Bill Nye vs. Ken Ham

  • Thread starter Thread starter Zachary
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
As you correctly note under today’s paradigm a divine foot cannot be let in the door. Today’s science then, by excluding the possibility of the supernatural, has painted itself in a corner. In the past design was part and parcel of science. Science is a discovery of truth, but yet it limits itself by its own definition to excluding truth itself.

Reason can lead us to a creator. Philosophy can get us to God, theology gets us to who He is.

34 The world, and man, attest that they contain within themselves neither their first principle nor their final end, but rather that they participate in Being itself, which alone is without origin or end. Thus, in different ways, man can come to know that there exists a reality which is the first cause and final end of all things, a reality “that everyone calls God”.10
35 Man’s faculties make him capable of coming to a knowledge of the existence of a personal God. But for man to be able to enter into real intimacy with him, God willed both to reveal himself to man and to give him the grace of being able to welcome this revelation in faith. The proofs of God’s existence, however, can predispose one to faith and help one to see that faith is not opposed to reason

159 Faith and science: "Though faith is above reason, there can never be any real discrepancy between faith and reason. Since the same God who reveals mysteries and infuses faith has bestowed the light of reason on the human mind, God cannot deny himself, nor can truth ever contradict truth."37 "Consequently, methodical research in all branches of knowledge, provided it is carried out in a truly scientific manner and does not override moral laws, can never conflict with the faith, because the things of the world and the things of faith derive from the same God. The humble and persevering investigator of the secrets of nature is being led, as it were, by the hand of God in spite of himself, for it is God, the conserver of all things, who made them what they are."38
Because something is not scientific does no mean it is not true. Evidence for the existence of god is not a matter for science. It can STILL be true, and I argue all the time against those who conflate science with truth. Physics, chemistry, biology, all the hard sciences speak to the imminant, physical world around us, not anything mrtaphyisical. Secularists “hijacked” science in that the nature of what kind of questions science can address is constantly being examined by philosophers of science and time and time again the supenatural seems beyond the scope of it. Science STARTED from a religious standpoint, and that standpoint has slowly chipped away because it doesn’t stand up to the observation and experimentation that science stands on.
 
Yeah the whole debate layout was poor in my opinion. They spent a large amount of time not debating. Then they went to some sort of Question and answer. There should have been a lot more back and fourth debating. Many times both Ham and Nye wanted to ask each other questions but were bogged down by the next question from the audience. Both guys seemed to not really be on the same page as far as to how they were debating either.

In the end of course there is a difference between what is directly observable and can be tested over and over vs something that happened a long time ago and can’t necessarily be repeated. That doesn’t mean we still can’t investigate and draw conclusions or ideas about the past based on evidence.
 
Because something is not scientific does no mean it is not true. Evidence for the existence of god is not a matter for science. It can STILL be true, and I argue all the time against those who conflate science with truth. Physics, chemistry, biology, all the hard sciences speak to the imminant, physical world around us, not anything mrtaphyisical. Secularists “hijacked” science in that the nature of what kind of questions science can address is constantly being examined by philosophers of science and time and time again the supenatural seems beyond the scope of it. Science STARTED from a religious standpoint, and that standpoint has slowly chipped away because it doesn’t stand up to the observation and experimentation that science stands on.
I see it very differently. I see science painting itself into a corner. In general, science is a search for true knowledge, yet it excludes the source. That means science can tell us that a ball will bounce, tell us about laws that are demonstrable, etc. When it moves away from this it crosses over into philosophy. Evolutionism is religion.
 
Yeah the whole debate layout was poor in my opinion. They spent a large amount of time not debating. Then they went to some sort of Question and answer. There should have been a lot more back and fourth debating. Many times both Ham and Nye wanted to ask each other questions but were bogged down by the next question from the audience. Both guys seemed to not really be on the same page as far as to how they were debating either.

In the end of course there is a difference between what is directly observable and can be tested over and over vs something that happened a long time ago and can’t necessarily be repeated. That doesn’t mean we still can’t investigate and draw conclusions or ideas about the past based on evidence.
When trying to draw conclusions about the past based on evidence do we include Revelation or reject it outright?
 
