women priests

  • Thread starter Thread starter mmmtoasty
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
well, st. bernard of clairvaux claims just that. a man not only can be a bride, but IS a bride of Christ. some truth is confusing.
Analogies are imperfect. Bride is to be understood in the context of affection and in no way is sexual.

In the physical realm, a man can not be a bride to another man or a woman. This is not man’s law but natural law.
 
It doesn’t. The word OBEY is no where in the vows
that is because it has been removed.

here is it happening in the anglican church

but you are right… the catholic church does not include it in their vows. my mistake.

of course the anglican church came out of the catholic church (just like every other protestant church) so the idea came from somewhere.
 
Analogies are imperfect. Bride is to be understood in the context of affection and in no way is sexual.

In the physical realm, a man can not be a bride to another man or a woman. This is not man’s law but natural law.
well, bernard did not teach it that way. he spoke regularly of the spiritual, sexual relationship between Christ and us (as individuals and as the church).

you are right about the physical realm, but that is not what we are talking about. we are talking about spiritual roles not physical ones. spiritually, we are all brides. spiritually, we all stand in place of the groom here on earth.
 
that is because it has been removed.

here is it happening in the anglican church

but you are right… the catholic church does not include it in their vows. my mistake.

of course the anglican church came out of the catholic church (just like every other protestant church)*** so the idea came from somewhere.***
Good point, now do the homework and figure it out where it comes from.
 
really good discussion! thank you all.

but here is the problem with forums:

i have to leave now and when i come back there will be like 5 more pages of comments and there is no way i have the time to respond to them all. i have said all i can say on this so peace out.
 
Would you care to expound on this post, so as to not be misunderstood?
Read theology of the body. There is no way to encompass the fastness of this understanding.

Females have a unique relationship with their dads. (this is an ideal). They are daddy’s little girl. Their understanding of God the Father is as a protector, provider, etc etc. That is how their unique relationship with him is developed. This is why when Fathers do not do their jobs, their little girls go seeking for “fatherly affection” in unhealthy ways. That affection from men… that make them feel good about themselves beause of their bodies.

Males have a unique relationship with their father too. An mentor, an example, there is that unexplainable “male bonding” that happens. This is how they understand God the Father as well. When the Father do not do their jobs, men either abuse the physical power they have, or possibly channel it in otherwise unhealthy ways.

We understand GOD in terms of who we are, as male and female.

This is just a bare bones basic understanding. There is no way I can fully articulate the delicate nature, especially when using such limited analogies and examples.
 
already did… it comes from the teaching of the man being the head of the wife.
What do you mean with the teaching that the man is the head of the wife? Not a criticism just confused. :confused:

The Catholic teaching says that the man must love his wife as Christ loves His bride. However, this is an impossible task for the man alone (because he is not Christ) and so the wife must submit (submissa= go below to support) to him in order to help him in accomplishing is mission of loving her. Submission is intended not as making yourself less important but to support a mission.
 
Read theology of the body. There is no way to encompass the fastness of this understanding.

Females have a unique relationship with their dads. (this is an ideal). They are daddy’s little girl. Their understanding of God the Father is as a protector, provider, etc etc. That is how their unique relationship with him is developed. This is why when Fathers do not do their jobs, their little girls go seeking for “fatherly affection” in unhealthy ways. That affection from men… that make them feel good about themselves beause of their bodies.

Males have a unique relationship with their father too. An mentor, an example, there is that unexplainable “male bonding” that happens. This is how they understand God the Father as well. When the Father do not do their jobs, men either abuse the physical power they have, or possibly channel it in otherwise unhealthy ways.

We understand GOD in terms of who we are, as male and female.

This is just a bare bones basic understanding. There is no way I can fully articulate the delicate nature, especially when using such limited analogies and examples.
thank you for your reply - i guess the misundersatnding was in your initial post in reply to mine - you weren’t talking about marriage, but I was…
 
but i am speaking more in practice. the church never wrote that the jews should convert or die, but the practice happened. and it goes much further back than just the church so don’t think i am blaming catholicism for women being oppressed throughout history. but the church did much to perpetuate it. the misinterpretations of paul’s writings do as much damage to the treatment of women as does the misinterpretation of matthew’s does for the jewish people (the whole “let His blood be on us and our children” statement has fueled much anti-semitism).
In relation to the thought patterns of the modern day I could see how one could arrive at that. However, in context of the days The Church was if anything a champion for women. In the days of the early Church the pagans litterally saw women and children as property of their fathers or husbands.

Now was the record perfect or was it practically speaking uniform in its treatment of women? No, but you can’t apply modern assumptions to earlier periods. The fact that people like Justin Martyr praised women in the Church and Origen castrated himself in order to instruct women speaks volumes about how that the Church was affecting its members to perceive women as something more than the cultural norms of the day suggested. The Church has always had to struggle against the current wisdom of whatever age it was in.

All of that being said it is fair that you can state that Churchmen have not always treated women with the respect that they ought to have. However, the priesthood is seperate issue all together. The Priesthood is a privelege not a right. Not every man can be a priest simply because he wants to be one. Priesthood is a call and one’s desire no matter how pious the intentions is not relavent.

