Ask a Pagan

  • Thread starter Thread starter Skadi
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
But even there there is a problem, because if god is all knowing then he knew Lucifer would fall. The devil isn’t necessary for free will, so why create him in the first place?** Of course I understand that we arn’t deitys and cannot think on a divine level** but if he made the universe than the logic of it would follow his, and there dosnt seem to be an ounce of logic in him creating a being who is destined to fall and cause such a ridiculous amount of pain and suffering.
The part in bold - agreed. I cannot address your concerns or queries because I do not know. I suppose God could have created robot-type people and programed them, so to speak, so that their free will was taken away. :shrug:That would suck. LOL…
 
…said a book. I’ve read lots of books, too, but I don’t believe them all.
Ok. That’s upto your freewill. Nobody can force you to believe, also God want’s one to believe and love him from the fullness of one’s heart. But remember, bible is not one single book. It is collection of holy scriptures. It contains 73 books (Old and new testaments). It is written around 1500 years by various persons. Its first book Genesis written around 1400 BC by Mosess. Its last book revelation is written by Apostle St John around AD 90’s. It is spiritual experiences of various persons through out history. It is written from three different continents (Asia, Africa and Europe). Not from a one single place.
 
Nothing about people at the cova seeing nothing. Perhaps you could provide a quote to support the notion that people saw nothing; something similar to this, which is valid, and from a 1917 secular newspaper:

“Before the astonished eyes of the crowd, whose aspect was biblical as they stood bare-headed, eagerly searching the sky, the sun trembled, made sudden incredible movements outside all cosmic laws—the sun ‘danced’ according to the typical expression of the people.” Avelino de Almeida, writing for O Século - Portugal’s most widely circulated and influential newspaper, which was pro-government and anti-clerical at the time.
Sorry, I’m totally uninterested in Fatima. I was just trying to help you for the present. You can always buy the book on Amazon or do your own research. I’m not going to say any more about it because I didn’t bring it up in the first place, it’s a non-entity in my worldview. Good luck!
 
It is spiritual experiences of various persons through out history.
It’s interesting that you say this, most Catholics seem to think that it is the word of God dictated to humans. It’s kind of heartening that you believe this. It’s also my belief. 🙂

The Upanishads are also a wonderful compilation of experiences of God, but that god is truly a loving god, there is no violence in the Upanishads, or stories about God killing thousands of his creation, etc. It’s always made much more sense to me than the bible. Easwaran is one of the best translators in case you’re interested in giving it a read.
 
Ok. That’s upto your freewill. Nobody can force you to believe, also God want’s one to believe and love him from the fullness of one’s heart.
And it’s not that I don’t believe, it’s that I don’t believe in the capricious and violent god of the bible. 😉
 
It does no such thing. Paganism fosters direct communing with the divine. What outsiders think they know and what is the reality of these religions is clearly quite different.
Then what you talking about, is not paganism. It is pantheism. Most often pagans uses these types of philosophies to attract others to their faith , instead of directly inviting others to worship their idols. When one person got attracted to their ideologies , they will lead them to the second stage, introducing about their imaginary Gods in place of these natural forces.
You’re not familiar with cosmologies outside of your own, yet are making blanketed statements as though you understand them.
I am expressing my faith. I am telling why I disagrees with you. If you have anything to tell me why I am wrong, you can point out that.
Incorrect, but I’ve pointed that out before, including not all pagans being polytheistic - Did you inadvertently miss it or are choosing to ignore in order to maintain your argument? :confused:
By the term Paganism, I mean worship of Idols, which is a result of human imagination. Searching of God through natural forces is Animism and Not paganism. Both are different. Ancient human beings considered the forces of nature which are beyond their control as Gods who rules them.

