Yet Another "NFP Stuggles" Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lookouts
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
They are aiming that at me…
Well Jea here seems to be talking in general and saying that people who disagree with Church teaching, or who don’t follow Church teaching on something, shouldn’t talk about it or mention it.

I was doing just that… I wasn’t talking about it or mentioning it, but last night she was actively trying to get me to talk about it… even though she claims to believe that doing so would cause scandal.

Weird. :confused:
 
If you are struggling with something, I would expect you at least have a basic knowledge of it? LIke, the Church says X is wrong. I am struggling with why X is wrong.

Yes, your lack of completely understanding can diminish your culpability, but it is still objectively a sinful action.
Morals are set in stone by the Church. Whether you know about them or not doesn’t change whether they are right or wrong. What does change is culpability/graveness. You don’t have to understand why something is a sin for it to be a sin. Do you have to understand how gravity works before you are expected to follow the law of gravity?
If a good Catholic does not understand HV properly and uses condoms, is it a sin?
 
If a good Catholic does not understand HV properly and uses condoms, is it a sin?
There are two ways to discuss sin- objective and subjective. Objective is speaking to the absolute truth that using condoms is a sin. Yes, it’s a sin. Mortal sin, actually.

Subjective is speaking to the specific instance of Jane and Mike using a condom last Thursday night. Was it a mortal sin? We don’t know, because we don’t know if they had full knowledge or full consent of the will.

So if a good Catholic doesn’t know… yes, it’s still a sin. But it may not be mortally sinful FOR THEM IN THAT INSTANCE.

But it’s always a sin.
 
There are two ways to discuss sin- objective and subjective. Objective is speaking to the absolute truth that using condoms is a sin. Yes, it’s a sin. Mortal sin, actually.

Subjective is speaking to the specific instance of Jane and Mike using a condom last Thursday night. Was it a mortal sin? We don’t know, because we don’t know if they had full knowledge or full consent of the will.

So if a good Catholic doesn’t know… yes, it’s still a sin. But it may not be mortally sinful FOR THEM IN THAT INSTANCE.

But it’s always a sin.
Are you sure that God will count it as a sin for them?
 
Are you sure that God will count it as a sin for them?
If something is objectively sinful, it is always a sin for everyone. Now their personal culpability is not something I can speak for. That’s why we can’t ‘judge’ people’s specific actions. We can only speak to the objective sinfulness. “Stealing is sinful.” “Artificial contraception is sinful.” “Murder is sinful.”

Their personal culpability could be so low that it is only the most venial of venial sins. Or it could be a mortal sin and they have cut themselves off from the grace of God. Only God knows.
 
Morals are set in stone by the Church. Whether you know about them or not doesn’t change whether they are right or wrong. What does change is culpability/graveness. You don’t have to understand why something is a sin for it to be a sin. Do you have to understand how gravity works before you are expected to follow the law of gravity?
So would not following gravity be a sin???

Might hurt, though…
I had to chuckle at that.

But I think that’s exactly the point Nate is making (correct me if I’m wrong) : If I decide I don’t want to be bound by gravity and jump from a tall place attempting to defy gravity, I will fall and get hurt no matter how much I feel that I am doing the right thing. Whether I understand it or not, when I go againt it, I suffer the consequence.

Same with God’s Laws…I may not understand them, or why things are wrong, but that does not make them any more safe or okay for me to willfully go against. I will still suffer the consequence of the respective sin. In this case…“the wages of sin are death.”
 
Are you sure that God will count it as a sin for them?
Yes. (We are still talking about ABC here I assume. ) As kristacecilia points out, however, a person’s culpability and the issue of full knowledge and consent factor into whether it is a venial or mortal sin. See CCC 2370 and 2399, and CCC 1854-1876.
 
I have a question… if you are with the belief that people who disagree with Church teaching on this issue shouldn’t publicize it, then why did you keep trying to coerce me into talking about it after I had already said I didn’t want to talk about it? 🤷
Last night I was trying to get you to understand that despite you saying “I’m not going to talk about my choices” you continually made posts that led one to believe you were acting contrary to Church teaching. And again I am not saying not to talk about it merely be honest and understand that our words may have greater impact.
 
Last night I was trying to get you to understand that despite you saying “I’m not going to talk about my choices” you continually made posts that led one to believe you were acting contrary to Church teaching. And again I am not saying not to talk about it merely be honest and understand that our words may have greater impact.
And why would it matter if someone made speculations about me and assumed something without me saying it?

And where was I being dishonest?
 
