Catholic Apologetics Greatest Weaknesses

  • Thread starter Thread starter Truthstalker
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It is curious to me
Indeed. Your ability to engage in honest debate is compromised by your straw man OP which you used to reduce yourself to ad hominem attacks rather than debate the responses.
It is curious to me that the response on this thread to the OP is at least to attack
It is amazing that people who go to confession, or claim to, are blind to their own sense of self-superiority and their venial contempt of their brethren.

That is how you come across. Nothing appealing. Rather revolting.
 
I think the greatest weaknesses are seen when atheists/agnostics ask questions that involve the* mind of God* or God’s plan. When they post those kinds of questions here at CAF, they will inevitably get one of two answers; 1) it’s a mystery, 2) I’ll pray for you. Both of which are non-answers.

Some examples of these types of questions:
  • theodicy: what purpose do natural disasters that kill hundreds of thousand of people serve? What part in God’s plan do genetic and congenital birth defects serve?
  • why did God wait so long in evolutionary history before revealing Himself in the person of Jesus? What about all the other hominids who lived in the preceding 500,000 years?
  • why does God demand faith in the supernatural as the only means of salvation? Why does this irrational behaviour please Him? God can be pleased? God has emotions? How do you know this?
  • what kind of existence will we have in heaven? Memories? Our existing psychological traits/characteristics? Sensory capabilities?
  • why is it that we are not allowed to have direct, full knowledge of God because that would take away our free will? Yet the angels have full knowledge **and **free will.
All these questions and many more have been posted here (some by me) and in the end there is no final answer, except to say that it’s a mystery.
 
There were practical considerations that existed then about which we (on this forum) are largely ignorant.

Ender
This bit is closest to the issue I think - pragmatic reasons.

I was reluctant to jump in here on this since its drifting from the OP. But let me quickly say that God is unchanging and everything we can SEE that God does must in some way teach us something since we are sensual beings as well as spiritual beings. God gave us a brain and reason so we can do His will as well as learn how to do His will and discern it. God did not give us a rational mind to confound us - we just need to trust that there is a legitimate reason to God.

We can assume that what appears to us by current ideals (which BTW are Christian NT ideals and from the same God) are valid and served God purpose. The most immediate thing I would offer is the notion that God is not compelled by His loving nature to show mercy to those who are His committed enemies. This is entirely consistent with the message we have always had about God - in fact the clear message is there is a day of judgment and woe to those who are on the wrong side of His favor and hate Him.

It is God’s sovereign right to annihilate those who refuse to acknowledge Him or to take back the gift of life when it has expired. For that matter it is God’s right to take us all anytime. Life is a free gift and therefor having life for even a day is infinitely more desireable than the oblivion of non-existence. It is just unnatural to sensibilities (and suicidal) to become an enemy to the Creator as well and to withhold the natural thanks due Him. Everyone alive should be looking into how to do something good with the gift of life we have been given to show our thanks - not scorn the Creator for giving us less than equality with Him.

But I like your practical view here. It may very well have been that Israel’s enemies were covertly intending to kill Israel or intended to infiltrate them to undermine their beliefs with pagan Gods and wicked practices (no doubt Israel had spies and observers and the prophets had personal knowledge of what they were up against as well).

So, it may very well have been the case as well that these people who God orders destroyed were infected with terrible diseases, disorders or even STDs from their hedonistic practises. Clearly, as God’s chosen people God has a motive and interest in keeping the Jewish bloodline absolutely pure in the Davidic lineage to make it possible for Mary - pure and born without sin to give birth to God in the person of Jesus. Our God is a jealous God for His people. Woe to His enemies is the clear message I get.
*
Exodus 33:19 “…I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I will have compassion.”*

I find it ironic that so many Christians have no problem with God delivering hell fire on Sodom and Gomorrah for their outrageous sins against nature and morality but just because there are mentions of “women and children” being slaughtered in other accounts where God elects to use Israel’s sword rather than divine fire to annihilate God’s enemies that God is suddenly assumed to no longer be just and compassionate anymore?

