Why should Bush be impeached?

  • Thread starter Thread starter NotWorthy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
Thekla:
I told you before that I am unable to listen to him. And you keep talking as if everything is crystal clear yet when I bring up the president saying things contrary to your point, they are ignored. What you are saying the president said and what he actually said are not the same things…
I am not ignoring you. I am saying that it doesn’t matter who placed the call. And in all the cases I know if the calls were inbound to the US. But it really doesn’t matter, at least not to me.
And the “Are you with us or against us” question is an insult and, quite frankly, it’s not worthy of my response.
Sorry, have you ever answered it? I don’t remember an answer. Not trying to insult you, just trying to find out which side you are on. You seem so anti American, and every time we bring up something positive that is happening in Iraq, you try to belittle it. So I keep thinking you are on the al-Qaeda or Sunni insergency’s side. This is a good opportunity for you to set me straight.
 
40.png
Thekla:
Dear Al,

I have to tell you that I find it extraordinary that you vehemently argue for the administration’s domestic spying program and you don’t know “what, exactly, is FISA?” One of your earlier posts said things like, " The activities do NOT include wiretaps," and you were quite emphatic about it. So please read up on this so that others, like me, don’t make the mistake of thinking you are speaking from a fact-based position when that appears not true.

Thekla:)
I know what FISA is, but I am quite sure that several other posters on this thread have no idea.

Can you elaborate on the “administrations’ domestic spying program”?

NSA monitors wireless communications emanating from overseas. No warrants are needed. ANYBODY with a receiver can monitor wireless communications. No magic involved. The FBI monitors wireless and non-wireless communications domestically.

In time of war, what SPECIFIC recommendations would you make for monitoring wireless communications generated by terrorists or suspected terrorists?
 
40.png
gilliam:
Sorry, have you ever answered it? I don’t remember an answer. Not trying to insult you, just trying to find out which side you are on. You seem so anti American, and every time we bring up something positive that is happening in Iraq, you try to belittle it. So I keep thinking you are on the al-Qaeda or Sunni insergency’s side. This is a good opportunity for you to set me straight.
That is a disgraceful thing to say. The fact that a person has honest differences with a current administration means you think that they side with terrorist murderers? Very poor form 😦

Mike
 
40.png
MikeWM:
That is a disgraceful thing to say. The fact that a person has honest differences with a current administration means you think that they side with terrorist murderers? Very poor form 😦

Mike
No, as far as I know Thekla is not on the side of the coalition. Every piece of evidence I have from her discussions points to that. This is an opportunity for her to tell me I am wrong. She has belittled me and my son and the cause we are fighting for, for months now. I would like an answer.
 
40.png
MikeWM:
That is a disgraceful thing to say. The fact that a person has honest differences with a current administration means you think that they side with terrorist murderers? Very poor form 😦

Mike
Actually, it’s not. What concerns me is, based on the writings in these forums, gilliam’s question is not out of order.
 
40.png
gilliam:
No, as far as I know Thekla is not on the side of the coalition. Every piece of evidence I have from her discussions points to that. This is an opportunity for her to tell me I am wrong. She has belittled me and my son and the cause we are fighting for, for months now. I would like an answer.
But it isn’t a dichotomy, that is the utter falsehood of the ‘are you with us or against us?’ nonsense. You can be utterly opposed to some of the actions of the supposed ‘good guys’ - the invasion of Iraq being the obvious example - without ‘being on the side’ of the terrorist murderers.

Suicide bombers murdered over 50 people only 50 miles away from here 6 months ago. I don’t agree with many of the decisions made by the Bush administration, not least Iraq - so you think I must be on the side of the murderers that blew up my fellow citizens?

I know your son is there, and you must be both proud of him and concerned. But that doesn’t excuse your question.

Mike
 
40.png
MikeWM:
But it isn’t a dichotomy, that is the utter falsehood of the ‘are you with us or against us?’ nonsense.
Not to me it isn’t and not to my son. Either you support what we are trying to do in Iraq today or you do not. You might disagree in some tactical choices, but you wish for the same outcomes we do in Iraq. It is your choice. You could have chosen differently. You can call us simple cowboys if you wish, but that is how we think out here in big sky country.

I think I know where you stand, you have stated it many times and I respect you for it. I may disagree with your politics but I know you are not siding with the terrorists, nor the insurgents in Iraq.

But then I am not asking for you to clarify your stand, since you have made it clear so many times. I am asking Thekla to tell me I am wrong and she does not stand with the insurgents in Iraq and/or she support what we are trying to do in Iraq.
 
40.png
MikeWM:
That is a disgraceful thing to say. The fact that a person has honest differences with a current administration means you think that they side with terrorist murderers? Very poor form 😦

Mike
If Gilliam is wrong it should be fairly easy for you to come up with some posts Thelka has made tsat dispoves he contention. Until you do that i can only assume that the real intention of your post is to shut down the debate.
 
40.png
gilliam:
Not to me it isn’t and not to my son. Either you support what we are trying to do in Iraq today or you do not. You might disagree in some tactical choices, but you wish for the same outcomes we do in Iraq. It is your choice. You could have chosen differently. You can call us simple cowboys if you wish, but that is how we think out here in big sky country.

I think I know where you stand, you have stated it many times and I respect you for it. I may disagree with your politics but I know you are not siding with the terrorists, nor the insurgents in Iraq.

But then I am not asking for you to clarify your stand, since you have made it clear so many times. I am asking Thekla to tell me I am wrong and she does not stand with the insurgents in Iraq and/or she support what we are trying to do in Iraq.
Ok - I do believe the ‘with us or against us’ attitude is wrong-headed and mistaken, but I’ve made that clear.

