Zika virus and contraception

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ron_Conte
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Then you live in a much kinder world than I do, because in my experience this has not been true.
Philo ,this world is as kind as we can make it .Our little worlds are as warm as we can try make things happen.
We put a little bit ,God does the rest.
I also come.from a family of doctors as from my great grandfather. They went in carriages far into places to help give birth , and they would not charge if you could not pay. ( andnI say " they" cause father and son worked together for somen time).My mom remembers grandad had to build a sort of cage in their home cause many patients brought them hens in return. They were Catholic ,no dichotomy…
Code:
I know many priests who serve and have served in the trenches ,my nephew is one.
And a lot ,but I mean a whole lot of persons ,friends ,working as a network to cover needs praying God will provide. And He does. He amazingly does.
There are a lot of positive things going on without loudspeakers within the warm.heart of the Church and beyond.
 
What you mean is that “we” should either:
  1. reject the Catholic Church teaching that contraception is intrinsically evil; OR
  2. reject the idea that intrinsically evil acts exist at all (which amounts to accepting the idea that the ends can justify the means).
I believe you position is in fact (1), the least bad of these.
Good morning Rau! This entire situation with this devastating virus is beyond my pay grade as a retired teacher, but I have to agree with Philomed on this one. The entire world is not Catholic so providing reliable ABC to those who wish to make sure that they do not become pregnant if they were at risk for the virus seems the best system until the scientific community develops a protocol to sterilize the nasty mosquito that is the carrier.
What I think about ABC is that it is a private decision made by each couple. I do not believe that the Church teaching on ABC is evil. As much as some here on CAF want to think that the world it’s black and white and that app answers are black and white, this very situation shows us how there are grey areas. Please remember that during the sixties, a committee formed by the Vatican urged Pope Paul VI to allow ABC. The Holy Father did not follow the recommendation, and fifty years later we can only guess at what the outcome would have been. As a progressive, I think that the Church in general would be better off, but that’s my biased opinion. We are lucky not to be living where this decision could affect thousands of infants.🤷
 
I must admit that I found your statements on suffering rather disturbing. You make it sound as if the Church doesn’t care about suffering and in fact thinks that suffering is a good thing. You make it sound as if using a condom, for example, is worse in God’s sight than the suffering that would result from children born with serious birth defects.
 
I must admit that I found your statements on suffering rather disturbing. You make it sound as if the Church doesn’t care about suffering and in fact thinks that suffering is a good thing.
A statement made in feigned ignorance of the great volume of charitable works carried out in the name of the Church.
You make it sound as if using a condom, for example, is worse in God’s sight than the suffering that would result from children born with serious birth defects.
In God’s sight the state of the soul is of more importance that that of the body. Moral failure is more importance that bodily failure.
 
I must admit that I found your statements on suffering rather disturbing. You make it sound as if the Church doesn’t care about suffering and in fact thinks that suffering is a good thing. You make it sound as if using a condom, for example, is worse in God’s sight than the suffering that would result from children born with serious birth defects.
There are 3 chances of “suffering” in this case:


  1. *]A couple use NFP to abstain until the Zika virus threat is contained. “Suffering” for some amount of time over a year or so.
    *]A couple conceive and possibly have a child with a birth defect (epidemiologist cannot say that Zika is actually the cause of microencephalitis increase in Brazil). “Suffering” for decades.
    *]A couple uses condoms or other forms of birth control. Eternal suffering as they are separated from God.

    Each option includes suffering. The difference between Catholics and others is the recognition of the eternal suffering if one chooses the third option.

    So how is the Church not concerned about suffering? They are trying to prevent eternal separation from God. Pushing condoms to reduce a small percentage of birth defects puts millions of souls at risk.

    Too many people here make three erroneous assumptions. Everyone in the Zika affected areas has contracted the Zika virus. Every act of intercourse can result in conception. And every pregnancy where the mother is infected will have a child with a birth defect. People treat it like conception with Zika is a death sentence when it is an increased chance. Even at that I have found no numbers that relate the actual risk rate (i.e. was 1 in 50,0000 and is now 1 in 18,000)

    Saving hundreds from birth defects is not worth millions of souls.

