Catholic Apologetics Greatest Weaknesses

  • Thread starter Thread starter Truthstalker
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Why not? Just as God Himself isn’t bound by His commandments, neither is He bound to bind us to them, so to speak.

He is every bit as free to dispense us from them at times as He is to impose them upon us in the first place, if His purpose is served by doing either. 🤷

So why, in order to achieve His purpose of destroying these idolatrous tribes, could He not dispense the Israelites from the commandment not to murder, and order them TO kill (in circumstances that ordinarily would be murder - I don’t think you can call killing in God’s service and at His express command ‘murder’ precisely, any more than you can call killing in self defence or any other justifiable killing murder).
God could have easily dispensed with “the wicked” directly Himself, or simply waited for nature’s end of their lives and placed them where He found appropriate.

Do you realize just how many people have been murdered in the name of “God’s service” over the aeons? Do you really believe these murders were all justified? Or at least the murders committed by the Jews and Christians? If not all the Jewish and Christian murders done in God’s name, then how would you determine just which sets of murders were sanctioned properly by God? I am including here, state sponsored murders such as in the context of war, as well.

Sorry, but your response is just the standard “cop out” answer. This issue needs much more thorough and deep reflection, with the admittance of the possibility my premise is correct and those parts of the Bible sanctioning murder should not be considered sacred writings in any way. This is not because it is my personal premise - I’m by no means the only person thinking along these lines. Church theologians would have to admit to this premise as a possible reality to do any kind of thorough discussion, since starting from the inerrancy position for the writings in question guarantees the type of conclusion you present.

You may answer that the Church did this already when they compiled the collection of writings known as the Bible, but that was not a group of infallible beings and they made their decisions at a time when warring and wiping out the loser was kind of a human norm.

Claiming infallibility and inerrancy for the fallible humans and texts they wrote or compiled is also a non-answer. Although I would agree a necessary work-around to cover for the obvious contradictions in the accepted texts.

Please keep in mind, I’m not presenting this position as a way to destroy anyone’s faith.

I do believe there is Truth within Christianity and Judaism.
Even a grain of Truth can support a whole lot of nonsense that may get attached to it.

I believe that the many writings considered as sacred parts of the Bible were corrupted and distorted by sometimes outright evil, and that Christianity would be a thousand times more effective if the falsehoods were stripped away.
 
God could have easily dispensed with “the wicked” directly Himself, or simply waited for nature’s end of their lives and placed them where He found appropriate.

Do you realize just how many people have been murdered in the name of “God’s service” over the aeons? Do you really believe these murders were all justified? Or at least the murders committed by the Jews and Christians? If not all the Jewish and Christian murders done in God’s name, then how would you determine just which sets of murders were sanctioned properly by God? I am including here, state sponsored murders such as in the context of war, as well.
Yes He could. And God could create every individual human being Himself instantly and out of thin air, instead of allowing the parents a look in, and could zap all our food into existence for us without all the tedium of us having to work to obtain money to buy it, or else grow it ourselves. But like any good boss, He knows people like to feel useful, and like any parent He knows it’s not good for us to have everything done for us or handed to us without any effort. So He delegates and He makes us work. 🤷
 
Yes He could. And God could create every individual human being Himself instantly and out of thin air, instead of allowing the parents a look in, and could zap all our food into existence for us without all the tedium of us having to work to obtain money to buy it, or else grow it ourselves. But like any good boss, He knows people like to feel useful, and like any parent He knows it’s not good for us to have everything done for us or handed to us without any effort. So He delegates and He makes us work. 🤷
And you honestly feel that committing genocide against other human beings can make you personally feel useful to God. And that this work should be done by us so as not to feel God does everything for us without any effort.

Pulling a trigger and ending a life is not “useful work”.
Creating beneficial things and transforming life in a positive manner is spiritually useful work.

The concept of murder in the name of God is sick,
if not altogether blasphemous.
 
Pulling a trigger and ending a life is not “useful work”.
So soldiers who are preventing enemies from invading your country and killing you, who are in fact defending you at the cost of many of their own lives, aren’t doing useful work?

