Ask an atheist a few questions.

  • Thread starter Thread starter Exalt
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Exalt,

Thus far everyone has focused specifically on God-the-father. But there are three more gorillas in the room.

The first gorilla is the existence of evil, demonic influence and demonic possession. Someone once said that people struggle with the proof of God, but as to the devil we have no doubt. Modern battles between humans and powerful malignant forces are well documented, with audio and video evidence. Can you discuss your understanding of the existence of super-natural forces which seem bent upon causing harm?

The second gorilla is related: psychic connections and extra-sensory perception that indicate the existence of a spirit-world beyond our ordinary knowledge. I’m talking about instances like this: A twin suddenly awakens in the middle of the night with a feeling of dread, then discovers the next morning that her sister was killed at the very moment she awoke. A missing person case goes unresolved for a year until a psychic steps forward, describing visions that lead the authorities straight to the accident site. There does appear to be sufficient modern-day evidence for a realm or plane of existence beyond what our five senses can readily touch.

The third gorilla is near-death experiences. A person who is clinically dead reawakens, able to accurately describe everything that happened in the room after his/her heart stopped, right down to the things people were wearing and actions they took. This person also describes what happened next: a sense of rapid movement, sometimes meeting family members long dead, and eventually encoutering a peaceful being of light that sends him/her back. Sometimes, though, the encounter is a vision of abject horror which results in the “returned” person completely reforming his/her morally decrepit life. These experiences, again, are well documented, particularly by people who were skeptics until they themselves had one.

None of these three gorillas are direct evidence for the existence of God, although the third one comes very close. But all three would indicate there is far more “out there” than what our five senses can detect. A shortage of direct evidence does not mean we should act as if something does not exist until proven otherwise. On the contrary, the cautious person acts as if it does exist until proven otherwise. If this were not so, no one would get upset when food service workers didn’t wash their hands.

Finally, I am interested in your answer to a question which I’m sure you have heard before. Consider Pascal’s Wager: the limited cost of following God’s mandates vs. the infinite reward, or the limited freedom of following your own mandates vs. the infinite penalty. If God is not real both the believer and the non-believer come to the same “happy” end - oblivion. If God is real, only the non-believer has a problem. Is the reward worth the risk? What if you are wrong?

Thank you for your frank and rational answers.
 
Did you not read what you quoted? People don’t talk about Big Foot, people don’t generally believe in Big Foot and nor do people try to tell you to believe in Big Foot.
Are you sure about that?
This is not the same with God. People do talk about God. People do believe in God and people do try and get me (and others) to believe in God. It has a rather lot more importance than Big Foot because of that.
yes, you are right. people also talk about how their lives have been changed by God. Not true with the Bigfoot believers.
Also some people that do not believe in God like to talk about God because they find it interesting.
People like to talk about Big Foot. Just do a google search and you will get over a million hits

I just can’t help but notice that you are re-defining the word belief and setting up your own rules. It is almost like you have “faith” that there is no God;)
 
How can you even say this about God “What does God give us?”. He’s given you life. So many are worse off than you. You should be thanking Him on your knees. But in time you will…
BTW, crying statues, at least the miracles that have been documented are signs that God does exist.
Just because a deadbeat dad fathered his children doesn’t mean he’s a good dad.
 
Eh?

Did you not read what you quoted? People don’t talk about Big Foot, people don’t generally believe in Big Foot and nor do people try to tell you to believe in Big Foot.

This is not the same with God. People do talk about God. People do believe in God and people do try and get me (and others) to believe in God. It has a rather lot more importance than Big Foot because of that.

Also some people that do not believe in God like to talk about God because they find it interesting.
I agree. Also…

Big Foot is not invoked by Presidential Candidates. Our president doesn’t believe Big Foot is guiding him. Belief in Big Foot doesn’t play much of a roll in our government.
 
40.png
teadough:
Are you sure about that?
I am pretty sure it is not at all on the same level as God.
40.png
teadough:
People like to talk about Big Foot. Just do a google search and you will get over a million hits
God is a much more active topic.
40.png
teadough:
I just can’t help but notice that you are re-defining the word belief and setting up your own rules. It is almost like you have “faith” that there is no God
Show me where I have re-defined the word belief.
 
God is a much more active topic.
Oh, I see. You don’t want to spread yourself too thin denfending a non-existent Big Foot but you want to defend the “belief” of the non-exsistence of God even though you feel both are not real.
 
Oh, I see. You don’t want to spread yourself too thin denfending a non-existent Big Foot but you want to defend the “belief” of the non-exsistence of God even though you feel both are not real.
I don’t want to defend the belief of either God or Big Foot.
 
I did answer this question. I used to be a hardcore conservative Catholic who believed in God and prayed to him quite sincerely.
So you say…

and then what about the cat situation that I covered. tell me exactly how your cat can answer your prayers.

thanks.
 