“For the grandeur and beauty of creatures lead us to ponder on their Author, greater and more magnificent.No doubt these men are not to be blamed severely, for possibly they strayed though they searched for God and desired to find him.They pondered over the created things that surrounded them and were captivated by the sight of such beauty.Even so they are not to be excused” Wisdom 13: 5-8)

Paganism presents these natural forces as forces that are controlled by their imaginary Gods. It is through this way paganism deceived ancient humanity".
Except it doesn’t take us from the creator at all. We just don’t worship the same god you do. It’s an exercise in futility to attempt a discussion when it’s erroneously assumed only one religion and one particular god is “right” and all others are “wrong” even though there’s nothing to support that position beyond it’s simply what adherents choose to believe.
That means you dont understand what christian God is. We believe in Holy trinity. There is only one God. God himself. When moses asked about his name, he didnt told a particular individual name (what pagan gods uses - such Zeus ) . He told I am who I am. He God of all. He is unkowable. We can realize him only through Jesus Christ , incarnation of word of God (Son).

youtube.com/watch?v=2KSx6nhUJvo&feature=share
There’s only one god you follow, this is true. But certainly not the only or true god, no matter how many videos you link to. The need to denounce that which one either fears and/or does not understand doesn’t change their divinity or existence. 🙂
Go through the video Link I provided. Your doubts about christian God is answered there in simple language. He is one true God (who was unknowable to humanity) , who revealed himself through Jesus Christ.
 
It’s interesting that you say this, most Catholics seem to think that it is the word of God dictated to humans. It’s kind of heartening that you believe this. It’s also my belief. 🙂

The Upanishads are also a wonderful compilation of experiences of God, but that god is truly a loving god, there is no violence in the Upanishads, or stories about God killing thousands of his creation, etc. It’s always made much more sense to me than the bible. Easwaran is one of the best translators in case you’re interested in giving it a read.
Bible is not a dictation to human beings. Judaism is not originated after writing all old testament books. Christianity is not originated after writing all new testament books. But it is spiritual experience of prophets and people with God. It is Guidelines that God gave to humanity through them. It is words of God , It also contains history of nation of Israel. Bible is not a revelation to one single person. It is collection of 73 books (sacred scriptures). It took 1500 years to complete the book. Its first book Genesis is written by Moses around 1400 BC and Last book revelation is written by Apostle St John around AD 90. It is not written in a single place. It is written from various places , in three different continents (Asia, Africa and Europe). Also traditional christian faith (Catholicism/ Orthodoxy) is not only depend upon the bible alone but also Sacred traditions and liturgy have equal importance.

orthodoxwiki.org/Panentheism

Upanishads provides a pantheistic (Everything are God) or pan in theistic (everything is in god) view of God. Eastern christian thoughts are based on Panentheistic. Gods spirit resides in all, but creator is a separate higher entity. Catholicism is based on Omnipresence. There is no violence is Upanishads. It explains pantheistic ideologies about God. It is one of hindu scriptures. But you can find, those Gods which are presented in upanishads engaged in war and violence in puranas , ramayana and mahabaratha which are also considered by hindus as divine scriptures.
 
And it’s not that I don’t believe, it’s that I don’t believe in the capricious and violent god of the bible. 😉
Can you tell me which pagan God you found as merciful.?. As per my knowledge and belief most of the pagan gods wear a weapon. Most of their mythologies are full of war and violence. What you mean by merciful god?. A forgiving machine?. Forgiving all faults of everyone without repentance?. Christ is a merciful God. He will forgive the sins of those persons who repent from their pure heart. He will punish a person or community if they are hopelessly continues in sinful life. It is for re establishing Goodness in this world.
 
The part in bold - agreed. I cannot address your concerns or queries because I do not know. I suppose God could have created robot-type people and programed them, so to speak, so that their free will was taken away. :shrug:That would suck. LOL…
No I understand the argument for free will, but Satan isn’t necessary for the existence of that.
 