A policeman who prevents an attack on your child by killing their would-be attacker isn’t doing useful work?

Those who executed Saddam Hussein as permissible and just punishment for his crimes weren’t doing useful work?

Well I’ll let your local police and your country’s military know your views. I’m sure they’ll be happy to know that there’s at least one person they need not bother defending since the idea of it is so repugnant to you.
Creating beneficial things and transforming life in a positive manner is spiritually useful work.
And eliminating idol-worshipping, child-and-adult-human-sacrificing pagans would have absolutely no spiritual use from the point of view of the God who created them and who they are sinning against with their idolatry and THEIR murder?

Heck, it possibly had practical value in terms of saving the lives of those they would have sacrificed to their false gods. Kind of like executing an unrepentant and unreformed murderer, or a Saddam Hussein, is fitting retribution for his crimes and possibly saves the lives of future victims.

You certainly can’t write a practical or spiritual cost-benefit analysis on the OT episode, it’s not in your job description.
The concept of murder in the name of God is sick,
if not altogether blasphemous.
Murder (illicit killing, which doesn’t include ALL killing) ‘in the name of God’? Absolutely.

Killing at God’s actual personal command? Neither sick nor blasphemous. Nothing God personally orders can be sick or blasphemous - who can God almighty possibly sin against or blaspheme against? In such a case they are merely His instruments, and He has every right to use what instruments He wants to accomplish any task He wishes, including that of the taking of life, which is His prerogative and something He does to each of us anyway.
 
…
Killing at God’s actual personal command?
And just how are you going to prove that the episodes described by the ancient jews in what is referred to as the Old Testament were “killings at God’s actual personal command”?

You can’t prove this. You have the circular arguments of infallibility and inerrancy, but these are not valid and never provable.

All you have is “I wanna believe this and so and so with a nice fancy religious title told me that not only can I believe it if I want, but I’m required to believe it”.

Neither sick nor blasphemous.
Wrong.

Nothing God personally orders can be sick or blasphemous - who can God almighty possibly sin against or blaspheme against?
“God personally orders.” Not verifiable. Not provable.
The things we’re discussing are not consistent with the teachings of Jesus.

In such a case they are merely His instruments, and He has every right to use what instruments He wants to accomplish any task He wishes, including that of the taking of life, which is His prerogative and something He does to each of us anyway.
This may be consistent with a fallen angel’s modus operandi, but it’s a very anthropomorphic view of God.
btw, you never really addressed any of the following questions:
Do you realize just how many people have been murdered in the name of “God’s service” over the aeons? Do you really believe these murders were all justified? Or at least the murders committed by the Jews and Christians? If not all the Jewish and Christian murders done in God’s name, then how would you determine just which sets of murders were sanctioned properly by God?

You have your beliefs, I have mine. Truth is Truth regardless.
 
btw, you never really addressed any of the following questions:
Do you realize just how many people have been murdered in the name of “God’s service” over the aeons? Do you really believe these murders were all justified? Or at least the murders committed by the Jews and Christians? If not all the Jewish and Christian murders done in God’s name, then how would you determine just which sets of murders were sanctioned properly by God?

You have your beliefs, I have mine. Truth is Truth regardless.
You believe plenty of things that aren’t provable. How can you ‘prove’ that your spouse and children love you? That life arrived at its current forms by evolution? That your car will start tomorrow? That WWIII won’t start tonight? Mere lack of deductive provability doesn’t make a belief wrong, although it makes it founded on great or partial faith rather than deductive certainty. Only deductive provability of a proposition that can’t coexist with what you believe makes your belief wrong.

As to your questions. For starters, apart from the instances in the Bible, I know of no Christians, Jews or Muslims who have ever claimed personal revelation from God instructing them to kill any particular person or class of people. So the issue of these later killings being at the personal and direct command of God doesn’t even arise. That’s a whole huge swathe of 'em eliminated, if not all.