Thekla is more than capable of answering the specific problem you have here, so I still stand by what I say, but I’ll butt out now.

Mike
 
40.png
MikeWM:
Ok - I do believe the ‘with us or against us’ attitude is wrong-headed and mistaken, but I’ve made that clear.
I know, but that is the way it is with us simple folk.
 
40.png
gilliam:
I know, but that is the way it is with us simple folk.
I don’t believe people here are simple, at all. I do believe that sometimes people look for a simple solution - understandably - when no simple solution exists.

Mike
 
40.png
MikeWM:
I don’t believe people here are simple, at all. I do believe that sometimes people look for a simple solution - understandably - when no simple solution exists.

Mike
God is Love :tiphat:
 
**General Reminder:

**This discussion has strayed from its original topic of Why should Bush be impeached??? Please return to the original topic under discussion. Thank you for your understanding and cooperation.
 
40.png
MikeWM:
Ok - I do believe the ‘with us or against us’ attitude is wrong-headed and mistaken, but I’ve made that clear.

Thekla is more than capable of answering the specific problem you have here, so I still stand by what I say, but I’ll butt out now.

Mike
Mike,
Thanks for chiming in, but you are right, I’m perfectly capable of answering questions that I think merit them.
Thekla

gilliam,

I find it interesting that you mix warrantless wiretapping inside of the United States with support for insurgents in Iraq. Was that deliberate on your part? Because the “them” in your question seems to shift and weave throughout the posts?

I think that what you are doing is part of a larger strategy to imply that anyone who does not agree with this administration’s policies is somehow aligned with terrorists. It’s a cheap shot and, apparently, easily taken since it happens so often. I said before that your question is insulting and does not merit my answer and I meant it.

I’ve been real clear about Iraq so no one should ever question where I stand on it. But I am an American so I put the Constitution of the United States far ahead of support for politicians. I have contempt for attempts to confuse, fool, or frighten the American people into willingly giving up their rights.

You didn’t get the answer you wanted? Tough. Life is more complicated than slogans on bumperstickers.
Thekla:)
 
If this discussion between Gilliam, Thekla and others is to continue, it will have to happen via PM. Please get back on topic.

Thank you.
 
40.png
Thekla:
Mike,
Thanks for chiming in, but you are right, I’m perfectly capable of answering questions that I think merit them.

I am sure there is a nicer way of saying the same thing.
Thekla

gilliam,

I find it interesting that you mix warrantless wiretapping inside of the United States with support for insurgents in Iraq. Was that deliberate on your part? Because the “them” in your question seems to shift and weave throughout the posts?

I think that what you are doing is part of a larger strategy to imply that anyone who does not agree with this administration’s policies is somehow aligned with terrorists. It’s a cheap shot and, apparently, easily taken since it happens so often. I said before that your question is insulting and does not merit my answer and I meant it.

I’ve been real clear about Iraq so no one should ever question where I stand on it. But I am an American so I put the Constitution of the United States far ahead of support for politicians. I have contempt for attempts to confuse, fool, or frighten the American people into willingly giving up their rights.

You didn’t get the answer you wanted? Tough. Life is more complicated than slogans on bumperstickers.
Thekla:)
 
OK.
  1. Who believes Bush should be impeached? Please make yourselves known.
  2. Would those of you who believe Bush should be impeached please set out the criteria for impeachment.
  3. Would those of you who believe Bush should be impeached also set forth credible evidence that Bush has committed treason, bribery, high crime or dismeanour.
  4. Would those of you who believe Bush should be impeached also set forth a connection between the criteria for impeachment and the evidence which you have for treason, bribery, high crime or dismeanour which you believe Bush has committed.
gilliam, I pursuant to Robert Bay’s request, I pm’d you. Your pm box is full. Would you clear out some space please and pm me so that I can re- pm you? Thank you. Ani
 
Ani Ibi:
  1. Who believes Bush should be impeached? Please make yourselves known.
I think he deserves to be impeached…but I’m not sure he should because impeachment is very divisive for the country. So bottom line is…no. The national interest would not be served by impeachment proceedings. But I’ll humor you and give the reasons why I believe he deserves impeachment, even if it would not be a good idea to actually go forward with it.
  1. Would those of you who believe Bush should be impeached please set out the criteria for impeachment.
Article 2, section 4:

The President, Vice President and all civil officers of the United States, shall be removed from office on impeachment for, and conviction of, treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors. For in-depth commentary, check out the bottom of this page from Cornell law, including discussion on actual historical cases of impeachment:

law.cornell.edu/anncon/html/art2toc_user.html

(for space and ease-of-reading, it makes more sense to refer readers to these links rather than post full text here):
  1. Would those of you who believe Bush should be impeached also set forth credible evidence that Bush has committed treason, bribery, high crime or dismeanour.
If Bush misled the nation, and the Congress, regarding the threat posed by Iraq, that would be impeachable. However, that is hard to prove - did he mislead, or was he simply wrong? A far more solid case would be violations of FISA. In addition, this has historical appropriateness, as it was largely in response to excesses of the Nixon administration that FISA was passed.
  1. Would those of you who believe Bush should be impeached also set forth a connection between the criteria for impeachment and the evidence which you have for treason, bribery, high crime or dismeanour which you believe Bush has committed.
The evidence of FISA violation is not clear-cut at this point. However, enough legitimate questions regarding this have been raised to justify further investigation.

This is, obviously, very quick and lacking in depth. If you are serious in wanting to know why I believe this would be grounds for impeachment, I’m happy to expand on specific points in subsequent posts.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top