Sorry, but this is just a false statement on its face. All of the “prophets” do not proclaim the same faith or we would all be the same faith. Does Muhammad proclaim Jesus as the Messiah? No, he does not. There are true prophets and there are false prophets.
So you are saying that there are some people who are in error, yes? And your faith tradition has made a discernment as to what is true and what is error, yes? How do the Buddhists and Hindus feel about your position?
And yet we know that this is not in the least bit true, at least with those whom you consider to be prophets. They are in no way unified. If they were we would not be having this conversation.
God bless.
Steve, Lets pretend we are in a philosophy class, abiding by the instruments of logic, or examining a theological statement being made.
With the statement is held the assumption that if we are speaking about “a Prophet of God”, and not someone who is a false prophet, then the quote is simply saying that if one is truly a Prophet of God, then he is proclaiming the same Faith as the other Prophets of God.
Within the accepted recognition of the prophets of Israel who are accepted by Christians, they all proclaim the same Faith. Right? That is, Moses didn’t proclaim a different Faith than Abraham, and Jesus didn’t proclaim a different Faith than either of Them.
Where the difficulty then arises is when each group fails to recognize further prophets than the last one accepted by their group. For example, Jews do not recognize Jesus, for He followed Moses, but they do not regard Him as authentic. The same thing occurs with Muhammad not being regarded by the followers of Moses or Jesus. Each has their reasons, or reasonings, for rejecting the next Prophet.
So the difficulty is convincing a Jew that Jesus is the Messiah, but if you can do that, then they accept Him as one of the Prophets proclaiming the same Faith. Similarly, the challenge has been for Muslims, who maintain that “Islam” was the religion of Abraham, and Moses and Jesus, in their view, for Islam means submission to the will of God.
But as each claims the next one to be a false prophet, there continues to be the religion of the Jews, the Christians, and the Muslims. Does this mean that the religion of Jesus is Not the religion of Moses? Not for me, because I recognize Jesus as the Messiah, and one of the continuing line of Prophets beginning with Adam.
Then the Muslims say yes to Jesus, but also Muhammad, etc…
As to Buddhists and Hindus, many of them accept Jesus, having no difficulty there.
There are many who are Baha’is, as there are Jews, Christians, and Muslims, seeing no contradiction, but rather having a new perspective, view them as revealers of Progressive Revelation:
“This is the changeless Faith of God, eternal in the past, eternal in the future.”
As to your question: “How do the Buddhists and Hindus feel about your position?”
One can also ask: “How do the Jews feel about your position?” for it is the same position.
Those Jews who recognize Jesus as are called Christians. The others feel whatever they do about the position of the Christians. It is the same.
I do realize how difficult it is to resolve these differences. If it were easy, there would be no problem. But after 2000 years, the Jews have still not resolved the position of Christ relative to their beliefs, nor have Christians after 1400 years resolved the differences of Islam with their beliefs.
“Beware, O believers in the Unity of God, lest ye be tempted to make any distinction between any of the Manifestations of His Cause, or to discriminate against the signs that have accompanied and proclaimed their Revelation. This indeed is the true meaning of Divine Unity, if ye be of them that apprehend and believe this truth. Be ye assured, moreover, that the works and acts of each and every one of these Manifestations of God, nay whatever pertaineth unto them, and whatsoever they may manifest in the future, are all ordained by God, and are a reflection of His Will and Purpose….”