How can you be convinced there is no God? I always wonder, I can understand being agnostic, but I cannot understand looking at creation and deciding, “Nope, there is no God.”
 
Maybe God is a drug addict and doesn’t want to involve us?
No. But you overextended the metaphor. Even in the overextension, however, there were "out"s.
**All **of those relationships are *faaar *more personal than God’s supposed relationship with human beings in the here-and-now.
Correct, at least from a human perspective. God limits the degree to which he explicitly gets chummy with us, which is part of the reason why the “as you do unto the least of your brothers you do unto me” is there. It’s why Christians are allowed to pray to the Saints: they’re a more personal connection. But that doesn’t mean they’re more real.
When’s the last time God took you out for icecream, like a father would for his son after a bad day at school?
I had a bad day at school today, and there were Girlscouts on my campus selling cookies.
Whens the last time God kissed you, like a husband would with his wife?
A couple weeks ago. I was having a tough time, and suddenly I felt soothed and calm, like I had been kissed.
When’s the last time God played ball with you, like a master would with his dog?
Whenever I boot up Guild Wars (a game whose existence I credit entirely to God). 😉
When’s the last time you and God went to a bar for drinks, like two friends would?
Mass.
When’s the last time God told you to drop and give you fifty pushups, like a sergeant might do to an underling?
Right now, this week.
*What has *God **done for you? Nothing that couldn’t be attributed to random chance or your imagination.
And how great it is that he gave us that, that he has given us candles and allowed us to find our way, giving us hints all along the way without which we would be lost but at the same time letting us have accomplishments. Now, this analogy is particularly fragile, but I think sufficient for this one point.
A dog, a husband, a superior officer in the army, a father - all those are far closer relationships than man and God.
Hence why they exist, to make the unimaginable imaginable.
I’m sorry I missed it. Was it the one about the date and too much space?
Yeah, that one. I wasn’t trying to accuse you or anything, I was just pointing out that you had skipped it and one way the skipping could have been interpreted.
I have looked into the problem of pain and the problem of evil - the only sane Christian answer I’ve encountered so far is “I don’t know.”
And you don’t think “it builds character” is sane at all? Have you seen “Little Miss Sunshine,” by any chance? It’s one of my favorite movies, in large part because of the pier scene between Dwayne and Frank. Here’s part of it, in case you haven’t seen the movie:

Little Miss Sunshine said:
Dwayne: I wish I could just sleep until I was eighteen and skip all this ****-high school and everything-just skip it.
Frank: Do you know who Marcel Proust is?
Dwayne: He’s the guy you teach.
Frank: Yeah. French writer. Total loser. Never had a real job. Unrequited love affairs. Gay. Spent 20 years writing a book almost no one reads. But he’s also probably the greatest writer since Shakespeare. Anyway, he uh… he gets down to the end of his life, and he looks back and decides that all those years he suffered, Those were the best years of his life, 'cause they made him who he was. All those years he was happy? You know, total waste. Didn’t learn a thing. So, if you sleep until you’re 18… Ah, think of the suffering you’re gonna miss. I mean high school? High school-those are your prime suffering years. You don’t get better suffering than that.

You think this is foolish? I don’t. Happiness is great, it’s what we’re all working for, but you can’t have it forever, not here. You might as well get yourself put into an artificial coma where machines wash your brain in seratonin and dopamine and other stuff like that, shocking the pleasure centers of your brain all day, and that’s no way for a human to live. Being human is more than being happy or miserable. It’s being the greatest store of potential in existence. And you gotta make something of that potential, even something terrible, because the great sinner is just a few steps away from being a great saint, but the smiling doped-up man who’s turned himself into an animal has nothing going for him at all, just a pleasant time until he dies.
It’s precious in large part because it’s rare.
It would be no less precious were it common, though we might be inclined to think that. Computers, for example, are amazing devices, but nowadays they’re just part of the landscape of a college dorm or an office cubicle. Love between a husband and a wife is beautiful no matter how many other couples have it.

(Con’t below)
 
(Con’t from above)
Why shouldn’t I demand it?
Because you don’t deserve it. Because if God wants to give it to you, it will be completelly gift, and you should no sooner demand a gift from God than you should become impudent when your parents don’t buy you that fancy BMW you’ve always wanted. Because you have no idea whether you can handle the gift or not, and you might burn up the world like Phaeton with Apollo’s chariot. Because you’re trying to force your destiny, which is impossible and absurd.
Why shouldn’t my friend Patrick (the son of a deadbeat dad, if you remember) demand contact with his father?
Those are all humans relationships, and humans are all equal to each other. God is infinitely above us. He has no obligations to his creations, none whatsoever. He gave us the great dignity of existing freely, and he gives us the far greater dignity of letting us choose what we will become. That alone puts us infinitely in his debt. Add to this that we frequently and incessantly spit in his face and insult and mock him, that we forsake him and break all manner of contract with him, and claiming that he is obligated to make us infinitely happy is all the more absurd. That he’s still willing to do it if only we’ll let him is all the more incredible.
 
