Animal Biotechnology and Guided Evolution

  • Thread starter Thread starter Camron
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
"the Holy Father’s message acknowledges that there are “several theories of evolution” that are “materialist, reductionist and spiritualist” and thus incompatible with the Catholic faith. It follows that the message of Pope John Paul II cannot be read as a blanket approbation of all theories of evolution, including those of a neo-Darwinian provenance which explicitly deny to divine providence any truly causal role in the development of life in the universe.
Yes, and I’ve already explained with precision which theories of evolution are expressly condemned by the Catholic Church.

How exactly is Guided Evolution considered to be condemned by the Catholic Church?
Mainly concerned with evolution as it “involves the question of man,” however, Pope John Paul’s message is specifically critical of materialistic theories of human origins and insists on the relevance of philosophy and theology for an adequate understanding of the “ontological leap” to the human which cannot be explained in purely scientific terms."
– CATHOLIC INTERNATIONAL THEOLOGICAL COMMISSION
COMMUNION AND STEWARDSHIP
Human Persons Created in the Image of God
And how have I suggested that our human origins do not also rely on the relevance of philosophy and theology for an adequate understanding of the “ontological leap” to the human? I myself have said that our origins cannot be explained in purely scientific terms. I’ve stressed this several times too.
“the theories of evolution which, because of the philosophies which inspire them, regard the spirit either as emerging from the forces of living matter, or as a simple epiphenomenon of that matter, are incompatible with the truth about man.”
– Pope John Paul II
MESSAGE TO THE PONTIFICAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES: ON EVOLUTION, 1996
Already covered here…in great detail…this has been pointed out to you already too…
“When one examines many New Age traditions, it soon becomes clear that there is, in fact, little in the New Age that is new. The name seems to have gained currency through Rosicrucianism and Freemasonry, at the time of the French and American Revolutions, but the reality it denotes is a contemporary variant of Western esotericism. This dates back to Gnostic groups which grew up in the early days of Christianity, and gained momentum at the time of the Reformation in Europe. It has grown in parallel with scientific world-views, and acquired a rational justification through the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. It has involved a progressive rejection of a personal God and a focus on other entities which would often figure as intermediaries between God and humanity in traditional Christianity, with more and more original adaptations of these or additional ones. A powerful trend in modern Western culture which has given space to New Age ideas is the general acceptance of Darwinist evolutionary theory; this, alongside a focus on hidden spiritual powers or forces in nature, has been the backbone of much of what is now recognised as New Age theory.”
PONTIFICAL COUNCIL FOR CULTURE
PONTIFICAL COUNCIL FOR INTERRELIGIOUS DIALOGUE
JESUS CHRIST THE BEARER OF THE WATER OF LIFE
Yes, and this is what I’ve been saying. There are many who attempt to use the theory of evolution to prove that God didn’t actually create us. But the theory of evolution does not actually claim this. Nor can the theory of evolution actually prove that God didn’t create us either. The claim that the theory of evolution proves that God didn’t actually create us is an atheistic philosophy that some have recklessly and irresponsibly attached to the theory of evolution. Evolution and atheism are not synonymous with each other, although some forms of evolution are atheistic in nature.
 
“As to the theory of evolutionism, you will not consider it acceptable if it is not clearly in agreement with the immediate creation of human souls by God and does not regard the disobedience of Adam, the first universal parent, as of decisive importance for the destiny of mankind.”

– Pope Paul VI, Address to Theologians at the Symposium on Original Sin, 1966
Regarding human souls, again already covered here…

We are in agreement that souls are immediately created by God. Theories of evolution do not explain the emergence of the human soul as breathed directly by God.

Regarding the disobedience of Adam, the first universal parent, as being of decisive importance for the destiny of mankind, I have no doubt that Adam is the first true human that all true humans are descended from Adam.

I also have no doubt that all true humans have suffered the effects of Adam’s Original Sin too (i.e., both spiritual and physical death).

I also have no doubt that Adam, the first true human, is of decisive importance to humanity as Christ Himself was considered the Second Adam, undoing the sin of the First Adam.