We should put aside the idea that people were inventing excuses to murder their enemies since in the OT times one did not just wage war for the sake of waging war - survival was hard enough without risking more death and its clear Israel did not exploit the victory for economic or gain of power like we see in other major powers and even to this day in contemporary times.

Also, since when does gender and age exempt anyone from being wicked and an instrument for promulgating wickedness. The very idea of “blessed” by God implies that one gets to have successive generations of children (e.g. Abraham’s descendants) and the idea behind “cursed” is that a blood line is cut-off utterly and perishes - never to be heard from again for all time. God is clearly telling us the wicked will be cut off and perish from the face of the earth.

Clearly, God curses those who are obstinate in their contempt for Him and hold contempt for His favored Children. That God even permits His enemies to live at all is only so God may expose the full measure of their evilness and then cut them off or to give them no excuse to say they had no opportunity to come into His grace and serve Him.

Anyway, the same exact principal is in the NT at the final judgement where the goats (wicked male, female and yes, even some children) are seperated from the sheep, cut off from His grace and punished for eternity. If that causes anyone duress then they should make sure they are training hard to repent and get into God’s favor before they are cut off.

I see no contradictions at all.

James
 
From a different prospective…

Some apologists are professionals… they actually get paid for what they choose to write, teach, opine.

Stealing a line from “House” “When a good person dies, there should be an impact on the world.” There was no better person than the 2nd Person of the Trinity.

Apologetics should be a concerted effort by each of us, even the unpaid amateurs, to learn, to share and to defend that impact He had and has on His world.

However,

too often a see the groups, the cliques, the buddies among those who “practice” apologetics.

Pick up one good apologetic work, and look at the endorsements. Then find a work by one of the endorsers… often the names just rotate. Now, this is not a bad thing. But when the “group” either rejects or ignores, or negatively critiques another’s efforts it seems that often it is because that other person has found disfavor with the group… not his or her work… but him or her… and too often it is because that other person offered something the group found offensive, or controversial, or even "radical’.

Simply put, I see too many attacks, for want of a better word, on some apologists from others who should all have the same end goal - furthering His impact on this world.

Put another way, and altering the phrase …
“…I think, therefore I am…”
I see too much of
“… I think, therefore I (we) am right…”

We have a lot of bright young and not so young apologists in the Church. But when they accept their own efforts as conclusive because
“…the Church does not say otherwise…” or perhaps because
“… look at all the people who agree with me…” or even perhaps
“… the other guy or gal was wrong on XYZ, so we should discount him or her…”
we doom our efforts to defeat in the long run. This applies to the liturgy, to sacraments, to Scripture interpretation, to all things Catholic.

It makes us, as Catholics, difficult to be accepted by others who are unfortunate (for now) to be out of the Catholic Church.

Is there that much importance to be the biggest “blog” on the block, or the most widely read/written in the bookstores, or even the most sought after speaker/teacher.

I think many of us could cite examples of apologists who perhaps “erred” in one thing or another. But the weakness we exhibit when we express too much group-think in place of further efforts to understand and discuss… well, I find it more than disconcerting

I can onlly imagine how our separated brethren might see us.

Perhaps the eighth thing apologists should not do… Toot your own horn while disabling the other’s.

.

.
 
Catholics,

Where do you see apologetics for the Catholic Church being weakest? Bear in mind that this is being asked by someone who you have every possible reason to believe will use those weaknesses against you, and he is not alone.
Seems we’ve gotten a bit off topic and the waters a bit muddy so…
As a kick back to TS’s original question I thought I might “define” the discussion just a bit so that we can seperate the message from the messenger.

According to MSN Encarta (a theologically neutral source)
Apologetics, (a) branch of theology concerned with the intellectual defense of Christian truth. The Greek word apologia means ‘defense’ and was originally defined as a defendant’s reply to the speech of the prosecution in a court of law.