And for the rest - I trust God’s word, the Bible. I believe it when it tells me that God said ‘thou shalt not steal’ or ‘thou shalt not commit adultery’, so there’s no reason to not believe it when it says that God ordered these killings. 🤷

For any outside the Bible - well, only the killers and God can really judge those. Since they’d be against the civil law in any case, the civil law can take its course and punish them regardless, and there’s no moral dilemma raised by its doing so. Otherwise it’s not my concern.

And speaking of unanswered questions - do you seriously believe that the work done by soldiers defending your country, policemen defending your life and property, or the executioners inflicting just and proportionate punishment upon the mass-murderer Saddam Hussein, isn’t useful? Even though that involves killing? Sometimes killing LOTS of people?
 
…

And speaking of unanswered questions - do you seriously believe that the work done by soldiers defending your country, policemen defending your life and property, or the executioners inflicting just and proportionate punishment upon the mass-murderer Saddam Hussein, isn’t useful? Even though that involves killing? Sometimes killing LOTS of people?
Soldiers aren’t always defending one’s country. Obviously only one of the countries involved is doing the defending. The other country’s soldiers and civilians are being fed that line to get them compliant.

Saddam Hussein was evil. Yes. However, the American invasion and occupation has resulted in far more deaths of civilian Iraqis than Saddam had caused. There was likely a far better way to remove him from power - starting way back when he was a pseudo ally and the American government was busy supporting him and selling him weapons. Of course we also sold weapons to Iran at the same time. Not quite so black and white as you present.

Believe what you want. Truth is Truth regardless.
 
Soldiers aren’t always defending one’s country. Obviously only one of the countries involved is doing the defending. The other country’s soldiers and civilians are being fed that line to get them compliant.
I never said that every action soldiers do is justified, just that at least some of their killings are, contrary to your earlier post, in fact useful.
Saddam Hussein was evil. Yes. However, the American invasion and occupation has resulted in far more deaths of civilian Iraqis than Saddam had caused. There was likely a far better way to remove him from power - starting way back when he was a pseudo ally and the American government was busy supporting him and selling him weapons. Of course we also sold weapons to Iran at the same time. Not quite so black and white as you present.
There may well have been better ways of achieving the desired result, but by the time of his capture those weren’t options any more. The most ‘useful’ thing to do, then, or one of the most ‘useful’ things, was to execute him.
Believe what you want. Truth is Truth regardless.
Well, we’ll just have to agree to disagree on which of our respective beliefs is Truth then.
 
OK, then if not God, who? And why?
There are other entities referenced in these ancient writings that are acknowledged as being interested in influencing human behavior in very deceptive ways.
I have yet to be convinced that the various ancient Jews who related these stories were all qualified to properly discriminate the sources of supernatural communications. Not to mention be honest about them. The concept of falsely claiming “God is on my side and He told me / sanctioned my ____________________…” is by no means a recent invention.
That concern my friend is precisely why the Bible is, and was Inspired by God!
It is precisely why the texts written by those people cannot be trusted.
My friend, God inspired His Holy Book, the Catholic Bible. He is on my side, and will too be on your side, if you only: “be still and Know!”
This is a belief only “proven” to believers. Be still and know does apply to everyone.
Perhaps my dear friend, this is because you woun’t let go of your obstinence?
The same could be, and is said of the Catholic position.
Perhaps, it is because God is not yet ready to enlighten you?
That is between you and God, but know that your in my prayers!
As you will be in mine.
Either the Entire Bible is TRUE, or NONE of the Bible is TRUE
This claim is patently nonsense. It is a collection of writings that was written over many generations by fallible humans and defined as a single collection by other fallible humans. Asserting this claim in large, bold, deep red lettering doesn’t make it true.
Quote:
The contortions theologians have to go through to reconcile certain old testament stories are stretched beyond believability to any outside objective observer who hasn’t already bought into the “single, unified, inerrant structure of the Bible” concept.
Friend, the Bible is filled with countless “unbelievable” accounts in both the Old and the New Testamants… Which is why God shares with us the following.
I am not referring to miraculous positive things. I am referring to “Godly” support of ungodly behavior.
"Isaiah 55: 9: "6"Seek the LORD while he may be found, call upon him while he is near; 7 let the wicked forsake his way, and the unrighteous man his thoughts; let him return to the LORD, that he may have mercy on him, and to our God, for he will abundantly pardon. 8 For my thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways, says the LORD. 9 For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are my ways higher than your ways and my thoughts than your thoughts.
Genocide is definitely within the ways and thoughts of humans.
Why do you insist God also thinks and deals in this way?
One cannot be a Christian without faith, Hope and Love.
So where does “God” sanctioned genocide fit in with this statement?
John Chapter 10: "25 Jesus answered them, “I told you, and you do not believe. The works that I do in my Father’s name, they bear witness to me; 26* but you do not believe, because you do not belong to my sheep. 27 My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me;”
Where does Jesus sanction genocide?
John 20:"28 Thomas answered him, “My Lord and my God!” 29* Jesus said to him, “Have you believed because you have seen me? Blessed are those who have not seen and yet believe.”