Again, I don’t see exactly how the theory of evolution actually refutes any of these beliefs. Some have erred into the direction of polygenism. I haven’t though as far as I can tell. I don’t think it’s required either. Church Dogma does not need to change for the Theory of Evolution.
“[Darwinism is] A system which is repugnant at once to history, to the tradition of all peoples, to exact science, to observed facts, and even to Reason herself, [Darwinism] would seem to need no refutation, did not alienation from God and the leaning toward materialism due to depravity, eagerly seek a support in all this tissue of fables… And, in fact,… after rejecting the Creator of all things and proclaiming man independent, wishing him to be his own king, his own priest, and his own God, pride goes so far as to degrade man himself to the level of the unreasoning brutes, perhaps even of lifeless matter, thus unconsciously confirming the Divine declaration, when pride cometh, then cometh shame. But the corruption of this age, the machinations of the perverse, the danger of the simple, demand that such fancies, altogether absurd though they are, should — since they borrow the mask of science — be refuted by true science.”
– Pope Pius IX, Letter to Dr. Constantin James, 1877
Again, I’m talking about Guided Evolution. If your argument is with Darwinism then you’re arguing with the wrong person.

Please note too that I would appreciate if you could actually respond in your own words. I highly value the words of the men that you’ve provided, especially since many Popes are included. But, as my responses indicate, the warnings they have issued do not necessarily apply to the topic at hand.

And it becomes exceptionally difficult to reply to people if they’re just posting huge quotes without a significant part of the post being in their own words.
 
There is no such thing as guided evolution. Never will be. Yes, it may be possible to manipulate genetic material to produce a certain product or certain changes but this is not evolution. It is simply manipulation.

The theory of evolution as written is like a business contract. If something does not appear in it, it is automatically excluded. Since anti-theists are fond of using the courts to get their way, they will also in regard to evolution. The theory is 100% perfect since it explains, supposedly, how purely random forces subjected to so-called natural selection, produced life. So, in their mind, the contract is acceptable as written. For the Christian, no. That is why the Pope must add the necessary wording and the critical information that must be at least heard by every human being. And that is one purpose of this forum - to spread the gospel and recognize God.

Human reason is not science? Is that so? And how else does science operate if not by human reason? And if science is limited to only the perceptible, and also scientists, what changes when the scientist hangs up his lab coat, walks outside and realizes, through his own reason, that the things he sees before him reveal God?

God bless,
Ed
 
I’m sorry – I thought it was a fairly simple question. I asked you to explain the difference between Guided Evolution and Unguided Evolution. In the posts that you linked to again (thanks for finding those) you talk about miracles and God’s work, but you don’t explain what is meant by “Unguided Evolution”.
Unguided evolution is any form of evolution that is claimed to happen without God’s creation, design, sustenance, awareness and inevitable entrance into or else amongst the very life forms that are evolving within it.

In a guided form of evolution God would actually create all things from nothing, providing all the raw potential energy and matter for all things that can exist to eventually exist if the conditions are correct for it to happen.

In a guided form of evolution God would be deeply involved in the design of the original parameters of the creation too, ensuring all the laws and effects that can possibly happen are designed with precision. This would ensure that the raw potential energy and matter that God created from nothing would indeed cause all things that can exist to eventually exist when the conditions are met.

In a guided form of evolution God would also be deeply involved in the sustaining His creation too, ensuring that, by His grace, the universe endures forever. This is where the God who guides evolution would sharply departs from the god of the Deists. He has not only created and designed the universe. He is also actively sustaining the universe too, so much so that if He were to withdraw His presence from the universe, the universe would cease to exist.

In a guided form of evolution God would also be deeply aware of His creation too, so much so that it could be said that God is indeed omniscient since He is fully aware of all things that can happen, have happened, and will happen. In the sense, God is not blind to the forces that He is using to accomplish His will. He is both deeply involved with and deeply aware of what’s happening within His creation.

In a guided form of evolution God would also be deeply penetrating of His creation too, so much so that He could even come and be born to a Virgin Mother and Incarnate within her pure womb as Human Baby Boy. In a guided form of evolution God would enter into His own creation in order to bring forth all those who love and trusted Him into Heaven.

