A Historical Dare to Protestants

  • Thread starter Thread starter nsper7
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The “inheritance which is imperishable” is JESUS, not people. The “new birth” is not a one time event. It is an ongoing process of victory after victory. But the "new birth is a state of being; not a state of doing. That’s why we are called “Human Beings.” God created us to be this way; and because we have fallen into sin (a state of being) we need to “be born again,” we need to allow Jesus to bring us back to being a human being. “Being” as in being like Christ in all areas of our life. Do you know anyone who has done this instantly? History shows that that just does NOT happen. I think the Catholic Church would be in basic agreement to this post?
Experientially we see a process of sanctification. But the amazing truth that Paul teaches is that the moment I am saved I am “a new creature. Old things have passed away and ALL things have become new.”. That is not merely “positional” truth. Get this: Paul says TWICE within 4 verses (take notice when that happens) in Rom 7 “it is no longer I that sins, but sin that dwells in me.” Does that fit your theology?
 
We also believe we are responsible for our sins! We just believe Christ already paid for them. That kind of GRACE gives us a gratitude at a level you can’t even understand! And it causes us to serve God with a motivation that means LIGHT YEARS more to him than when people serve him out of obligation and fear of punishment!!! YOU JUST DON’T GET THIS.
Okay, this isn’t the first time I’ve heard this but I really want to know, WHY do some people think that we are doing anything out of fear??
Please, don’t try to tell ME about Grace and gratitude, you don’t have a clue about what all I know about that.
 
Experientially we see a process of sanctification. But the amazing truth that Paul teaches is that the moment I am saved I am “a new creature. Old things have passed away and ALL things have become new.”. That is not merely “positional” truth. Get this: Paul says TWICE within 4 verses (take notice when that happens) in Rom 7 “it is no longer I that sins, but sin that dwells in me.” Does that fit your theology?
2 Cor 5:17 tells us that “if anyone is in Christ, all things become new.” It does not say that the “all things” happens all at once. That’s why the apostle says: “grow in grace…” 2 Pet.3:18 Steady growth, constant victories are the witness that will move the world!! A mere profession after a one time event will never cut it.

You can’t excuse yourself away by saying: “I don’t sin anymore, it’s JUST sin that dwells in me!!!” If you do, then you have to admit that it is NOT “all things” yet that have become new.
 
**So what? You’re reduced **to taking her word on her teachings being truth without knowing for sure. She claims that only she can rightly interpret Scripture; therefore, you have no way of knowing whether or not she’s telling the truth because she’s excluded you from her ability to rightly divide the word. 🤷

**But one thing the prideful and stubborn mind of the anti-Catholic understands, and notes, **is the conspicuous absence of the word, “CHURCH” from the verses you’ve cherry-picked above.

Not a good job of interpretation… 👍 :nope:

Neither do you. Again, according to your Church only she has the ability to rightly divide scripture (the Mother of all circular arguments, by the way), and you’ve differentiated yourself from the Church in this statement:IOW, you are not the Church, and cannot rightly divide the scripture, and so you have no way of knowing with certainty whether or not she teaches truth.
:tiphat:

Fortunately we have millions and millions of Christians in the world who have the Holy Spirit–“the Teacher” according to Jesus–living inside them to discern what is truth and what is error.
 
But this is all just evasion.

Cath Dad, I can’t understand your and other protestant’s fear of answering a simple question.

I have posed this to many others and every single one of them would not answer.

Is it that you do not understand the question?

As I said before the the question is addressed to you. This time around and I am not asking if God would do it but rather if YOU would do it.

So for the third time.

Would YOU create human beings just so you can can burn them in hell for all eternity?

That is all I am asking. Yes or No. Very simple.
To create humans, I would have to be God. And if Iwas God, yes, I would. Now let me ask you a question: God created everyone. The Bible states both that God knows the end from the beginning AND that multitudes will spend eternity in hell. So which do you find fault with–God or the Bible?
 