And how does this quote validate “God” sanctioned genocide?
continued…

May God bless you (and your circle of family, friends and acquaintances) in His own way with ever transcending spiritual growth, far beyond anything you or I or any religious authority can imagine.
My Dear friend,

I can look in the mirror and talk to myself, so know that your in my prayers.

Have agreat life:shrug:
 
The reason for the delay was because it is a tough question, and there are many both-ands. Both the best and the worst people I have known have been Catholic. Both the most superstitious and the most atheistic people I have known have been Catholic. I had a high school teacher who was impressive, and a co-worker who was also, but there have been the loud beasts who have drowned out the quiet beauties. I There are mountains and valleys, both the admirable and the disgusting, and I will confess that I both am moved more and revolted more by my contacts with Catholicism than I am as a Presbyterian in my dealings with my fellow rebels traitors and material heretics… We are a foul crew, we are.

We see things differently, across this Tiber. One man’s calm statement of fact is a war cry to the other side. Those on CARM - and I spent some time on CARM DEFENDING Catholicism - think they are witnessing with Christ’s love to the heathen Catholics. I’ve gotten shot at both for defending the Catholic Church, and for attacking it. Straw man OP? To some. Spy? Is the phrase “separated brother” not in your vocabulary? I will give this thread some distance and see if I spoke too much last night. I get mad and say things. I am the only one who does, I suppose.

That doesn’t come close to an answer. Hmmm. You have a maddeningly thought out theological system, but the opposite pole of it is that no one seems to be able to express its depths. Paul said that the church at Corinth was an epistle and that he had written on their hearts. There is that, that unwritable letter, that is carried down in time, that one can whiff from time to time. It is not enough to call it Tradition. In tension with it is an intense carnality. There is the incarnation of the Gospel in the Church, but every Christian (and that includes Catholics) is a walking contradiction to it.

Possibly the Eucharist is the strongest apologetic argument. In those silent moments alone in the stillness of the church, when the candle wavers without wind like a beckoning finger. Perhaps that 's it, when we fumbling humans get out of the way, and allow God to speak. Our heads are full of theology but it is posters like puzzleannie who do the best job of conveying it. “Preach always…when necessary, use words.” Great line.

Catholic apologetics greatest strength? I think it would take someone a lot better than I am to say what that is. You can see that all I can do is fumble about it.
Actually TS, I think you’ve said things pretty well here. The depth of what is written on the heart is nearly impossible to communicate coherently. We humans - All of us - with our puny words and worldy eyes can only hint at the Glory that is God’s Love for his Children.

Thank you for your “fumbling”. To me it is beautiful.

Peace
James
 
Catholic apologetics are weak. This is so because Catholic apologetics are arguing to defend the Roman Catholic Church instead of building a case to bring people to Christ.

Catholics are very weak on Christian evangelism. They are focused on evangelizing the Catholic Church and say very little about Christ. Instead many times you hear elaborate apologies for Marian devotions or devotions to saints or why the Roman Church has authority.

