Yet Another "NFP Stuggles" Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lookouts
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally I asked two questions. You did not answer the second one.
You don’t have to. I am just curious how many of you understood that you could end up without sex for very long time.
It’s like celibate but in one bed with your loved spouse which makes it so much harder. 🙂
You keep going back to this but have yet to answer my question. Can you give me a specific example? Because I find it difficult to believe that a couple will knowtheir family is done when they have 20+ years of fertility left. And if we are literally talking about death then I hope that a couple could understand that there is more to marriage than sex.
 
emmar and Debora123:

You have just proven the point that people are trying to make for you here. Marriage is HARD WORK, but you wanted this part of it to be breezy and easy. When I presented our *very *tough circumstances you both said, “I’m glad it is so easy for you.” Seriously?!?

Please look at what you are doing. You blaming NFP for something that has absolutely nothing to do with NFP. Contraception will tear you apart. *Not *contracepting will bring you together! That is a fact that our society of broken marriages, has proven!

My life is tough, day in and day out. My cycles are *insanely *wonky, extremely difficult to interpret, and my reasons for periodic continence are serious enough to warrant a LOT of abstinence!

It is my health problems, my reasons for needing to not conceive that are tough, though. NFP is a GIFT! If I used a condom, my health problems remain. Sure, I would be having a lot more sex, but it would be empty sex. Tell me how empty sex would improve an already good marriage?

Please, please, I beg you both to look at the untruths you are believing. Please don’t spread these untruths that “NFP hurts marriage.” Our culture is already so broken! Contraception is deadly to marriage! Please, please don’t do this! You are making my work doubly hard to have to unteach all of the misinformation you are spreading. There are times after the two of you post that my PM inbox lights up like someone lit it on fire. People are believing you and they are going into marriage contracepting.

NFP is not the problem. It is information and abstinence. That is all. If *abstinence *is a problem in a marriage, they need MORE of it, not less, whether they are fertile or not.

God’s design is perfect! If He wants you to abstain more, why wouldn’t you? Yes, it is tough to do God’s will in all aspects of our lives. Why would our sex life be any different? If I were to come on here and whine and moan that I don’t really want to abstain sometimes, would that make it better? I have been here for years and everyone who reads KNOWS that I wanted to have a lot of kids. Sex makes babies! I wanted a lot of kids, so I obviously planned to do a lot of practicing to get there!

But that isn’t God’s will for me. There is nothing to gain by blaming the gift of NFP for where my will doesn’t match God’s will. So far, God hasn’t called us to total abstinence. Yay, us. But if He does, then so be it. He has a plan in letting me have chronic pain. I probably won’t know that plan if or until I get to heaven.

I am just asking the one thing. Please don’t blame NFP for the problems in your marriage. The world doesn’t need another voice supporting contraception. Satan and secular culture are plenty loud as it is.
 
NFP promoters make it sound like it’s a wonderful thing, rather than preparing the couple for what it actually is - a very difficult thing that may not work for everyone.
I’ll agree with this.
I think this ties alot into Marriage Prep. I get the feeling that many couples are not much atuned (is that a word?) to the fact that having babies is a natural end to Marriage. Most young couples I meet are getting married to be with each other, to live their dreams, etc…but it’s sadly rare that they mention children.

And then when some Parishes promote NFP, they promote it like some toy we get to play with…as though it’s fun and a great way to plan the family. The folks who promote NFP to young couples need to be emphasizing, first, that Marriage is for growing and educating a family…for having children. Then, they should be presenting NFP as a natural means by which conception can be avoided, via periodic abstinence, when there is a just reason to avoid having children for a time.
 
I don’t think that is true. No one has judged anyone for not being able to use NFP. What has been emphasized is that ABC is never permissible…because it is a grave evil. What were you hoping to hear? That we think it’s fine for people to use ABC if NFP is too difficult? We can’t say that because it would lead to scandal…and it’s WRONG.

Yes, she needs support and love. ABC does not fit into either of those. It is truly sad that many people face the hardship of having to avoid pregnancy, but that does not justify the use of a grave evil.

No person is perfect, yet God calls each person to perfection. God gave us rules that did not come with disclaimers or exceptions. He did not say “Thou salt not…unless you really need…”. No personal hardship can justify committing an evil act, an act contrary to God’s Natural Law.

There are ways to support and love people in difficult times that don’t involve leading them to sin.
That’s a fine post.
I am not sure if you know that there are pragmatic priests who prefer less evil.
Some would even argue that what you might think is less evil is not even that.
 