In all seriousness I think you are not understanding where many of us are coming from. The fact that you failed to live up to the moral standards of the Church at times is nothing new and we have all failed as well at times I’m sure. No one blames you for failing especially given your situation. The problem we have is that you assume since you failed, the morals must be wrong. In blaming the morals instead of acknowledging the innate weakness in all of us and our need for God in order to live up to his moral standards you make it impossible to even have a chance. The only way a person can truly fail is to quit trying, and start believing their failure is not a failure at all.

Think of it this way:
You don’t believe what the Church is teaching is right, but you follow it anyways. This contradiction makes that part of your life a living hell. You have three choices:
  1. Continue living in this hell
  2. Assume what the Church is teaching is wrong, and live your life how you feel God is telling you specifically to.
  3. Assume what the Church is teaching is right and find some peace. Give up trying to understand it to God and just be content with doing it out of fear of God, and because you believe the Church does have the authority to speak on the issue. Allow yourself to be ok with the fact that you may never understand the teaching even up to your death. If your going to follow the teaching anyways, why choose to continue to live in a living hell of indecision? When you fall, pick yourself up (confession), acknowledge you fell, and forgive yourself and move on.
How dare you are to even mention the group number 2. 🙂
It’s a serious thing but it happens.
 
And why would it matter if someone made speculations about me and assumed something without me saying it?

And where was I being dishonest?
I didn’t say you were being dishonest. Wow if someone isn’t saying something to upset you do you have to create it? It matters for the same reason it matters that searching’s posts come across as hating the Church. Because people come here for CATHOLIC ANSWERS. If they think people are oking immoral behavior they will take it to heart. Not everyone, but some will.

Also I pointed it out because I personally would want to know if that was what I portrayed to the public.
 
I didn’t say you were being dishonest. Wow if someone isn’t saying something to upset you do you have to create it?
My apologies, it sounded like you were trying to say I wasn’t being honest when you said this to me:
And again I am not saying not to talk about it merely be honest and understand that our words may have greater impact.
Now as for this:
It matters for the same reason it matters that searching’s posts come across as hating the Church. Because people come here for CATHOLIC ANSWERS. If they think people are oking immoral behavior they will take it to heart. Not everyone, but some will.
I’m not sure how what I said comes off as me hating the Church, since all I said was that I did not have a good experience with it and that maybe it would have been different if the promoters had been more honest about what to expect emotionally.

Seems like everyone who has a bad experience with NFP and mentions it, gets shunned one way or another.

🤷 It’s all spilled milk now anyway.
 
I had to chuckle at that.

But I think that’s exactly the point Nate is making (correct me if I’m wrong) : If I decide I don’t want to be bound by gravity and jump from a tall place attempting to defy gravity, I will fall and get hurt no matter how much I feel that I am doing the right thing. Whether I understand it or not, when I go againt it, I suffer the consequence.

Same with God’s Laws…I may not understand them, or why things are wrong, but that does not make them any more safe or okay for me to willfully go against. I will still suffer the consequence of the respective sin. In this case…“the wages of sin are death.”
What I had in mind is that you don’t have a clue it’s wrong.
The church teaches clearly that you are supposed to listen to your conscience.
 
I didn’t say you were being dishonest. Wow if someone isn’t saying something to upset you do you have to create it? It matters for the same reason it matters that searching’s posts come across as hating the Church. Because people come here for CATHOLIC ANSWERS. If they think people are oking immoral behavior they will take it to heart. Not everyone, but some will.

Also I pointed it out because I personally would want to know if that was what I portrayed to the public.
You are a self-appointed, arrogant I-don’t-know-what.

You obviously do not see where YOU are coming across telling or insinuating that people just need to not post or watch their words if they disagree.

Who in the heck are you to dare to even assume I hate the church?

So it is only for Catholic Answers? Athiests and Protestants and Jews and Muslims and whoever need not post or visit?

Get off you high horse and come down to earth with the rest of us mere mortals. You might just learn something.
 
My apologies, it sounded like you were trying to say I wasn’t being honest when you said this to me:

Now as for this:

I’m not sure how what I said comes off as me hating the Church, since all I said was that I did not have a good experience with it and that maybe it would have been different if the promoters had been more honest about what to expect emotionally.

Seems like everyone who has a bad experience with NFP and mentions it, gets shunned one way or another.

The part about hating the church was directed at searching. I even posted his screen name.

🤷 It’s all spilled milk now anyway.
 
You are a self-appointed, arrogant I-don’t-know-what.

You obviously do not see where YOU are coming across telling or insinuating that people just need to not post or watch their words if they disagree.

Who in the heck are you to dare to even assume I hate the church?

So it is only for Catholic Answers? Athiests and Protestants and Jews and Muslims and whoever need not post or visit?

