Why would anyone want to be a Mormon or Jehovah Witnesses?

  • Thread starter Thread starter TheSufi
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
That isn’t relevant since temples were not where couples got married.
So going to my point — why are the qualifications for entry into the ancient temple, which are no different with the temples now, such a problem to understand?

Otherwise, unrepentant people should have been allowed into the ancient temple, as that what you are suggesting?
 
The WoW talks about “hot drinks,” and the interpretation of that over time has always seemed a bit funny to me. First, hot drinks applies to tea whether it’s hot or not, and to anything with caffeine. Second, hot chocolate is in bounds, despite being a hot drink while plenty of cold drinks are excluded. Third, certain kinds of soft drinks used to be banned according to authoritative interpretation, but that same authoritative interpretation has placed some of them back in bounds more recently.
You have no disagreement from me on that point.
 
I’m just saying that when answering the question: Why would anyone want to be a Mormon; and a Mormons tells me about families forever and family home evening; I don’t see anything there that I don’t have in Catholicism. So for me, it doesn’t answer the question.
Well, I think a living prophet would answer the question. Kind of, at least.
 
You have no disagreement from me on that point.
It’s one of those things that makes me look on the diversification of Mormonism with some approval- meaning, in and around Provo, Utah, things are going to be a lot more strictly orthoprax in general while in some other parts of the US or overseas, certain things won’t be adhered to as strictly. And rather than label these people as bad Mormons, maybe they can be seen as a slightly different expression of Mormonism. Or- rather than look at them as apostates, maybe it’s more like Orthodox Jews compared with Ultra-Orthodox Jews. I tend to look on it with approval when (imo) silly teachings are not adhered to, but I do realize the same principle can easily be applied to teachings that are not silly. Being a mixed bag as it is, it will be interesting to see how Mormon presidents and Quorum members handle those trends in the future.
 
I am blessed in having been born a Catholic, and would never change

However… Sometimes I look at many parishes and think that if someone came to see these Christian communites, would they be attracted / temptedvto join them? travel a lot and frequently go to Mass in different churches - most often I am ignored. I am not welcomed nor am I made to feel welome. There is little outward sign of Christian love.

The JWs while for us are techinally not Christian are very christian in their lives. They have a very deep sense of fellowship. I can only imagine that this is one of the things which tempts people to join the JWs.
Very true I have to agree with being raised momon they have a strong community. When I go to mass nobody really says hi hows your family nothing. In the LDS they are always there helping each other with it be moving or projects. I am glad that I went to RCIA but I have to say the mormons do have a way tighter community with in them selfs.
 
Very true I have to agree with being raised momon they have a strong community. When I go to mass nobody really says hi hows your family nothing. In the LDS they are always there helping each other with it be moving or projects. I am glad that I went to RCIA but I have to say the mormons do have a way tighter community with in them selfs.
I have to agree with Army. Even my priest and deacon agree that as catholics, we are lacking in the love thy neighbor catergory. We are not a well put unit.

Army, are you currently deployed overseas? Even if your not, thanks for everything you do.
211th Company, Hooah!!
 
I have to agree with Army. Even my priest and deacon agree that as catholics, we are lacking in the love thy neighbor catergory. We are not a well put unit.

Army, are you currently deployed overseas? Even if your not, thanks for everything you do.
211th Company, Hooah!!
We are deployed right now also. You guys just got back right?
 
We are deployed right now also. You guys just got back right?
I am no longer in the Army. My old unit got back not to long ago. I was a 67 Romeo at the time (Apache Maintenence) They have come and gone a few times since 9/11.
 
Your church manuals have changed! I quoted from two of them from the 1970’s. The context is what I told you, as I was taught from these manuals. I had no doubt at that time, whatsoever, that exaltation meant billions of spirit children who would need a planet to live on, and a God to worship. (Which isn’t the heavenly mother of course, but would be the husband.)

But you can just keep pretending that your church never taught these things. :rolleyes:
Personally, I find LDS apologetics fascinating for this very reason. A few years back I was perusing an ex-LDS website that had lots of gripping stories. I read of one account where a missionary lost his LDS faith after reading about the Adam-God doctrine. As in, he had no idea it ever existed before some guy whose door he knocked on told him about it.