I am just curious how many of you understood that you could end up without sex for very long time.
I understood this when I got married. We had no pressing concerns at that time, but both of us had lived through enough “stuff” to know that we should be prepared for anything. And we loved (and still love) each other enough that if we did have to abstain (whether periodic or constant) for the remainder of our lives, we’d do it…and every marital act we engage in would still be ordered toward its natural procreative end.

By the way, my wife is on an NFP forum with literally thousands of women who use NFP, and has never once run across anyone who has had to abstain for years. Months? Yes. Years. Nope.
 
I’m slightly confused about something.

Why are women waiting until marraige prep to learn about their cycles, about when ovulation happens compared to when menstuation starts?

Shouldn’t this knowledge be had around puberty and adolescence? Women are only fertile about 6 days per cycle. It isn’t hard to notice the changes during the cycle.

The deciding whether being intimate or not is more difficult, but the couple needs to assess, what need is greater, the need to be intimate vs the need to postpone or avoid a pregnancy.

I think that this is where the upset lies, “Hey, I can’t have sex when I want and avoid pregnancy simultaneously with NFP”
 
I did understand that before marriage. 🙂

That is not what I was referring to.

I was told a lot of wonderful things about NFP. That it would bring a couple closer together, that it was 99.3% effective, that it was easy/fun… etc etc.

NFP promoters make it sound like it’s a wonderful thing, rather than preparing the couple for what it actually is - a very difficult thing that may not work for everyone.
Someone lied to you if they told you that having serious reasons to delay children was easy and fun. I would suggest you write to the people in charge and see that those folks are kept from lying to other people.
 
emmar and Debora123:

You have just proven the point that people are trying to make for you here. Marriage is HARD WORK, but you wanted this part of it to be breezy and easy. When I presented our *very *tough circumstances you both said, “I’m glad it is so easy for you.” Seriously?!?

Please look at what you are doing. You blaming NFP for something that has absolutely nothing to do with NFP. Contraception will tear you apart. *Not *contracepting will bring you together! That is a fact that our society of broken marriages, has proven!

My life is tough, day in and day out. My cycles are *insanely *wonky, extremely difficult to interpret, and my reasons for periodic continence are serious enough to warrant a LOT of abstinence!

It is my health problems, my reasons for needing to not conceive that are tough, though. NFP is a GIFT! If I used a condom, my health problems remain. Sure, I would be having a lot more sex, but it would be empty sex. Tell me how empty sex would improve an already good marriage?

Please, please, I beg you both to look at the untruths you are believing. Please don’t spread these untruths that “NFP hurts marriage.” Our culture is already so broken! Contraception is deadly to marriage! Please, please don’t do this! You are making my work doubly hard to have to unteach all of the misinformation you are spreading. There are times after the two of you post that my PM inbox lights up like someone lit it on fire. People are believing you and they are going into marriage contracepting.

NFP is not the problem. It is information and abstinence. That is all. If *abstinence *is a problem in a marriage, they need MORE of it, not less, whether they are fertile or not.

God’s design is perfect! If He wants you to abstain more, why wouldn’t you? Yes, it is tough to do God’s will in all aspects of our lives. Why would our sex life be any different? If I were to come on here and whine and moan that I don’t really want to abstain sometimes, would that make it better? I have been here for years and everyone who reads KNOWS that I wanted to have a lot of kids. Sex makes babies! I wanted a lot of kids, so I obviously planned to do a lot of practicing to get there!

But that isn’t God’s will for me. There is nothing to gain by blaming the gift of NFP for where my will doesn’t match God’s will. So far, God hasn’t called us to total abstinence. Yay, us. But if He does, then so be it. He has a plan in letting me have chronic pain. I probably won’t know that plan if or until I get to heaven.