    The purpose of the Church is to get people to heaven and reduce, not eliminate, suffering on Earth. Too many focus solely on today with zero regard for eternity. Where so many focus on “how can I get me some and not risk a birth defect”, the Church is looking at the long game.

    What do you think should have happened 100 years ago if we had the same knowledge but without the availability of birth control? Would you think the Church proposing NFP to limit conception would be unjust then or would it be a mercy?
 
I must admit that I found your statements on suffering rather disturbing. You make it sound as if the Church doesn’t care about suffering and in fact thinks that suffering is a good thing. You make it sound as if using a condom, for example, is worse in God’s sight than the suffering that would result from children born with serious birth defects.
Your real point is that you consider contraception a good or neutral act. For were it otherwise, you would be arguing that the ends justify the means.
 
There are 3 chances of “suffering” in this case:


  1. *]A couple use NFP to abstain until the Zika virus threat is contained. “Suffering” for some amount of time over a year or so.
    *]A couple conceive and possibly have a child with a birth defect (epidemiologist cannot say that Zika is actually the cause of microencephalitis increase in Brazil). “Suffering” for decades.
    *]A couple uses condoms or other forms of birth control. Eternal suffering as they are separated from God.

    Each option includes suffering. The difference between Catholics and others is the recognition of the eternal suffering if one chooses the third option.

  1. Eternal suffering would not necessarily arise from temporarily using a condom or birth control. If that is a sin, someone could easily just repent later on. That might be a better option than risking decades of suffering for a child born with serious birth defects.
 
Eternal suffering would not necessarily arise from temporarily using a condom or birth control. If that is a sin, someone could easily just repent later on. That might be a better option than risking decades of suffering for a child born with serious birth defects.
First and foremost it is a sin. There are no ifs, ands, or buts about it. Just because people justify it does not make it any less a sin for Catholics, Lutherans, Buddhists or any other member of the Human race.

If they just figure they will repent later on then contrition is suspect at best. That is actual presumption on God’s mercy which is itself a sin. You can never do something immoral and just expect to say sorry later. The means never justify the ends. Full Stop.

Tell a judge you are going to steal from the bank, but you plan to pay it back in the future. I’m sure he’ll understand and let you go as long as you intend to pay it back before you die. And if you die before that happens? Well too late to worry now, unless of course you have an immortal soul to pay for you misdeeds.

This goes beyond today. It basically says that contraceptive use is situational. It isn’t. It is pure relativism to say that truth only applies if it’s not inconvenient to me.
 
Eternal suffering would not necessarily arise from temporarily using a condom or birth control. If that is a sin, someone could easily just repent later on. That might be a better option than risking decades of suffering for a child born with serious birth defects.
Sin, with a plan to repent later,? Are you mocking Reconciliation?
 
Sin, with a plan to repent later,? Are you mocking Reconciliation?
You sound surprised and why have you capitalized Reconciliation as if the notion that Christians do things with a plan to repent later is just an attempt to mock the Catholic sacrament of Reconciliation? I bet that lots of Christians, including Catholics, do things they suspect might be sinful (but perhaps not too sinful) and plan to ask for God’s forgiveness later on just in case or just believe that God in His mercy is likely to forgive them regardless.
 
You sound surprised and why have you capitalized Reconciliation as if the notion that Christians do things with a plan to repent later is just an attempt to mock the Catholic sacrament of Reconciliation? I bet that lots of Christians, including Catholics, do things they suspect might be sinful (but perhaps not too sinful) and plan to ask for God’s forgiveness later on just in case or just believe that God in His mercy is likely to forgive them regardless.
Yes, we call them un-catechised or holding erroneous beliefs. People who push condoms and other forms of contraception are just making things worse. I truly worry about those who flatly reject doctrine and teach error. They seem to forget Christ’s own words in Luke 17:2.
It would be better for him if a millstone were put around his neck and he be thrown into the sea than for him to cause one of these little ones to sin.
 
There are 3 chances of “suffering” in this case:


  1. *]A couple use NFP to abstain until the Zika virus threat is contained. “Suffering” for some amount of time over a year or so.
    *]A couple conceive and possibly have a child with a birth defect (epidemiologist cannot say that Zika is actually the cause of microencephalitis increase in Brazil). “Suffering” for decades.
    *]A couple uses condoms or other forms of birth control. Eternal suffering as they are separated from God.

