Yet Another "NFP Stuggles" Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lookouts
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I am sorry you think this is ridiculous? It’s the truth.

Do not project your defensiveness onto what you think I said. I never said anyone’s struggle wasn’t real or was lessened by Church teaching. I just laid out the Church teaching on sexual intimacy in black and white.
Your post:
No one has ever died from not having sex.

Your only moral options are periodic abstinence and total abstinence if you feel you have a just/serious reason to postpone or avoid pregnancy indefinitely.

But you already know this. How many times have we been around this block?

It is ridiculous because it simply shrugs off and disregards the facts of what some couples go through, and is dismissive.
 
Your post:
No one has ever died from not having sex.

Your only moral options are periodic abstinence and total abstinence if you feel you have a just/serious reason to postpone or avoid pregnancy indefinitely.

But you already know this. How many times have we been around this block?

It is ridiculous because it simply shrugs off and disregards the facts of what some couples go through, and is dismissive.
It’s not dismissive. It just wasn’t candy coated. It was also directed to Emmar who has been on threads identical to this one a dozen times or more. I stopped candy coating things for people who didn’t give a darn a long time ago.
 
Where am I leading others to sin because I disagree with church teachings and state the fact it has had negative impacts on my marriage? Your statement is a perfect example of what someone mentioned earlier - shove into a corner those who disagree with and do in fact have problems with NFP and church teachings; sit still, be quiet NFP is rosy.

No, it is not. Stating the facts of what is happening in one’s marriage is not leading others to sin.
Krista quoted what I mentioned. I don’t think there’s anything wrong w/ saying NFP is hard. However it doesn’t serve any purpose to stew about how you don’t agree w/ it and that you think immoral acts are OK. If someone is on the fence regarding that, they don’t understand, they may pick out your post and say “searching04 says it’s ok”. You would be responsible on some level for that person’s sin.
 
No one has ever said that the Church requires couples to practice NFP. They are certainly free to have as much sex as often as they want, but they have to be prepared to accept the consequences of their sexual act.

If they think they can handle the consequences… fine. Have sex.
Another dismissive answer. Yes, the church does dictate NFP, because no other means of avoiding are acceptable if a couple wishes to be sexually intimate and possibly avoid getting pregnant.
 
Another dismissive answer. Yes, the church does dictate NFP, because no other means of avoiding are acceptable if a couple wishes to be sexually intimate and possibly avoid getting pregnant.
The Church does not DICTATE anything. The Church OFFERS us an alternative to complete abstinence in the face of a crisis that prevents us from accepting the natural consequences of having sex during our fertile time- children.

No one has to take that offer. No one is dictating anything.

It is not dismissive of me to say, “I understand this is hard. You are struggling. Immorality is not okay, though. We are all given crosses to bear, obviously this is yours. I’ll pray for you.”

It is not dismissive of me to lay out, in black and white, Church teaching after I have said the above.

Dismissive would be saying something like, “Boo hoo. Poor you. You can’t have sex. There are people in the world who DON’T HAVE FOOD. Suck it up.”

But I never said that.
 
Another dismissive answer. Yes, the church does dictate NFP, because no other means of avoiding are acceptable if a couple wishes to be sexually intimate and possibly avoid getting pregnant.
How is that dismissive? If NFP is that difficult perhaps it is time to re-evaluate your reasons to avoid. And yes, I am married and I am actually in circumstances that many would consider is a just reason to avoid. My husband and I have decided it is not for us. Is it a bit scary? Sure until we just give that fear to God.
 
I was emphasizing the parts of your post where you were causing scandal that could lead other people to sin.
Stating my beliefs, feelings, experiences, frustrations, and disagreements is not causing scandal - heaven forbid!

You don’t like it, but tell me what the difference is between that and you or someone else saying how rosy things are and to just offer it up? Those are your experiences, your beliefs.

Actually, tell me where I am wrong, The church does dictate what can and cannot happen in sex as far as where the man can climax, and does indeed tell us that all else is disordered, grave and evil. And couples are not allowed under any circumstances whatsoever to pray and discern what maybe best for them at that time. You don’t have to like that I state it that way, but it is a fact.
 