I’m also fascinated by LDS members’ ideas of persecution. I have no doubt the average Mormon is probably faced with more prejudice than your everyday Christian, but what Mormons tend to think we Gentiles believe seem a little whack. I’m an occasional freelance comedy writer and I belong to an online workshop. Back when Romney was running for president one fellow writer (who was Mormon came up with an idea for an article involving every single stereotype or myth about the LDS church and how IT WAS ALL TOTALLY NOT TRUE YOU GUYS.

His list of stereotypes were pretty odd. It ran from Mormon underwear being magical fire resistant armor to Mormons having horns. Like, on their head. This young man truly thought that everyone not affiliated with the LDS church actually believed that Mormons were horned polygamists wearing magical underwear who robbed graves to baptize corpses. And he wasn’t the only one. There were a couple of other LDS writers chiming in with crazy examples of Mormon stereotypes. I mean, how do you explain to someone that you don’t think his garments are magical, and neither does he, and besides magic isn’t real,* and he knows that too?*

It was without a doubt one of the most surreal online discussions I’d ever had.
 
Personally, I find LDS apologetics fascinating for this very reason. A few years back I was perusing an ex-LDS website that had lots of gripping stories. I read of one account where a missionary lost his LDS faith after reading about the Adam-God doctrine. As in, he had no idea it ever existed before some guy whose door he knocked on told him about it.

I’m also fascinated by LDS members’ ideas of persecution. I have no doubt the average Mormon is probably faced with more prejudice than your everyday Christian, but what Mormons tend to think we Gentiles believe seem a little whack. I’m an occasional freelance comedy writer and I belong to an online workshop. Back when Romney was running for president one fellow writer (who was Mormon came up with an idea for an article involving every single stereotype or myth about the LDS church and how IT WAS ALL TOTALLY NOT TRUE YOU GUYS.

His list of stereotypes were pretty odd. It ran from Mormon underwear being magical fire resistant armor to Mormons having horns. Like, on their head. This young man truly thought that everyone not affiliated with the LDS church actually believed that Mormons were horned polygamists wearing magical underwear who robbed graves to baptize corpses. And he wasn’t the only one. There were a couple of other LDS writers chiming in with crazy examples of Mormon stereotypes. I mean, how do you explain to someone that you don’t think his garments are magical, and neither does he, and besides magic isn’t real,* and he knows that too?*

It was without a doubt one of the most surreal online discussions I’d ever had.
Ha, yeah, I’ve heard all of those, and more. There’s a really old one that says Mormons kidnap women to make them their polygamist wives. The women sometimes escape by jumping out a window of the SLC temple, into the Great Salt Lake. If you’ve never been to SLC, the SLC Mormon temple is miles from the lake!

I heard that one when I was growing up, and we laughed at how silly “Gentiles” were to believe such a thing. 😃
 
Personally, I find LDS apologetics fascinating for this very reason. A few years back I was perusing an ex-LDS website that had lots of gripping stories. I read of one account where a missionary lost his LDS faith after reading about the Adam-God doctrine. As in, he had no idea it ever existed before some guy whose door he knocked on told him about it.

I’m also fascinated by LDS members’ ideas of persecution. I have no doubt the average Mormon is probably faced with more prejudice than your everyday Christian, but what Mormons tend to think we Gentiles believe seem a little whack. I’m an occasional freelance comedy writer and I belong to an online workshop. Back when Romney was running for president one fellow writer (who was Mormon came up with an idea for an article involving every single stereotype or myth about the LDS church and how IT WAS ALL TOTALLY NOT TRUE YOU GUYS.

His list of stereotypes were pretty odd. It ran from Mormon underwear being magical fire resistant armor to Mormons having horns. Like, on their head. This young man truly thought that everyone not affiliated with the LDS church actually believed that Mormons were horned polygamists wearing magical underwear who robbed graves to baptize corpses. And he wasn’t the only one. There were a couple of other LDS writers chiming in with crazy examples of Mormon stereotypes. I mean, how do you explain to someone that you don’t think his garments are magical, and neither does he, and besides magic isn’t real,* and he knows that too?*

It was without a doubt one of the most surreal online discussions I’d ever had.
The JWs consider us to be cannibals if we say that we eat the flesh of Christ.
 
