Bart Stupak Cashes In

  • Thread starter Thread starter 1holycatholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
In your opinion. But there is absolutely nothing in church teaching that supports that. In fact for the hundred years prior to the civil rights movement it was the Democrat party that enforced brutal segregation upon blacks. And lest you try to contend that they have made up for by their treatment of blacks now keep in mind that their policies aid abette the killing of 400,000 black children year and their only regret about this is that the taxpayers are not forced to pay for it.

So let’s review. From 1865 through 1965 the Democrats enforced segregation of blacks, hardly the actions of that party that is in line with Catholic teaching. From 1973 to today they have embraced Roe V Wade and the culture of death-again hardly in line with Catholic teaching. So are you trying to make the case that for a grand total of eight years the Democratic Party was more in line with Catholic teaching than anyone else? Appears you are damning them with faint praise even if your supposition is correct
You are ignorant of history. The Civil Rights act and Voting Rignts act came under a Democratic administrated, spearheaded by JFK and LBJ.
 
What about war? Let’s let the Pope address that:

While the Church exhorts civil authorities to seek peace, not war, and to exercise discretion and mercy in imposing punishment on criminals, it may still be permissible to take up arms to repel an aggressor or to have recourse to capital punishment. There may be a legitimate diversity of opinion even among Catholics about waging war and applying the death penalty, but not however with regard to abortion and euthanasia.

Having disposed of that can you show us where the Republican Party opposes the right of workers to form unions? I believe you will find that not only does the Republican Party support the right of workers enjoy the union they also support the right of workers not to join a union -something the Democrat party refuses to do .

Whether a pro-life Democrat is superior pro-life Republican is debatable however it is a theory very hard to test as there are so few of them

…
The United States Has not been engaged in a Just War since WWII. All of which, save one have been commenced under Republican administrations (Korea is the exception (truman). Vietnam is not the fault of Kennedy or Johnson, but Ike, another Republican).
 
Four of the five are life issues. I think I have already addressed that. The fifth is something that has no bearing on elections, because the electorate is opposed, and SCOTUS is loathe to decide against the electorate. What about war? Republicans tend to like wars. It is a right of workers to organize into unions Something else the Republicans are opposed to, You cannot serve God and mammon. A democrat who is truly pro-life is a superior candidate to a pro-life Republican. YOu need to get beyond party labels. Vote for the person.
Democrats like wars just as much as Republicans. Don’t kid yourself.

WWI - Woodrow Wilson - Democrat
WWII - Franklin Roosevelt - Democrat
Korea - Harry Truman - Democrat
Vietnam - John Kennedy - Democrat
Bay of Pigs - Kennedy again
Panama - Bush 41 - Republican
Desert Storm - Bush 41 again
American military action in Kosovo - Clinton - Democrat
Afganastan - Bush 43 - Republican
Iraq - Bush 43 again
Libya - Obama - Democrat

of the 10 (and there are more) easily identifiable wars (police actions, humanitarian bombings, whatever) in the last 100 years, 6 were initiated by Democrats.
 
You are ignorant of history. The Civil Rights act and Voting Rignts act came under a Democratic administrated, spearheaded by JFK and LBJ.
The Civil Rights act was initiated by Eisenhower and its most vociferous opponent in the Senate was the one who gets credit for its signing, Lyndon Johnson. History has facts, learn them.
 
And subsidiarity? So what, now one also has to adhere to right wing positions on devolution and dimembering the federal government to be a real Catholic? Tell me, is it against Church teaching to oppose the abolition of public education too?
There is a real danger in invoking one principle of the Church’s social doctrine while ignoring others. The danger is that the Church’s doctrine can be distorted. As the Compendium of the Social Doctrine of the Church emphasizes, the doctrines of *the common good, the universal destination of goods, subsidiarity, and solidarity *must be studied as one organic whole to be properly understood. They are all interrelated.

