Protestant 101,
We wrote: Protestant 101*:The “Real Presence” can be experienced by Christians without “The Eucharist” or “Communion”.*
***Jerry: ***This is just so much sectarian persiflage and evasion of the issue. The “Real Presence” in the Eucharist is a Presence that is promised, assured, and objectively effected in the Mass (or Holy Communion, as Protestants prefer to call it).
***Protestant 101: ***“Persiflage!” Ha ha! I like that. Another new word for me from my friends at CAF! Thanks, Brother.
*Perhaps I could remind you though, that what I view the Mass as may not be all that different from other Catholics. From a few posts ago I quote: *
Quote:
*“Well, all I can say is that when I attend mass at my church, it’s the most boring thing ever. Nobody sings, everyone is just standing there like zombies. There are two Catholic churches and they are very dry and boring. I will admit, when I went to my fiancée’s church (she’s Assembly of God) people actually sang and rejoiced, as opposed to standing their looking disinterested * and ready to go home.” **
*I believe that in past discussions here I stated that I firmly believe Christ works at the Catholic Mass. I have no trouble with that basic principle. But I think there is a misunderstood portion of this phenomenon, regarding HOW Jesus does this. I would have no trouble going to a Mass with you my friend; but I would see it a bit differently. *
You know, as I hope that you do, that words are in the vocabulary of English, or of any other language, to be used. “Persiflage” is a well accepted word and has both the denotation and connotation that I wished to express, so I used it. Consider yourself enriched, buster, if you have learned what that word means. I do not choose words to
impress, I select them to convey exactly what I want to
express. I am always glad to learn a new and useful word; if you are an educated person, with a thirst to learn, you also would be happy to acquire an addition to your vocabulary.
Now you are doing a diversionary tactic, avoiding the brunt of what I had written criticising sectarian (Baptist, Fundamentalist, Campbellite, etc) practice, as opposed to that of Catholics, Lutherans, and some other Protestants (Presbyterian, Reformed, Anglican). I was referring to how Christ conveys grace to His people, objectively through the sacraments and the Real Presence, with real efficacy, of Christ. Your reply goes on about matters of socialisation and enjoyment among the congregants. There is a disconnect here! The quote from another Catholic which you provided has nothing to do with the Real Presence in the Mass (Holy Communion), but with disappointment at the inadequate sense of fellowship in Christ among Catholic worshippers. This impersonality and isolation among Catholic worshippers (which was not such a problem before the introduction of the stripped-down and coldly functional 1970
Novus Ordo displaced the traditional liturgy of the Mass) is something that can bother me, too, and I have commented on that in prior messages, but suchlike in no way invalidates what Catholic Eucharistic worship is all about.
If I did injustice to what you sated in your earlier postings, those before the one on which I am commenting now, I apologise for that. It is a bit hard to keep track of things on a computer screen, scrolling up and down while trying to obtain an impression of all that you and others already have said; that’s one of the enduring advantages of printing and typing on paper!
We Catholics, with some effort and ingenuity, can have a better sense of fellowship before and after worship (hopefully, not during it, however great our spiritual solidarity should be). Protestants and sectaries, on the other hand, cannot effect the tremendous blessing of Christ’s Real Presence in the Eucharist by their own effort’s; that is something that only our sovereign God can effect through a genuinely ordained episcopacy and priesthood in a right-believing Church.
However, there is much about these ancillary matters of fellowship and outreach that Catholics with profit (but also with
caution) can learn from evangelical Protestants and even from fundamentalist and neo-evangelical sects.
Pax, Jerry ParkerYes; of course Jerry, Adventists always have “tactics” up their sleeves don’t they? LOL, be sure and warn everyone in those big red letters that others have used!
I was well aware of the meaning of your “new” word above, and I still think it’s funny. Sometimes, people like to just use bigger words that are not used in the average daily vocabulary, to add emphasis to their point. Then, it doesn’t sound so much like an accusation.
I am sure that we can all pat ourselves on the back saying how much “better” our Church is than some other denomination; but I am thankful I don’t have to run around worrying about it. I know Jesus cares; and “I love the Lord because He hath heard my voice.” (Ps 116:1). There’s not too much you can do to shake that, so keep up with all those vociferous darts and malignant barbs! Other Christians coming to this forum will follow your example; I am sure, but Jesus loves you anyways.