Fortunately we have millions and millions of Christians in the world who have the Holy Spirit–“the Teacher” according to Jesus–living inside them to discern what is truth and what is error.
How sure are you that you are guided by the Holy Sprit?

Since you cannot even agree on matters of doctrine, which one of you is truly guided by the Holy Spirit?

Or is the Holy Spirit confused such that he teaches one this and the other that?

As po18guy put it:
Does the Spirit Unite?
Does the Devil Divide?
 
To create humans, I would have to be God. And if Iwas God, yes, I would. Now let me ask you a question: God created everyone. The Bible states both that God knows the end from the beginning AND that multitudes will spend eternity in hell. So which do you find fault with–God or the Bible?
Evading again.

Why can’t you answerr a simple hypothetical question?

Okay if you don’t want the word create. Would you and your wife plan and conceive children, just so after giving birth to them you can torture them over and over again?

Yes or No.
 
To create humans, I would have to be God. And if Iwas God, yes, I would. Now let me ask you a question: God created everyone. The Bible states both that God knows the end from the beginning AND that multitudes will spend eternity in hell. So which do you find fault with–God or the Bible?
And the Bible says

Wisdom 11:
22 4 **Indeed, before you the whole universe is as a grain from a balance, or a drop of morning dew come down upon the earth. ****23 ****But you have mercy on all, because you can do all things; and you overlook the sins of men that they may repent. ****24 ****For you love all things that are and loathe nothing that you have made; for what you hated, you would not have fashioned. ****25 ****And how could a thing remain, unless you willed it; or be preserved, had it not been called forth by you? ****26 **But you spare all things, because they are yours, O LORD and lover of souls,

So is the murderous god all of you protestants have been painting here the God of the Bible?
 
Okay, this isn’t the first time I’ve heard this but I really want to know, WHY do some people think that we are doing anything out of fear??
Please, don’t try to tell ME about Grace and gratitude, you don’t have a clue about what all I know about that.
I think that response is merely a kneejerk reaction to something you can’t intelligently refute. IF you are a father, I will let you answer this question: Which child’s birthday gift to you would you appreciate more–the one from the child who feels they HAVE to give you a gift to keep in good standing with you, or the one from the child that is totally excited about you, loves to give you gifts, and knows your relationship won’t change a bit if you forget the gift?
 
And the Bible says

Wisdom 11:
22 4 **Indeed, before you the whole universe is as a grain from a balance, or a drop of morning dew come down upon the earth. ****23 ****But you have mercy on all, because you can do all things; and you overlook the sins of men that they may repent. ****24 ****For you love all things that are and loathe nothing that you have made; for what you hated, you would not have fashioned. ****25 ****And how could a thing remain, unless you willed it; or be preserved, had it not been called forth by you? ****26 **But you spare all things, because they are yours, O LORD and lover of souls,

So is the murderous god all of you protestants have been painting here the God of the Bible?
Dear friend, if you are saying what I think you are saying, then I have two statements:
  1. You don’t believe anyone will go to hell (but how can you not find fault with God for knowingly creating people who would horribly suffer rape, murder, aids, etc???)
  2. That is one of the reasons the Apocrapha was rejected by most–it contradicts the rest of Scripture and the words of Jesus.
I
 
Evading again.

Why can’t you answerr a simple hypothetical question?

Okay if you don’t want the word create. Would you and your wife plan and conceive children, just so after giving birth to them you can torture them over and over again?

Yes or No.
You think you’re better than the Bible don’t you! When god ordered the Jews to wipe out all those men, women and children, was He a murderous God? Or do you part company with the RCC when it affirms the infallability of Scripture? Which is it?
 