Get off you high horse and come down to earth with the rest of us mere mortals. You might just learn something.
I do not assume you hate the Church in fact based on the fact that you are practicing NFP, etc despite disagreeing w/ Church teaching I’d say you love the Church. However I wouldn’t think that if I hadn’t bothered to read all of your posts.

I get that you are angry. You can think I’m arrogant if it helps you. That’s fine. Of course other denominations are here, however I assume they are here for dialogue and want to understand the Catholic view point or argue it. Thus even theywant Catholic Answers.
 
I do not assume you hate the Church in fact based on the fact that you are practicing NFP, etc despite disagreeing w/ Church teaching I’d say you love the Church. However I wouldn’t think that if I hadn’t bothered to read all of your posts.

I get that you are angry. You can think I’m arrogant if it helps you. That’s fine. Of course other denominations are here, however I assume they are here for dialogue and want to understand the Catholic view point or argue it. Thus even they want Catholic Answers.
This thread is a good answer. There are people who like it and there are people who struggle in regards to NFP and sex.
That’s as good Catholic answer as it gets. 🙂
 
I’m having a little trouble buying this honestly. Did you seriously not put two and two together here? Regardless of whether or not they were “promoting” it (and I do not Really think it’s Their responsibility to make sure you understand what a holy marriage will entail), you must have had to have thought (at least Once) something like “because this is The Only Moral form of birth control, it might mean that we won’t have sex for very extended periods of time!” That’s like the first thing people go to when criticizing it. They think of the generally far-fetched hypotheticals of where a couple might not get to have sex to show why NFP is clearly wrong.

Why did/do you think the Church finds it necessary to Encourage its use? Why did/do you think non-Catholics criticize NFP and rally for ABC so much? Did you think they just irrationally disliked the Church? No, they just have that same “I should get to have sex when I want to” mentality that all modern people have, and are offended by the notion that a couple might not get to have sex when they want to.

This whole issue is a little silly to me, though. ALL sexual issues revolve around the virtue of chastity. A person practices chastity Always (whether single, a monk, married, or otherwise), or he is not a good person. Getting married is not a free ticket to all the sex you want to have whenever you want to have it. That completely undermines the entire notion of chastity. Chastity just means using your sexual gifts appropriately. Does that mean you will you get to have sex often with your husband when you’re married? Yes, probably; the vast majority of the time, that’s the case. Could there exist a time when you Won’t be able to because it’s not appropriate? Yes, obviously.

If you honestly went into marriage thinking “oh, this NFP thing will allow me to do it even more often than if I were using ABC! Sweet!” then you were going into it with the wrong mindset to begin with. I imagine that’s the reason you didn’t really connect the dots—all the Church’s promotion aside. It’s just baffling to me that you didn’t realize that all of this would be difficult. Chastity, like every single virtue, is difficult. Maybe women have more trouble understanding this because they aren’t constantly struggling to avoid sexual sin like most men are? I have no idea.

I don’t mean to be too harsh, and I hope that your marriage continues on wonderfully and you continue to enjoy sex with your husband (you should!), but there was something that was bugging me about your “I didn’t know! They should have warned us!” attitude. I may even agree with you that the Church should spend more time focusing on the difficulties of life and maintaining the virtues, etc. That may be the case. I just don’t think you, or any like-minded person here, is really justified in promoting that how-could-I-have-known-it’s-not-fair-this-sucks victim attitude.
I don’t think you understand why people struggle with NFP. It’s not because they can’t have sex everyday, it’s because of the time of the month that they are abstaining. The time of the month that most women want to have sex is when they are ovulating. For me this has been the struggle. I don’t have a strong urge or a want to have sex when I am post ovulation. It is hard for my husband also because he is more drawn to me during that time (pheromones or something). Plus, relations are better when both of you are in the mood. When you are permanently practicing NFP it is kind of sad to think that we may never have sex that is for lack of a better word, great. It would have been helpful to have been told how hard this would be in our premarital class and maybe given some coping techniques. Instead I was told that charting and abstaining is a great bonding experience :rolleyes:. In reality, a great bonding experience is having great sex. 😉
 
You do know that people can search your past posts right? I haven’t done so but I know that many posters do this when reading someone for the first time. I happen to know Deb from frequent postings and know that if she is calling you out on something it is to warn others.

And though I will concede that you have not specifically said anything you are saying much between the lines. It sounds as though you are angry that NFP hasn’t/doesn’t work for you and as I’ve said you are projecting an image that seems at odd w/ Church teaching.
If I am misreading your intentions I am sorry. However, this strikes me as a “mean girl” post and nothing more. Lets not bully posters we disagree with. It doesn’t help anyone. Btw, this thread is moving way too fast for me so my posts probably seem kind of late.🤷
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top