Because something is not scientific does no mean it is not true. Evidence for the existence of god is not a matter for science. It can STILL be true, and I argue all the time against those who conflate science with truth. Physics, chemistry, biology, all the hard sciences speak to the imminant, physical world around us, not anything mrtaphyisical. Secularists “hijacked” science in that the nature of what kind of questions science can address is constantly being examined by philosophers of science and time and time again the supenatural seems beyond the scope of it. Science STARTED from a religious standpoint, and that standpoint has slowly chipped away because it doesn’t stand up to the observation and experimentation that science stands on.
Because science cannot say or prove the supernatural are we to conclude it does not exist? It is a deficiency of science that restricts its investigation.

How far then can we rely on what provisional science has to say about the world? And why are so many people swayed by the conclusions of modern science?

I submit, lack of philosophical training and the indoctrinization that science has rendered god useless. The question is - did our human reasoning lead us down this path through ignorance or is it part of a larger agenda?
 
There are OT bible verses about a round earth. Anyone who looked can see the horizon is not flat, then and now.
This is what I don’t understand; the complete denial of history. A lot of people DID believe that the Earth was flat even up through the Middle Ages and many of the people who kept that fable alive that long were Christians. And that horizon? People thought it was just the edge of the Earth where their God(s) had placed a dome from which the stars hang like christmas ornaments. BTW - the OT doesn’t say anything about an ellipsoidal Earth. It describes it as a circle, which is only two-dimensional ie flat.
 
This is what I don’t understand; the complete denial of history. A lot of people DID believe that the Earth was flat even up through the Middle Ages and many of the people who kept that fable alive that long were Christians. BTW - the OT doesn’t say anything about an ellipsoidal Earth. It describes it as a circle, which is only two-dimensional ie flat.
So an old ancient guy walking next to the ocean sees himself as standing on the edge of a dime? Then he turns 90 degrees and sees the curve there too?

Chuwg the Hebrew word for circle. They did not have a second world for a sphere. It is much like the word brother meant cousin too in Jesus’ time. They simply did not have a word for it. We see this too in modern language translations.
 
So an old ancient guy walking next to the ocean sees himself as standing on the edge of a dime? Then he turns 90 degrees and sees the curve there too? Chuwg the Hebrew word for circle. They did not have a second world for a sphere. It is much like the word brother meant cousin too in Jesus’ time. They simply did not have a word for it. We see this too in modern language translations.
This isn’t an issue of translation. The Jews believed the Earth to be flat and depicted it as such. I think they knew what was meant to be said since they wrote it. And by the way, this isn’t just about “ancient guys.” Lucius Lactantius, Christian religious advisor of Emperor Constantine, believed the Earth to be flat. St. Augustine also argued the Earth was flat and even went so far as to call it “absurd” and a “fable” that people could actually travel or even exist on another “side” of the Earth. There is a long list of examples extending all the way through the Middle Ages of Christian bishops, monks, theologians, and philosophers arguing for a flat Earth and using the Bible as evidence. If you’re only relying on the Bible, that is the only conclusion that can be reached based on what it contains. There just isn’t any way around it if you take the Bible literally.
 
This isn’t an issue of translation. The Jews believed the Earth to be flat and depicted it as such. I think they know what was meant to be said since they wrote it. And by the way, this isn’t just about ancient “guys.” Lucius Lactantius, Christian religious advisor of Emperor Constantine, believed the Earth to be flat. St. Augustine also argued the Earth was flat and even went so far as to call it “absurd” that people could actually travel or even exist on another “side” of the Earth. There is a long list of examples extending all the way through the Middle Ages of Christian bishops, monks, theologians, and philosophers arguing for a flat Earth and using the Bible as evidence.
Yes, there were some that argued for a flat earth, but they were wrong. The Greeks had influence on some of this as they pushed for perfect geometric shapes.

Another example is “the ends of the earth” - means the end of dry land as in shoreline and/or boundaries. (look at the usual depiction with the end of dry land in a new light)

St Augustine- … “although it be supposed or scientifically demonstrated that the world is of a round and spherical form, yet it does not follow that the other side of the earth is bare of water; nor even, though it be bare, does it immediately follow that it is peopled.”

The Late Birth of a Flat Earth
by Stephen Jay Gould
 
Yes, there were some that argued for a flat earth, but they were wrong.
Obviously, but no one figured it out by reading the Bible. The Bible describes a flat Earth which is why biblical literalists continued to flog that dead horse for well over a thousand years after the Greeks had proven otherwise.
 