I am just asking the one thing. Please don’t blame NFP for the problems in your marriage. The world doesn’t need another voice supporting contraception. Satan and secular culture are plenty loud as it is.
AMEN to this and one more thing…

The way we live out the sacrament in our community is not something that is just “between me and God”. We are not Protestants, we know that our sin and our virtue touches every other member of the Body of Christ.
 
emmar and Debora123:

You have just proven the point that people are trying to make for you here. Marriage is HARD WORK, but you wanted this part of it to be breezy and easy. When I presented our *very *tough circumstances you both said, “I’m glad it is so easy for you.” Seriously?!?
Deb
  1. Why are you getting so angry?
  2. Can you please keep it under control?
  3. Please stop putting words in my mouth, making assumptions, and please read what I said and take what I said without making false accusations.
  4. Ok, finally to respond to your post above - NO, I did not say I “wanted this part to be easy breezy.” I said I wasn’t prepared for what was ahead in regards to NFP because I trusted what was told to me.
  5. Honestly, I AM glad it’s easy for you. Yes, seriously. No need to get so hostile. It was meant to be a genuine, polite thing to say. I am happy for you… more power to you. I can see now that you took it as me being sarcastic but I promise you that is not at ALL how I meant it.
 
Hi Jaaanosik,

During our premarital counselling, I was told very clearly that the only option available for avoiding children completely was abstinence. The priest (EF, very traditional, pulled no punches) was very clear about that to us, as well as what was okay. NFP was discussed in terms of its morality (not its effectiveness or any technical details, because that’s not really the priest’s role). I guess it never really occurred to me that it was a real possibility (however small) that I might need to permanently abstain.

As it turns out, I don’t, so it’s not an issue for me, and I have no idea how I’d feel or how my husband would feel if it was an issue.

We have, however, been given the green light by the priest to avoid indefinitely because of our particular circumstances, which are not as grave as I would have thought (very happy to have been told this, because it all seemed too hard before). That doesn’t mean we’ll be celibate, just that we’ll periodically abstain and not try to conceive.
 
I think I am reading you wrong. It seems like you are saying that observing your fertile cycle and abstaining sometimes, even needing to for extended times, is something you didn’t understand before marriage. What am I missing?
In all fairness, I think you’re being too hard on people. I grew up thinking (from speaking with my Catholic parents), that sex was a perk of marriage, and that “anything goes” as long as it’s consensual. I never was told anything about abstaining, unless the couple couldn’t have sex, for example, if an illness prevented them. Considering all the years I have spent in Catholic schools (from grammar, high school, college and university) without mention of NFP at all whatsoever, the Church isn’t doing a stellar job educating Catholics on NFP. In addition, many people have been told ABCs are a matter of conscience. My mother was told by her priest in the 70s that it was a matter of conscience, and my holy rollar grandmother never argued with her that I know of. So you can criticize all you like, but the fact is, people don’t know about NFP outside of online forums and if they do, they won’t touch it with a ten foot pole.
I am also looking for “they” who “paint rosy pictures.”
Well, you don’t have to look too far. If you do a search on NFP and Contraception even, you will find many who paint a very rosy picture of NFP. There was even a poll on this forum in which half the respondants painted the rosy picture while half said it was a burden on their marriage…
NFP is not hard. Period. Even dingy me with wonky cycles can do it. Abstinence is also not difficult. I am doing it right now. I promise before you all that I am not engaging in relations as I type this. What ***is ***difficult, however, is putting God’s will before my own. It is also very tough to unite my husband’s and my will together and conform that to God’s will for us.
I don’t think too many people here have a problem with God’s will. What they have a problem with is what others tell them God’s Will is.

It’s great that you find NFP not hard, and abstinence from your husband not difficult. But as you see from this thread, not everyone is the same as you.
The only ones wearing rosy glasses are those who refuse to take them off.
I don’t wear glasses at all. And I assure you, my contacts are blue 😃
 
Please, please, I beg you both to look at the untruths you are believing. Please don’t spread these untruths that “NFP hurts marriage.” Our culture is already so broken! Contraception is deadly to marriage! Please, please don’t do this! You are making my work doubly hard to have to unteach all of the misinformation you are spreading. There are times after the two of you post that my PM inbox lights up like someone lit it on fire. People are believing you and they are going into marriage contracepting.
Whoa whoa… wait a minute. When did I do that??

Did I ever say the words “NFP hurts marriage?” Did I promote or even MENTION contraception on this thread? The only time I even acknowledged contraception was when someone asked me about it personally, of which I thought was uncalled for - and I didn’t say anything about it either way.

And lastly… what in the world “misfortune” am I spreading???

All I did was reiterate that NFP is difficult, and say that I feel lied to by all the promoters who painted this wonderful picture without even mentioning the difficulties or that it could possibly not even work! Heck, I wish someone had told ME nfp would be difficult before I got married… I’d be much better prepared for it if that was the case, and maybe it would’ve worked out better for me!
 
Whoa whoa… wait a minute. When did I do that??

