T
thestickman
Guest
How about this?
mediamatters.org/items/200601040002
Sometimes an expert view proves illuminating…
Mike
How about this?
mediamatters.org/items/200601040002
Sometimes an expert view proves illuminating…
Mike
Well, yesNot if the “expert” is wrong.
I thought it was previously (at least since the late 70s) done through the FISA court.The president is not acting without counsel, you know. I’m certain they have their constitutional lawyers who have a case laid out for the wiretapping - as previous presidents have done.
Yes, indeed. It probably isn’t ‘clearly’ illegal. It may nevertheless be illegal, and I think the point this guy is saying is that once it is found to be illegal or likely to be illegal, if Bush says ‘well I’m going to carry on anyway’ then we’re in just that situation.Now, if it was clearly illegal, and the president said “I’m going to do it anyway”, then he would be breaking the law and therefore have committed an impeachable offense.
thestickman said:That’s funny. It’s not against the law to spy/listenin/wiretape a phone call from a suspected member of Al-Qeada when they call a number inside the US.
uchicagolaw.typepad.com/faculty/2005/12/presidential_wi_1.htmlPresidential Wiretapping: Disaggregating the Issues
The legal questions raised by President Bush’s wiretapping seem to me complex, not simple. Here is a rough guide: (1) Did the AUMF authorize his action? (2) If not, does the Constitution give the President inherent authority to do what he did? (3) If the answer to (1) or (2) is yes, does his action violate the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA)? (4) If the answer to (3) is yes, is FISA constitutional, or is it inconsistent with the President’s inherent authority? (5) If the answer to (1) or (2) is yes, does the wiretapping nonetheless violate the Fourth Amendment?
Well, yes
I thought it was previously (at least since the late 70s) done through the FISA court.
I thought the actual issue was that President Bush did it outside of the FISA court’s jurisdiction, and that the question was whether he could do that.
I’m still not convinced that question has been answered.
Yes, indeed. It probably isn’t ‘clearly’ illegal. It may nevertheless be illegal, and I think the point this guy is saying is that once it is found to be illegal or likely to be illegal, if Bush says ‘well I’m going to carry on anyway’ then we’re in just that situation.
Mike
YesIt’s not as simple as that Mike…from The University of Chicago Law School faculty blog:
uchicagolaw.typepad.com/faculty/2005/12/presidential_wi_1.html
Clear as mud isn’t it?![]()
Fallacious question. Reagan’s former AG can be just as wrong on this issue as you areOk, we’ll try it that way. Reagan had a deputy attorney-general who doesn’t know what is legal and what isn’t. Better?
Mike
:yup:Fallacious question. Reagan’s former AG can be just as wrong on this issue as you areIn fact, every former AG in the history of the nation is capable of being wrong as well. Because it’s Reagan’s former AG makes him no more or no less apt to be correct.
Being in error on this issue in no way infers or suggests the former AG is/was “doesn’t know what is legal and what isn’t.”
Lots of folks with the right experience – both Democrats and Republicans – seem to be coming out with convincing arguments that President Bush’s “impeachable” executive order authorizing certain eavesdropping of terrorist suspects and contacts without a court order is in fact perfectly legal.
First John Schmidt, Associate Attorney General in the Clinton Administration, writes:
President Bush’s post- Sept. 11, 2001, authorization to the National Security Agency to carry out electronic surveillance into private phone calls and e-mails is consistent with court decisions and with the positions of the Justice Department under prior presidents.
…
In the Supreme Court’s 1972 Keith decision holding that the president does not have inherent authority to order wiretapping without warrants to combat domestic threats, the court said explicitly that it was not questioning the president’s authority to take such action in response to threats from abroad.
Four federal courts of appeal subsequently faced the issue squarely and held that the president has inherent authority to authorize wiretapping for foreign intelligence purposes without judicial warrant.
In the most recent judicial statement on the issue, the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court of Review, composed of three federal appellate court judges, said in 2002 that “All the … courts to have decided the issue held that the president did have inherent authority to conduct warrantless searches to obtain foreign intelligence … We take for granted that the president does have that authority.”
In other words, even the court that grants the warrants concedes that in certain situations, the warrants are not needed – and these situations are those under discussion now.
Schmidt also noted, as I did earlier, that Jamie Gorelick, who was Deputy Attorney General in the Clinton Administration, and more recently a member of the “9/11 Commission,” testified before Congress on July 14, 1994:
“The Department of Justice believes, and the case law supports, that the president has inherent authority to conduct warrantless physical searches for foreign intelligence purposes, and that the President may, as has been done, delegate this authority to the Attorney General.”