Because science cannot say or prove the supernatural are we to conclude it does not exist? It is a deficiency of science that restricts its investigation.

How far then can we rely on what provisional science has to say about the world? And why are so many people swayed by the conclusions of modern science?

I submit, lack of philosophical training and the indoctrinization that science has rendered god useless. The question is - did our human reasoning lead us down this path through ignorance or is it part of a larger agenda?
No. Not at all. Science not touching god doesn’t mean god doesn’t exist. It just means that science doesn’t speak on the matter. Science doesn’t speak on a lot of topics, like ethics. But ethics certainly exists as a thing. Science just cannot give an account of it.

I’m not arguing against god. Science itself is a poor argument against god too. I’m arguing about the nature of science.
 
Obviously, but no one figured it out by reading the Bible. The Bible describes a flat Earth which is why biblical literalists continued to flog that dead horse for well over a thousand years after the Greeks had already proven otherwise.
Catholics understand the Bible literally not literalistically.

There is no Chruch teaching of a flat earth.
 
No. Not at all. Science not touching god doesn’t mean god doesn’t exist. It just means that science doesn’t speak on the matter. Science doesn’t speak on a lot of topics, like ethics. But ethics certainly exists as a thing. Science just cannot give an account of it.

I’m not arguing against god. Science itself is a poor argument against god too. I’m arguing about the nature of science.
But scientists themselves have stated modern science has rendered God useless.

Why?
 
Catholics understand the Bible literally not literalistically.
Ahh, so you aren’t a creationist after all? And btw - thats a pretty recent development for Catholicism.
There is no Chruch teaching of a flat earth.
The Church doesn’t take sides on such things anymore. It doesn’t have a position on a literal creation vs evolution either. In short, it remains on the fence these days.
 
Ahh, so you aren’t a creationist after all? And btw - thats a pretty recent development for Catholicism.
I am a Catholic. In the broad sense all Catholics are creationists as God created it all.

Catholics always had Tradition and Scripture. Tradition came first. We have always understood Scripture as what the author intended to convey.

I would like your source for your claim otherwise.
 
In his volumes History of the Inductive Sciences (1837) and The Philosophy of the Inductive Sciences (1840), Whewell distinguished sciences such as physics and chemistry from what he called palaetiology —literally, the “study of past causes.” And he argued that “palaetiological,” or historical, sciences could be distinguished from nonhistorical sciences in three ways. 5 First, the palaetiological, or historical, sciences have a distinctive objective: to determine ancient conditions or past causes, as opposed to establishing universal laws by which nature generally operates. 6 Second, such sciences explain present events (“ manifest effects ”) by reference to past (causal) events, rather than by reference to general laws (though Whewell acknowledged that laws often play a supporting role in such explanations). 7 Historical scientists cite the occurrence of an event or series of events in the past as the explanation for some observable phenomenon in the present. 8 For example, a geologist might explain the origin of the Alps as the result of a series of geological events involving the collision of specific tectonic plates, the overthrusting of sedimentary layers, and then the subsequent folding and faulting of those layers. As science historian Jonathan Hodge explains, Whewell realized that historical sciences do not study “forces that are permanent causes of motion, such as gravitational attraction,” but “causes that have worked their effects in temporal succession.” 9 Third, in their attempt to reconstruct “ancient conditions,” Whewell argued that historical scientists also utilized a distinctive mode of reasoning. 10 Using knowledge of cause-and-effect relationships, historical scientists “calculate backwards” and “infer” past conditions and causes from “manifest effects.” 11 As Gould later put it, historical scientists proceed by “inferring history from its results.” 12 For example, in order to reconstruct the Cambrian environment, paleontologists such as Gould and Conway Morris made inferences about the past based on present-day fossils and other clues. 13 They inferred a past environment and set of conditions as the cause of the evidence they found. Like other historical scientists, they reasoned from clues back to causes. 14
**Abductive Reasoning **

This type of reasoning is called abductive reasoning or abduction. It was first described by the American philosopher and logician Charles Sanders Peirce. He noted that, unlike inductive reasoning, in which a universal law or principle is established from repeated observations of the same phenomena, and unlike deductive reasoning, in which a particular fact is deduced by applying a general law to another particular fact or case, abductive reasoning infers unseen facts, events, or causes in the past from clues or facts in the present. 15

Meyer, Stephen C. Signature in the Cell (p. 153).
 