My belief is that those with a Republican ideology emphasize subsidiarity so much (and not the other doctrines at all, btw) because, taken by itself, it seems to jibe with the spirit of social Darwinism that animates Republican policy. Dismantle the national social safety net and let the locals fend for themselves. Only how, they never quite tell us.
 
Four of the five are life issues. I think I have already addressed that. The fifth is something that has no bearing on elections, because the electorate is opposed, and SCOTUS is loathe to decide against the electorate. What about war? Republicans tend to like wars. It is a right of workers to organize into unions Something else the Republicans are opposed to, You cannot serve God and mammon. A democrat who is truly pro-life is a superior candidate to a pro-life Republican. YOu need to get beyond party labels. Vote for the person.
A Democrat who is truly pro-life and doesn’t recognize that they have no place in the Democratic party is delusional. I don’t vote for delusional candidates.

As you have noted, the Democrats are on the wrong side of the Church on every life and family issue. But even if they weren’t in direct opposition to the Church on every life and family issue they still directly oppose the Catholic teaching on subsidiarity in every sphere of their policies. A Democrat is the worst possible choice for a Catholic.

The electorate is opposed to abortion, but that doesn’t mean the Democrats don’t promote it above all other issues. The Democrats were willing to shut down the government over abortion, though they euphemistically called it “women’s health” or some other such claptrap.
 
There is a real danger in invoking one principle of the Church’s social doctrine while ignoring others. The danger is that the Church’s doctrine can be distorted. As the Compendium of the Social Doctrine of the Church emphasizes, the doctrines of *the common good, the universal destination of goods, subsidiarity, and solidarity *must be studied as one organic whole to be properly understood. They are all interrelated.

My belief is that those with a Republican ideology emphasize subsidiarity so much (and not the other doctrines at all, btw) because, taken by itself, it seems to jibe with the spirit of social Darwinism that animates Republican policy. Dismantle the national social safety net and let the locals fend for themselves. Only how, they never quite tell us.
You are entitled to you opinion but the Church deos not share it. They make it clear that no issue or combination of issues trump abortion. There is absolutely nothing in the republcian Parety Platform that is in conflict with the teachings of the Church
 
There is a real danger in invoking one principle of the Church’s social doctrine while ignoring others. The danger is that the Church’s doctrine can be distorted. As the Compendium of the Social Doctrine of the Church emphasizes, the doctrines of *the common good, the universal destination of goods, subsidiarity, and solidarity *must be studied as one organic whole to be properly understood. They are all interrelated.

My belief is that those with a Republican ideology emphasize subsidiarity so much (and not the other doctrines at all, btw) because, taken by itself, it seems to jibe with the spirit of social Darwinism that animates Republican policy. Dismantle the national social safety net and let the locals fend for themselves. Only how, they never quite tell us.
:hmmm:
The Democrats directly oppose the Church’s social doctrine on the universal destination of goods, Republicans don’t.

acton.org/pub/religion-liberty/volume-10-number-1/universal-destination-material-goods

The Democrats directly oppose the Church on the common good as well since abortion is contrary to the natural law.
 
You are ignorant of history. The Civil Rights act and Voting Rignts act came under a Democratic administrated, spearheaded by JFK and LBJ.
The same Democrat party that instituted segreagtion and fought civil rights up unitl the mid 60s. Like I said it appears that at the most one could say the democrat party was in line with Church teachng for 8 of the last 150 years.
 
Before Roe v. Wade, the Democratic Paty was the home of the majority of Catholics because of the moral bankruptcy of the Republican party, which has historically been motivated by promoting big business.

“The business of America is business”–Herbert Hoover (Republican)
The flight of the Catholics from the Democrat party happened before Roe V Wade and actually started in the '60s with the Vietnam war protests and sexual/youth revolution. The Democrat party’s leftward lurch with the nomination of McGovern also helped ensure the flight of blue collar Catholic Democrats because McGovern was a softie on communism and blue collar Catholics hated communism. This continued through the 70’s and culminated with Reagan winning the presidency with “Reagan Democrats”. Roe v Wade was a factor in all of this but not the only one. The Democrat party left Catholics, actually, not the other way around.

