Yet Another "NFP Stuggles" Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lookouts
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I know I’m just jumping right in here, but I actually have been following this thread and other NFP threads, just never contributed much.

I do agree. I think as a natural progression of life, it is expected that people will change and evolve through the years. Hopefully, it is for the better. 🙂 I was definitely not the same at 18 as I was at 28 and any other age. My views on certain things and even how I handled discussing situations have even changed from few years ago. I’m even certain that some things I posted here from a few years ago, or even a few months ago, may not be my opinion today or has modified slightly. Unless a person is consistent up through the most recent post, I don’t think it is wise to just assume that the person still has the same views even from a few months ago, especially when a person does explicitly express they would like to keep some things private. There is something unsavory when people do search for individual’s past posts to try to either prove a point against them. They should only focus on the opinions and statements expressed on that particular thread.
Thanks for the kind words. I’ve been open about things here in the past but a couple things made me change my mind about sharing things with the people here.

One thing is I get branded with a scarlet letter, and anything I say on a past thread comes back to haunt me when I say something on a present thread, even when it isn;t even the same subject. For example, people have bashed me on modesty threads by announcing something like “Debora is also the same poster who thinks this and that about NFP and who does this and that with her husband.” And I’m just like… are you kidding me??

Another reason is that I’ve had other members here message me and ask me to stop talking about my views on this certain issue because it causes scandal. While at first I thought that wasn’t fair, I have come to respect that, and to agree that when someone asks about contraception, I should give them the facts about Church teaching rather than how I feel about it.

So I’ve stopped talking about it, I keep it private, but I still have people calling me out and continuing to brand me on each thread because of something I haven’t talked about here in thread for months! :confused:

I completely regret opening myself up and thinking I could trust people with my personal issues. All I can do now is refrain from doing so, and keep hoping people stop bullying me for it.
 
He comes across that way with me though.
Ok but he doesn’t to at least 3 other people so can you at least concede that it is possible he will to others as well? Possibly people who are struggling themselves and are just looking for that one person to agree so that they can continue in their sin feeling justified. And please don’t tell me you don’t think people do this here.
 
Thanks for the kind words. I’ve been open about things here in the past but a couple things made me change my mind about sharing things with the people here.

One thing is I get branded with a scarlet letter, and anything I say on a past thread comes back to haunt me when I say something on a present thread, even when it isn;t even the same subject. For example, people have bashed me on modesty threads by announcing something like “Debora is also the same poster who thinks this and that about NFP and who does this and that with her husband.” And I’m just like… are you kidding me??

Another reason is that I’ve had other members here message me and ask me to stop talking about my views on this certain issue because it causes scandal. While at first I thought that wasn’t fair, I have come to respect that, and to agree that when someone asks about contraception, I should give them the facts about Church teaching rather than how I feel about it.

So I’ve stopped talking about it, I keep it private, but I still have people calling me out and continuing to brand me on each thread because of something I haven’t talked about here in thread for months! :confused:

I completely regret opening myself up and thinking I could trust people with my personal issues. All I can do now is refrain from doing so, and keep hoping people stop bullying me for it.
The thing is though your not the one with your back to the wall we are haha. You have 95%+ of humanity behind you. You may be in the minority on this site, but at least you can get up and walk away from it when you get tired of it.
 
Ok but he doesn’t to at least 3 other people so can you at least concede that it is possible he will to others as well? Possibly people who are struggling themselves and are just looking for that one person to agree so that they can continue in their sin feeling justified. And please don’t tell me you don’t think people do this here.
Ok, I’ll tell you what I think, since you asked. I’m sure there are people here who engage in sin and want that one person to agree with them so they can continue sinning. But I think there are many people that are angry over Church teachings and feel exactly the way Searching does, but are not coming forward because they don’t want to be met the same way he is. I think that’s unfortunate because they can learn from each other and lean on each other.
 
Ok, I’ll tell you what I think, since you asked. I’m sure there are people here who engage in sin and want that one person to agree with them so they can continue sinning. But I think there are many people that are angry over Church teachings and feel exactly the way Searching does, but are not coming forward because they don’t want to be met the same way he is. I think that’s unfortunate because they can learn from each other and lean on each other.
I think there is an assumption that people that don’t struggle with NFP never fail. An assumption is made that if it isn’t a struggle that means there is no problem using it. That would be like saying Padre Pio wasn’t struggling when he got to fight demons every night since he didn’t complain about it and accepted the fact that he only had to fight those battles because God allowed it. The difference in happiness, parallels the difference in the degree with which we accept the struggle.

You know how they say football is 10% skill/talent and 90% mental? NFP is like that 😉
 
Thanks for the kind words. I’ve been open about things here in the past but a couple things made me change my mind about sharing things with the people here.

One thing is I get branded with a scarlet letter, and anything I say on a past thread comes back to haunt me when I say something on a present thread, even when it isn;t even the same subject. For example, people have bashed me on modesty threads by announcing something like “Debora is also the same poster who thinks this and that about NFP and who does this and that with her husband.” And I’m just like… are you kidding me??

Another reason is that I’ve had other members here message me and ask me to stop talking about my views on this certain issue because it causes scandal. While at first I thought that wasn’t fair, I have come to respect that, and to agree that when someone asks about contraception, I should give them the facts about Church teaching rather than how I feel about it.

