Why should I remain Catholic vs. become a Buddhist or a Hindu?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Susansdec
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
#1 The Creator has dominion over the created.
#2 How many people did God create, heal, raise from the dead, feed? How many did Buddha? Can you name even one miracle Buddha performed?
 
Last edited:
Because it is too complex and too difficult.
Interesting, especially since Jesus Christ said (Matt 11, 30)
30 For my yoke is easy, and my burden is light.
Note that in the state of sanctifying grace one can remain free from mortal sins – with the cooperation with grace – what is impossible for man is possible with God.
 
Last edited:
o*ssum So none of the Christian bad things count, b

AI find it very odd that you are blaming others for ‘evil’. As I noted in another thread, Buddhism has no belief in evil or good, and has always stated that good and evil are illusions.

That Buddhists don’t believe in good and evil and teach that there is no self, that we are all illusions, has resulted in true, horror in the last century. The books “The Rape of Nanking” and “Zen at War” explain how Buddhist belief that we are all illusions resulted in such monstrous deeds as surgery without anesthesia, medical experiments that were, if anything, worse than anything done by the Nazis, vast numbers of rapes, burying civilians alive, and so on. All due to Buddhist dogmas that insisted there was no such thing as good or evil and there was not even such a thing as self; that you are no-self and so is that person across from you. .

As I noted elsewhere: the most frequent complaint against Buddhism is its utter lack of good effect upon society. Walls enclosed monks, meditating on nothing, while around them people starved, rotted in prisons, were enslaved, lived in misery, in unending centuries…

In the first 500 years of Buddhism, one historian could find only two hospitals to the credit of Buddhists. Two. Two, in five hundred years.

Compare this to Christianity. Even during the early Roman persecutions, every single Catholic church had a charity to feed the poor, and aid the widows and even aid non Christians. During the plague, when the Roman physician Galen fled the city, Christians stayed and gave up their lives taking care of pagans. And speaking of hospitals, pretty much the second the persecutions were over, Christians set up free hospitals. Many historians argue that St. Basil of Caesarea founded the first real hospital in the world in the mid 300s, and thereafter free medical aid was found in Christian hospitals in pretty much every city of size throughout the ancient Roman empire. But of course it wasn’t simply aiding the sick. Christians, for the first time in history, founded homes to take care of the deaf, the mute, and even lepers.

Look, you cannot compare the positive effect, the staggeringly constructive effect, Christianity has had upon the world to the utter void that has been Buddhism. The Catholic church gave the world human rights. The universities. Science. Most of all, the morality, which utterly changed the world for the better. And, of course, hope. God will provide absolute justice to every person who suffered on this earth, will fill hearts battered by lack of love with perfect love, and has given us all eternal life, conquering the ultimate evil, death, forever.
 
How many people did God create, heal, raise from the dead, feed? How many did Buddha? Can you name even one miracle Buddha performed?
You would do well to study more of Buddhism before asking such questions. At the very least a quick Google search would pull up a page like: Miracles of Gautama Buddha.

As for feeding people, the Bodhisattva Vimalakirti fed a whole city, 84,000 people, from a single bowl of rice. See chapter 10 of the Vimalakirti Nirdesa sutra.
 
In the first 500 years of Buddhism, one historian could find only two hospitals to the credit of Buddhists. Two. Two, in five hundred years.
I suspect your single source is in error here. Many monasteries had hospitals attached to them, though they would be recorded in the histories as monasteries, not stand-alone hospitals.
 
rossum.
You would do well to study more of Buddhism before asking such questions. At the very least a quick Google search would pull up a page like: Miracles of Gautama Buddha.
*

You have such a tendency toward distortion. Name some historians that believe there even was a Buddha. Go ahead. And as for the miracles, good grief, can you name even one Buddhists who believe in them? Do you? Of course Buddhists argue that all is illusion, so perhaps.

At any rate, this is in startling contrast to the New Testament, which was so close in time to the historical Jesus.
 
At any rate, this is in startling contrast to the New Testament, which was so close in time to the historical Jesus.
Buddhist scriptures date back to the First Council, shortly after the Buddha died. All you are doing here is showing your ignorance of Buddhism.
 
And not Buddhist or Hindu??? Please convince me… I’m ready… thank you…
The greatest and best answer is that you should be whatever is dominant to the culture in which you live.

If I move to Japan, I’m going to observe Shinto and Buddhism. Saudi Arabia, Islam.

You get the point.
 
I disagree; the greatest and best answer to go with what you know is true.
 
Unlike Catholicism, Hinduism does not have the forgiveness of sins. If you are sinful in this life you are reincarnated into a lower caste or even a lower life form as punishment, and this cycle goes on and on for all eternity until you gain liberation through intense spiritual self-exploration and perfection.