This goes perfectly with mwncheesehead’s comment that “no one said living the faith is easy”. This is the insanity of the dictates by the church in teachings on sex. It isn’t NFP that is the problem; NFP works. It is that the church mandates that under all circumstances, at all times, no matter what, the man must climax via intercourse - semen has to land in one spot. And if not, it is “grave”, and “intrinsically evil”, and “disordered”.
You’re right, that’s what the Church teaches…
Does anyone honestly, sincerely, deeply believe that God intends for couples to be distant and suffer and not be sexually intimate whatsoever, in any manner, for months on end or even years, because there may be times the semen lands somewhere else? I do not.
No, I don’t think that’s what God intended. But in all fairness, I don’t think he intends many things specifically, though as I said in another posts: He doesn’t micromanage things, but lets life operate as it does, and intercedes when asked. Some couples will be abstinent for various reasons, for various times, regardless of NFP or ABCs. But I do understand what you’re frustrated about.
The church tells us *what *we are supposed to believe, but it does not change reality. Couples have no option to pray and decide for themselves that for the sake of a marriage and intimacy, they may need to choose non-intercourse sex or some other means for sex. Is it right all the time? Maybe or maybe not. Should the church tell couples to suck it up, life’s a *****, that’s just the way it is, and what you’re going thru isn’t supposed to be? Absolutely not. Should couples be able to pray and decide what is best for them without being condemned? Absolutely yes.
You’re right that this is a teaching of the Church. And you’re not the only one who finds this teaching a stumbling block. Many do, and people deal with it in different ways, doing the best they can on their journey in faith and understanding. No one can choose your decisions for you. They can only tell you what the Church teaches, which you know, and you have to go from there.
Some couples are perfectly fine or able to cope with no sex or extremely limited sex; some are not and it has a major, negative impact on the marriage.
That’s correct…
And for the record, even guys need intimacy; it isn’t just sex. As a couple, we disagree on, but we follow, church teachings and NFP, and it has not been positive.
I’m sorry that NFP is a burden on you and your husband, and I know that you’re not the only couple that feels that way. I will pray for you. :hug1:
 
In that, I will agree - there may be other problems, and there were/are; however, the point is that consistently in these boards it is stated that NFP surely cannot be the problem. Yes, it can be. And again, it isn’t the lack of sex; it is the lack of sexual intimacy with one’s God given spouse. Even people here who promote NFP so much seem to miss that.
So if a couple is struggling with incredible financial strain and is in debt up to their ears, they are in the clear to steal money to solve that problem? By your thinking above the problem that couple is having is at least in part the moral choice they made not to steal, right? I believe financial problems is up near being the number one reason for divorce and has an even greater threat to marriage than lack of sexual intimacy. If a person can avoid sexual morals in the name of saving a marriage why not other morals that might prevent an even greater threat to a marriage?
 
So if a couple is struggling with incredible financial strain and is in debt up to their ears, they are in the clear to steal money to solve that problem? By your thinking above the problem that couple is having is at least in part the moral choice they made not to steal, right? I believe financial problems is up near being the number one reason for divorce and has an even greater threat to marriage than lack of sexual intimacy. If a person can avoid sexual morals in the name of saving a marriage why not other morals that might prevent an even greater threat to a marriage?
This is a great analogy.
 
I keep wondering, what if a couple who was infertile tried using NFP to CONCEIVE and was unable to?

They are frustrated and hurt.

Obviously, the NFP is to blame here, right? What? No? It’s the infertility? gasp

Well, then they should be mad at God about the fact that NFP didn’t work for them! After all, they were promised that they could use it to conceive in their pre-cana classes!

Or… maybe they should discover WHY they are infertile?

Maybe if they discover there is nothing they can do about their infertility, they should accept that cross and move forward with other moral options?

Or would you suggest that, because they were told that NFP would help them conceive that the Church is at fault here? That they should look into other, immoral options like IVF?
 
Krista quoted what I mentioned. I don’t think there’s anything wrong w/ saying NFP is hard. However it doesn’t serve any purpose to stew about how you don’t agree w/ it and that you think immoral acts are OK. If someone is on the fence regarding that, they don’t understand, they may pick out your post and say “searching04 says it’s ok”. You would be responsible on some level for that person’s sin.
Relating how she is stewing about how she doesn’t agree with the teachings, but follows it anyway despite not believing in the teachings, is not wrong. If anything other people who share the same view will be able to relate to her. If someone is on the fence regarding that, and is knowledgeable about the teachings of the Church (which Searching doesn’t deny, and has posted about many times - I don’t recall her posting an incorrect teaching, just that she didn’t agree with the teaching), they need to come to their own conclusions like everyone else. The teachings are presented to all readers. All readers have to come to their own conclusiongs regarding them.

Relating her struggles is not scandalizing anyone. If anything those on the fence should see how much she suffers but has decided to follow the teachings anyway, even if she feels she is being coerced to do so. There is nothing really special about following the rules when one is totally on board about them, and they’re not a burden for one. But it takes a lot to bend to the rules when everything inside of you is screaming the opposite. So I give Searching a lot of credit, even though she hates the rules and and resents those who made them, and thinks they are complete bogus, she still trusts the Church enough to follow the rules. Having that much faith and trust is guiding her actions, despite the lack of faith and trust in the Church. The balance is tipped in favor of the Church in her case and no one can deny that because it’s obvious in her struggles. I think her dialogs are important because she is real.
 