Also, it was Calvin Coolidge who said " the business of America is business."

I would recommend reading up on some of the history.

Ishii
 
The flight of the Catholics from the Democrat party happened before Roe V Wade and actually started in the '60s with the Vietnam war protests and sexual/youth revolution. The Democrat party’s leftward lurch with the nomination of McGovern also helped ensure the flight of blue collar Catholic Democrats because McGovern was a softie on communism and blue collar Catholics hated communism. This continued through the 70’s and culminated with Reagan winning the presidency with “Reagan Democrats”. Roe v Wade was a factor in all of this but not the only one. The Democrat party left Catholics, actually, not the other way around.

Also, it was Calvin Coolidge who said " the business of America is business."

I would recommend reading up on some of the history.

Ishii
I have read a great deal of history, thank you very much.
 
:hmmm:
The Democrats directly oppose the Church’s social doctrine on the universal destination of goods, Republicans don’t.

acton.org/pub/religion-liberty/volume-10-number-1/universal-destination-material-goods

The Democrats directly oppose the Church on the common good as well since abortion is contrary to the natural law.
You are wrong there bucko. The Republicans call for the concentration of wealth in the hands of the very few, which is in direct opposition to the Universal Destination of Goods. I am done with this thread and feckless individuals attempting to sacramentalize a political party.
 
You are wrong there bucko. The Republicans call for the concentration of wealth in the hands of the very few, which is in direct opposition to the Universal Destination of Goods. I am done with this thread and feckless individuals attempting to sacramentalize a political party.
Please show us where the Republicans call for the concentration of wealth in fewer hands. Of course given the Democrats support of the distruction of the unborn there are fewer and fewer hands that wealth can go to but that is not the fault of Republicans. Those who plot the destruction of others often perish in the attempt.”**http://thinkexist.com/i/sq/as4.gifS Thomas Moore

What we are seeing in this thread is usual mental gymnastics that a Catholic Democrat has to go through to support the party of death. They have to make up things about the Republican Party to justify their votes. The problem is we don’t have to make it anything whatsoever about the Democrat party to show their rejection of Catholic teaching, all we have to do is quote their party platform
 
40.png
estesbob:
It would seem to be a no-brainer to realize that all right rights flow from the right to life. Peace and prosperity for all do little for those who were killed in the womb. I will have to admit that in my 35 years of working in the pro-life ministry this is the first time I’ve been compared to Joseph Stalin but then when dealing with those trying to defend the indefensible one runs into all sorts of strange analogies.
I didn’t compare anyone with Stalin, merely noting that we should not be content with a mere lesser of two evils.

And what’s so indefensible about criticizing the errors of the GOP? Oh, you mean because I must be an evil Democrat babykiller? Well, as I’ve told you before, I’m neither a Democrat, nor a babykiller. Maybe I should put my voting record in my signature s you don’t keep accusing me of this.
40.png
1holycatholic:
A Democrat who is truly pro-life and doesn’t recognize that they have no place in the Democratic party is delusional. I don’t vote for delusional candidates.
But there is certainly no place in the Republican party for a Catholic for one who opposes laissez faire capitalism, a deregulated insurance industry, and unrestricted gun rights. So what are such Catholics do to, just stay the hell out of politics? Or should they merely accept the fact whatever their disagreements they must be in error and should just assent to the teachings of the Party?
 
I didn’t compare anyone with Stalin, merely noting that we should not be content with a mere lesser of two evils.

And what’s so indefensible about criticizing the errors of the GOP? Oh, you mean because I must be an evil Democrat babykiller? Well, as I’ve told you before, I’m neither a Democrat, nor a babykiller. Maybe I should put my voting record in my signature s you don’t keep accusing me of this.
It wouldn’t matter.
But there is certainly no place in the Republican party for a Catholic for one who opposes laissez faire capitalism, a deregulated insurance industry, and unrestricted gun rights. So what are such Catholics do to, just stay the hell out of politics? Or should they merely accept the fact whatever their disagreements they must be in error and should just assent to the teachings of the Party?
What are we to do? Sit down, shut up and vote Republican. What else. 😉
 
It wouldn’t matter.

