Why young couples aren't getting married

  • Thread starter Thread starter TheTrueCentrist
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I have a question. If marriage is simply about the ‘meaningful feelings’ of two people, why on earth is the government even involved? Do they get involved in other matters of feelings? Won’t a durable power of attorney and a living will accomplish the same secular goals?
Indeed, I think every legal benefit can be gained by other means, except for Social Security Survivor benefits and Joint filing on your taxes which may or may not be a benefit.
 
Don’t get me wrong, I strongly believe in commitment. But to marry out of a sense of duty? No way. If that works for you, great. But I need love, communication, trust, commitment, shared values and goals, etc. Just because I don’t believe in god does not make my relationship or my family whimsical. FYI-My family is very religious. You’re just being insulting at this point.
:confused: Did I post something about marrying out of a sense of duty? Did I post anything contrary to to “love, communication, trust, commitment shared values and goals, etc.?” :confused:

You can feel insulted, if you like. You appear to be ruled by emotion rather than rational thought, which is the point of my jabs. Your nonsensical post about what you think “works for me,” is just more evidence of that. I’m glad your family is religious. I haven’t commented on them because I know nothing about them. 🤷
 
Indeed, I think every legal benefit can be gained by other means, except for Social Security Survivor benefits and Joint filing on your taxes which may or may not be a benefit.
Not true. Before I married my wife she was my “domestic partner” and was on my insurance at work. My payroll insurance deduction for my domestic partner was taken out after taxes. Now that she is my wife it is taken out pre-tax.
 
:confused: Did I post something about marrying out of a sense of duty? Did I post anything contrary to to “love, communication, trust, commitment shared values and goals, etc.?” :confused:

You can feel insulted, if you like. You appear to be ruled by emotion rather than rational thought, which is the point of my jabs. Your nonsensical post about what you think “works for me,” is just more evidence of that. I’m glad your family is religious. I haven’t commented on them because I know nothing about them. 🤷
You seem to think that my way of doing things is wrong and all about emotion. You couldn’t be further from the truth and I don’t know where you got that idea. I had no choice but to assume that if you saw what I valued as all wrong than what you valued was completely lacking in feeling. Just because I see marriage as essentially outdated and unnecessary for a fulfilling and lifelong commitment does not make me any less rational than you.

As for thinking that you insulted my family, I said that this worked for us and that we are happy. You responded by telling me that there was nothing there but feelings.

So far you seem very cold towards the idea of love and marriage, so I would love to hear your outlook.
 
You seem to think that my way of doing things is wrong and all about emotion. You couldn’t be further from the truth and I don’t know where you got that idea. I had no choice but to assume that if you saw what I valued as all wrong than what you valued was completely lacking in feeling. Just because I see marriage as essentially outdated and unnecessary for a fulfilling and lifelong commitment does not make me any less rational than you.

As for thinking that you insulted my family, I said that this worked for us and that we are happy. You responded by telling me that there was nothing there but feelings.

So far you seem very cold towards the idea of love and marriage, so I would love to hear your outlook.
After your odd assumptions and easily hurt feelings? No thanks.
 
It used to be called “living in sin” … but our priests have stopped preaching about sin. And it just isn’t taught anymore by the Catholic Church … [yes, it’s in the Catechism of the Catholic Church … but almost no one reads that. Seems that mostly in CCD they still do a lot of coloring. Not much memorization. Maybe they should bring back the Baltimore Catechism … it’s still available on Amazon.]
 
At one time, governments saw value in genuine marriage. Propagation of the populace in a stable setting, protection of women, taming of men, and so on. Consequently, states undertook to encourage, protect and preserve marriages, even to honor them with their laws.

Clearly, governments no longer see much value in any of those things, and with predictable results; low birth rates, illegitimacy, poverty of single mothers and children, predatory men. In redefining marriage to include unions based on sexual perversion, the state has, in effect, declared that marriage has, to it, no objective value; that it is simply a vague term used to describe voluntary (and often temporary) unions having a sexual component. In other words, a subjective condition having value only to those directly involved.

