R
Rence
Guest
GotchaSorry I am responding on my phone and so formatting is difficult. My response was regarding that poster’s use of bold the word “honestly”. As though those of us that have responded were not responding honestly.
GotchaSorry I am responding on my phone and so formatting is difficult. My response was regarding that poster’s use of bold the word “honestly”. As though those of us that have responded were not responding honestly.
I’m getting married soon, and I honestly understand it.The issue is that almost no priest is going to tell you that at the marriage preparation.
I would really like to find out how many can** honestly** claim they understood it that way before marriage.
This statement is what leads us to believe you are using ARC coupled w/ your comments regarding NFP not working for you. Obviously this is between you and your husband and God but you should know that if you are using any birth control other than NFP then you are objectively engaged in mortal sin. That means, as kristacecilia pointed out, you are cut off from the Graces of God. If you didn’t know that before your culpability is lessened but now you have been told.I guess it could work for some people to not have relations with their spouse. But it wouldn’t work for my husband and I. I’d rather take the 1% chance of a dangerous pregnancy occurring (given my birth control method failed) over not being intimate with my husband again. I actually think most people would feel the same way. But perhaps not all.
I think the subject, though is NFP specifically. Not where babies come from. Of course we all know where babies come from.Well not to be argumentative, but I haven’t said anything about what anyone else knew or didn’t. Aside from people should know before marriage that sex=babies and the only moral means of avoiding pregnancy are periodic or permanent abstinence.
Most birth control methods have a 1% failure rate, including perfect use of NFP, condoms, or hormones. I did not specify on any particular method.I am confused by your posts. Have you abandoned NFP for an immoral contraception? That’s persona you don’t have to answer, but you’ve stated that you are willing to take a 1% risk so that you can have sex w/ your spouse. Why not then chart what you can, look for answers as to why NFP hasn’t worked and abandon the rest to God?
I don’t think it will.And I hope that never changes for you :hug1:
I appreciate the concern. And you are right, this is between me, my husband, and God. No one else.This statement is what leads us to believe you are using ARC coupled w/ your comments regarding NFP not working for you. Obviously this is between you and your husband and God but you should know that if you are using any birth control other than NFP then you are objectively engaged in mortal sin. That means, as kristacecilia pointed out, you are cut off from the Graces of God. If you didn’t know that before your culpability is lessened but now you have been told.
If you are not and we are all misunderstanding you apologies if course.
It SHOULDN’T cease to amaze you. Everyone is different, and what one couple considers “just” (grave is not necessary), will not be the same thing YOU would consider just. That’s perfectly normal. The important thing is not to judge and have the attitude of “oh my goodness, that person does NOT have a just reason!” …as if you are able to judge a family from the outside.It never ceases to amaze me what people consider “grave” or “just” reasons for nfp or even abandoning nfp in favor of ABC. Do you suppose when you get older you will regret not having more babies? Do you think that most people feel illprepared financially? For the person that stated financial and health insurance as their reason for delaying children. I don’t know your circumstances, but you have to know there are options out there insurance-wise if you do become pregnant.
Have you considered adoption?Consequently, it has been very difficult to get pregnant, and my last 4 pregnancies have ended in miscarriage… so I guess what I am saying, is celebrate your fertility, have your babies while you can, and above all, TRUST in God that he will provide… God’s plan is better than your plan anyway…
I think I am reading you wrong. It seems like you are saying that observing your fertile cycle and abstaining sometimes, even needing to for extended times, is something you didn’t understand before marriage. What am I missing?I think the subject, though is NFP specifically. Not where babies come from. Of course we all know where babies come from.
I agree with what another poster said about the Church’s engagement programs not preparing a couple for the hardships of NFP and for the possibility that it may not work at all. Instead they do the opposite by paining an unrealistically rosy picture of NFP without discussing the possible negative aspects at all. It doesn’t prepare the couple very well for it at all.
I did understand that before marriage.I think I am reading you wrong. It seems like you are saying that observing your fertile cycle and abstaining sometimes, even needing to for extended times, is something you didn’t understand before marriage. What am I missing?
WowI think I am reading you wrong. It seems like you are saying that observing your fertile cycle and abstaining sometimes, even needing to for extended times, is something you didn’t understand before marriage. What am I missing?
I am also looking for “they” who “paint rosy pictures.” My experience is that it is the young engaged couple doing all the rosy painting. They are planning their wedding, not planning how to be married. I have been watching for years, both before and after I was married myself. The couple likely to end in divorce is pretty easy to pick out of a lineup. They are the ones who refuse to listen to the information that is presented. They are often the ones saying they know better than the Church; and they always *believe *they know better than the Church, whether they voice it or not.
NFP is not hard. Period. Even dingy me with wonky cycles can do it. Abstinence is also not difficult. I am doing it right now. I promise before you all that I am not engaging in relations as I type this. What ***is ***difficult, however, is putting God’s will before my own. It is also very tough to unite my husband’s and my will together and conform that to God’s will for us.
