Young Hispanics Leaving Catholic Church for Protestant Faith

  • Thread starter Thread starter bellasbane
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

bellasbane

Guest
Young Latinos are joining Protestant, especially evangelical, churches for a variety of reasons. According to an NPR report, young Protestant Latinos prefer the more boisterous, musical services and less structured environment to more rigid Catholic masses.

One young man told NPR he wanted a personal relationship with God instead of having to rely on a priest as an intermediary.

Protestant churches have also done a good job of reaching out to Latino youth, particularly from poverty- and gang-ridden neighborhoods. They offer youth groups, bilingual services in English and Spanish, social activities and a place to hang out.

One line of the NPR report is telling. It says of one young man, “[H]e made friends first, and then got religion.” Many Protestant churches have accepted that path, but some young Latinos don’t see that as an option in the Catholic church.

Catholics have an established and successful tradition of helping the poor and caring for the sick and elderly, but some young people also view the faith as anti-gay and intolerant. Younger Hispanics, like other demographics, are more likely to be liberal than older generations and are more likely to chafe at the Catholic Church’s conservative stances on issues like abortion and gay marriage.

abcnews.go.com/ABC_Univision/Politics/young-hispanics-leaving-catholic-church-protestant-faith/story?id=18598257#.UVQ-6RfZ60s

My understanding it that evangelical protestants also oppose abortion and gay marriage, so that cannot be why these religious young people are leaving the Catholic Church.

The protestant evangelical revival style of worship is a powerful force. We need to counter it with an equally powerful response. Liturgies in the style of the Misa Criolla could make a big difference.
 
But Catholicism isn’t necessarily losing followers to Protestants in droves, yet — the more urgent culprit for the five-year decline appears to be the growth in the number of young Latinos who have no religious affiliation at all. According to Gallup, 20 percent of 18- to 29-year-old Hispanics have no religious affiliation, fueling the decline in the number of Catholic Latino followers now and, perhaps, into the future.
Marilyn Santos, president of the National Catholic Network de Pastoral Juvenil Hispana (La Red), an association of Roman Catholic Church organizations and pastoral ministers committed to the evangelization of Hispanic youth in the United States, said assimilation into U.S. culture is partly to blame.
“They are following behind the footsteps of their non-Hispanic adults, choosing not to affiliate with any organized religion,” Santos said.
But assimilation isn’t necessarily a bad thing, Santos said. She believes the Catholic church needs to empower young Latinos to be the evangelizers, those that minister and preach to the dynamic growing Latino community. Young Latino evangelizers, she said, can better connect with their followers and help the Catholic church take notice of subtle cultural differences.
It’s as simple as the kind of music Latinos listen to in Mass, as well as the language in which they hear their sermons. Santos recalled visiting a national convention in which they translated Catholic songs into Spanish, “but beat-wise and melody-wise it just was so not Latino.” She said she believes a song entirely in English with a Hispanic rhythm would go just as far.
Santos also praised innovative national programs like Theology Untapped, created by Renewal International, which hosts guest speakers and talks for young Catholics at restaurants and bars with free food and beer.
latino.foxnews.com/latino/lifestyle/2013/02/26/us-latino-catholic-population-shrinking-less-religious-than-booming-protestant

Little off topic but a poll from Pew Hispanic center poll from 2010 found a difference in political affiliation between Hispanic Protestants and Hispanic Catholics:

catholicnewsagency.com/news/report-catholic-hispanic-voters-still-strong-democrats-but-motivation-to-vote-is-weak
 
My Catholic friends from Latin America have this amusing remark going around, especially to encourage one another to deepen their knowledge of Catholicism: “catolico ignorante, futuro protestante😃
 
My Catholic friends from Latin America have this amusing remark going around, especially to encourage one another to deepen their knowledge of Catholicism: “catolico ignorante, futuro protestante😃
Love it!
 
My Catholic friends from Latin America have this amusing remark going around, especially to encourage one another to deepen their knowledge of Catholicism: “catolico ignorante, futuro protestante😃
:sad_yes: And, isn’t that the way it is everywhere? I, myself, was almost lost due to ignorance of my faith.
 

One young man told NPR he wanted a personal relationship with God instead of having to rely on a priest as an intermediary.

How much more of a “personal relationship with God” can you have than the intimacy of becoming one in full communion with Him? 🤷
 
Yes, this is a significant problem for the Church, mostly because many people desire to be entertained above all else. What I don’t understand about this is that many Hispanics have a great devotion to the Blessed Virgin Mary. Yet these Evangelicals would teach them that she was just a sinner that God used and that she cannot hear their prayers etc., etc. This is what I do not understand! 🤷
 
How much more of a “personal relationship with God” can you have than the intimacy of becoming one in full communion with Him? 🤷
That just goes to show how they are being brainwashed. Catholics have so many avenues for developing a personal relationship with God - but the Protestants have only one. How that’s more liberating is beyond me. 🤷
 
My understanding it that evangelical protestants also oppose abortion and gay marriage, so that cannot be why these religious young people are leaving the Catholic Church.

The protestant evangelical revival style of worship is a powerful force. We need to counter it with an equally powerful response. Liturgies in the style of the Misa Criolla could make a big difference.
If they truly oppose abortion then 70% of them wouldn’t have voted for Obama.
 
If they truly oppose abortion then 70% of them wouldn’t have voted for Obama.
Obama has no power to change abortion laws, but he does have the power to change immigration laws and how they are enforced. The GOP has only themselves to blame for loosing the Hispanic vote so badly.