As Peirce himself showed , there is a problem with abductive reasoning. 16

Consider the following syllogism:

If it rains, the streets will get wet.
The streets are wet.
Therefore, it rained.

In this syllogism, a past condition (it was raining) is inferred from a present clue (the streets are wet). Nevertheless, this syllogism commits a logical fallacy known as affirming the consequent. Given that the street is wet (and without additional evidence to decide the matter), one can only conclude that perhaps it rained. Why? Because there are other possible ways the street may have gotten wet. A street-cleaning machine, an uncapped fire hydrant, or rain might have caused the street to get wet. It can be difficult to infer the past from the present because there are often many possible causes of a given effect . When this is the case, abductive inferences yield plausible, but not certain, conclusions.

Meyer, Stephen C. Signature in the Cell (p. 153). HarperCollins.
 
Obviously, but no one figured it out by reading the Bible. The Bible describes a flat Earth which is why biblical literalists continued to flog that dead horse for well over a thousand years after the Greeks had proven otherwise.
People did of course figure out (though non-Catholics may say ‘decided’) that the literalist interpretation was invalid long before scientific discoveries could be employed to argue against it. St. Augustine’s refutation of literalism came long before Copernicus’s. And generally speaking, people who believed the earth was flat didn’t believe that because religious texts told them so; they believed it because there wasn’t much else to believe. It took more thought and education to deduce that the Earth was round back then than most people had the time or resources to obtain. Religious traditions’ claim that the earth was flat were merely recapitulating general knowledge, not creating it; an as opinion amongst the educated clergy on that matter changed with the available evidence; indeed many of the natural philosophers of the middle ages who were proponents of the round earth theory were clergymen. Many common people continued to believe in the flatness of the earth, but that wasn’t necessarily because they were Christian, but rather because they were common people.
And btw - thats a pretty recent development for Catholicism.
How could it not be, evolution is itself a recent development. Even to say it’s as old as Darwin is to jump the gun. Evolutionary theory didn’t have a good body of knowledge with thorough support and well-articulated theory until the early to mid 20th century with the work of the likes of Ernst Mayr and Theodosius Dobzhansky. It’s unfair to blame everyone in the world for not immediately jumping on board in 1859.

It’s also worth noting that modern creationism (particularly the young earth kind) is also a recent development. Most English Clergy in Darwin’s time (like most educated people) would have believed that the earth was many million years old and many subscribed to Lamarckism; obviously both those views are inaccurate, but they were based on the best scientific evidence available at the time.
The Church doesn’t take sides on such things anymore. It doesn’t have a position on a literal creation vs evolution either. In short, it remains on the fence these days.
This is quite a mischaracterization. The Church is not “on the fence.” It is quite fine with the evolution. It also notes, however, that there is nothing morally wrong with being a creationist. It does not tell people what to believe on such matter because, quite simply, it is not it’s place to tell people what they should believe one way or the other. It is not ‘on the fence’ or ‘unsure’ or waiting to make a conclusion. It is saying that it is not it’s purpose to declare scientific research to be true or false. What would you have them do, declare creationism a sin?

You might me interested to know that the Catholic Church also has no opinion on whether IL-10 secreting B-cells play a role in regulating killer T-cells. Personally, I think IL-10 B-cells probably do in fact do this. And in a few years, we may know for a fact that this is the case. And yet, the Church will still refrain from making a formal declaration on the truth about IL-10 B-cell modulation of T-cells. Most likely, it will not declare the hold-outs who insist that these B-cells only regulate helper T-cells, not killer T-cells, are heretics. This does not mean, however, that are declaring all positions on the matter to be equal, but rather that it is not within its scope to make such decrees one way or the other.
 
It is not possible to have a scientific debate about unfalsifiable philosophical/religious concepts because it isn’t science. Has nothing to do with bubble bursting.
Shouldn’t, but it does. They can’t stand the Truth when it interferes with their agenda. :rolleyes:
Um, that “rigid criteria” is called science so I’m sure where you’re going with this.
No, that was just your opinion.
 
de·vo·lu·tion

Full Definition of DEVOLUTION


2
: retrograde evolution : degeneration
Great, you’ve proved that is a word in the dictionary. So is the word “scrumptuous”. That doesn’t give it meaning as a scientific term. There is no such thing, from a scientific understanding, as “devolution”.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top