A
anon5216
Guest
God could have easily dispensed with “the wicked” directly Himself, or simply waited for nature’s end of their lives and placed them where He found appropriate.Why not? Just as God Himself isn’t bound by His commandments, neither is He bound to bind us to them, so to speak.
He is every bit as free to dispense us from them at times as He is to impose them upon us in the first place, if His purpose is served by doing either.
So why, in order to achieve His purpose of destroying these idolatrous tribes, could He not dispense the Israelites from the commandment not to murder, and order them TO kill (in circumstances that ordinarily would be murder - I don’t think you can call killing in God’s service and at His express command ‘murder’ precisely, any more than you can call killing in self defence or any other justifiable killing murder).
Do you realize just how many people have been murdered in the name of “God’s service” over the aeons? Do you really believe these murders were all justified? Or at least the murders committed by the Jews and Christians? If not all the Jewish and Christian murders done in God’s name, then how would you determine just which sets of murders were sanctioned properly by God? I am including here, state sponsored murders such as in the context of war, as well.
Sorry, but your response is just the standard “cop out” answer. This issue needs much more thorough and deep reflection, with the admittance of the possibility my premise is correct and those parts of the Bible sanctioning murder should not be considered sacred writings in any way. This is not because it is my personal premise - I’m by no means the only person thinking along these lines. Church theologians would have to admit to this premise as a possible reality to do any kind of thorough discussion, since starting from the inerrancy position for the writings in question guarantees the type of conclusion you present.
You may answer that the Church did this already when they compiled the collection of writings known as the Bible, but that was not a group of infallible beings and they made their decisions at a time when warring and wiping out the loser was kind of a human norm.
Claiming infallibility and inerrancy for the fallible humans and texts they wrote or compiled is also a non-answer. Although I would agree a necessary work-around to cover for the obvious contradictions in the accepted texts.
Please keep in mind, I’m not presenting this position as a way to destroy anyone’s faith.
I do believe there is Truth within Christianity and Judaism.
Even a grain of Truth can support a whole lot of nonsense that may get attached to it.
I believe that the many writings considered as sacred parts of the Bible were corrupted and distorted by sometimes outright evil, and that Christianity would be a thousand times more effective if the falsehoods were stripped away.