I think the greatest weaknesses are seen when atheists/agnostics ask questions that involve the* mind of God* or
God’s plan. When they post those kinds of questions here at CAF, they will inevitably get one of two answers; 1) it’s a mystery, 2) I’ll pray for you. Both of which are non-answers.
Some examples of these types of questions:
- theodicy: what purpose do natural disasters that kill hundreds of thousand of people serve? What part in God’s plan do genetic and congenital birth defects serve?
I will attempt to provide a short reply to your questions, as your post is thoughtful and you deserve a return on “your time investment”.
However while I do know the Mind of my RCC Faith, no sane person can claim to know the Mind of God. Thank God I’m lucid!
One should couch this debate with an understanding of who and what God is.
Simply put God (One Person with Three Divine Natures — think of as manifestations — God the Father, God the Son and God the Holy Spirit,) is all everything good. Therefore God is all Wise, Powerful, Mighty, Loving, Merciful, Kind, Knowing, and Just (as is fair) to name some of God’s attributes. Significantly, God being God, Has To Be all of these things, and in the fullest and most Perfect way. That is what makes God, God.
So I do not assume to no God’s mind,
but we get a glimpse of God by knowing His Nature, which as I have said is and must be all –good.
God manifest His Goodness in way’s that suit His Will. The facts that we agree with, disagree with, approve of or disapprove of God’s decisions and actions, is for the time being irrelevant. Why? Because very often our point of view stems from us not being able to understand the Will of God.
God either causes something to happen or God permits something to happen for two constant and consistent reasons, for our POSSIBLE sanctification and or God’s greater glory.
We can know if the act is “caused” by God, or simply “permitted” by God, by the merits of the action in question. If it is good, it is caused by God and if not it is only permitted (tolerated) by God.
Either way,
God will cause the Good that He desires to come from the event.
- why did God wait so long in evolutionary history before revealing Himself in the person of Jesus? What about all the other hominids who lived in the preceding 500,000 years?
Because that was the time chosen by God from the beginning of all of God’s Creation (to make something out of nothing.) In His time, and in His way.Keep in mind that "time’ does not exist for God who is “All-Knowing.”
- why does God demand faith in the supernatural as the only means of salvation?
Friend, I confess to not understanding the question? If you’re asking why God performs miracles it is to prove His Divinity b) to help our faith grow and c) to demonstrate His Love and Compassion for us. All that God “demands” is Christian Baptism, full adhereance to all of His Commandments, and “love one another as I have Loved you.”
- Why does this irrational behavior please Him? God can be pleased? God has emotions? How do you know this?
Again, I don’t comprehend what you mean by “irrational behavior?” God can’t be irrational, humanity can as we are given the gifts of intellect and freewill, to prove that we Love God. God gives us emotions, some good, some not, but allows us free use of them, which is the primary tool of Satan to get us to sin. Satan cannot alter our freewill, but can and does take advantage of our emotions.
**God became human,
God died on the Cross, God Rose from the Dead = LOVE
Jesus wept over “The City” Luke 19:41 = Sorrow
Jesus demonstrated just anger John 2: 15 = Anger
Jesus feels joy Luke 15:7 = Joy**
Yes Jesus was and is true man (humanity) and True God (Divinity.)
- what kind of existence will we have in heaven? Memories? Our existing psychological traits/characteristics? Sensory capabilities?
In comprehensible and total joy, happiness and peace because we will be in the Very Presence of God, but not face to face until the Final Judgement we will be ‘spirits” as is God. We can know all that is good, nothing that is not. At the Second and Final Judgement, we will, like the Angels know God face to face and finally be able to understand the Mind of God.” Our only purpose for being in Heaven to Love, Honor, and Praise God. And in these acts we will find complete satisfaction, joy and peace.
- why is it that we are not allowed to have direct, full knowledge of God because that would take away our free will? Yet the angels have full knowledge **and **free will.
Yes. Even God “cannot” take away our freewill as that is His plan for us to prove that we Love Him.
All these questions and many more have been posted here (some by me) and in the end there is no final answer, except to say that it’s a mystery.
My dear friend in Christ, there indeed is a final answer, There has to be, because their is only One Truth for every question. And this we can know, because God has to be all-just.