This is an enormous weakness and is why the Protestants far outdo the Catholics in Evangelizing the lost. The Protestants focus on Christ. The Catholics focus on their Church.
My, what unfamiliarity with argumentation, logic, and reasoning we see here.
  1. Catholic apologetics are weak.
  2. This is so because Catholic apologetics are arguing to defend the Roman Catholic Church instead of building a case to bring people to Christ.
Can you spot the fallacy here?

Correct—it places Christ at one pole and the Church he founded, promised to abide within, and promised the gates of Hell would not prevail against at the other. Becoming Catholic brings people to Christ in the most literal sense possible—thanks to the Blessed Sacrament, the Body and Blood of Christ.
  1. Catholics are very weak on Christian evangelism.
  2. They are focused on evangelizing the Catholic Church and say very little about Christ.
  3. Instead many times you hear elaborate apologies for Marian devotions or devotions to saints or why the Roman Church has authority.
Aside from the complete lack of supporting evidence, what’s wrong with this argument?

Correct—the proponent has no idea what “evangelization” means. It means preaching the Gospel, spreading the good news. One cannot “evangelize” the Catholic Church and say “very little” about Christ, Christ being the focus of the Gospel and the foundation of the Church being Christ’s primary objective in the Gospel. Once again, the proponent has relied on extra-Scriptural tradition—anti-Catholic tradition—spoonfed to them by others to place Church and Christ in opposition, despite Christ’s explicit promises in Scripture. This simply does not compute.

This is sadly typical of Protestant apologists, who simply cannot:
  1. State clearly a proposition.
  2. Support it with historical, Scriptural, and statistical evidence.
  3. Draw logical conclusions from said evidence.
It is beyond the vast majority of them, which is why so much of what we see from them on these boards reduces to “Papist!”
 
My, what unfamiliarity with argumentation, logic, and reasoning QUOTE]

Just a personal observation. From my experience with Catholic apologetics, the basics of the gospel, who Christ is, what he did, why that is important, how to be saved from eternal damnation etc, are simply missing. Instead you get detailed apologies for things that simply don’t matter like devotions to Mary and the Saints, Indulgences, the Pope, why their communion is supposed to be better thatn the rest of Christianity, etc.

Catholics spend more time trying to convert other Christians to Catholicism than they do trying to convert the lost to Christianity!

So, what “Catholic” apologetics is missing is “Christian” evangelization in the vast majority of their topics.

You guys asked for weaknesses in it, that is where I see the weakness. If that bothers you then change it.

:ehh:
 
That sounds like a plausible way of looking at the problem. I read harpercollins.com/books/9780061173974/Gods_Problem/index.aspx and I don’t recall Bart Ehrman entertaining that solution.

Now that you rephrased it that way, I think maybe both. Of course that makes no sense, so I may have to withdraw this argument. On one hand I don’t see the reason for excluding all the humans born in the last 160,000 years. On the other, I think maybe now would have been a good time for revelation given the Information Age we live in. Hmm, it’s a dilemma.
Hi Redhen
I appreciate your honesty in looking at these issues. As for Bart Ehrman, I have not read that particular book. I do think dealing with the problem of evil is more of a philosophical issue than one a history professor should be answering. But I am quite familiar with Ehrman. I have taken all (or nearly all) of the classes he offered through the teaching company and read all (or nearly all) of the books he has available in audio format from audible.

One thing you should know about Ehrman is he is quick to point out contradictions and use terminology like - the bible has “many” inconsistencies and mistakes. But when it comes down to it there are only a few issues along these lines that have any real significance.

His background is that of a fundamentalist and in one book he describes how he struggled with the issue of whether a mustard seed might have actually been the smallest seed in the world at the time Christ described it as such. From a Catholic perspective such emphasis on trifling matters seems odd and is in fact tantamount to error in interpreting scripture. But anyway, as for that book from the introduction it appeared that he was saying the bible contradicts itself as to why there is evil. I suspect (just from reading the description of the book) he may again be a bit too quick to find contradictions. Perhaps God permits evil for many different reasons and just because each bible author does not always tell us all the reasons every time the issue comes up does not mean they contradict each other.