I think that response is merely a kneejerk reaction to something you can’t intelligently refute. IF you are a father, I will let you answer this question: Which child’s birthday gift to you would you appreciate more–the one from the child who feels they HAVE to give you a gift to keep in good standing with you, or the one from the child that is totally excited about you, loves to give you gifts, and knows your relationship won’t change a bit if you forget the gift?
Boy you just don’t let up do you? You insult our faith, and now our intelligence. I am not a father, but I had one, one so good that he helped me to understand how loving our heavenly Father is.

As a matter of fact, he even helped me to understand that you actually have to be sorry about something, not just pretend to be, or act like you can get away with things and that it doesn’t matter.

I was the youngest of nine, I am female, and it would have been so easy for my father to just overlook everything and spoil me and let me get away with everything, but instead, he instilled in me a deep love of God, a respect and awe for HIM, my own father loved me no matter what, but he did teach me that there are limits. Our heavenly Father, God, is the same way. Eventually you have to come to the understanding that you can’t get away with everything and pretend that it just doesn’t matter, if you love someone and have respect for them, you want to please them and do all you can for them, not take advantage of them.

I didn’t obey my earthly father because I feared him, but rather, because I loved him and wanted to please him. When you love God with all your heart, mind and soul, you certainly want to obey Him and make HIM the center of your life and please HIM in all things.

Was that intelligent enough for your standards or are you going to find something to pick apart about that too?
 
Boy you just don’t let up do you? You insult our faith, and now our intelligence. I am not a father, but I had one, one so good that he helped me to understand how loving our heavenly Father is.

As a matter of fact, he even helped me to understand that you actually have to be sorry about something, not just pretend to be, or act like you can get away with things and that it doesn’t matter.

I was the youngest of nine, I am female, and it would have been so easy for my father to just overlook everything and spoil me and let me get away with everything, but instead, he instilled in me a deep love of God, a respect and awe for HIM, my own father loved me no matter what, but he did teach me that there are limits. Our heavenly Father, God, is the same way. Eventually you have to come to the understanding that you can’t get away with everything and pretend that it just doesn’t matter, if you love someone and have respect for them, you want to please them and do all you can for them, not take advantage of them.

I didn’t obey my earthly father because I feared him, but rather, because I loved him and wanted to please him. When you love God with all your heart, mind and soul, you certainly want to obey Him and make HIM the center of your life and please HIM in all things.

Was that intelligent enough for your standards or are you going to find something to pick apart about that too?
Thank you for sharing something personal with me. In one sense, you didn’t answer my question, though. But in another sense you did. I think I heard you tell me that you had a special and loving relationship with a man, your father, who, NO MATTER HOW BADLY you stumbled, even if in a weak moment or period in your life you told him you “hated” him, would always love you UNCONDITIONALLY and who would NEVER disown you, no matter what. THAT is how we believe our heavenly Father treats us once we accept the death of His Son as the payment for all our sins and are born into His Family. That’s all weakre saying!
 
You think you’re better than the Bible don’t you! When god ordered the Jews to wipe out all those men, women and children, was He a murderous God? Or do you part company with the RCC when it affirms the infallability of Scripture? Which is it?
Are you incapable of understanding a simple question?

Over and over again you have failed to answer an extremely simple question even someone with the lowest IQ would understand.

So please stop this evasion tactic and just answer this question.


*This is not a question about what God would do but what you would do. Nothing to do with the Bible. *

So for the 5TH time.

Would you and your wife plan and conceive children, just so after giving birth to them you can torture them over and over again?

Yes or No.

What is so hard about that?
 
To Catholics on this thread,

I have posed this question to protestants and not a single one of them has answered this question.

I was wondering if I would get a response from any of you or perhaps this is really something it is hard for people to answer.

So here it is:

*Would you and your wife (ie if you are married and if not imagine yourself married) plan and conceive children, just so after giving birth to them you can torture them over and over again?

Yes or No.
*

Many thanks!
*
*
 
Are you incapable of understanding a simple question?

Over and over again you have failed to answer an extremely simple question even someone with the lowest IQ would understand.