So, Reagan’s *former *is against Bush, and Clinton’s *formers *are for Bush.Liberal Law Professor Cass Sunstein of the University of Chicago is not entirely decided, but he seems to think it’s likely the President has the authority to wiretap people against whom he also has the right to use military force. The alternative is truly bizzarre – he can order a terrorist bombed, but can’t listen to his phone calls?
You know, this quote by Gorelick gets repeatedly misused by the administration and its supporters…
“The Department of Justice believes, and the case law supports, that the president has inherent authority to conduct warrantless physical searches for foreign intelligence purposes, and that the President may, as has been done, delegate this authority to the Attorney General.”
The reason it’s misused is obvious, but the error in using it lies in the fact that the Clinton administration was not arguing about something already covered by law. They were arguing for something **not **covered by a specific law. The wiretapping of American citizens without a warrant was already addressed by the Congress with a very specific law and court, so to claim that the Bush administration’s argument is the same as the Clinton administration’s is patently false.
I agree. I have read enough to be totally confused on the issue.As I have no idea, I will gladly give you that point…now what about the John Schmidt quote and the point made in the Univ. of Chicago blog, I originally referenced. Do wish to argue with these attorneys who are directly addressing the Bush issue?
Personally, I’m not convinced either way. I’m hearing very strong, valid arguments from attorneys on both sides, so I’m always amazed when other non-legally trained people are so sure of the legality/illegality of Bush’s actions.
Congress can not pass a law limiting the Constitutional powers of the Presdident. Bush was under no obligation to follow FISA law when dealing in a National security issues concering foreign nationals. The courts has repeatedly ruled the Presdient has this authority.You know, this quote by Gorelick gets repeatedly misused by the administration and its supporters…
“The Department of Justice believes, and the case law supports, that the president has inherent authority to conduct warrantless physical searches for foreign intelligence purposes, and that the President may, as has been done, delegate this authority to the Attorney General.”
The reason it’s misused is obvious, but the error in using it lies in the fact that the Clinton administration was not arguing about something already covered by law. They were arguing for something **not **covered by a specific law. The wiretapping of American citizens without a warrant was already addressed by the Congress with a very specific law and court, so to claim that the Bush administration’s argument is the same as the Clinton administration’s is patently false.
Actually it was an attempt at vague humour. I’d hoped that someone who spends so much of his time rolling around laughing at things would have seen that. Oh well…Your post, IMO, is another glaring example of disordered thinking.
I agree. This much is clear:Personally, I’m not convinced either way. I’m hearing very strong, valid arguments from attorneys on both sides, so I’m always amazed when other non-legally trained people are so sure of the legality/illegality of Bush’s actions.
I prefer they have rules governing their conduct and follow them. An attitude of ‘anything goes’ isn’t helpful. In this case there are the rules under FISA. If you want to change the rules, then you make the case for doing so, but you don’t just ignore them because they are inconvenient.Meanwhile, a couple of CIA field agents in hip deep snow in a valley in the Hindu Kush mountains find a cell phone with some phone numbers on it…
…
I agree. This much is clear:
One for the lawyers, and they obviously don’t agree either.
- This isn’t the same scenario as the actions of immediately preceding presidents.
- No-one is quite sure if the President is allowed to do this without FISA - or, that if FISA stops him doing so, if then FISA is itself constitutional.
So, it’s an argument. It can’t be trivially dismissed, but it isn’t obvious that it is wrong either.
Mike
With all do respect, I disagree. It is my understanding that under our Constitution, the Supreme Court has no say in the matter. The house studies the issue. They decide if charges should be filed with the Senate, and the Senate tries him. If he is “found guilty”, that is to say, articles of Impeachment are voted upon and passed by the Senate, he is removed from office.Bottomline for me: If it is determined by the Supreme Court that the President is acting outside of the authority given to him by the Constitution, then he should cease and desist. If he doesn’t (basically giving an ‘up yours’ to the SCOTUS), then articles of impeachment should be drawn up.
With all do respect, I disagree. It is my understanding that under our Constitution, the Supreme Court has no say in the matter. The house studies the issue. They decide if charges should be filed with the Senate, and the Senate tries him. If he is “found guilty”, that is to say, articles of Impeachment are voted upon and passed by the Senate, he is removed from office.
I would be very surprised if the current House would vote in favor of issuing the articles on these particular charges.
Instead, I see the congress consulting with the President and amending the laws to give him what he wishes.
Sure, but they don’t have to sue to impeach the President. Articles just need to be passed by the House (normally the Judicial Committee draws them up).Are you sure? If someone sues the government for being wiretapped illegally, wouldn’t it eventually end up in the Supreme Court? Otherwise, why do the lawyers talk about previous court decisions? Are they talking about the House?
Sure, but they don’t have to sue to impeach the President. Articles just need to be passed by the House (normally the Judicial Committee draws them up).
Remember, impeachment is a political tool, not a judicial tool. It removes someone from office, that is all.