P
Portrait
Guest
Dear grannymh,The issue for ordinary folk is not necessarily that a “program” e.g. the Catholic Charismatic Renewal be affirmed by doctrine or de fide. The basic issue is that the “program” be recognized as being in keeping with Catholic doctrines.
Discerning that a “program” such as the Catholic Charismatic Renewal is in keeping with Catholicism does not imply that one has to accept it. What is implied is that one may choose to accept it.
Would that be a fair, brief summary of your position?
If you would kindly go back to my post 27, the section where I refer to the public concerns of the Bishops in the early years of the Renewal, you will find that those in charge of protecting the Faith, did evaluate the Catholic Charismatic Renewal.
Snip/
Cordial greetings and a very good day. Thankyou for your response.
If, dear friend, the CCR is a genuine movement of God in our times then it ought surely to be enthusiastically embraced by all the faithful as it will greatly enrich their spiritual lives. Thus assuming it was genuine, it would be sheer folly and, indeed, disobedience to “choose” not to be a part of it. However, the key issue to be decided is whether or not it is a genuine movement of God’s Spirit and not some counterfeit phenomena, possibly inspired by Satanic activity.
With respect to the appraisal of this movement since its inception, the quasi-official ‘studies’ by the National Conference of Catholic Bishops have never been accepted by that body as official positions. On the contrary, they have merely been accepted as “pastoral guidelines” for the individual dioceses.
The conclusion of the 1969 report recommends allowing the movement to develop under episcopal supervision and with priestly participation. What is interesting to observe, dear friend, is that the bishops accept without argument one of the most glaringly dangerous assumptions of the CCR. This is that the charismatic phenomena in our midst today, which resemble the descriptions of the charismata in the New Testament, are the true charismata, simply by virtue of this resemblance. Moreover, there is also the tacit assumption that the Holy Spirit is the author of the current manifestations, simply by virtue of the fact that he was the author of the genuine charismata in the early days of Christianity. Unfortunately, they entirely discount the possibilty that these extraordinary phenomena (which the CCR is labouring to make ordinary) could well be deceptions of the Devil, who is a past master at counterfeiting - “…even Satan disguises himself as an angel of light. So it is not strange if his servants also disguise themselves as servants of righteousness” (II Cor. 11: 14). Satan is most hurtful to the Church when he opposes it by subtlety and creeping and when he comes not as an open enemy, appearing as a friend to religion. He is never so much a devil, as when he appears in white and transforms himself into an angel of light. False apostles and seducers in the Church have been more harmful to it by fraud, than all the pagan persecutions.
In 1975 in America the US Bishops issued a “Statement on the Charismatic Renewal”, which characterised itself as “pastoral in tone and content” and “not an exhaustive treatment” This document sounds a note of warning and acknowledges some of the dangers inherent in the movement, namely, elitism, biblical fundamentalism, exaggeration of the importance of the charismata, reckless ecumenism and the so called small faith communities. What is most interesting, dear friend, is that the bishops specifically do not commit themselves to say that the CCR is a genuine work of the Holy Spirit, although they do admit to encouraging signs of this in some quarters.
It is undeniable that extraordinary manifestations did occur in the early days of our most holy religion, but it is equally undeniable that these extraordinary phenomena dwindled considerably and disappeared after the apostolic age. The Church had by that time achieved a moral universality and was firmly established in such a way that these manifestations were no longer either useful or necessary. It is really as simple as that.
As for glossolalia or tongues speaking, dear friend, this gift was given to enable the Gospel to be preached to everyone in attendance regardless of his language. Thus the ‘tongues’ were ordinary earthly languages and not ecstatic utterences as is often claimed by those in the CCR. Prophecies, healing and miracles etc., were given to verify the claims of the Church and to foster conversions in a world where there were “lord’s many”. However, as I remarked in the preceding paragraph, when the Church achieved moral universality, the need for such phenomena ceased for several reasons, but chiefly because of the Church’s proven record as the one true religion, jolly short though it was.
Now, dear friend, the very same argument can be made today against the true charismata’s presence within Holy Mother Church. Since the Church is now both morally and physically universal, containing within its bosom men and clergy of every nation, what need could there possibly be of glossolalia for the purposes of evangelisation? After all, the Church now has a 2000 year track record as the one true religion and so what further need has she to confirm her claims? As St. Augustine says:
“Whereas even now the Holy Ghost is received, yet no one speaks in the tongues of all nations, because the Church herself already speaks in the languages of all nations: since whoever is not in the Church, receives not the Holy Ghost”.
God bless.
Warmest good wishes,
Portrait
Pax