The crucial issue is why religious pro-life Hispanics are leaving the pro-life Catholic Church in order to join pro-birth evangelical Protestant congregations. This is a big problem.
 
My Catholic friends from Latin America have this amusing remark going around, especially to encourage one another to deepen their knowledge of Catholicism: “catolico ignorante, futuro protestante😃
Yup so true I have seen it happen over and over.😦
 
Obama has no power to change abortion laws, but he does have the power to change immigration laws and how they are enforced. The GOP has only themselves to blame for loosing the Hispanic vote so badly.]
He can influence congress to enact more pro life laws and not allow expanding abortion through legislative means.

Yes the GOP have hurt themselves with a lack of immigration policy unity on that.
The crucial issue is why religious pro-life Hispanics are leaving the pro-life Catholic Church in order to join pro-birth evangelical Protestant congregations. This is a big problem.
Perhaps they are not that good of a Catholic? But yes it is a problem and it is better that they leave and join a church that represents their beliefs.
 
I’m a young guy, was a Southern Baptist. The peppiness and emotionality truly disgusted me, no snark. I was like, “Why am I coming here for this?” Those youth events practically made me dissociate…
 
Perhaps they are not that good of a Catholic? But yes it is a problem and it is better that they leave and join a church that represents their beliefs.
That has never been a Catholic attitude, but something American Catholics have unfortunately picked up from our Protestant culture. It reflects what Cardinal George meant when he stated that that U.S. citizens “are culturally Calvinist, even those who profess the Catholic faith.”

American society, he continued, “is the civil counterpart of a faith based on private interpretation of Scripture and private experience of God.” He contrasted this kind of society with one based on the Catholic Church’s teaching of community and a vision of life greater than the individual.

newoxfordreview.org/article.jsp?did=1199-storck
 
Obama has no power to change abortion laws, but he does have the power to change immigration laws and how they are enforced. **The GOP has only themselves to blame **for loosing the Hispanic vote so badly.
I agree. They painted themselves into a corner, maybe going all the way back to Bush I. I think it was Donald Trump himself who said the reason why the Republicans won’t support too many immigration reforms is because they know it will add up to 11 million votes for the Democrats immediately.

And don’t forget that Asian vote.
 
I agree. They painted themselves into a corner, maybe going all the way back to Bush I. I think it was Donald Trump himself who said the reason why the Republicans won’t support too many immigration reforms is because they know it will add up to 11 million votes for the Democrats immediately.

And don’t forget that Asian vote.
  • Obama had a pivitol vote in 2007 that helped to block comprehensive immigration reform:
The short story is that the immigration bill was the work of a small, bipartisan group of senators. Late in the game, Mr. Obama joined the process, where he asked for (and received) changes in the bill. Yet when the legislation moved forward, Mr. Obama backed a series of poison-pill amendments. One was pushed by Sen. Byron Dorgan (D., N.D.) to weaken the guest-worker program. Sen. Ted Kennedy (D., Mass.) was outraged because he knew this amendment was really organized labor’s effort to kill the immigration bill, not to help workers. “Who is the senator from North Dakota trying to fool?” Mr. Kennedy snapped from the Senate floor.
  • Mr. Obama voted “yea” on the Dorgan amendment. We know he knew it was a deal-killer because several senators had said so (Sen. Jim DeMint, who had voted “nay” on an earlier version, switched his vote for precisely that reason). Thus Mr. Obama pulled off a trifecta: appeasing Big Labor while telling Latinos he supported the bill and blaming Republicans for its failure…What makes Mr. Obama’s 2007 Senate vote so galling—and different from that of others who voted the same way—was that his support for the poison pills betrayed the bipartisan group of senators who had let him in on the writing of the bill.
 
Obama has no power to change abortion laws, but he does have the power to change immigration laws and how they are enforced. The GOP has only themselves to blame for loosing the Hispanic vote so badly.

The crucial issue is why religious pro-life Hispanics are leaving the pro-life Catholic Church in order to join pro-birth evangelical Protestant congregations. This is a big problem.
When Obama wasa senator he voted three times against a bill that would of provided medical care to newborns who survived a late term failed abortion

Nurse Jill Stanek has described how babies were left for hours to die and Illinois law did not protect them

Abortions can be expanded or to limited with more restrictions. Obama has expanded abortion laws as president, as you can see from this long record:

lifenews.com/2010/11/07/obamaabortionrecord

From authorusing tax funding for embryonic stem cell research
 
Obama has no power to change abortion laws, but he does have the power to change immigration laws and how they are enforced. The GOP has only themselves to blame for loosing the Hispanic vote so badly.

The crucial issue is why religious pro-life Hispanics are leaving the pro-life Catholic Church in order to join pro-birth evangelical Protestant congregations. This is a big problem.
When Obama was a senator he voted three times against a bill that would of provided medical care to newborns who survived a late term failed abortion

Nurse Jill Stanek has described how babies were left for hours to die and Illinois law did not protect them

Abortion laws can be expanded or limited with more restrictions. George Bush restricted abortion laws by signing the Unborn Victims of Violence Act, Born Alive Infants Protection Act and Partial Birth Abortion Ban Act and Bush nominated Samuel Alito and John Roberts who upheld the Partial Birth Abortion Act when a lawsuit challenged it in 2007. When Obama has left office in 2016, the many pro abortion judiciary members he has selected will have a lasting impact

Obama has expanded laws regarding abortion and embryonic stem cell research as president, as you can see from this long record:

lifenews.com/2010/11/07/obamaabortionrecord
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top