So from this we can divine that TS’s question deals with what we see as the weakest point of our argument. Naturally since we, as Catholics, believe our Doctrines and Teachings are correct, there really cannot be a “weak point” in that sense. This is why the converstion has turned somewhat to the problems, strengths and weaknesses of the Apologists themselves.

If we look at those who “Apologize”, that is the Apologist, we can see all of the various strengths and weaknesses of any group of people from Doctors to Lawyers to Janitors to…whomever. Some are brighter, kinder, more patient, others more cunning, devious, short tempered.

So the upshot of the conversations is this. TS is concerned about how we go about apologizing, that is there is a problem with some Apologists. He has not, so far as I can see, found any problems with our Apologetics (intellectual defence of Christian Truth).

Peace
James
 
I think the greatest weaknesses are seen when atheists/agnostics ask questions that involve the* mind of God* or God’s plan. When they post those kinds of questions here at CAF, they will inevitably get one of two answers; 1) it’s a mystery, 2) I’ll pray for you. Both of which are non-answers.

Some examples of these types of questions:
  • theodicy: what purpose do natural disasters that kill hundreds of thousand of people serve? What part in God’s plan do genetic and congenital birth defects serve?
I will attempt to provide a short reply to your questions, as your post is thoughtful and you deserve a return on “your time investment”.

However while I do know the Mind of my RCC Faith, no sane person can claim to know the Mind of God. Thank God I’m lucid!

One should couch this debate with an understanding of who and what God is.

Simply put God (One Person with Three Divine Natures — think of as manifestations — God the Father, God the Son and God the Holy Spirit,) is all everything good. Therefore God is all Wise, Powerful, Mighty, Loving, Merciful, Kind, Knowing, and Just (as is fair) to name some of God’s attributes. Significantly, God being God, Has To Be all of these things, and in the fullest and most Perfect way. That is what makes God, God.

So I do not assume to no God’s mind, but we get a glimpse of God by knowing His Nature, which as I have said is and must be all –good.

God manifest His Goodness in way’s that suit His Will. The facts that we agree with, disagree with, approve of or disapprove of God’s decisions and actions, is for the time being irrelevant. Why? Because very often our point of view stems from us not being able to understand the Will of God.

God either causes something to happen or God permits something to happen for two constant and consistent reasons, for our POSSIBLE sanctification and or God’s greater glory.

We can know if the act is “caused” by God, or simply “permitted” by God, by the merits of the action in question. If it is good, it is caused by God and if not it is only permitted (tolerated) by God.
Either way, God will cause the Good that He desires to come from the event.
  • why did God wait so long in evolutionary history before revealing Himself in the person of Jesus? What about all the other hominids who lived in the preceding 500,000 years?
Because that was the time chosen by God from the beginning of all of God’s Creation (to make something out of nothing.) In His time, and in His way.Keep in mind that "time’ does not exist for God who is “All-Knowing.”
  • why does God demand faith in the supernatural as the only means of salvation?
Friend, I confess to not understanding the question? If you’re asking why God performs miracles it is to prove His Divinity b) to help our faith grow and c) to demonstrate His Love and Compassion for us. All that God “demands” is Christian Baptism, full adhereance to all of His Commandments, and “love one another as I have Loved you.”
  • Why does this irrational behavior please Him? God can be pleased? God has emotions? How do you know this?
Again, I don’t comprehend what you mean by “irrational behavior?” God can’t be irrational, humanity can as we are given the gifts of intellect and freewill, to prove that we Love God. God gives us emotions, some good, some not, but allows us free use of them, which is the primary tool of Satan to get us to sin. Satan cannot alter our freewill, but can and does take advantage of our emotions.