Did I ever say the words “NFP hurts marriage?” Did I promote or even MENTION contraception on this thread? The only time I even acknowledged contraception was when someone asked me about it personally, of which I thought was uncalled for - and I didn’t say anything about it either way.

And lastly… what in the world “misfortune” am I spreading???

All I did was reiterate that NFP is difficult, and say that I feel lied to by all the promoters who painted this wonderful picture without even mentioning the difficulties or that it could possibly not even work! Heck, I wish someone had told ME nfp would be difficult before I got married… I’d be much better prepared for it if that was the case, and maybe it would’ve worked out better for me!
Hi Debora,

I didn’t read the whole thread, but is it the charting that is difficult or the times of separation?
 
emmar and Debora123:

You have just proven the point that people are trying to make for you here. Marriage is HARD WORK, but you wanted this part of it to be breezy and easy. When I presented our *very *tough circumstances you both said, “I’m glad it is so easy for you.” Seriously?!?

Please look at what you are doing. You blaming NFP for something that has absolutely nothing to do with NFP. Contraception will tear you apart. *Not *contracepting will bring you together! That is a fact that our society of broken marriages, has proven!

My life is tough, day in and day out. My cycles are *insanely *wonky, extremely difficult to interpret, and my reasons for periodic continence are serious enough to warrant a LOT of abstinence!

It is my health problems, my reasons for needing to not conceive that are tough, though. NFP is a GIFT! If I used a condom, my health problems remain. Sure, I would be having a lot more sex, but it would be empty sex. Tell me how empty sex would improve an already good marriage?

Please, please, I beg you both to look at the untruths you are believing. Please don’t spread these untruths that “NFP hurts marriage.” Our culture is already so broken! Contraception is deadly to marriage! Please, please don’t do this! You are making my work doubly hard to have to unteach all of the misinformation you are spreading. There are times after the two of you post that my PM inbox lights up like someone lit it on fire. People are believing you and they are going into marriage contracepting.

NFP is not the problem. It is information and abstinence. That is all. If *abstinence *is a problem in a marriage, they need MORE of it, not less, whether they are fertile or not.

God’s design is perfect! If He wants you to abstain more, why wouldn’t you? Yes, it is tough to do God’s will in all aspects of our lives. Why would our sex life be any different? If I were to come on here and whine and moan that I don’t really want to abstain sometimes, would that make it better? I have been here for years and everyone who reads KNOWS that I wanted to have a lot of kids. Sex makes babies! I wanted a lot of kids, so I obviously planned to do a lot of practicing to get there!

But that isn’t God’s will for me. There is nothing to gain by blaming the gift of NFP for where my will doesn’t match God’s will. So far, God hasn’t called us to total abstinence. Yay, us. But if He does, then so be it. He has a plan in letting me have chronic pain. I probably won’t know that plan if or until I get to heaven.

I am just asking the one thing. Please don’t blame NFP for the problems in your marriage. The world doesn’t need another voice supporting contraception. Satan and secular culture are plenty loud as it is.
I think the issue is that you don’t seem to be acknowledging the sacrifice that NFP is. NFP has not improved my marriage, it has made it harder. Abstinence is not good for marriage. It is a hardship that may have to be endured, but it is in no way good for the relationship. Explaining to couples that NFP is a sacrifice would help a lot of people to accept it. I was painted a rosy picture of NFP in our marriage prep course and I can’t help but feel that I was lied to. Btw, just because someone shares that they are struggling with NFP does not mean that they support or are using artificial contraception.
 
I’ll agree with this.
I think this ties alot into Marriage Prep. I get the feeling that many couples are not much atuned (is that a word?) to the fact that having babies is a natural end to Marriage. Most young couples I meet are getting married to be with each other, to live their dreams, etc…but it’s sadly rare that they mention children.

And then when some Parishes promote NFP, they promote it like some toy we get to play with…as though it’s fun and a great way to plan the family. The folks who promote NFP to young couples need to be emphasizing, first, that Marriage is for growing and educating a family…for having children. Then, they should be presenting NFP as a natural means by which conception can be avoided, via periodic abstinence, when there is a just reason to avoid having children for a time.
Okay. I’ll bite. Though I am still looking for the “they” from before. I know a LOT of marriage prep people.

Understanding fertility is COOL!! There is no doubt about that. But I have yet to meet someone who promotes it like a toy. My experience is the exact opposite, that it is a sacred thing to be handled with dignity and respect. Now contraception? Oh yeah, big time. It is treated exactly like a toy. “Maybe if we make flavored condoms they will use them.” That is the theme of fast food joints who give away toys with the meal, as well.