    Each option includes suffering. The difference between Catholics and others is the recognition of the eternal suffering if one chooses the third option.

    So how is the Church not concerned about suffering? They are trying to prevent eternal separation from God. Pushing condoms to reduce a small percentage of birth defects puts millions of souls at risk.

    Too many people here make three erroneous assumptions. Everyone in the Zika affected areas has contracted the Zika virus. Every act of intercourse can result in conception. And every pregnancy where the mother is infected will have a child with a birth defect. People treat it like conception with Zika is a death sentence when it is an increased chance. Even at that I have found no numbers that relate the actual risk rate (i.e. was 1 in 50,0000 and is now 1 in 18,000)

    Saving hundreds from birth defects is not worth millions of souls.

    The purpose of the Church is to get people to heaven and reduce, not eliminate, suffering on Earth. Too many focus solely on today with zero regard for eternity. Where so many focus on “how can I get me some and not risk a birth defect”, the Church is looking at the long game.

    What do you think should have happened 100 years ago if we had the same knowledge but without the availability of birth control? Would you think the Church proposing NFP to limit conception would be unjust then or would it be a mercy?

  1. :clapping:
 
Eternal suffering would not necessarily arise from temporarily using a condom or birth control. If that is a sin, someone could easily just repent later on. That might be a better option than risking decades of suffering for a child born with serious birth defects.
That would be the sin of presumption, which is a mortal sin and mocks the sacrament of confession. Furthermore, going to confession to confess the sin of contracepting when contrition is not present (as it might not be in a situation where presumption has occurred) would be sacrilegious. So many sins heaped upon sins in this plan.
 
You sound surprised and why have you capitalized Reconciliation as if the notion that Christians do things with a plan to repent later is just an attempt to mock the Catholic sacrament of Reconciliation? I bet that lots of Christians, including Catholics, do things they suspect might be sinful (but perhaps not too sinful) and plan to ask for God’s forgiveness later on just in case or just believe that God in His mercy is likely to forgive them regardless.
Your post on this point presumed that such a course of action assuredly leads to forgiveness. You well know the error of that thinking. But if you didn’t, the subsequent posts above have explained it.
 
What I think about ABC is that it is a private decision made by each couple. I do not believe that the Church teaching on ABC is evil.
So just to be clear, as a person who says he is Catholic, you do not believe Catholic doctrine to be evil.

Did I misread this?
 
So just to be clear, as a person who says he is Catholic, you do not believe Catholic doctrine to be evil.

Did I misread this?
I don’t wish to speak for koz but I would hazard a guess that he is hampered by forum rules in having a legitimately honest conversation about this. A sort of caf invocation of the 5th amendment if you will…😉
 
I don’t wish to speak for koz but I would hazard a guess that he is hampered by forum rules in having a legitimately honest conversation about this. A sort of caf invocation of the 5th amendment if you will…😉
Which forum rule?
 
I am betting it was a typo (which is why I asked). It makes as much sense as telling your wife, " I really do not think you are Satan." Or how about, “Over the years my hatred for you has grown less and less.”

I use these examples so they can double as Valentine card greetings for all the romantics.
 
I don’t wish to speak for koz but I would hazard a guess that he is hampered by forum rules in having a legitimately honest conversation about this. A sort of caf invocation of the 5th amendment if you will…😉
😃 thanks Hoosier Daddy! I thought suggesting that I find any part of Church dogma “evil” as odd too. My take on this entire situation is purely from a public health stance. BTW - I’m a 62 year old SHE!:rolleyes:
 
😃 thanks Hoosier Daddy! I thought suggesting that I find any part of Church dogma “evil” as odd too. My take on this entire situation is purely from a public health stance. BTW - I’m a 62 year old SHE!:rolleyes:
I think we would all be concerned about public health. And I would not “blame” a secular government for promoting condoms - but that’s not really the point. The point is - what’s the moral course to avoid transmitting a serious medical condition? If a poster believes contraception is a moral course, they should simply say so.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top