Exalt,

Thus far everyone has focused specifically on God-the-father. But there are three more gorillas in the room.

The first gorilla is the existence of evil, demonic influence and demonic possession. Someone once said that people struggle with the proof of God, but as to the devil we have no doubt. Modern battles between humans and powerful malignant forces are well documented, with audio and video evidence. Can you discuss your understanding of the existence of super-natural forces which seem bent upon causing harm?
“No doubt” about the existance of the devil or other demonic forces? You’re kidding, right?

Why don’t you go ahead and cite some of those well documented sources. I have access to a pretty big library, and can find pretty much anything you cite.
The second gorilla is related: psychic connections and extra-sensory perception that indicate the existence of a spirit-world beyond our ordinary knowledge. I’m talking about instances like this: A twin suddenly awakens in the middle of the night with a feeling of dread, then discovers the next morning that her sister was killed at the very moment she awoke. A missing person case goes unresolved for a year until a psychic steps forward, describing visions that lead the authorities straight to the accident site. There does appear to be sufficient modern-day evidence for a realm or plane of existence beyond what our five senses can readily touch.
I’m not sure how to account for that, if it is true. But it hardly proves the existance of a divine creator-God, who loves us.
The third gorilla is near-death experiences. A person who is clinically dead reawakens, able to accurately describe everything that happened in the room after his/her heart stopped, right down to the things people were wearing and actions they took. This person also describes what happened next: a sense of rapid movement, sometimes meeting family members long dead, and eventually encoutering a peaceful being of light that sends him/her back. Sometimes, though, the encounter is a vision of abject horror which results in the “returned” person completely reforming his/her morally decrepit life. These experiences, again, are well documented, particularly by people who were skeptics until they themselves had one.
I have heard of this before, but havn’t given it much thought. I’d like some citation here.
None of these three gorillas are direct evidence for the existence of God, although the third one comes very close. But all three would indicate there is far more “out there” than what our five senses can detect. A shortage of direct evidence does not mean we should act as if something does not exist until proven otherwise.
I don’t think that’s neccessarily true. There might be a viscious, blood-thirsty alligator in the next room, suddenly. It’s remotely possible that it might be there. Now, should I jump out the window instead of walking out my front door, just because I don’t have evidence of it’s existence?

My opinion on God and demons and psychic phenomenon is sort of like that. Give me some direct evidence before I jump out the window.

As I have said before, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
Finally, I am interested in your answer to a question which I’m sure you have heard before. Consider Pascal’s Wager: the limited cost of following God’s mandates vs. the infinite reward, or the limited freedom of following your own mandates vs. the infinite penalty. If God is not real both the believer and the non-believer come to the same “happy” end - oblivion. If God is real, only the non-believer has a problem. Is the reward worth the risk? What if you are wrong?

Thank you for your frank and rational answers.
Which religion do I subscribe to? Which creed do I feign faith in? I might get it wrong and join the wrong religion, and go to hell anyway. And this supposes that I have the ability to just change my beliefs without sufficient evidence. I’m not sure I have that ability anymore, as an adult. (And even if I did, as I said, I could join any number of religions, and they might be the wrong one.)

And if the good, loving, altrustic non-believer really will get sent to hell by the Divine, I don’t know if that Divine being is really worth being worshiped.

I think I shall follow my own conscience and reason and believe in no God or Gods - and die in peace.
 
So you say…

and then what about the cat situation that I covered. tell me exactly how your cat can answer your prayers.

thanks.
It can’t.

Niether can God.

Because *God *doesn’t exist.

But my *Cat *actually exists.

Therefore, if I were to say “Oh great cat, please help me find my checkbook” my cat just might happen to lead me to my checkbook. But if I were to say “Oh great God, please help me find my checkbook” (Or pray to St. Anthony, for that matter), God won’t do anything. Because he can’t. Because he isn’t real.
 
There might be a viscious, blood-thirsty alligator in the next room, suddenly. It’s remotely possible that it might be there. Now, should I jump out the window instead of walking out my front door, just because I don’t have evidence of it’s existence?
the example you just gave makes absolutely no sense in regards to the numbers of people in the world who have had life changing experiences simply due to having a beliefe in some sort of God.

The example would have had some merit had you have used"blood thirsty Big Foots"😃
 
40.png
teadough:
Oh, I see. I guess I got you confused when you said
Yes.

My standpoint. I will defend my standpoint - which is there is no reason to believe in God. How good is your English?
Mary Gail 36:
How can you be convinced there is no God? I always wonder, I can understand being agnostic, but I cannot understand looking at creation and deciding, “Nope, there is no God.”
First of all, I am not convinced of anything.

Secondly, to me - I am not looking at ‘creation’. There’s your flaw.
 
Is that some sort of snide remark or am I not reading you correctly?
Read it as you will. I don’t seriously get how you could interpret that to think I was defending the opposite of my contention.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top