Normally I don’t respond to what I regard as baiting threads, but I’m going to take a shot at this one because I think this is a silly debate.
Why do you think that this is a “silly” debate? This issue is one of the major causes of division between Catholics and Protestants. It has been a problem since the beginning of the “Protestant Movement”. Have you read any of Martin Luther’s letters? If you would like, I can post some of Luther’s quote’s here, which address “good works” to show you what I am talking about. Calvin, made “Catholic, good works” an issue as well.
There is a belief in Protestantism (whether it has any historical basis in truth or not) that the Catholic Church has taken the position at some time in the past that you can “earn” (good works) or buy (indulgences) your way into heaven.
The was an exaggeration and is an issue, that was resolved 500 years ago and should not be an issue today but unfortunately it is.
The reformers emphasized the sovereignty of God–that there is NOTHING we can do to be worthy of God’s grace or our salvation. Hence the reformers emphasized that our salvation is solely from God, not based on our individual merit.
This is similar to the Catholic belief, but not quite.
Catholics now simplify and parody the Protestant belief in faith alone by contending or implying (falsely) that Protestants deny the obligation to do good works.
This statement is inaccurate. There exist today, many thousands of Protestant denominations that do preach, “Saved by Faith Alone” or “Saved by Grace Alone” or “Once Saved Always Saved” and these people will argue that the Catholic Church is on the wrong side of this issue. Moreover, there are many Protestants here at CAF, who have taken the position the you claim, is false.
This is far from what most Protestants believe (indeed, I have NEVER heard any Protestant take this position).
What “position” exactly? If we are taking about “good works” here, this is, and continues to be a major issue.
Instead, we believe that we can never DESERVE salvation, that it is an unmerited work of grace, a gift of God. However, every Church I have ever attended (moderately Calvinistic to Arminian) also emphasized that we are to love the Lord with all our heart and that if we love the Lord we will do good works, that we are to love our neighbor as ourself. We are not earning our salvation by our good works, we are obeying God’s clear commands to love in truth and in deed.
This is just another case of semantics to try to turn a Catholic belief into a Protestant belief.
Now, finally, I have a question? If my description of what faith alone means (to us Protestants) is accurate, will it make any difference on judgment day whether one believes in “faith alone” or “faith and good works” as the Catholic Church teaches?
There are too many variables to answer this question. There are those, who claim to be Christian and do not believe in the Holy Trinity, or that, Christ was fully human and fully divine and deny a need to be baptized. Some so-called Christians, deny the Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist and believe that abortion, embryonic stem cell research, euthanasia, homosexual marriages, openly gay Bishops, and multiple-marriages and divorce and so on, are fine. Finally, some do not ask for forgiveness when they have commit serious or grave sins. I’m not judging here…but you asked, so in my opinion, there are some who claim to be “Christian”, including some Catholics, who may have a problem because of their own bad decisions.
Your description is not an accurate one, Luther was the one who misinterpreted the Bible incorrectly in the first place and since then, Protestants have made “goods works” a wedge issue, which has divided, Christianity ever since.
As a follow up, if your answer to the preceding question is no, then why in the world are we worrying about it here and now?
Obviously, my answer, wasn’t - “No”. This is still an issue for millions of non-Catholic (Protestant) Christians…However, I am always happy when I learn about a non-Catholic (Protestant) denomination that has become more “Catholic” in their beliefs.