What are we to do? Sit down, shut up and vote Republican. What else. 😉
I guess so. I can handle the argument that abortion outweighs other issues. But when people start arguing this nonsense about how Republican economic policy is reflected in Church teaching, I don’t know whether to laugh or cry, or both.

And what’s more, you can’t even be a dissenting Republican! Because the second you question a particular Republican party policy, estesbob will come on and call you babykiller. Does this attitude sway Catholics to support “the party of life?” Absolutely not. I’m a moderate, but after a little while on these threads I feel tempted to become a democratic socialist just to get as far away from the extreme right as possible. But if it gives some people a chance to be self-righteous, then I guess that’s what matters.

I’d thank God that I’m pessimistic enough that I don’t even vote, and so it’s not such a dilemma for me, but I’ve already been told once on these boards that even not voting is enough to get me sent to hell.
 
But there is certainly no place in the Republican party for a Catholic for one who opposes laissez faire capitalism, a deregulated insurance industry, and unrestricted gun rights. So what are such Catholics do to, just stay the hell out of politics? Or should they merely accept the fact whatever their disagreements they must be in error and should just assent to the teachings of the Party?
You’re flailing about like a just caught fish tossed onto a hot pier.

Your criteria:

Google Search: “gun rights” site:vatican.va
Your search - “gun rights” site:vatican.va - did not match any documents
Google Search: “laissez faire capitalism” site:vatican.va
Your search - “laissez faire capitalism” site:vatican.va - did not match any documents.
Google Search: “insurance industry” site:vatican.va
Your search - “insurance industry” site:vatican.va - did not match any documents.
🤷

My criteria:

Google Search: “abortion” site:vatican.va
**About 563 results (0.12 seconds) **

First returned hit:
Catechism of the Catholic Church - The fifth commandment - 6 visits - Apr 14
2271 Since the first century the Church has affirmed the moral evil of every procured abortion. This teaching has not changed and remains unchangeable. …
www.vatican.va/archive/ccc_css/archive/…/p3s2c2a5.htm - Cached - Similar
:coffeeread:
 
I didn’
But there is certainly no place in the Republican party for a Catholic for one who opposes laissez faire capitalism, a deregulated insurance industry, and unrestricted gun rights. So what are such Catholics do to, just stay the hell out of politics? Or should they merely accept the fact whatever their disagreements they must be in error and should just assent to the teachings of the Party?
BUT none of what you mention are tenants of the Church and a catholic in good conscience can support everything you oppose. Of course what you mention bear little or no realtionship to what the Party actaully stands for but even if they were true a Catholic could support them.

If you beleieve that the only way you can participate in politics is to support abortion by your vote then yes, you should stay the hell out of politics.
 
You’re flailing about like a just caught fish tossed onto a hot pier.

Your criteria:

Google Search: “gun rights” site:vatican.va
Your search - “gun rights” site:vatican.va - did not match any documents
Google Search: “laissez faire capitalism” site:vatican.va
Your search - “laissez faire capitalism” site:vatican.va - did not match any documents.
Google Search: “insurance industry” site:vatican.va
Your search - “insurance industry” site:vatican.va - did not match any documents.
🤷

My criteria:

Google Search: “abortion” site:vatican.va
**About 563 results (0.12 seconds) **

First returned hit:
Catechism of the Catholic Church - The fifth commandment - 6 visits - Apr 14
2271 Since the first century the Church has affirmed the moral evil of every procured abortion. This teaching has not changed and remains unchangeable. …
www.vatican.va/archive/ccc_css/archive/…/p3s2c2a5.htm - Cached - Similar
:coffeeread:
👍👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top