**God became human,

God died on the Cross, God Rose from the Dead = LOVE
Jesus wept over “The City” Luke 19:41 = Sorrow
Jesus demonstrated just anger John 2: 15 = Anger
Jesus feels joy Luke 15:7 = Joy**

Yes Jesus was and is true man (humanity) and True God (Divinity.)
  • what kind of existence will we have in heaven? Memories? Our existing psychological traits/characteristics? Sensory capabilities?
In comprehensible and total joy, happiness and peace because we will be in the Very Presence of God, but not face to face until the Final Judgement we will be ‘spirits” as is God. We can know all that is good, nothing that is not. At the Second and Final Judgement, we will, like the Angels know God face to face and finally be able to understand the Mind of God.” Our only purpose for being in Heaven to Love, Honor, and Praise God. And in these acts we will find complete satisfaction, joy and peace.
  • why is it that we are not allowed to have direct, full knowledge of God because that would take away our free will? Yet the angels have full knowledge **and **free will.
Yes. Even God “cannot” take away our freewill as that is His plan for us to prove that we Love Him.
All these questions and many more have been posted here (some by me) and in the end there is no final answer, except to say that it’s a mystery.
My dear friend in Christ, there indeed is a final answer, There has to be, because their is only One Truth for every question. And this we can know, because God has to be all-just.
 
… continued
Originally Posted by anon5216
One passage of these ancient writings being convincingly shown to be divinely inspired does not in any way prove that other passages from other writers (or even the same writer at a different time) were also divinely inspired.
 
I think the greatest weaknesses are seen when atheists/agnostics ask questions that involve the* mind of God* or God’s plan. When they post those kinds of questions here at CAF, they will inevitably get one of two answers; 1) it’s a mystery, 2) I’ll pray for you. Both of which are non-answers.

Some examples of these types of questions:
  • theodicy: 1)what purpose do natural disasters that kill hundreds of thousand of people serve? 2)What part in God’s plan do genetic and congenital birth defects serve?
  • 3)why did God wait so long in evolutionary history before revealing Himself in the person of Jesus? 4)What about all the other hominids who lived in the preceding 500,000 years?
  • 5)why does God demand faith in the supernatural as the only means of salvation? 6)Why does this irrational behaviour please Him? 7)God can be pleased? 8)God has emotions? 9)How do you know this?
  • 10)what kind of existence will we have in heaven? Memories? Our existing psychological traits/characteristics? Sensory capabilities?
-11) why is it that we are not allowed to have direct, full knowledge of God because that would take away our free will? Yet the angels have full knowledge **and **free will.

All these questions and many more have been posted here (some by me) and in the end there is no final answer, except to say that it’s a mystery.
I have numbered your questions to make responding easier.

1 and 2) I’m not sure everything that happens is something we can say is purposefully done by God. God allows these sorts of natural harmful events occur this is true. God created a world were we can act freely and without duress. God created a world with natural laws that we can predict through science. This allows us to develop our intellect and due science. There are many good things that come from this - including science. Natural disasters and birth defects are simply these scientific laws in motion. You may be convinced God was wrong for giving us these reliable laws of nature but I hope you would at least be open to the possibility he sees some good in this sort of universe. Your complaint is basically why doesn’t God constantly step in and miraculously stopping hurricanes tidal waves and other effects of scientific laws? Well if God was constantly doing this it would be a completely unpredictable world. You may think “If I were God I would do it different. To heck with science and regularity in the workings of creation.” I think this way sometimes myself - believe me. But in the end I can at least step back and say Ok it does make some sense to have predicable laws of science in the world. It does allow us in some ways to develop and reveal who we are without a completely chaotic environment with God constantly stepping and changing things.
  1. Do you think he waited so long or revealed himself too early? I mean I don’t understand why you would think one over the other?
  2. We don’t know what happens in the afterlife that is true. I suppose that is somewhat mysterious but of course that is a mystery to everyone not just believers. Christians at least believe God will judge them justly and all mouths will be closed.
  3. It is only by believing in God and supernatural that morality makes any sense. The natural world and the natural science will not give you understanding of moral codes (no matter how many electrons we accelerate) To rationally believe we have reliable information about morality we do need to believe in the supernatural.
  4. Its not irrational. Indeed I believe it’s the only rational way to live a moral life but that is another matter. Belief in God is pleasing to him for among other reasons because it leads us to acting morally and that is pleasing to him because he loves us.
  5. Clearly the bible is giving us information about the mind of God and trying to use our language (or Greek or Hebrew) to approximate what is meant. So we understand that God can be something that is close to pleased.  I’m not sure why this is a problem.
  6. I suppose
  7. See 7.
  8. Paul says we can’t really imagine it but also see number 4 above. Why pick on only the religious for not knowing the afterlife? No one knows what it holds or what it is like.
  9. I forgot the differences between us and Angels. But I think we have some things angels lack. I just can’t remember everything.
Final Answer? No your right we all need to keep searching for God what he is like and what he has planned for us.
 
