Why young couples aren't getting married

  • Thread starter Thread starter TheTrueCentrist
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, but with a joint account not being married, it is more difficult to split and separate those shared assets. (Now being married, you are probably entitled to less total assets, because you make more than her, but it is all martial property). But as unmarried, she could have tried to show that the assets in the account were a gift to get a larger share. Either way lawyer’s bill and court costs would be extreme, if it was a contentious break up. (Costs can be mitigated with a settlement).
Lol, believe me, there was never nearly enough in that shared account to justify the costs of a legal battle. There was just enough to cover the bills and groceries and that was about it.

I was committed though; she was largely dependent on me and not the other way around. I was committed in my heart to taking care of her. We did go through a rough patch once and I considered ending it, but I worried about what would happen to her because she couldn’t afford to live on her own. We worked through it though and came out stronger, and that is part of what convinced to marry her.
 
I was committed though; she was largely dependent on me and not the other way around. I was committed in my heart to taking care of her. We did go through a rough patch once and** I considered ending it**, but I worried about what would happen to her because she couldn’t afford to live on her own. We worked through it though and came out stronger, and that is part of what convinced to marry her.
Don’t get me wrong. I’m very happy things worked out for you, and I wish you and your wife many years of marital bliss, BUT…

You weren’t committed. Your language betrays your claim. I know the “fear” word bothers you…how about uncertainty? Doubt?
 
I know the “fear” word bothers you…how about uncertainty? Doubt?
Fair enough, I’ll admit to uncertainty, which is distinct from fear. I realize that nothing in life is guaranteed, but when I make major decisions I always carefully consider them. Living together was a way to carefully consider marriage with my wife.
 
I am completely appalled by the idea that freethinker treated his now wife like a car because he lived with her first. It seems like if he made more than she did, and he was committed to staying in part because of what would happen to her if he left, and he loved her than he was working hard and making sacrifices to make his relationship work. That’s not disrespecting someone or treating them like an object, that’s doing exactly what love and commitment require.

I currently live with my fiance. It happened gradually. We originally said that we didn’t want to live together until we were married. He didn’t want to because he wanted moving in together to be part of the married experience, and I didn’t because I had lived with someone previously and the relationship ended. Although the break up wasn’t messy (we remained roommates for 2 years, and he will be my “bridal attendant of honor” at my wedding) it could have been, and I didn’t want to risk it again. But, after six months we were spending 5 nights a week together and after a year it was every night. So why not just officially move in and save ourselves a lot of time and money? We aren’t married yet because honestly, I don’t see marriage as important to our relationship. It will give our families a chance to celebrate, and it will allow us to easily present ourselves to others as permanent, but beyond that, we know that its forever and that’s all we need.

And for the record, I asked him to move in and be added to my lease. If he had said “No, because I don’t want to treat you like a car” I would have been confused and angry.
 
Fair enough, I’ll admit to uncertainty, which is distinct from fear. I realize that nothing in life is guaranteed, but when I make major decisions I always carefully consider them. Living together was a way to carefully consider marriage with my wife.
Fair enough…and it worked out for you! Mazel tov!

That said, depending on the reports you read, divorce rates are either higher or the same for those who cohabitate prior to marriage. Also, split ups are just as painful, psychologically.

These young folk who are avoiding marriage are only kidding themselves, and, I believe, it is detrimental to society long term.
 
I am completely appalled by the idea that freethinker treated his now wife like a car because he lived with her first. It seems like if he made more than she did, and he was committed to staying in part because of what would happen to her if he left, and he loved her than he was working hard and making sacrifices to make his relationship work. That’s not disrespecting someone or treating them like an object, that’s doing exactly what love and commitment require.