The only ones wearing rosy glasses are those who refuse to take them off.
Hmmm well I can’t speak for everyone, but that wasn’t the case with me. I believed about NFP what I had been told by the Church’s NFP promoters. That it would bring the couple closer together, strengthen the marriage … etc etc… not a peep about how much pressure it can put on a marriage or how it might not work for people with certain health conditions. I didn’t paint any rosy picture myself, I simply trusted what was being told to me. I am of the belief that they should prepare the couples for it a little bit better and discuss or at least warn about hardships regarding it.I am also looking for “they” who “paint rosy pictures.” My experience is that it is the young engaged couple doing all the rosy painting. They are planning their wedding, not planning how to be married. I have been watching for years, both before and after I was married myself. The couple likely to end in divorce is pretty easy to pick out of a lineup. They are the ones who refuse to listen to the information that is presented. They are often the ones saying they know better than the Church; and they always *believe *they know better than the Church, whether they voice it or not.
I am glad it’s been easy for you.NFP is not hard. Period. Even dingy me with wonky cycles can do it. Abstinence is also not difficult. I am doing it right now. I promise before you all that I am not engaging in relations as I type this. What ***is ***difficult, however, is putting God’s will before my own. It is also very tough to unite my husband’s and my will together and conform that to God’s will for us.
Agreed. I wish it had been presented to me in a more honest way.The only ones wearing rosy glasses are those who refuse to take them off.
I don’t think that is true. No one has judged anyone for not being able to use NFP. What has been emphasized is that ABC is never permissible…because it is a grave evil. What were you hoping to hear? That we think it’s fine for people to use ABC if NFP is too difficult? We can’t say that because it would lead to scandal…and it’s WRONG.I think all these threads about NFP share a common theme.
There are a few strong supporters who NFP works for and the rave and gush about it, and are judgmental toward those who don’t or those who NFP doesn’t work for.
Yes, she needs support and love. ABC does not fit into either of those. It is truly sad that many people face the hardship of having to avoid pregnancy, but that does not justify the use of a grave evil.Those who NFP has failed for are rather shoved in a corner and told to just deal. The OP wife is going through this right now. She doesn’t need her DH or others pushing NFP facts and figures; she needs his support and love.
No person is perfect, yet God calls each person to perfection. God gave us rules that did not come with disclaimers or exceptions. He did not say “Thou salt not…unless you really need…”. No personal hardship can justify committing an evil act, an act contrary to God’s Natural Law.Once again, I truly believe that God takes into account each situation and you do the best you can with what God’s given you. Some days it is not perfect, but that’s just part of being human; we aren’t Mary here.
Originally I asked two questions. You did not answer the second one.Sorry I am responding on my phone and so formatting is difficult. My response was regarding that poster’s use of bold the word “honestly”. As though those of us that have responded were not responding honestly.
I wish you all the best and I hope it works for you!I’m getting married soon, and I honestly understand it.
there is a difference between having empathy and understanding that it is difficult, and comisserating w/ one to the point of “yes the Church lied to me and nobody understands and it isn’t fair…ad nauseum”. And certainly there is a difference between being charitable and helping by support someone to sin. Those that say “it’s OK to use a condom for now because going w/out sex is just too hard” are completely lacking in charity. After all how can helping someone sin be charitable? And really what does complaining about it do anyway? Maybe you weren’t told everything about NFP, maybe people should have explained it more but what would that change? It is still the only moral way to avoid children besides complete abstinence so you are still in the same position. Unless of course knowing the difficulty you would not have married?I think all these threads about NFP share a common theme.
There are a few strong supporters who NFP works for and the rave and gush about it, and are judgmental toward those who don’t or those who NFP doesn’t work for. The posters don’t know every couples entire situation. There are those who quote every single encyclical known to man. There are those who try to empathize and accept each where they are currently at. Those who NFP has failed for are rather shoved in a corner and told to just deal. The OP wife is going through this right now. She doesn’t need her DH or others pushing NFP facts and figures; she needs his support and love. Once again, I truly believe that God takes into account each situation and you do the best you can with what God’s given you. Some days it is not perfect, but that’s just part of being human; we aren’t Mary here. My mission is to support all women who are struggling with NFP, because my experience and others is such a negative one in the Catholic Church today. Like I say, you take each day and do the best you can.![]()
I knew about NFP before getting married. The people I knew that had used NFP (one because she had “died” and was revived during her last delivery) had never had any unexpected pregnancies, all except for one couple that had fertile days and infertile days backwardsOriginally I asked two questions. You did not answer the second one.
You don’t have to. I am just curious how many of you understood that you could end up without sex for very long time.
It’s like celibate but in one bed with your loved spouse which makes it so much harder.![]()