And, of course, since many, if not most, people derive their moral sense from the state’s declarations, societal mores follow what the elites decree by way of the laws.

And so, without some push into a different direction, this society is likely to continue on a path of increasing sterility, subjectivism in sexual mores, and increasing poverty among those who bear the consequences of widespread moral subjectivism.
 
Clearly, governments no longer see much value in any of those things, and with predictable results; low birth rates, illegitimacy, poverty of single mothers and children, predatory men…
Call it what it is - bastardy.

Euphemizing immoral activity promotes it even further, when sexual perversion becomes “alternative lifestyle” (and I’m including a good slice of the heterosexual population here), bastardy becomes “love child”, fornication becomes “premarital sex”, adultery becomes “extramarital relations”, etc.

“Illegitimacy” is a decent descriptor, but even after two generations of it having no real legal effect in America, insofar as I understand the related law, and the term passing from public (and legal) discourse, the term “bastardy” seems to drive the point home with greater poignancy and efficacy.
 
…the term “bastardy” seems to drive the point home with greater poignancy and efficacy.
It might if Americans weren’t largely ignorant of their own language. If you use that word in conversation today, Joe Sixpack will think you are referring to somebody rude, obnoxious and generally a jerk. Parentage won’t even cross their minds.

In any case, I’d suggest we’d be better off criticising the parental behavior than calling the kids names.
 
It might if Americans weren’t largely ignorant of their own language. If you use that word in conversation today, Joe Sixpack will think you are referring to somebody rude, obnoxious and generally a jerk. Parentage won’t even cross their minds.

In any case, I’d suggest we’d be better off criticising the parental behavior than calling the kids names.
I’m sorry, but the term “bastardy” is an old-fashioned word that has fallen out of use. Why would modern Americans know it? Why would they have too? The English language is constantly changing. If the modern use of “bastard” is calling someone a rude jerk, then that’s what it will mean, if not now then in the future. I think it has fallen out of use when talking about an illegitimate child because of the negative connotations toward said child through no fault of his own. Are you gonna go around and call children born to unwed parents bastards? That would be a good way to get yourself punched in the face nowadays.
 
I’m sorry, but the term “bastardy” is an old-fashioned word that has fallen out of use. Why would modern Americans know it? Why would they have too? The English language is constantly changing. If the modern use of “bastard” is calling someone a rude jerk, then that’s what it will mean, if not now then in the future. I think it has fallen out of use when talking about an illegitimate child because of the negative connotations toward said child through no fault of his own. Are you gonna go around and call children born to unwed parents bastards? That would be a good way to get yourself punched in the face nowadays.
It does, however, give rise to a certain genre of insults, which one might or might not get away with, depending on the understanding of the hearer.

Example: “I understand your parents were not wealthy when they first married and before you were born. I guess that means you are a self-made man.” 😉
 
It might if Americans weren’t largely ignorant of their own language. If you use that word in conversation today, Joe Sixpack will think you are referring to somebody rude, obnoxious and generally a jerk. Parentage won’t even cross their minds.

In any case, I’d suggest we’d be better off criticising the parental behavior than calling the kids names.
That’s where “adultery” and “fornication” come in, instead of “pre-marital sex” and “extra-marital relations”. My point still stands in regards to the euphemizing of language as related to certain behaviors and attitudes, even if one example of it was incorrect by contemporary standards.
Bastardy (countable, uncountable): plural bastardies.
The condition of being illegitimate, of being born to an unmarried woman or as the fruit of adultery.
“Bastardy” describes the parental behavior as well, as far I understand the term: a child born in bastardy is a bastard, or illegitimate, or a natural son. “Bastardy” is the entire situation surrounding a bastard (including archaic legal ramifications), not the bastard himself in particular.

I remain constantly surprised that I seem to have a better grasp of English than native American (and probably English) Anglophones in many ways, but much (most) of my vocabulary has been called antiquated on more than one occasion (along with, “he speaks as if he were a book”, etc.), as most of it, beyond the basic, “Hello, my name is… where is the bathroom? What hour is it?”, comes from books.