Then what you talking about, is not paganism. It is pantheism. Most often pagans uses these types of philosophies to attract others to their faith , instead of directly inviting others to worship their idols. When one person got attracted to their ideologies , they will lead them to the second stage, introducing about their imaginary Gods in place of these natural forces.
We do not worship idols we worship the Gods.

You make it sound like we are some devious cult that tries to seduce good little christian children away from your god then slowly turn them evil. Pagans don’t proselytize, thats your religions MO. Pagans are very up front about the gods aswell.

You don’t seem to understand what paganism is, nor the idea of soft-polytheism (a pantheist god with many personal divine faces) which some pagans adhere to. Dont tell us what our religion is or isnt when you yourself obviously know little to nothing about it.
 
We do not worship idols we worship the Gods.

You make it sound like we are some devious cult that tries to seduce good little christian children away from your god then slowly turn them evil. Pagans don’t proselytize, thats your religions MO. Pagans are very up front about the gods aswell.

You don’t seem to understand what paganism is, nor the idea of soft-polytheism (a pantheist god with many personal divine faces) which some pagans adhere to. Dont tell us what our religion is or isnt when you yourself obviously know little to nothing about it.
Tell me about your God
 
Tell me about your God
God is everywhere, transcendent, made up of all life and impersonal. the “Is All”.

The various gods of the worlds religions are the faces through which universal truths are conveyed, in cultural context.

Thats my belief but there are also many “Hard” polytheist pagans.

The individual deitys and traditions vary from group to group.
 
God is everywhere, transcendent, made up of all life and impersonal. the “Is All”.

The various gods of the worlds religions are the faces through which universal truths are conveyed, in cultural context.

Thats my belief but there are also many “Hard” polytheist pagans.

The individual deitys and traditions vary from group to group.
God is everywhere and transcendent - It is not contradictory to christian faith.

Can you please explain , what do you mean by God is made up of all life?. Means everything is in God ?. God is impersonal?. God is all - is it mean pantheism - All are God and everything is God?
 
No I understand the argument for free will, but Satan isn’t necessary for the existence of that.
You do not believe in Satan. OK. 🙂 Actually, I hope you are right. No one belonging to the CC hopes hell is real; the exact opposite! I suppose everyone will find out in the end.
 
Sorry, I’m totally uninterested in Fatima. I was just trying to help you for the present. You can always buy the book on Amazon or do your own research. I’m not going to say any more about it because I didn’t bring it up in the first place, it’s a non-entity in my worldview. Good luck!
👍
 
God is everywhere and transcendent - It is not contradictory to christian faith.

Can you please explain , what do you mean by God is made up of all life?. Means everything is in God ?. God is impersonal?. God is all - is it mean pantheism - All are God and everything is God?
God is made up of all life. this dosnt mean we are gods, but we are all part of the ultimate reality, from the smallest single celled organism to the largest metaphysical force.
 
God is made up of all life. this dosnt mean we are gods, but we are all part of the ultimate reality, from the smallest single celled organism to the largest metaphysical force.
What do you mean when you say that “God is made up of all life”?

God being the source of all life, and God can residing in all life, certainly makes sense.
 
Do hard polytheists tend to think that the Christian Trinity theology is a form of soft polytheism?
 
God is made up of all life. this dosnt mean we are gods, but we are all part of the ultimate reality, from the smallest single celled organism to the largest metaphysical force.
If we are part of God, then why we are not called as Gods?. If we are part of God then how we can do sin?. How sin (impurity) exists in God?. If we are part of God, then our sins will be binding on God and God is a sinner?. If everything is part of God, is it mean evil spirit (satan) is also part of God?
 
If we are part of God, then why we are not called as Gods?. If we are part of God then how we can do sin?. How sin (impurity) exists in God?. If we are part of God, then our sins will be binding on God and God is a sinner?. If everything is part of God, is it mean evil spirit (satan) is also part of God?
I could be wrong but I do not believe that Skadi believes in the existence of Satan. However, those are some good questions.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top