There will be more later. But this is the basic outline for now.
My first response was that you had posted too much to respond to. I didn’t have the time.
Your posts have been long and detailed too, often incorporating various different in-depth topics in a single post. And yet I’ve been taking the time to respond to them as best as I could without responding to topics brought up multiple times.

Do you have the time to respond to them now?
 
I fully intended to reply, but hecd2 decided to interrupt the conversation and attack me from a materialist-philosophical position.
Then place hecd2 on your ignore list for a bit and stay with the discussion we are having.
I therefore had to spend time replying to his attacks against the Catholic Faith because I was quite certain that none of the Darwinian-Catholics would say anything against his comparisons of Catholicism with magic and witch doctors.
I see now. I had to take hecd2 off my ignore list to actually read what he said.
When you argue that everything is guided by God, what you really meant was “some things” are guided by God.
No, I meant that everything is guided in some way by God.

Simply put, there are diferent levels of control. I will explain this in more detail later, but could you please stop telling me what I actually meant?

It’s very annoying actually, especially since you’ve already admitted that you didn’t really know what Guided Evolution was and now you’re claiming that it’s nothing more than a cover-up.

Pay attention to what I’m saying.
The problem here is that the distinction that was covered-over is the crux of the issue.
I haven’t covered anything up. You don’t actually understand what I’m talking about. You’ve said so yourself many times too.
It’s the difference between Guided and Unguided – and you seemed to dispense with the idea that there is any difference at all (or that anything can be called “unguided”).
You don’t even understand what I mean by when I say guided and unguided and then you have the audacity to actually claim that I’ve dispensed with the idea that there is any difference at all (or that anything can be called "unguided”)? :whistle:
That position is condemned by the Church in the first place.
No, the position that nature does God’s bidding, accomplishing God’s will, is not condemned by the Church. In fact, the Bible states that various elements of nature do God’s bidding.
Praise the LORD from the earth, you great sea creatures and all ocean depths,
lightning and hail, snow and clouds, stormy winds that do His bidding…
Psalm 148:7-8
And if you claim that this passage is just poetic and not meant to be taken literally, then why does the Bible use the same language regarding God’s angels too within Psalm 103:20?
Praise the LORD, you His angels, you mighty ones who do his bidding, who obey His word.
We know that angels do indeed do God’s bidding.

And if so, why is it that cannot God use angels to guide the course of nature to do His bidding too?

Or why couldn’t God simply guide the course of nature to do His bidding for that matter, especially since the Bible does say that nature does God’s bidding?

No, that position has not been condemned by the Church in the first place. That position has been condemned by you. And the question before us is stil whether God used natural or miraculous means to form Adam’s body or not.
First of all, “Adam” is not a product of natural laws since natural laws cannot create supernatural substances.
I didn’t say that God could have used natural laws to create Adam’s spirit and soul. I said that God could have used natural laws to create Adam’s natural body. You should understand this by now.

And, no, I’m not saying that God did it this way.

Yes, I’m saying that God could have done it this way.
 
Ok, you just contradicted your prior statements, but that’s understandable. It’s a difficult topic.
Please stop doing that. I haven’t tried to humiliate or patronize your position. And I’ve treated it with fairness, as much fairness as I can consider bearing in mind I don’t actually agree with you.
You previously claimed that God guides everything.
Yes.
Now you’re saying that a miracle is distinguished from that activity by a “specific intervention”.
Yes, a “specific intervention” that overrides a previous “specific intervention”.

The Big Bang was most likely according to this model a “specific intervention”. This is a supernatural action of God.

Then the introduction of laws into the universe was most likely another “specific intervention”. This was another supernatural action of God, overlaid over or else integrated within the previous “specific intervention”.

All things have a supernatural origin Reggie. The problem is that, from our limited human perspective, once the “specific intervention” happens and has been ongoing for a long time, we can no longer tell that it was a “specific intervention” by God.

The universe still exists for example, starting from the Big Bang. But we no longer say that the universe requires a “miraculous” means to sustain itself even though the Bible does say that God sustains all things by His powerful Word. Indeed, according to Hebrews 1:3, the Son is the radiance of God’s glory and the exact representation of His being, sustaining all things by His powerful word.