NOT contracepting, is the gift that is promoted in marriage prep. NFP is a form of not contracepting. I have a lot of complaints about how marriage prep is handled, but pushing babies is not one of them. I spend MOST of *my *time trying to help people realize that they don’t know better than the Church.

But then, I am a fire-hose. I have **never **had a single couple say to me, “Deb, I wish you would have told us more about the realities of sex in marriage!” The joke on me is, “TMI, Deb! TMI” 😃
 
Hi Jaaanosik,

During our premarital counselling, I was told very clearly that the only option available for avoiding children completely was abstinence. The priest (EF, very traditional, pulled no punches) was very clear about that to us, as well as what was okay. NFP was discussed in terms of its morality (not its effectiveness or any technical details, because that’s not really the priest’s role). I guess it never really occurred to me that it was a real possibility (however small) that I might need to permanently abstain.

As it turns out, I don’t, so it’s not an issue for me, and I have no idea how I’d feel or how my husband would feel if it was an issue.

We have, however, been given the green light by the priest to avoid indefinitely because of our particular circumstances, which are not as grave as I would have thought (very happy to have been told this, because it all seemed too hard before). That doesn’t mean we’ll be celibate, just that we’ll periodically abstain and not try to conceive.
I am happy for you and anybody else when you are lucky and it works.

I am sorry to burst a bubble for people here but Catholic marriages suffer and break due to sex issues and NFP.

Please, just be patient and considerate with people like OP.
 
I am happy for you and anybody else when you are lucky and it works.

I am sorry to burst a bubble for people here but Catholic marriages suffer and break due to sex issues and NFP.

Please, just be patient and considerate with people like OP.
Marriages suffer and break down because of sin. A valid marriage lived according to God’s plan, worked at by two people who put God first and seek frequent grace of Confession is a marriage that lasts til death.
 
I’ll agree with this.
I think this ties alot into Marriage Prep. I get the feeling that many couples are not much atuned (is that a word?) to the fact that having babies is a natural end to Marriage. Most young couples I meet are getting married to be with each other, to live their dreams, etc…but it’s sadly rare that they mention children.

And then when some Parishes promote NFP, they promote it like some toy we get to play with…as though it’s fun and a great way to plan the family. The folks who promote NFP to young couples need to be emphasizing, first, that Marriage is for growing and educating a family…for having children. Then, they should be presenting NFP as a natural means by which conception can be avoided, via periodic abstinence, when there is a just reason to avoid having children for a time.
I would completely, 100% agree with this.

Although, just in the general light how well catechized people are these days :rolleyes: I can’t say I am surprised that it’s being done poorly.
 
Hi Debora,

I didn’t read the whole thread, but is it the charting that is difficult or the times of separation?
The charting was difficult and tedious, but I didn’t have a problem with that. It was the pressure it put on our sex life that was difficult - having a limited amount of days each month made us feel like we HAD to do it a lot on those days bc it would be 2 weeks until we could do it again… this is just the tip of the iceberg, I’m not going to delve into the whole thing on this thread bc I’ve been accused to spreading scandal by telling my whole story.

One thing I will say though is that NFP did NOT bring me and my husband closer… neither did it help our relationship… (2 things I had been told over and over again). It turned out being a pretty detrimental thing.
 
I think the issue is that you don’t seem to be acknowledging the sacrifice that NFP is. NFP has not improved my marriage, it has made it harder. Abstinence is not good for marriage. It is a hardship that may have to be endured, but it is in no way good for the relationship. Explaining to couples that NFP is a sacrifice would help a lot of people to accept it. I was painted a rosy picture of NFP in our marriage prep course and I can’t help but feel that I was lied to. Btw, just because someone shares that they are struggling with NFP does not mean that they support or are using artificial contraception.
LucyLight,
My heart goes out to you.

I agree that people who struggle aren’t necessarily promoting contraception. There are people who in other threads, who were being addressed, who do. They have bragged about their contraception use and told those of us who don’t contracept to “stop judging them.” Understand: They came to a Catholic board and pushed very wrong behavior as a good alternative and then accused faithful Catholics of judging them.

As to your more important issue, I would like to address it if I can, but it might be more appropriate in a PM to get to the nitty gritty. I will try in my next post since it is relevant to this thread, though. God bless you, LucyLight!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top