His list of stereotypes were pretty odd. It ran from Mormon underwear being magical fire resistant armor to Mormons having horns. Like, on their head. This young man truly thought that everyone not affiliated with the LDS church actually believed that Mormons were horned polygamists wearing magical underwear who robbed graves to baptize corpses.
Yeah, I have met some very sheltered mormons who believe all sorts of strange things about the world and people in it. As far as ‘persecution’ goes, I really have very little to complain about. I’ve read stories of real persecution. Never had a loved one killed, never been a victim of bigoted violence, never been treated like a 2nd class citizen (except once or twice by individuals at various christian-based homeschool co-ops).

But I do have a list of funny anecdotes.
  • When my wife was flying to Orlando, she sat next to somebody who was genuinely curious about the medical procedure my wife had done to her skull, to remove the horns. No really - this person honestly did believe mormons had some congenital birth defect thing going on, creating long lumpy bone masses that needed to be corrected at birth. I don’t think this guy believed my wife’s claims that no really, mormons don’t have horns.
  • We had a pet sitter who was also a good friend. She and my wife had similar outlooks on life and stinging senses of humor. When it dawned on her one day that we were mormon, she actually took a step backwards and raised her hands as if she was afraid we were going to hit her. She thought that us being mormon meant that she couldn’t be friends with us any more. She eventually thought things through and realized she was being silly, but it did change the relationship. One time when we got home from vacation, she was beside herself with fear and worry, because one of our dogs had gotten loose and run around the neighborhood for about a half an hour. She thought we would be mad at her.
My wife: “So, you did find [our dog] and she’s fine now, right?”
Petsitter: “Yes - I made sure she’s fine, and I gave her extra treats, and I’m so sorry, and…”
My wife: “Good. Because you know, it’s against our religion for you to lose our dog…”

The petsitter sort of flinched and cringed - pulling her chin down to her chest and hiding behind her shoulder. Then after a few seconds, she realized my wife was joking and she finally lightened up.
  • I have met exactly one person (she was a 17 yr old teen at the time) who honestly believed we dug up corpses to baptize them. She was wondering if we left them in the coffins or not when we baptized them, because “wouldn’t the bones and rotting flesh and stuff make the water dirty?”
  • My nonreligious father’s gall bladder exploded, and after the surgery, his doctor told him he had to give up beer or be dead within a year. He accused the doctor of just saying that because he was a mormon. Then he got a second opinion from a nonmormon doctor who told him the same thing, and gave up beer. But to his dying day (over a decade later), he had various conspiracy theories about how the mormons were after him, and how “bad the inbreeding problem” was. He was a hoot. I miss him.
But yeah, this hardly rises to the level of stories appearing in Fox’s book of Martyrs. Just funny anecdotes.
 
I was visited by some Mormons, and after listening to them, I don’t understand why anyone would want to be a Mormon, except that they were born into it. They had no choice in the matter. But to convert to it. I would rather be an Orthodox or Catholic before being a Mormon, the Mormons have no spiritual tradition outside of outward prayer.

And I feel the same about Jehovah Witnesses as well. Why convert to these two group?
I can’t’ answer for the JWs; but the best answer from a Mormon perspective is to put yourself in the situation of someone asking that question in the early days of Islam. Why would someone in the early days of Islam, or in the days of the Prophet Muhammad, want to be a Muslim? It had no “spiritual tradition” as yet. It was a young religion. Spiritual traditions take time to develop. Your question amounts to saying, “A religion is not worth joining until it is old!” Well that is silly. If a religion is true, it is worth joining at any stage in its history. If it is not true, then it is not worth joining at any stage in its history.

There is another potential problem. A religion may have been true when it started, but not true any more! An old religion does not necessarily mean a true religion. Are you looking for truth, or are you looking for pomp and ceremony and tradition? The question one should ask about any religion before joining is whether its claims are true or not. And if its claims were true at one time, whether they remain true still. That is the right approach before joining a new religion.
 
The question one should ask about any religion before joining is whether its claims are true or not. And if its claims were true at one time, whether they remain true still. That is the right approach before joining a religion.
Mormonism fails both.
 
Mormonism fails both.
That is one possible perspective, obviously. I am not denying that. What I am saying is that the criteria by which he is trying to judge a religion is not the right one—whether it is Mormonism or something else.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top