In other words, our continued existence is actually prolonged within the extension of a grand miracle, the creation of the entire universe from nothing. But we can no longer discern the “miraculous” from the “natural” even though the origin of the universe (and it’s sustained existence) is indeed held together on a spiritual level that we can no longer distinguish from the physical medium that it holds together.

The same to applies to all other events too. What we perceive as a miracle now is actually an augmented “specific intervention” by God building upon previous miracles. The problem is that we can no longer, in many cases, actually distinguish the “natural” from the formerly “miraculous”. To us it just appears “natural”

But we can still recognize the miraculous from the natural now, so long as God actually does something that supersedes the former “specific intervention”, such as transforming a staff into a serpent for example.
But most importantly, you’ve introduced the phrase “natural creation could not accomplish on it’s own”.
The universe could not create itself on it’s own either.

Are you really not getting this? :confused:
Thus, you’ve refuted the notion that “Guided” applies to everything in nature…
:banghead:

Yeah…Later for now… 👋
 
Unguided evolution is any form of evolution that is claimed to happen without God’s creation, design, sustenance, awareness and inevitable entrance into or else amongst the very life forms that are evolving within it.
You’re defining Unguided Evolution as a form of evolution that is *claimed *to happen without God … etc.

The key word there is “claimed”. Of course, evolutionists will all deny that evolutionary theory claims that it happened without God. It just says “it happened”.

Essentially, you’re denying that any natural process is “unguided” since it is only “claimed” and not actually an unguided process. I already showed that this conflicts with Catholic theology that distinguishes between “aided” and “unaided” reason, for example.

The proposal you’ve given is that “everything is guided”. Therefore, anything that Darwinists claim happened is merely interpreted as “God did it” without the need to show God’s involvement (or that the results reveal God’s power).

Again, in the example I gave many times – a pile of rocks after an avalanche would be considered the product of a “guided natural law”. Thus, the operation of the natural laws alone would be as miraculous as anything else.
In a guided form of evolution God would actually create all things from nothing, providing all the raw potential energy and matter for all things that can exist to eventually exist if the conditions are correct for it to happen.
I’m sorry, I can’t follow this. If God created the prime matter and form of all things (as St. Thomas teaches), then what follows from that is not “evolution” (as it is commonly known).

If we’re going to define the term evolution to mean “change over time” then I think the counterpoint to that would be “nothing in nature ever changed since the beginning of the world”. I don’t see that argument raised even by hard-core fundamentalists.
In a guided form of evolution God would be deeply involved in the design of the original parameters of the creation too, ensuring all the laws and effects that can possibly happen are designed with precision. This would ensure that the raw potential energy and matter that God created from nothing would indeed cause all things that can exist to eventually exist when the conditions are met.
I think you’re doing a decent job describing God’s involvement in the creation of the natural laws here. The argument you could make is that God created the natural laws to thereby create, by evolution, all of the things in nature “on their own”. This is not “guided” evolution though since there is no need for God to “guide” laws which He designed to fulfill the task.

What would happen if God didn’t “guide the laws”? In your view, nothing at all would happen because nothing can happen without God guiding it.

This is something quite different than what one calls “evolution”. Certainly, it’s a refutation of Darwinism (and I believe you’ve affirmed that already). That is good – but again, I wouldn’t call it “evolution”. It’s really a form of creationism. God is creating all of the things in nature.
And yet I’ve been taking the time to respond to them as best as I could without responding to topics brought up multiple times.
Yes, you have and you’ve done a very good job of it.
Do you have the time to respond to them now?
They’re too far back for me to retrieve and I haven’t been thinking about them.

You asked about wind burst (or something like that). Those can either be explained through natural causes or not. If not, then they could be evidence of God’s power. If so, then they’re explained naturally. They could still be miracles but they cannot be used in a test for science. In the same way, God could work a miracle to cure someone of a cold, but science will not accept it as out of the natural course of events.

You asked about God writing on the tablets and what that says about His personality. Writing analysis is designed to understand human personality – not divine. Something might be said about God’s personality in looking at the tablets, or not. The shaping of the letters themselves would be specified complexity and evidence of intelligent design. If the letters could not have been produced by human hand, or by any tools known to mankind at the time – then it’s evidence that an intelligence beyond human created them.
 