Simply put neither men or women have a right to the priesthood. This is the problem I most often see when subject comes up. The arguments for it ultimately seem rooted in a concept that not being allowed to be a priest is an “oppresion” or that it denies a position of power. The priesthood is not about power its about service. It isn’t a title that someone is being denied its a burden.

It’s interesting to me that in my experience the women that I’ve known that I think have all the qualities of a good priest are usually the women that are most opposed to the idea. While those I’ve heard bemoan not being able to be a priest usually display attitudes that would not be productive to the ministry. I think the reason is simple the issue isn’t about being a priest its about not being allowed to do something.
 
People often view church “hierarchy” as a typical pyramid where in fact it is the exact opposite.

The pope is at the bottom, in service to the cardinals and bishops, who are in service to the priests, then to the people at the top.

It is about doing the “dirty work”. Christ, God, and the church hold women in such dignity that by definition of their very being, they are to be held in esteem at the top. He calls the men to do the “dirty work”…(Please forgive the raw language, but its simply an explanation). The work is difficult that he makes it a sacrament that bestows grace and an indellible mark on the soul.

This isnt’ about oppression or power over people, its about service to people.
 
What do you mean with the teaching that the man is the head of the wife? Not a criticism just confused. :confused:
.
Ephesians 5
  • 22Wives, submit to your husbands as to the Lord. 23For the husband is the head of the wife as Christ is the head of the church, his body, of which he is the Savior*. 24Now as the church submits to Christ, so also wives should submit to their husbands in everything.
Code:
25Husbands, love your wives, just as Christ loved the church and gave himself up for her 26to make her holy, cleansing** her by the washing with water through the word, 27and to present her to himself as a radiant church, without stain or wrinkle or any other blemish, but holy and blameless. 28In this same way, husbands ought to love their wives as their own bodies. He who loves his wife loves himself**
this verse has been used as a defense (by some… not by the church as far as i can tell) for men beating their wives into “submission”.
 
but you are stuck only thinking physically. men do give birth spiritually to other believers. the church gives birth to Christ into the world (rev. 12… and i know it is talking about mary, but it is also talking about the church, and it is also talking about israel) and men are a part of that church.
I’m not stuck anything. It has to do with the physical body. That’s where the basis for it comes from.
 
in context of the days The Church was if anything a champion for women.
agreed… so what happened? 😉
The fact that people like Justin Martyr praised women in the Church and Origen castrated himself
actually, many historians say that origen probably didn’t castrate himself and that it was just a rumor spread by eusebius in book IV of ecclesiastical history. that aside, the reason for castration was not only to avoid the appearance of scandal, it was for self protection. women in much of society were thought of as temptations for men. this idea is very much built upon in medieval times (and ridiculed in monty python’s holy grail… the castle anthrax anybody…lol). also, the church viewed it as a “mutilation of the body” and it is highly doubtful that origen would have sinned in that way. plus, you are talking about a man who read the bible very allegorically… does it make sense for him to take the matthew passage literally?
speaks volumes about how that the Church was affecting its members to perceive women as something more than the cultural norms of the day suggested
.

but their own words show that they did not believe women were on the same level as men. they were not equal but different. they were considered inferior.
Priesthood is a call and one’s desire no matter how pious the intentions is not relavent.
i completely agree. the problem is when you or i or anyone tries to tell some one that feels that call, that their call is not valid.
Simply put neither men or women have a right to the priesthood.
agreed. except for the fact that we are all a part of the priesthood of all believers as found in the NT.
The arguments for it ultimately seem rooted in a concept that not being allowed to be a priest is an “oppresion” or that it denies a position of power.
i think in some cases this is true, but in others there are women who truly feel called to the priesthood and they are told that because they are a woman, their call is not real. that would feel like oppression to me.

a black man in this country, at one time, was not permitted to own land. if he wanted to own land, had the money to pay for it, and had a plan to develop it, he would still have been forbidden to own it because he was black. that is oppression.

but i do agree that some (men and women) get angry when they are told they are not allowed to do something.
I think the reason is simple the issue isn’t about being a priest its about not being allowed to do something.
i agree in some cases, but in others i disagree. either way, you are putting yourself in a position to say you can judge the hearts of others. that is a dangerous place to be.
 
I’m not stuck anything. It has to do with the physical body. That’s where the basis for it comes from.
but Christ transcends the physical. and, actually our basis is spiritual not physical. it was not until after the fall that we began to base things on the physical. now that Christ has reconciled us to Himself, we can stop the focus on the physical and put it back on the spiritual. that is why i said you were stuck in that thinking.
 
but Christ transcends the physical. and, actually our basis is spiritual not physical. it was not until after the fall that we began to base things on the physical. now that Christ has reconciled us to Himself, we can stop the focus on the physical and put it back on the spiritual. that is why i said you were stuck in that thinking.
again, as I stated before, this is incorrect. It isn’t “sprit good body bad”.
Our bodies are manifestations of who we are, not simply shells. We are not to abandon the physical.

READ THEOLOGY OF THE BODY
 
The pope is at the bottom, in service to the cardinals and bishops, who are in service to the priests, then to the people at the top.
so can i go stay in the pope’s room at the vatican then?

why does he not kiss the rings of the people instead of the other way around?

i am not trying to be rude as i think the pope (especially JPII and John XXIII) were amazing men. but there are plenty of times, in practice, that your reverse hierarchy does not play out.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top