Krista quoted what I mentioned. I don’t think there’s anything wrong w/ saying NFP is hard. However it doesn’t serve any purpose to stew about how you don’t agree w/ it and that you think immoral acts are OK. If someone is on the fence regarding that, they don’t understand, they may pick out your post and say “searching04 says it’s ok”. You would be responsible on some level for that person’s sin.
No, I wouldn’t be.

You cannot just leave it at “NFP can be hard.” That is dishonest.

So anyone who disagrees is supposed to be quiet and not post? Not have a discussion? Not maybe, maybe learn something that can help?
 
You’re right, that’s what the Church teaches…

No, I don’t think that’s what God intended. But in all fairness, I don’t think he intends many things specifically, though as I said in another posts: He doesn’t micromanage things, but lets life operate as it does, and intercedes when asked. Some couples will be abstinent for various reasons, for various times, regardless of NFP or ABCs. But I do understand what you’re frustrated about.

You’re right that this is a teaching of the Church. And you’re not the only one who finds this teaching a stumbling block. Many do, and people deal with it in different ways, doing the best they can on their journey in faith and understanding. No one can choose your decisions for you. They can only tell you what the Church teaches, which you know, and you have to go from there.

That’s correct…

I’m sorry that NFP is a burden on you and your husband, and I know that you’re not the only couple that feels that way. I will pray for you. :hug1:
A sincere thank you for at least acknowledging and in how you posted.
 
No, I wouldn’t be.

You cannot just leave it at “NFP can be hard.” That is dishonest.

So anyone who disagrees is supposed to be quiet and not post? Not have a discussion? Not maybe, maybe learn something that can help?
How is saying “I understand NFP can be hard” dishonest?

People who claim to be Catholic and post on a Catholic forum and encourage others to sin should be quiet.
 
No, I wouldn’t be.

You cannot just leave it at “NFP can be hard.” That is dishonest.

So anyone who disagrees is supposed to be quiet and not post? Not have a discussion? Not maybe, maybe learn something that can help?
What exactly do you want? Despite people agreeing that it is indeed difficult you want more. Well it’s hard. It’s supposed to be hard. Is that being dismissive? Do you just want an outlet to say “oh this is so awful how could the Church do this to us???”
 
So if a couple is struggling with incredible financial strain and is in debt up to their ears, they are in the clear to steal money to solve that problem? By your thinking above the problem that couple is having is at least in part the moral choice they made not to steal, right? I believe financial problems is up near being the number one reason for divorce and has an even greater threat to marriage than lack of sexual intimacy. If a person can avoid sexual morals in the name of saving a marriage why not other morals that might prevent an even greater threat to a marriage?
The reason is because the teachings of the Church are a matter of faith, and are more abstract without physical consequences that compare to the civil laws that govern people. If you steal, and get caught, you will have to defend yourself in a court of law, and most likely will be fined and/or jailed. There are no physical and immediate consequences to going on birth control because they are legal and acceptable in society. The Church says it is wrong, and you will be punished for it later and all that is abstract and removed from many people’s reality. So I have a hard time relating to your analogy. But maybe it will help someone else 🙂
 
Relating how she is stewing about how she doesn’t agree with the teachings, but follows it anyway despite not believing in the teachings, is not wrong. If anything other people who share the same view will be able to relate to her. If someone is on the fence regarding that, and is knowledgeable about the teachings of the Church (which Searching doesn’t deny, and has posted about many times - I don’t recall her posting an incorrect teaching, just that she didn’t agree with the teaching), they need to come to their own conclusions like everyone else. The teachings are presented to all readers. All readers have to come to their own conclusiongs regarding them.

Relating her struggles is not scandalizing anyone. If anything those on the fence should see how much she suffers but has decided to follow the teachings anyway, even if she feels she is being coerced to do so. There is nothing really special about following the rules when one is totally on board about them, and they’re not a burden for one. But it takes a lot to bend to the rules when everything inside of you is screaming the opposite. So I give Searching a lot of credit, even though she hates the rules and and resents those who made them, and thinks they are complete bogus, she still trusts the Church enough to follow the rules. Having that much faith and trust is guiding her actions, despite the lack of faith and trust in the Church. The balance is tipped in favor of the Church in her case and no one can deny that because it’s obvious in her struggles. I think her dialogs are important because she is real.
She has said that the Church should not tell us that sex needs to end w/ climax in the wife. She has alluded that people should have the right to pray about what is right for them and then engage in possibly immoral sex. How is that not scandalous?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top