I currently live with my fiance. It happened gradually. We originally said that we didn’t want to live together until we were married. He didn’t want to because he wanted moving in together to be part of the married experience, and I didn’t because I had lived with someone previously and the relationship ended. Although the break up wasn’t messy (we remained roommates for 2 years, and he will be my “bridal attendant of honor” at my wedding) it could have been, and I didn’t want to risk it again. But, after six months we were spending 5 nights a week together and after a year it was every night. So why not just officially move in and save ourselves a lot of time and money? We aren’t married yet because honestly, I don’t see marriage as important to our relationship.
That is the bigger problem, and it isn’t your fault. As a society, we’ve made divorce so easy and are now including homosexual unions, so marriage has become meaningless…especially to the non-religious. I can understand why young people think this way. I just think it’s bad for society.
40.png
BlueEyedLady:
It will give our families a chance to celebrate, and it will allow us to easily present ourselves to others as permanent, but beyond that, we know that its forever and that’s all we need.
You can certainly spend your money on a big party to give your families a chance to celebrate, if you want. The commitment we make in marriage is at a different level than “we know that it’s forever.” Most couples “know” that…up until they decide it’s not forever and split up.

For us, the commitment is before God, “for richer or for poorer, in sickness and in health, til death do us part.” When a couple is truly committed, those words become a covenant.
 
MODERATOR NOTE

Please charitably discuss the issues, not each other
 
I don’t know, I’m young and I want to get married…it seems to me everyone else either got married at 18 (shotgun or not) or just afraid of commitment. 😛

Too bad the elders cannot get a little more involved in this matter…it’s really hard to be told “Good Luck, hope you meet that special someone:thumbsup:” and you’re basically going in and out of bad relationships because you have no guidance whatsoever. This is one of the problems I see with the Christian faith, they seem to want to be very hands-off on the issue of trying to get young singles matched up as opposed to Muslims and Jews and as a result many couples wind up in inter-denominational marriages and there’s confusion on whether the married couple will live the Protestant or Catholic faith.

Just my opinion.
 
That said, depending on the reports you read, divorce rates are either higher or the same for those who cohabitate prior to marriage. Also, split ups are just as painful, psychologically.
I would imagine some of this is because religious people are less likely to cohabitate and are more likely to have a strong moral objection to divorce.

I would personally never “throw in the towel” on my marriage and would pursue every avenue to repair it if we were in trouble, but you do not find that same attitude with everyone. Now even I will admit that things could theoretically get bad enough for a divorce, but for me personally it would have to be quite extreme. I take my oaths very seriously.
 
I would imagine some of this is because religious people are less likely to cohabitate and are more likely to have a strong moral objection to divorce.

I would personally never “throw in the towel” on my marriage and would pursue every avenue to repair it if we were in trouble, but you do not find that same attitude with everyone. Now even I will admit that things could theoretically get bad enough for a divorce, but for me personally it would have to be quite extreme. I take my oaths very seriously.
Good for you! 👍
 
That is the bigger problem, and it isn’t your fault. As a society, we’ve made divorce so easy and are now including homosexual unions, so marriage has become meaningless…especially to the non-religious. I can understand why young people think this way. I just think it’s bad for society.
Actually, I’ve spent the better part of the last 5 years working for an organization that fights for gay rights. If anything the fact that gays cannot get married in most states makes me like the idea less. And I’ve always believed that people who say that they don’t want to get married because other people get divorced are precisely the type of people that shouldn’t marry. If you feel like two men getting married or two people getting divorced makes your marriage less special than you are focusing on the wrong things.
For us, the commitment is before God, “for richer or for poorer, in sickness and in health, til death do us part.” When a couple is truly committed, those words become a covenant.
I don’t believe in god. Of course I believe that marriage vows mean something, but seeing as how I don’t believe that saying them in a church or in any religious context makes them any more valid or meaningful than making the commitment privately, there’s no real incentive there to marry.
 
Actually, I’ve spent the better part of the last 5 years working for an organization that fights for gay rights. If anything the fact that gays cannot get married in most states makes me like the idea less. And I’ve always believed that people who say that they don’t want to get married because other people get divorced are precisely the type of people that shouldn’t marry. If you feel like two men getting married or two people getting divorced makes your marriage less special than you are focusing on the wrong things.
It has nothing to do with what I “feel.” That’s the problem with liberal ideology. It’s all about feelings. Marriage is important to society. Easy divorce and recognition of homosexual unions as equivalent to Marriage render Marriage meaningless to the detriment of society.
40.png
BlueEyedLady:
I don’t believe in god. Of course I believe that marriage vows mean something, but seeing as how I don’t believe that saying them in a church or in any religious context makes them any more valid or meaningful than making the commitment privately, there’s no real incentive there to marry.
Of course they “mean something” to you. :rolleyes:

BlueEyedLady said:
**I don’t see marriage as important to our relationship. It will give our families a chance to celebrate, and it will allow us to easily present ourselves to others as permanent, but beyond that, **we know that its forever and that’s all we need.