God cannot commit “murder” or “genocide” because He is the only one of His species. As our Creator, He is well within His rights to destroy any part of His creation that does not attain to His standards - including us.
 
1 and 2) I’m not sure everything that happens is something we can say is purposefully done by God. God allows these sorts of natural harmful events occur this is true. God created a world were we can act freely and without duress. God created a world with natural laws that we can predict through science. Natural disasters and birth defects are simply these scientific laws in motion. You may be convinced God was wrong for giving us these reliable laws of nature but I hope you would at least be open to the possibility he sees some good in this sort of universe. Your complaint is basically why doesn’t God constantly step in and miraculously stopping hurricanes tidal waves and other effects of scientific laws? Well if God was constantly doing this it would be a completely unpredictable world.
That sounds like a plausible way of looking at the problem. I read harpercollins.com/books/9780061173974/Gods_Problem/index.aspx and I don’t recall Bart Ehrman entertaining that solution.
  1. Do you think he waited so long or revealed himself too early? I mean I don’t understand why you would think one over the other?
Now that you rephrased it that way, I think maybe both. Of course that makes no sense, so I may have to withdraw this argument. On one hand I don’t see the reason for excluding all the humans born in the last 160,000 years. On the other, I think maybe now would have been a good time for revelation given the Information Age we live in. Hmm, it’s a dilemma.
 
I’m curious, will you in turn offer your opinion on where Catholic apologetics is strongest?
The reason for the delay was because it is a tough question, and there are many both-ands. Both the best and the worst people I have known have been Catholic. Both the most superstitious and the most atheistic people I have known have been Catholic. I had a high school teacher who was impressive, and a co-worker who was also, but there have been the loud beasts who have drowned out the quiet beauties. I There are mountains and valleys, both the admirable and the disgusting, and I will confess that I both am moved more and revolted more by my contacts with Catholicism than I am as a Presbyterian in my dealings with my fellow rebels traitors and material heretics… We are a foul crew, we are.

We see things differently, across this Tiber. One man’s calm statement of fact is a war cry to the other side. Those on CARM - and I spent some time on CARM DEFENDING Catholicism - think they are witnessing with Christ’s love to the heathen Catholics. I’ve gotten shot at both for defending the Catholic Church, and for attacking it. Straw man OP? To some. Spy? Is the phrase “separated brother” not in your vocabulary? I will give this thread some distance and see if I spoke too much last night. I get mad and say things. I am the only one who does, I suppose.

That doesn’t come close to an answer. Hmmm. You have a maddeningly thought out theological system, but the opposite pole of it is that no one seems to be able to express its depths. Paul said that the church at Corinth was an epistle and that he had written on their hearts. There is that, that unwritable letter, that is carried down in time, that one can whiff from time to time. It is not enough to call it Tradition. In tension with it is an intense carnality. There is the incarnation of the Gospel in the Church, but every Christian (and that includes Catholics) is a walking contradiction to it.

Possibly the Eucharist is the strongest apologetic argument. In those silent moments alone in the stillness of the church, when the candle wavers without wind like a beckoning finger. Perhaps that 's it, when we fumbling humans get out of the way, and allow God to speak. Our heads are full of theology but it is posters like puzzleannie who do the best job of conveying it. “Preach always…when necessary, use words.” Great line.