And if so, why is it that cannot God use angels to guide the course of nature to do His bidding too?
I’m confused by your reasoning. God guides everything. But God also uses angels to guide the things that God is already guiding. Nature is actually a supernatural expression of God’s will, but God also bids things of nature. On top of it all, you don’t accept that there’s any evidence of God’s intelligent design in any of this. :confused:
No, that position has not been condemned by the Church in the first place. That position has been condemned by you. And the question before us is stil whether God used natural or miraculous means to form Adam’s body or not.
You added the term “body” to the original term you used which was “Adam”. So, you’ve refined your focus here. If we talk about “Adam”, we’re not talking about his body, so then yes, the Church condemns the idea that Adam, the person, was the product of natural processes alone.
 
Yes, and this is what I’ve been saying. There are many who attempt to use the theory of evolution to prove that God didn’t actually create us. But the theory of evolution does not actually claim this. Nor can the theory of evolution actually prove that God didn’t create us either. The claim that the theory of evolution proves that God didn’t actually create us is an atheistic philosophy that some have recklessly and irresponsibly attached to the theory of evolution. Evolution and atheism are not synonymous with each other, although some forms of evolution are atheistic in nature.
Does the theory of evolution claim that it is Guided, Unguided or something else? In other words, is “the theory of evolution” the same as “guided evolution”?
 
YAnd how have I suggested that our human origins do not also rely on the relevance of philosophy and theology for an adequate understanding of the “ontological leap” to the human? I myself have said that our origins cannot be explained in purely scientific terms. I’ve stressed this several times too.
It’s good to hear that, but you’re arguing for something that is not what one might call “orthodox evolutionary theory”. In other words, the “evolutionary theory” held by the vast majority of scientists accepts that human origins can be explained in purely scientific terms.

We could take a look at hecd2’s recent comments where he stated this and he affirmed that the natural laws provide an adequate explanation of all of nature (obviously including human origins).

I would consider him a mainstream evolutionist.

I would consider your views to be wildly outside of the mainstream of evolutionary thought. This shouldn’t be a problem at all, except that you cover-over this distinction when you argue in favor of “evolution”. You’re actually talking about a theory that a tiny minority of scientists hold – in fact, possibly even a smaller group than ID scientists.
 
Cameron,

Before you read and reply to my two previous posts, I hope you will read this one first.

I think I have discovered a core reason for the disagreement we have about a number of things on this topic.

With your more detailed explanation of Guided Evolution in your last posts, I conclude that you posit a world and a universe that is entirely shaped and supported by God’s power and providence. All of the natural laws are made by Him, and all of the laws are constantanly sustained by Him. The laws themselves are a product of His supernatural power and what they create and act upon is the same. The development of human beings, life itself and the things of nature are Guided by God and oriented to fulfill his purpose.

I hope you agree with all of that, because that all is perfectly compatible with Scripture and the Deposit of Faith.

In fact, I fully agree with and embrace all of that myself. The only exception is the use of the word “evolution” above, because what you’re talking about is not “evolution” in the ordinary use of that word. It’s actually creationism – God is creating all things and sustaining all things.

In that scenario, there’s no need to talk about evolution, because God is the Prime Mover behind all of the development of nature.
 
You’re defining Unguided Evolution as a form of evolution that is *claimed *to happen without God … etc.
No, you can’t just list all that I said as “etc.” and then just dismiss it.

Remember what I said:
Unguided evolution is any form of evolution that is claimed to happen without God’s creation, design, sustenance, awareness and inevitable entrance into or else amongst the very life forms that are evolving within it.
All of these components are critical to what I am saying could be the case. I am not saying they are the case. I am saying could be the case
The key word there is “claimed”.
No. The keys words are Guided Evolution (cf., A Theistic Form of Evolution) with various levels of control exerted by God. Now would please stop trying to change the topic and would you please start focusing on what I am actually stressing.
Of course, evolutionists will all deny that evolutionary theory claims that it happened without God. It just says “it happened”.
But I’m talking about a form of Theistic Evolution, something which you seem to be determined to reduce to the atheistic philosophies condemned by the Catholic Church that many attempt to attach to the theory of evolution. I’ve been very clear that these atheistic philosophies that some try to attach to the theory of evolution are not what I am talking about too.
Essentially, you’re denying that any natural process is “unguided” since it is only “claimed” and not actually an unguided process.
No. I am saying that by the light of reason one can clearly discern that these “natural processes” are supernaturally directed by their Creator for a purpose to point toward God. I’ve been very clear about this. Now stop doing that please.
 