So, it means a meaningless party…
 
It has nothing to do with what I “feel.” That’s the problem with liberal ideology. It’s all about feelings. Marriage is important to society. Easy divorce and recognition of homosexual unions as equivalent to Marriage render Marriage meaningless to the detriment of society.

Of course they “mean something” to you. :rolleyes:

So, it means a meaningless party…
Like everything else in life marriage is what you make of it. If you are not religious its between you and your spouse what marriage means. Honestly, legal benefits aside if there was a way to have my relationship publicly considered permanent and given the same standing as married couple’s, I would probably completely disregard the whole tradition. But as it stands now marriage is pretty much required to have your relationship given the same respect as everyone else’s.

In my family it’s a bit different. My family doesn’t really do weddings or legal marriages. We just don’t see the point. My brother has been with what he (and we) consider to be his wife for about 15 years. They have four beautiful and talented daughters together. My mom was with her husband for years before they married, and only resorted to it because of his Social Security benefits. So in my family my fiance is given the exact same standing that my husband would be.

It’s not like that everywhere though. My fiance’s family is very different; they see married and not married as a very clear and distinct line. Society in general still views it that way, although things are changing.
 
It’s not like that everywhere though. My fiance’s family is very different; they see married and not married as a very clear and distinct line. Society in general still views it that way, although things are changing.
…for the worse.
 
…for the worse.
I very strongly disagree. Women have gained a lot since marriage stopped being seen as the ultimate goal. I would hate to go back in time for that reason alone.

Besides, I love the way my family works. We have a lot of love, and it has a lot to do with the way we view family.
 
I don’t believe in god. Of course I believe that marriage vows mean something, but seeing as how I don’t believe that saying them in a church or in any religious context makes them any more valid or meaningful than making the commitment privately, there’s no real incentive there to marry.
I have a question. If marriage is simply about the ‘meaningful feelings’ of two people, why on earth is the government even involved? Do they get involved in other matters of feelings? Won’t a durable power of attorney and a living will accomplish the same secular goals?

The reason catholic oppose ‘gay marriage’ is because we subscribe to the original meaning of marriage: the union of a man and woman in a lifelong relationship of self sacrificial love so profound that it, by its very nature, is ordered towards the creation and nurturing of new life.

Catholics are two steps ‘behind’ current societal trends in marriage. We declined to participate in the redefinition of marriage from self sacrificial focus to a narcicisstic focus on ones own feelings in the 1960’s (when sterilized marriage was first rationalized) which is the redefinition that has spawned the ‘gay marriage’ movement today. ‘Gay marriage’ is an oxymoron when you comprehend the truly traditional definition of marriage above, but it is the logical outcome of a definition of marriage focused solely on the feelings of the couple. Moral Majority types don’t realize that they are defending a phony definition of traditional marriage that is inward feeling focused instead of focused on the giving of self manifested in the very design of the human body.

What’s my point? Perhaps the two issue are related. Marriage in society in general has lost its appeal because society long ago abandoned the actual definition of the word. To paraphrase Jesus, it is like poor quality salt that has lost its saltiness.
 
I very strongly disagree. Women have gained a lot since marriage stopped being seen as the ultimate goal. I would hate to go back in time for that reason alone.

Besides, I love the way my family works. We have a lot of love, and it has a lot to do with the way we view family.
Feelings…nothing more than…feelings. The liberal theme song.
 
Agreed.

A lot more women now live in poverty.
In fairness, she’s probably right to assert that a lot less women feel like they have no other choice but to remain in abusive situations than in ages past. But I don’t think that improvement is necessarily linked to the devalued definition of marriage or the sexual license now common in our culture.
 
Feelings…nothing more than…feelings. The liberal theme song.
Don’t get me wrong, I strongly believe in commitment. But to marry out of a sense of duty? No way. If that works for you, great. But I need love, communication, trust, commitment, shared values and goals, etc. Just because I don’t believe in god does not make my relationship or my family whimsical. FYI-My family is very religious. You’re just being insulting at this point.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top