This belief has been used for centuries to justify the barbaric conditions and treatment of the Untouchables. Their lot in the current life is cosmic punishment for their sins in a previous life, and so there is no point in trying to improve their condition. I wouldn’t be surprised if this affects the psychology of those Untouchables; after all, if you believe that you deserve your current state living in grinding poverty surrounded by filth and disease, then you have no real motivation to improve your own current situation. That same concept can easily apply to any terrible situation you can find in the West.

I think that is horrifying. Why would you want to immerse yourself in such a belief system? Christianity recognizes the imperfections of mankind and offers salvation through the forgiveness of sins via Jesus Christ and the clear specific paths laid out by the Catholic Church. If you are honest with yourself and your repentance, you can attain salvation without total perfection and self-awareness. With Hinduism, how do you know if you did it all correctly? You don’t.

On top of that there’s the animal sacrifice practiced by some Hindu sects. For example, about a month ago some 3,500 buffalo were ritually beheaded in Nepal. God gave man dominion over animals, but that does not justify animal cruelty.

Then there’s the vegetarianism. That’s an incredibly unhealthy lifestyle that leads to all sorts of health problems such as diabetes, heart disease, and malnutrition.

Stay Catholic.
 
.
ricmat said:
Buddhism is not compatible with Christianity.
Buddhism is an ‘enlightenment by works’ religion. Nobody else, not even one of the gods, is going to enlighten you. That is something you have to do for yourself.

None of the necessary works: avoid evil, do good, meditate, are contrary to Christianity. From the Buddhist side, the two are compatible.
Love God above all else, and oh by the way, love your neighbor as yourself.
The Buddha said: “Love others as you love yourself” – Bhadramayakaravyakarana sutra 91.
They totally don’t have, and don’t care about the Love God above all else part.
All gods are included in “love others” above.

The above is a meaningless statement. You learn how to “enlighten” in Buddhism, which is why they have books. Then, you follow the path. All religions are the same.
 
40.png
Angel_Bradford:
Because Jesus is God made man; Buddha never said he was God. Buddha said to “follow my doctrines; Jesus said, “Follow me”.

Now my question is, do you want to follow a doctrine written by a man or do you want to follow God?
How many people does God kill? How many people does the Buddha kill?

I know which one I prefer.
Well, of course, especially if you do not believe that God created anybody.
 
…If you are sinful in this life you are reincarnated into a lower caste or even a lower life form as punishment…
Just a minor correction - most Hindus do not believe that you can reincarnate in a ‘lower life form’. Most believe you will always reincarnate as a human being, perhaps in a lower station in life if you have a lot of bad karma to pay off. The possibility of being reborn as an animal is more of a Buddhist belief not a Hindu one.

Anyway, it does not matter which religion you choose, everyone regardless of religion, will be subjected to the same process after death. If the theory of reincarnation is true, everyone will have to go through being reborn (unless they have been liberated) whatever their current belief system maybe.
 
Last edited:
Just correcting misconceptions. Depending on the specific Hindu tradition God actually does forgive sins and mitigates the effects of Karma.
This belief has been used for centuries to justify the barbaric conditions and treatment of the Untouchables. Their lot in the current life is cosmic punishment for their sins in a previous life, and so there is no point in trying to improve their condition
Also not authentic Hindu belief. Original texts/ culture had more of a checks and balances system to prevent one group from being too powerful. No Hindu system “justifies” mistreatment of those of “lower castes” and whole Hindu traditions repudiate this. Many Hindus see caste a social system that became corrupt over time, not part of religion or or the salvation concept.

“Plant based diets” are these days being advocated as healthy, having said that, also not necessary for all Hindus.
 
Are you considering converting to Buddhism or Hinduism? Both of those religions ignore God. Hindus worship false gods and Buddhists are indifferent to God. Some Buddhist believe in God and some don’t. God is so loving!!! He made you!!! He gave you everything you had!!! He loves you and protects you and keeps you safe!!! The thought of anyone knowingly abandoning him is so sad!!! We must pray that they return to the Catholic faith!!! Jesus died on the Cross. Think about how painful that must have been!!! Can you imagine what it’s like to be nailed to a cross? He was mocked, ridiculed, and scorned!! People made fun of him constantly!!! He went through SO MUCH Pain. Did the Buddha die for the salvation of mankind? No, he did not. Did the founder of Hinduism die for the salvation of mankind? No, he did not. I think we both know what the right decision is. I really hope you choose to stay Catholic and I’ll be praying that you make the right choice. 🙂
 
Did the Buddha die for the salvation of mankind? No, he did not.
The Buddha taught mankind how to attain enlightenment for themselves, and people have been doing so ever since… It is an error to assume that Indian religions have the same goals as the Abrahamic religions.
 
Are you a Catholic or a Buddhist? Teaching people to to attain enlightenment is not the same thing as dying (It’s a lot less painful!) Jesus went through a LOT of pain that the Buddha didn’t go through. God watches over us constantly. The Buddha does not. I’ll admit, that I don’t know much about Buddhism, but I do know that they are agnostic (at best) And you’re right, I’m sure they do have a different goal than the Abraham religions. 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top