Catholic apologetics greatest strength? I think it would take someone a lot better than I am to say what that is. You can see that all I can do is fumble about it.
 
The reason for the delay was because it is a tough question, and there are many both-ands. Both the best and the worst people I have known have been Catholic.
Jesus said something to the effect of, “Be hot, or be cold, But do not be lukewarm. I will spew out the lukewarm.” 🙂
 
God cannot commit “murder” or “genocide” because He is the only one of His species. As our Creator, He is well within His rights to destroy any part of His creation that does not attain to His standards - including us.
That is a complete non-answer.

Nowhere in my posts did I refer to God committing murder or genocide.
Nowhere did I refer to God destroying any part of His creation - including us.

I referred to the old testament books claiming God sanctioned humans to commit genocide against other humans.

I am suggesting those humans made claims that weren’t true.
i.e. The support of God was either a lie (as humans throughout history have done to support their heinous actions), or the being who gave them those instructions via supernatural means was neither God nor one of his faithful Angels.

If you or anyone else would care to respond to the real issues I raised, I’d be interested.
 
The lack of patience, wisdom, and endurance to soften and penetrate the hardened hearts of those who have been immersed in false doctrine, half truths, and improper translations of scripture, would be the biggest weakness.

For me personally when I feel that I have failed to bring a person closer to the Catholic perspective often times I realize that even though that person doesn’t get it, that by the experience the Holy Spirit was working through that person to help me gain knowledge and grow deeper in my own faith so was there really failure… no.

So Truthstalker if you want use this against me be my guest.

If I may quote from two of my favorite Pat Benetar songs:

" Hit me with your best shot" because " I believe there comes a time when everything just falls in line, we live and learn from our mistakes the deepest cuts are healed by"…Faith.

I’m ready to let you help me grow.

May God bless and protect us,
JLC
 
Catholics,

Where do you see apologetics for the Catholic Church being weakest? Bear in mind that this is being asked by someone who you have every possible reason to believe will use those weaknesses against you, and he is not alone.
Catholic apologetics are weak. This is so because Catholic apologetics are arguing to defend the Roman Catholic Church instead of building a case to bring people to Christ.

Catholics are very weak on Christian evangelism. They are focused on evangelizing the Catholic Church and say very little about Christ. Instead many times you hear elaborate apologies for Marian devotions or devotions to saints or why the Roman Church has authority.

This is an enormous weakness and is why the Protestants far outdo the Catholics in Evangelizing the lost. The Protestants focus on Christ. The Catholics focus on their Church.
 
Where do you see apologetics for the Catholic Church being weakest?
Poorly catechized Catholics and angry ex-Catholics who cause people to get the notion that we believe all sorts of things that we actually don’t.
 
That is a complete non-answer.

Nowhere in my posts did I refer to God committing murder or genocide.
Nowhere did I refer to God destroying any part of His creation - including us.

I referred to the old testament books claiming God sanctioned humans to commit genocide against other humans.

I am suggesting those humans made claims that weren’t true.
i.e. The support of God was either a lie (as humans throughout history have done to support their heinous actions), or the being who gave them those instructions via supernatural means was neither God nor one of his faithful Angels.

If you or anyone else would care to respond to the real issues I raised, I’d be interested.
Why not? Just as God Himself isn’t bound by His commandments, neither is He bound to bind us to them, so to speak.

He is every bit as free to dispense us from them at times as He is to impose them upon us in the first place, if His purpose is served by doing either. 🤷

So why, in order to achieve His purpose of destroying these idolatrous tribes, could He not dispense the Israelites from the commandment not to murder, and order them TO kill (in circumstances that ordinarily would be murder - I don’t think you can call killing in God’s service and at His express command ‘murder’ precisely, any more than you can call killing in self defence or any other justifiable killing murder).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top