Cameron,

Before you read and reply to my two previous posts, I hope you will read this one first.
Ok. I have read this one.

But I need to proceed with the discussion as it was going because you need to seriously understand that you were actually arguing with someone who actually agreed very much with most of what you were stating, except the science part.

Reggie, you saw the word “evolution” and simply assumed the worst. And you need to stop doing that because, in the end, you were actually starting argue against many things that you actually hold dear to yourself.

Remember when you asked about angels doing God’s will?

You know as well as I do that angels do indeed do God’s will.

Exactly why?

Nobody knows exactly for sure.

But through Revelation we know that God has allocated some degree of responsibility to them. And yet, simply because I used the word “evolution”, you were prepared to go tooth and nail in an argument with me to prove a point. I could almost hear the hairs bristle on the back of your neck whenever I mentioned it

In the end, in my opinion, you were actually starting to deconstruct many of your own beliefs simply because I used the word 'evolution" in my text. This is the danger behind the ID movement in its most succinct form as I see it.

Am I saying there are no dangers behind the theory of evolution?

No. That’s not what I’m saying at all. There are indeed many dangerous and deadly philosophies associated with the theory of evolution. I’ve noted more than a few here in this thread.

Anyway, I hope you seriously pray over this and seriously think about this.

Evolution is not evil. And if God did indeed use it, then it’s something very good indeed, even if we don’t fully understand how it all works. 🙂

For the record, I am going to post some of my thoughts as I was typing them before I read this link. Keep in mind that they are all trying to get you to see past the word “evolution”. After you read them perhaps we can take a stroll throughout the first three books of Genesis and see what we can find verse by verse and share some thoughts as to what we think the Bible actually means.
 
I already showed that this conflicts with Catholic theology that distinguishes between “aided” and “unaided” reason, for example.
Here is your original post too for further reference.
I mean first we have the notion – “Nature looks like it was designed (as Richard Dawkins among many others admit) but it was actually caused by random chance.”
But then we would have to twist that:
“Nature looks like it was designed, but the process used to design was essentially random, although – it just appears like the process is random, when it really is God designing it.”
Again, that cannot be refuted as I see it. God could have created the appearance of design, then the appearance of randomness, but the reality was design.
But if that’s true - why wouldn’t we just say that the appearance of design is true – since it was designed? I guess there are too many loops in that cycle for me.
Then we would consider Catholic philosophy and theology to understand the nature of God. Would God create something that looks like He designed it, only to show us that there are processes that look random, so we’d then conclude that the randomness is not random, and the design is not design - except through the appearingly random process?
I think Catholic philosophy would direct us to conclude that God would not create that many illusions in our grasp of reality. By unaided reason, we can see the essence of things. Through intuition and common sense, we can see God’s creative intelligence expressed in nature. I just don’t see how a"random-appearing" process really fits. But we have to look at this more later…
God has not created these “illusions”. We have.

Just as humanity deceived itself into thinking it was the center of the Universe because the Sun and planets “appeared” to go around the Earth and the Biblical text “appeared’ to say that the Earth did not move, I think that humanity could also be potentially deceiving itself into thinking it was created especially by an overtly miraculous means because our bodies “appear” to be radically different from the animals and the Biblical text “appears’ to say we were created from the dust of the earth.

If we misunderstand God’s creation or His Sacred Books we dare not ever claim that it was God’s fault. It is our fault.