So I’ve stopped talking about it, I keep it private, but I still have people calling me out and continuing to brand me on each thread because of something I haven’t talked about here in thread for months! :confused:

I completely regret opening myself up and thinking I could trust people with my personal issues. All I can do now is refrain from doing so, and keep hoping people stop bullying me for it.
You’re not alone. Many people feel that way too. I don’t open up about many things either unless I’m caught in an emotional state and can’t resist replying to one thread or another. I just stick to 1-3 things. It would exhaust me to discuss everything. I usually regret it when I do because the pointless badgering is just relentless…and it doesn’t change anything anyway. 🤷
 
Ok but he doesn’t to at least 3 other people so can you at least concede that it is possible he will to others as well? Possibly people who are struggling themselves and are just looking for that one person to agree so that they can continue in their sin feeling justified. And please don’t tell me you don’t think people do this here.
So AGAIN - those who disagree and struggle and question are just to be quiet, just in case someone else in the same boat only sees that they are alone in all of that. Peachy.

You don’t think it might be that we come to see that in fact we are NOT alone? But you just want quiet, compliant posters.
 
Relating her struggles is not scandalizing anyone. If anything those on the fence should see how much she suffers but has decided to follow the teachings anyway, even if she feels she is being coerced to do so. There is nothing really special about following the rules when one is totally on board about them, and they’re not a burden for one. But it takes a lot to bend to the rules when everything inside of you is screaming the opposite. So I give Searching a lot of credit, even though she hates the rules and and resents those who made them, and thinks they are complete bogus, she still trusts the Church enough to follow the rules. Having that much faith and trust is guiding her actions, despite the lack of faith and trust in the Church. The balance is tipped in favor of the Church in her case and no one can deny that because it’s obvious in her struggles. I think her dialogs are important because she is real.
I agree with this. People are giving Searching a hard time when they should in fact be admiring that someone has that much devotion. 🤷

It sometimes seems like some of us here just like to see the bad in people, when really, we are called to see the good, and to assume the best of others.

I admire Searching for her strength and devotion to following the rules, despite what his own judgements tell him and despite the difficulties it’s given him.
 
So AGAIN - those who disagree and struggle and question are just to be quiet, just in case someone else in the same boat only sees that they are alone in all of that. Peachy.

You don’t think it might be that we come to see that in fact we are NOT alone? But you just want quiet, compliant posters.
Please tell me where I said to not post? I am just saying that the level of anger in your posts is such that you seem more like you are saying “the Church is wrong” than you are saying “I struggle w/ this does anyone else?”
 
Did you think I was talking about you? I was saying that the other Deb offered support and advice without deviating from Church teaching. Which is what the forum is for.

I wasn’t even speaking about you.
Ah, I see. My apologies. I thought you were talking about me being the one deviating the OP from Church teaching, haha. I was like “what in the WORLD?!” :eek:
 
Please tell me where I said to not post? I am just saying that the level of anger in your posts is such that you seem more like you are saying “the Church is wrong” than you are saying “I struggle w/ this does anyone else?”
Your post:

Ok but he doesn’t to at least 3 other people so can you at least concede that it is possible he will to others as well? Possibly people who are struggling themselves and are just looking for that one person to agree so that they can continue in their sin feeling justified. And please don’t tell me you don’t think people do this here.

This tells me you think I should be quiet and not post because I might be “that one person”.
 
Okay, so you are struggling to conform your will to the teachings of the Church. That’s understandable and normal. Do you pray for it? Do you research WHY the Church teaches what it does about both conjugal sex and IVF? Do you work towards understanding the teachings?

That’s what we are supposed to do. No one said you have to have 100% understanding of all the Church’s teachings. Everyone has said, you cannot choose sin.
Now you are on thin ice here, hockey mom. 🙂
If you do not understand the teaching how can you say what is a sin?
 
Now you are on thin ice here, hockey mom. 🙂
If you do not understand the teaching how can you say what is a sin?
If you are struggling with something, I would expect you at least have a basic knowledge of it? LIke, the Church says X is wrong. I am struggling with why X is wrong.

Yes, your lack of completely understanding can diminish your culpability, but it is still objectively a sinful action.
 
Now you are on thin ice here, hockey mom. 🙂
If you do not understand the teaching how can you say what is a sin?
Morals are set in stone by the Church. Whether you know about them or not doesn’t change whether they are right or wrong. What does change is culpability/graveness. You don’t have to understand why something is a sin for it to be a sin. Do you have to understand how gravity works before you are expected to follow the law of gravity?
 
Morals are set in stone by the Church. Whether you know about them or not doesn’t change whether they are right or wrong. What does change is culpability/graveness. You don’t have to understand why something is a sin for it to be a sin. Do you have to understand how gravity works before you are expected to follow the law of gravity?
So would not following gravity be a sin??? :rotfl:

Might hurt, though… 😃
 
Your post:

Ok but he doesn’t to at least 3 other people so can you at least concede that it is possible he will to others as well? Possibly people who are struggling themselves and are just looking for that one person to agree so that they can continue in their sin feeling justified. And please don’t tell me you don’t think people do this here.

This tells me you think I should be quiet and not post because I might be “that one person”.
Then you are missing my point. I am saying that your words have more impact than you may realize so you should use them more carefully. Your posts have so much anger seething through them it is hard to see past that. I read several of your posts before it became apparent that while you don’t agree w/ the teaching you follow it. Someone less discerning may not take the time to wade through it all especially when we are talking about 20 pages of posts.
 
Then you are missing my point. I am saying that your words have more impact than you may realize so you should use them more carefully. Your posts have so much anger seething through them it is hard to see past that. I read several of your posts before it became apparent that while you don’t agree w/ the teaching you follow it. Someone less discerning may not take the time to wade through it all especially when we are talking about 20 pages of posts.
I have a question… if you are with the belief that people who disagree with Church teaching on this issue shouldn’t publicize it, then why did you keep trying to coerce me into talking about it after I had already said I didn’t want to talk about it? 🤷
 
I have a question… if you are with the belief that people who disagree with Church teaching on this issue shouldn’t publicize it, then why did you keep trying to coerce me into talking about it after I had already said I didn’t want to talk about it? 🤷
They are aiming that at me…
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top