Likewise, my vulgar English is limited. I did not recognize the use of “bastard” as a general insult (although it certainly applies to 50%? of children born in Europe today).
 
That’s where “adultery” and “fornication” come in, instead of “pre-marital sex” and “extra-marital relations”. My point still stands in regards to the euphemizing of language as related to certain behaviors and attitudes, even if one example of it was incorrect by contemporary standards.

“Bastardy” describes the parental behavior as well, as far I understand the term: a child born in bastardy is a bastard, or illegitimate, or a natural son. “Bastardy” is the entire situation surrounding a bastard (including archaic legal ramifications), not the bastard himself in particular.

I remain constantly surprised that I seem to have a better grasp of English than native American (and probably English) Anglophones in many ways, but much (most) of my vocabulary has been called antiquated on more than one occasion (along with, “he speaks as if he were a book”, etc.), as most of it, beyond the basic, “Hello, my name is… where is the bathroom? What hour is it?”, comes from books.

Likewise, my vulgar English is limited. I did not recognize the use of “bastard” as a general insult (although it certainly applies to 50%? of children born in Europe today).
“Bastardy proceedings” still exist in the law. They are used for the purpose of establishing parenthood, the ultimate objective being to obtain child support when the parents weren’t married and the father won’t acknowledge paternity.

I’ll add that there is a lot of archaic language and expression in legal parlence. People complain about it and call it “legalese”.
 
The milk is free, and young men feel entitled to their fair share. Why commit to a person when that person places so little value on herself? I know this is a generalization, but there is more than a germ of truth to it. 😦 Rob
 
“Bastardy proceedings” still exist in the law. They are used for the purpose of establishing parenthood, the ultimate objective being to obtain child support when the parents weren’t married and the father won’t acknowledge paternity.

I’ll add that there is a lot of archaic language and expression in legal parlence. People complain about it and call it “legalese”.
It’s not surprising that someone who doesn’t speak English as their native language has, as you say, a better formal grasp of the language. You studied it differently that someone who picked it up through their surroundings over their lifetime. What the native speakers have is better understanding of nuance, meaning they will have no problem understanding something said in an offbeat way that will confuse someone who hasn’t been immersed in the language for a very long time.
 
when was the last time you saw a film or TV show of a happily married couple?

For me it was the animated film “Up”.
 
For us living together wasn’t about being able to have unfettered sex or the option of just picking up and moving on when things got rough. We were 100% committed to each other, his daughters, and our family. We attended Mass weekly without receiving Communion, and I went to regular Confession. After much penance, prayer, reflection, and gentle coaxing by our priest, we realized t hat we didn’t have any moral choice but to enter into the Sacrament of Marriage, so we did.
I know this is an old thread, and you may or may not see this response, but it needs to be said. You were right not to receive Communion while living together outside of marriage, but you shouldn’t have been going to Confession either. Confession requires not just a resolve to avoid sin in the future but also the near occasions of sin. If you confess your sins but are unwilling to avoid the near occasions of sin (which living together outside of marriage is at best), then that makes your confession invalid, meaning that NONE of your sins are forgiven. Even worse, to make an invalid confession is also to commit sacrilege – another mortal sin. And of course, receiving Holy Communion while in the state of mortal sin (including after having made bad confessions) is sacrilegious. If you 've made bad confessions, then you need to make a general confession – where you confess all your sins (or at least all your mortal sins) committed since your last VALID confession (making sure to mention bad confessions and any sacrilegious Holy Communions).
 
Young men don’t want to get married anymore because marriage has become toxic for men. The divorce courts are heavily slanted against him if he goes through divorce. He loses a wife, his property, and his wages. If he has children then he loses them too.
Code:
 Contrary to popular belief young men aren't stupid. Why should they work hard just to lose everything? They have figured out that the system is completely against them.
I would advise any young man - DO NOT get married in today’s political environment. It’s safer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top