So please stop this evasion tactic and just answer this question.


*This is not a question about what God would do but what you would do. Nothing to do with the Bible. *

So for the 5TH time.

Would you and your wife plan and conceive children, just so after giving birth to them you can torture them over and over again?

Yes or No.

What is so hard about that?
The answer is Yes. Niw answer mine. You are the one who is evasive. God says his ways are FAR above your ways, my dear. But you laugh at that notion, I fear.
So which is it for you? Do you judge the God of heaven for ordering the Jews in the OT to kill all those people, or do you judge the infallable RCC for declaring that Scripture is the infallable word of God?
 
Dear friend, if you are saying what I think you are saying, then I have two statements:
  1. You don’t believe anyone will go to hell
I am not sayiing that at all.
(but how can you not find fault with God for knowingly creating people who would horribly suffer rape, murder, aids, etc???)
So you think it’s God’s fault that these people are murderers, rapists,etc.

You’re image of god is growing more evil by the minute. You are beginning to argue like my atheist friend.
  1. That is one of the reasons the Apocrapha was rejected by most–it contradicts the rest of Scripture and the words of Jesus.
    I
Ah yes of course. I forgot. You have chopped up the Word of God.

The contradiction exists only in your mind.
 
To Catholics on this thread,

I have posed this question to protestants and not a single one of them has answered this question.

I was wondering if I would get a response from any of you or perhaps this is really something it is hard for people to answer.

So here it is:

Would you and your wife (ie if you are married and if not imagine yourself married) plan and conceive children, just so after giving birth to them you can torture them over and over again?

Yes or No.

Many thanks!
*
*
I was not evading you, my dear. I have not one speck of need to do that. I needed to wait until I knew how God wanted me to answer…If it was me, as I exist here, knowing what I know, I couldn’t do that. No. But dear woman I wouldn’t put my son to death on a cross for a bunch of people in rebellion against me either.
God’s ways are so far above the ways of your puny mind and system of reason its beyond comprehension. That is what He says in his word.
Now you answer my question: Do you call the God of heaven a murderer for telling His people in the OT to kill all those pagan people, or do you judge the “infallable” RCC for teaching that Scripture is the Divinely inspired infallable word of God? Which is it?
 
I am not sayiing that at all.

So you think it’s God’s fault that these people are murderers, rapists,etc.

You’re image of god is growing more evil by the minute. You are beginning to argue like my atheist friend.

Ah yes of course. I forgot. You have chopped up the Word of God.

The contradiction exists only in your mind.
You are not following very well. I find no fault at all with God. He is perfect in every way. I’m saying if YOU think GOD couldn’t create people He knew were going to hell, then you must also have a problem with a notion of a God who ALLOWS innocent people to be born, knowing that they will be raped, molested by who knows what, die of starvation, etc. He could have prevented all of that. He ordered the Jews to kill whole towns. Do you understand He was perfectly just in doing that?
 
2 Cor 5:17 tells us that “if anyone is in Christ, all things become new.” It does not say that the “all things” happens all at once. That’s why the apostle says: “grow in grace…” 2 Pet.3:18 Steady growth, constant victories are the witness that will move the world!! A mere profession after a one time event will never cut it.

You can’t excuse yourself away by saying: “I don’t sin anymore, it’s JUST sin that dwells in me!!!” If you do, then you have to admit that it is NOT “all things” yet that have become new.
All right, you’re going to have to be sharper than that. That verse says “if ANY man is in Christ, he is a new creation…” The moment I receive Christ I am in Him. That moment I am a new creation, etc. There are lots more verses that confirm this. Look below at my signature. Read Romans 6-8.
Secondly, you didn’t even deal with the text I quoted from Romans 7. I didn’t write those verses. Why don’t you read them first, then tell me what they mean. Hint: you might want to tie them to II Cor 5:17 and said signature below. Just a thought! Have fun.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top