Speaking of aided and unaided, you also said this…
I think we need to talk about this more (Guided Evolution) – since that is the topic of this thread.
I have an idea about the difference between Guided Evolution and Unguided Evolution, but I’m not sure that I’m correct.
Camron said:
That what exactly is your idea of the difference between Guided Evolution and Unguided Evolution?
I would say that Unguided Evolution is Darwin’s theory. Guided Evolution is considerably different as I see it.
40.png
Camron:
Then how do you see “Guided Evolution”?
I do not think we can call ordinary natural processes “guided” in the way the term is used in Guided Evolution. Yes, God’s providence guides all things, but we don’t think of gravity, for example, as a “guided” process.
40.png
Camron:
Here you said, “Yes, God’s providence guides all things, but we don’t think of gravity, for example, as a “guided” process.” Are you not saying that God guides all things by His Providence? Why exactly is gravity, for example, excluded from God’s Providence?
Gravity is predictable and consistent. It is sustained by God, but it is “unguided” as a natural law. We can pray that God will “redirect” gravity from it’s inevitable path – but that means we want God to intervene and change the “unguided law” and “guide it” in ways it would not ordinarily go.
40.png
Camron:
Again, as I asked before
, but isn’t He already guiding it anyway?

Or is He only guiding nature when we pray for Him to guide nature?

When a storm comes, we pray that the tree won’t fall on our house.

The next day, when we see the most obvious path for the tree was directly at our house, but that it somehow turned away and missed – we rightly thank God for this miracle of His Guidance of the natural law. Otherwise, without His help – our house would have been crushed. The unguided law would have worked without God’s help and would have done the obvious and predictable thing.
40.png
Camron:
But this was always God’s will to begin with, wasn’t it?

We have certainly not changed God’s mind, have we?

I think there are still some things you have not adequately addressed here.

Does God’s Providence guide all things: Yes or No?
 
Remember: This was typed before I read your post above…
Now, before you respond any further, you really need to read this post. Please read this post before you continue with this line of reasoning. You really are demonstrating that you are not fully comprehending what I’m saying could be the case.
The proposal you’ve given is that “everything is guided”. Therefore, anything that Darwinists claim happened is merely interpreted as “God did it” without the need to show God’s involvement (or that the results reveal God’s power).
No. That is not what I’m claiming. :banghead:
Again, in the example I gave many times – a pile of rocks after an avalanche would be considered the product of a “guided natural law”. Thus, the operation of the natural laws alone would be as miraculous as anything else.
Yes, and I’ve addressed this.too. This is something that you have failed to fully respond to.

Consequently, the operation of the natural laws alone would not be as miraculous as any other miracle. I’ve already stressed that God builds upon miraculous events overlapping each other. I’ve also noted that He sustains His creation too, sustaining all thing by His powerful word. I’ve been very clear that if God were to withdraw His presence the universe most likely cease to exist too.
I’m sorry, I can’t follow this. If God created the prime matter and form of all things (as St. Thomas teaches), then what follows from that is not “evolution” (as it is commonly known).
I’m not talking about evolution as it is “commonly known”. I’m talking about Guided Evolution, something which you seem determined to reimage as the atheistic philosophies attached to the theory of evolution which the Catholic Church has condemned. The Catholic Church has not condemned the theory of evolution. The Catholic Church has condemned the atheistic philosophies that some have tried through sedition to impose throughout the theory of evolution
If we’re going to define the term evolution to mean “change over time” then I think the counterpoint to that would be “nothing in nature ever changed since the beginning of the world”. I don’t see that argument raised even by hard-core fundamentalists.
When on earth have I argued that “nothing in nature ever changed since the beginning of the world”? That’s really (self moderated) of you to even suggest that I’m saying that too. I’ve been stressing that things do change over time over and over again. Stop doing that please.
I think you’re doing a decent job describing God’s involvement in the creation of the natural laws here. The argument you could make is that God created the natural laws to thereby create, by evolution, all of the things in nature “on their own”. This is not “guided” evolution though since there is no need for God to “guide” laws which He designed to fulfill the task
What would happen if God didn’t “guide the laws”? In your view, nothing at all would happen because nothing can happen without God guiding it.
I said the universe would most likely cease to exist if God did not sustain all things by His powerful word. Are you really not reading what I’m typing here?
This is something quite different than what one calls “evolution”. Certainly, it’s a refutation of Darwinism (and I believe you’ve affirmed that already). That is good – but again, I wouldn’t call it “evolution”. It’s really a form of creationism. God is creating all of the things in nature.
Yes, that why I’m calling it…

**Theistic Evolution! **
 
Let’s get back to the beginning and take a stroll through Genesis for a bit…
In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth.
Reggie, what do you think this passage from the Bible means?