Don’t get me wrong I think it can be worthwhile to read what he says (especially since few others put out audio books or courses that deal with these sorts of factual issues) and I think he is honest. But he does have his own pet agendas. Well that is my two cents on Ehrman.

As for the second issue. This argument may have some more traction with certain non-catholic Christians. Some of them take their “faith in Jesus alone” doctrine to an extreme and often admit that many of those who lived before must be in hell. I think this doctrine does suggest some unfairness of God. However this is not what the Catholic Church teaches. The Church teaches that people who have not been exposed to the gospel still may hear God’s call in nature and seek him as best they can. God will account for this. To whom much is given much is expected. The Church basically takes these considerations into account and is therefore more hesitant than certain other Christian Churches to write off many people to hell. Hence the argument just doesn’t have as much weight against the Catholic faith.
 
Teflon93;4697072:
My, what unfamiliarity with argumentation, logic, and reasoning
Just a personal observation. From my experience with Catholic apologetics, the basics of the gospel, who Christ is, what he did, why that is important, how to be saved from eternal damnation etc, are simply missing. Instead you get detailed apologies for things that simply don’t matter like devotions to Mary and the Saints, Indulgences, the Pope, why their communion is supposed to be better thatn the rest of Christianity, etc.

Catholics spend more time trying to convert other Christians to Catholicism than they do trying to convert the lost to Christianity!

So, what “Catholic” apologetics is missing is “Christian” evangelization in the vast majority of their topics.

You guys asked for weaknesses in it, that is where I see the weakness. If that bothers you then change it.

:ehh:
You are actually revealing a perfect case here of what Catholic Apologists have to deal with - false dichotomies and preconceived ideas that all fall into the “strawman” category. These take an enormous amount of effort and time to slowly point out the many fallacies that are present.

For example within the short paragraphs you have condensed a large number of errors that can take days of back and forth dialog to correct and the chance of loosing the Protestant’s short term attention is very high…

List of Fallacies I see in the above:
  • The error of Easy Believism where the Bible message is not holistic and has just a couple of important core salvation slogans that one need be concerned with for salvation.
  • The error that repentance and penance are unnecessary since all one must do is “believe” and nothing else matters (another variant on Easy Believism)
  • The error that one can come to Christ without The Church - as if the two are disjoint and seperate.
  • That error that Christianity is somehow seperate from Catholics
  • Naked fundamentalism
It is the latter thing that is most difficult for Apologists to operate with since Apologetics assumes a channel of reason and intellect. We can only appeal to intellect and reason - in its absence apologetics is without a motive force. Apologetics can only be used to enlighten where there is a channel of reason.

Fortunately though Catholic apologetics is not the only tool that the Holy Spirit uses since it is limited to efficacy to only a mind that is open to truth and has the capacity for reason and logic. It is the power of prayer through the sacrament of The Church itself that is most effective for Catholics since that brings supernatural grace into the minds and hearts of those who are willing to know the truth. Thus Catholic Apologetics appeal to reason is only one avenue of approach to conversion to the Catholic faith.

A true Catholic Apologist is one who can successfully integrate force of reason with the greater force of prayer and grace to make a life changing point.

James
 
Just a personal observation.
Oh, well THAT changes everything.
From my experience with Catholic apologetics, the basics of the gospel, who Christ is, what he did, why that is important, how to be saved from eternal damnation etc, are simply missing.
You have no experience with Catholic apologetics, clearly. Feel free to browse this forum with abundant Catholic apologetics on the very topic.

Meanwhile, consider the words of Luther in my signature. You would know nothing of Christ nor Scripture but for the Catholic Church whence you learned of both.
Instead you get detailed apologies for things that simply don’t matter like devotions to Mary and the Saints, Indulgences, the Pope, why their communion is supposed to be better thatn the rest of Christianity, etc.
Because, you know, the mother of Christ doesn’t matter to Christ, nor do the many Christian martyrs, nor the Apostles, nor the great Christians like Mother Theresa and John Paul the Great, nor does obeying Christ’s commands, as in John 6.

