling due to over-strict interpretations of FISA. As chief counsel for the Senate Intelligence Committee from 1981 to 1984, I participated in oversight of FISA in the first years after its passage. When I subsequently became deputy assistant attorney general in the Reagan administration, one of my responsibilities was the terrorism portfolio, which included working with FISA.”

“There are other valid reasons for the president not to ask Congress for a legislative fix. To have public debate informs terrorists how we monitor them, harming our intelligence-gathering to an even greater extent than the New York Times revelation about the NSA program. Asking Congress for legislation would also weaken the legal argument, cited by every administration since 1978, that the president has constitutional authority beyond FISA to conduct warrantless wiretaps to acquire foreign intelligence information.”

Justice Department career lawyers told me that the FISA statute defined its “primary purpose” as foreign intelligence gathering. Because crimes were taking place, the FBI had to shut down the wire.

FISA’s “primary purpose” became the basis for the “wall” in 1995, when the Clinton-Gore Justice Department prohibited those on the intelligence side from even communicating with those doing law enforcement. The Patriot Act corrected this problem and the FISA appeals court upheld the constitutionality of that amendment, characterizing the rigid interpretation as “puzzling.” The court cited an FBI agent’s testimony that efforts to investigate two of the Sept. 11 hijackers were blocked by senior FBI officials, concerned about the FISA rule requiring separation.

Today, FISA remains ill-equipped to deal with ever-changing terrorist threats. It was never envisioned to be a speedy collector of information to prevent an imminent attack on our soil. And the reasons the president might decide to bypass FISA courts are readily understandable, as it is easy to conjure up scenarios like the TWA hijacking, where strict adherence to FISA would jeopardize American lives.

Regarding NSA and the kind of work it does; It’s not as secret as the media makes out… So readers need to review some other material:

www.ftva.org which is a Web page for alumni of the Air Force “wing” of the National Security Agency.

www.nsa.gov especially the sections on the National Cryptologic Museum, the National Crypotolgic Museum Foundation, and the Center for Cryptologic History.

There is a lot more stuff available than one might assume.

Also review the NSA Museum and library site for Venona, which was declassified and there is TONS of information available on how the NSA worked that case.

Haynes & Klehr and Romerstein & Breindel have written detailed analyses of Venona, which can be purchased through Amazon.

Tart & Keefe have written “The Price of Vigilance” which details all the NSA aircraft that have been shot down in the line of duty.

Visit the NSA museum. The library even has free stuff on declassified cases.

OR, call the NSA gift shop, give them your credit card and ask for one of each book.

There is a lot of really good information available without relying on the MSM that insists on using expressions such as “domestic wiretaps” when the situation is actually “foreign radio monitoring”.
 
40.png
estesbob:
The you should be pleased to know that everything Bush has done is Constitutional. I have contempt for those who weaken out Country’s ability to defend itself in order to take cheap political shots at the President.

There has not been one itoa of evidence presented that what Bush did is illegal and of course no evidence whatsoever that anything he has done is an impeachable offense-its not like he LIED to a federal grand jury!
You keep saying that everything he has done is Constitutional but I see some pretty big holes in that statement. At the very least, there is a lot of evidence to suggest that the president does not have the healthy respect for the Constitution that I require. There have been too many efforts to pay off and manipulate the press, imprison US citizens without charges, torture our enemies, and now spy on US citizens without warrants.

There’s a lot of emphasis on “legality” these days, but almost no mention of morality and decency. Some of the things I listed are legal. Some of the things I listed were illegal and changed. Some things I listed are teetering on the edge and the jury is still out. But there should be little doubt that several of the “troubling” things I listed are lacking in simple decency and morality.

But having concerns over the Constitution of the United States and the way many of us see it being ignored? Or chipped away at? Or sneared at? That’s not called a cheap political shot. As a matter of fact, I think it’s what has been missing; AWOL if you will (there’s your example of a cheap shot). I think it’s patriotism. I think it’s the “for real” kind of patriotism where people fight for an esoteric concept like liberty when we all know it’d be easier to let it go.
 
40.png
Thekla:
You keep saying that everything he has done is Constitutional but I see some pretty big holes in that statement. At the very least, there is a lot of evidence to suggest that the president does not have the healthy respect for the Constitution that I require. There have been too many efforts to pay off and manipulate the press, imprison US citizens without charges, torture our enemies, and now spy on US citizens without warrants.

There’s a lot of emphasis on “legality” these days, but almost no mention of morality and decency. Some of the things I listed are legal. Some of the things I listed were illegal and changed. Some things I listed are teetering on the edge and the jury is still out. But there should be little doubt that several of the “troubling” things I listed are lacking in simple decency and morality.

But having concerns over the Constitution of the United States and the way many of us see it being ignored? Or chipped away at? Or sneared at? That’s not called a cheap political shot. As a matter of fact, I think it’s what has been missing; AWOL if you will (there’s your example of a cheap shot). I think it’s patriotism. I think it’s the “for real” kind of patriotism where people fight for an esoteric concept like liberty when we all know it’d be easier to let it go.
Who would you replace him with?
 
Ani Ibi:
What laws has Bush broken?
  1. He is a republican
  2. He opposes abortion
  3. He takes his Faith Seriously
  4. He opposew homosexual marriage
  5. He vigorously defends our country
  6. He believes the United States is a great country
For Democrats all of those are impeachable offenses
 
40.png
Thekla:
You keep saying that everything he has done is Constitutional but I see some pretty big holes in that statement. At the very least, there is a lot of evidence to suggest that the president does not have the healthy respect for the Constitution that I require. There have been too many efforts to pay off and manipulate the press, imprison US citizens without charges, torture our enemies, and now spy on US citizens without warrants…
And those holes are? All of your charges are partisan attacks without basis.
There’s a lot of emphasis on “legality” these days, but almost no mention of morality and decency. Some of the things I listed are legal. Some of the things I listed were illegal and changed. Some things I listed are teetering on the edge and the jury is still out. But there should be little doubt that several of the “troubling” things I listed are lacking in simple decency and morality…
So the bar has been raised. Being constitutional is not enough-in addition Bush’s actions must meet your views on morality and decency.
But having concerns over the Constitution of the United States and the way many of us see it being ignored? Or chipped away at? Or sneared at? That’s not called a cheap political shot. As a matter of fact, I think it’s what has been missing; AWOL if you will (there’s your example of a cheap shot). I think it’s patriotism. I think it’s the “for real” kind of patriotism where people fight for an esoteric concept like liberty when we all know it’d be easier to let it go.
But no one has pointed out anything he has done that is unconstitutional. Poor Bush-not only dos ne have to meet your definition of what is moral and decent he must also meet your warped view of what is patriotic.

It appears you have backed away from Bush is violating the consitutiton to he is chipping away at it. What does that mean?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top