Is there any scientific value behind it? Are there any metaphors conveyed here? Is this considered literal truth? What exactly is God telling us here?
 
Yes, that why I’m calling it…

**Theistic Evolution! **
I think theistic evolution is bad religion mixed with bad science. When you look at the Bible it doesn’t give any indication, need or reason for todays “evolution” and when you study the evolutionary science literature it NEVER mentions God.

.
 
I think theistic evolution is bad religion mixed with bad science.
First of all, I’m Catholic.

Secondly, I don’t think theistic evolution is either a religion or a science.

I think theistic evolution is a metaphysical framework where people who are theists can philosophically express their theological views regarding how they feel God may have employed evolutionary means to naturally do His bidding, albeit expressed in scientific language.

Theistic evolution is the theological counterpoint to the atheistic philosophies that are commonly and erroneously attached to the theory of evolution via feebly minded hard-core materialists who incorrectly think they can erratically use evolutionary science to somehow prove God doesn’t exist.

As far as the science behind the theory of evolution is concerned, would you agree that the science behind a paternity test is good science?

A test to prove paternity (whether a man is someone’s father) is known as a paternity test. A paternity identification test is conducted to establish whether a person is the biological parent of another person.

Comparing the DNA sequence of an individual to that of another individual can show if one of them was derived from the other or not. Specific sequences are usually looked at to see if they were copied verbatim from one of the individual’s genome to the other. If that was the case, then this proves that the genetic material of one individual could have been derived from that of the other (i.e.: one is the parent of the other).

Consequently, if you agree that the science behind a paternity test is good science, then why would you disagree with the idea that the science behind the theory of evolution is good science?

Much of the genetic science behind the theory of evolution is the same science as the genetic science behind a paternity test, albeit extended over longer time periods to more distant ancestors.

For example, consider the genetic similarities between a mouse and a human chromosome.

https://www.llnl.gov/str/May01/gifs/Stubbs2.jpg

As Francis Collins points out…
The order of genes along a chromosome is often the same in humans and mice, though the precise spacing between genes may vary somewhat.
Thus, if you find the order of the three genes to be A, B, and C along a human chromosome, you are very likely to find the mouse counterparts of the A, B, and C genes in the same order on the mouse chromosome.
Furthermore, now that complete genome sequences of both humans and mice are available, it is possible to identify in the spaces between genes the remnants of many “jumping genes”. These are transposable elements that can insert themselves at random into the genome, and even continue to do so at a low level today.
By DNA sequence analysis, some of these elements have acquired many mutations compared with the original jumping genes, and thus appear to be very old; these are referred to as ancient repetitive elements (AREs). Interestingly, these ancient elements are often found in similar locations in the mouse and human genomes…
…Particularly interesting are examples where the ARE was truncated at the precise base pair at the time of insertion, losing part of its DNA sequence and all possibility of future function…
…Finding a precisely truncated ARE in the same place in both human and mouse genomes is compelling evidence that this insertion event must have occurred in an ancestor that was common to both the human and the mouse.
Another interesting article regarding Junk, Shattered Genes, and a Twist can be found here.
When you look at the Bible it doesn’t give any indication, need or reason for today’s “evolution”…
Actually, the Bible does seem to indicate the possibility that there were other “humans” before Adam. Note that even if there were other humans before Adam, Adam is indeed the first true human that we are all descended from.
…and when you study the evolutionary science literature it NEVER mentions God.
Then read this book…

 
This is not compelling evidence of an ancestor. In the genetic blueprint, the leg of a mouse and the leg of a human would have similar, and in some cases, the same coding.

There is a pelvis, a thigh and a leg in both. Similarities in the blueprint only show that the instructions to construct these similar shapes will be similar.

When scientists declared something called “junk DNA,” they thought it would reveal the supposed ‘evolutionary’ twists and turns of human evolution. This turned out to not be the case.

Peace,
Ed
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top