All on your authority.
Catholics spend more time trying to convert other Christians to Catholicism than they do trying to convert the lost to Christianity!
Wow, are you ignorant of Church history?

What do you think the Jesuits were about? Why do you think Brazil and many other places were Catholic long before the Protestant megachurches discovered a world outside the United States?
So, what “Catholic” apologetics is missing is “Christian” evangelization in the vast majority of their topics.
We’re apparently also missing the need for “scare” quotes, the heralds of the snide.
You guys asked for weaknesses in it, that is where I see the weakness. If that bothers you then change it.
Yes, we shall. Because YOU said so. 🤷
 
btw, you never really addressed any of the following questions:
  1. Do you realize just how many people have been murdered in the name of “God’s service” over the aeons? 2) Do you really believe these murders were all justified? 3) Or at least the murders committed by the Jews and Christians? 4) If not all the Jewish and Christian murders done in God’s name, then how would you determine just which sets of murders were sanctioned properly by God?
You have your beliefs, I have mine. Truth is Truth regardless.
I have numbered your questiosn so its easier to respond.
  1. Short answer: No.
    Long answer: I’m not sure what an aeon is, but I suppose you mean something like since humanity existed. No one can come to know that since we don’t any written records for much of that time. We may be able to see some ribs had arrow heads in them but we wouldn’t know it was a murder done in the name of God. We wouldn’t even know it was a murder – as opposed to self defense or death due to war etc. Moreover I don’t think what you ask is something that you “realize” I think it’s something that you might try to “find out” but I think the prospects are dim.
  2. No murders are justified or they wouldn’t be murders. Murder is defined as the unjustified killing of a human.
  3. No their murders by definition would be unjustified killings.
  4. Ok at this point I think you can see that claiming to have a justified murder is an oxymoron. So I think you mean how do we determine just which killings were sanctioned properly by God. I am sorry to say there is no simple minded way to do this. One would have to take each killing and consider it on an individual basis.
 
I have numbered your questiosn so its easier to respond.
  1. Short answer: No.
    Long answer: I’m not sure what an aeon is, but I suppose you mean something like since humanity existed. No one can come to know that since we don’t any written records for much of that time. We may be able to see some ribs had arrow heads in them but we wouldn’t know it was a murder done in the name of God. We wouldn’t even know it was a murder – as opposed to self defense or death due to war etc. Moreover I don’t think what you ask is something that you “realize” I think it’s something that you might try to “find out” but I think the prospects are dim.
  2. No murders are justified or they wouldn’t be murders. Murder is defined as the unjustified killing of a human.
  3. No their murders by definition would be unjustified killings.
  4. Ok at this point I think you can see that claiming to have a justified murder is an oxymoron. So I think you mean how do we determine just which killings were sanctioned properly by God. I am sorry to say there is no simple minded way to do this. One would have to take each killing and consider it on an individual basis.
Can all you guys talking OT scripture please kindly spin off a new thread - you are way out in the weeds from the original OP and cluttering up the discussion. This is about apologetics.

Thanks,
James
 
Can all you guys talking OT scripture please kindly spin off a new thread - you are way out in the weeds from the original OP and cluttering up the discussion. This is about apologetics.

Thanks,
James
We are discussing apologetics and what is believed to be the greatest weakness in the Catholic Church’s apologetics.

I think you might assume that the catholic apologist’s greatest weakness has something to do with defending the faith against Protestants. I and others in this thread are simply disagreeing with your assumption. I think the bigger challenges clearly come from defending the faith against the Orthodox religion and from atheism or agnosticism. I might suggest you are so focused on issues with Protestants that you fail to recognize “apologetics” means much more than that rather narrow interest.

Thanks

Joe
 
This is a false dichotomy.
Indeed, even if one rejects the theological message of the Bible, it’s still useful for historical information, as Biblical archaelogists continue to demonstrate to secular dismay.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top