Catholic tongues advice

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dutch_H
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The issue for ordinary folk is not necessarily that a “program” e.g. the Catholic Charismatic Renewal be affirmed by doctrine or de fide. The basic issue is that the “program” be recognized as being in keeping with Catholic doctrines.

Discerning that a “program” such as the Catholic Charismatic Renewal is in keeping with Catholicism does not imply that one has to accept it. What is implied is that one may choose to accept it.
Would that be a fair, brief summary of your position?

If you would kindly go back to my post 27, the section where I refer to the public concerns of the Bishops in the early years of the Renewal, you will find that those in charge of protecting the Faith, did evaluate the Catholic Charismatic Renewal.

Snip/
Dear grannymh,

Cordial greetings and a very good day. Thankyou for your response.

If, dear friend, the CCR is a genuine movement of God in our times then it ought surely to be enthusiastically embraced by all the faithful as it will greatly enrich their spiritual lives. Thus assuming it was genuine, it would be sheer folly and, indeed, disobedience to “choose” not to be a part of it. However, the key issue to be decided is whether or not it is a genuine movement of God’s Spirit and not some counterfeit phenomena, possibly inspired by Satanic activity.

With respect to the appraisal of this movement since its inception, the quasi-official ‘studies’ by the National Conference of Catholic Bishops have never been accepted by that body as official positions. On the contrary, they have merely been accepted as “pastoral guidelines” for the individual dioceses.

The conclusion of the 1969 report recommends allowing the movement to develop under episcopal supervision and with priestly participation. What is interesting to observe, dear friend, is that the bishops accept without argument one of the most glaringly dangerous assumptions of the CCR. This is that the charismatic phenomena in our midst today, which resemble the descriptions of the charismata in the New Testament, are the true charismata, simply by virtue of this resemblance. Moreover, there is also the tacit assumption that the Holy Spirit is the author of the current manifestations, simply by virtue of the fact that he was the author of the genuine charismata in the early days of Christianity. Unfortunately, they entirely discount the possibilty that these extraordinary phenomena (which the CCR is labouring to make ordinary) could well be deceptions of the Devil, who is a past master at counterfeiting - “…even Satan disguises himself as an angel of light. So it is not strange if his servants also disguise themselves as servants of righteousness” (II Cor. 11: 14). Satan is most hurtful to the Church when he opposes it by subtlety and creeping and when he comes not as an open enemy, appearing as a friend to religion. He is never so much a devil, as when he appears in white and transforms himself into an angel of light. False apostles and seducers in the Church have been more harmful to it by fraud, than all the pagan persecutions.

In 1975 in America the US Bishops issued a “Statement on the Charismatic Renewal”, which characterised itself as “pastoral in tone and content” and “not an exhaustive treatment” This document sounds a note of warning and acknowledges some of the dangers inherent in the movement, namely, elitism, biblical fundamentalism, exaggeration of the importance of the charismata, reckless ecumenism and the so called small faith communities. What is most interesting, dear friend, is that the bishops specifically do not commit themselves to say that the CCR is a genuine work of the Holy Spirit, although they do admit to encouraging signs of this in some quarters.

It is undeniable that extraordinary manifestations did occur in the early days of our most holy religion, but it is equally undeniable that these extraordinary phenomena dwindled considerably and disappeared after the apostolic age. The Church had by that time achieved a moral universality and was firmly established in such a way that these manifestations were no longer either useful or necessary. It is really as simple as that.

As for glossolalia or tongues speaking, dear friend, this gift was given to enable the Gospel to be preached to everyone in attendance regardless of his language. Thus the ‘tongues’ were ordinary earthly languages and not ecstatic utterences as is often claimed by those in the CCR. Prophecies, healing and miracles etc., were given to verify the claims of the Church and to foster conversions in a world where there were “lord’s many”. However, as I remarked in the preceding paragraph, when the Church achieved moral universality, the need for such phenomena ceased for several reasons, but chiefly because of the Church’s proven record as the one true religion, jolly short though it was.

Now, dear friend, the very same argument can be made today against the true charismata’s presence within Holy Mother Church. Since the Church is now both morally and physically universal, containing within its bosom men and clergy of every nation, what need could there possibly be of glossolalia for the purposes of evangelisation? After all, the Church now has a 2000 year track record as the one true religion and so what further need has she to confirm her claims? As St. Augustine says:

“Whereas even now the Holy Ghost is received, yet no one speaks in the tongues of all nations, because the Church herself already speaks in the languages of all nations: since whoever is not in the Church, receives not the Holy Ghost”.

God bless.

Warmest good wishes,

Portrait

Pax
 
Portrait, I believe Grannymh asked you for specific citations, whereas you simply continue to promote your own opinions here. She has given excellent references that you obviously overlook, reject, and dismiss with utmost denial that has nothing to do with the Church’s teachings. It seems to be your own private interpretation, to which you may be entitled. The CCR is not for everybody, just as not everybody will adopt the same private devotions.

As I noted previously, you have a long-standing negative prejudice as evidenced in your 44 previous posts, so I don’t anticipate that you will change your mind or listen to anyone else.

How about answering her questions and providing the citations she asked you for?
 
Citations, please. 🙂

In the meantime, would you kindly share the most reasonable definition of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal and how “tongues” per OP fits in.

By the way, it is possible that the Catholic Church is getting ready for its biggest role yet in bringing humankind to God. I say this because as I try to understand your deepest meanings, I find myself thinking that for ordinary folk, the Catholic Charismatic Renewal is the best thing since sliced bread.😃

Just imagine the joy in one’s heart in being able to say Jesus is my Lord and Savior in the midst of our noisy secularism. Imagine the peace that comes with truly committing our very lives to God. Does this mean that everyone has to be a quote charismatic unquote? Of course not. It does mean that everyone has to renew their own spiritual life according to any of the marvelous Saints and of course Jesus Himself.

Imagine the joy of attending the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass during the week when able. Imagine the love of Mary, our Blessed Mother, as we pray her Rosary. This is the fruit of Renewal. It is the second Pentecost. And yes, there will be people gifted with the gifts of the first Pentecost. But what people are not realizing is that the gift of praying in Tongues is available to ordinary folk who freely choose to learn about that gift.

What is necessary is praying in whatever way is comfortable for the individual.

To understand how all the various forms of spirituality and good works fit together, one has to learn about the Mystical Body of Christ.
Dear grannymh,

Hello again and thankyou for your response above.

The CCR, which emerged on the scene in 1967, owes it origin to Protestant Fundamentalism, which in turn had become deeply influenced by the hippy-culture of those rebellious times. With the benefit of hindsight, dear friend, we can see how well the Charismatic movement fitted in with the milieu of that unhappy and confused era when men were busy, selfishly ‘doing their own thing’. Adapting this outlook to Protestant Christianity, which had tragically drifted away from historical and traditional norms, was not too difficult, especially when one takes into account the doctrinal/moral laxity that was then so prevalent. Protestantism was fertile ground for the growth of such heresy and very few stood against it or bothered to refute its untenable and wild claims, except for some orthodox traditional High-Church Anglican’s and ‘Reformed’ Protestants.

The CCR will not usher in spiritual revival within Holy Mother Church and those, dear friend, who expect it to do so will be sadly disappointed. Catholic Charismatic parishes have been among us now for somewhile and the long awaited world-wide revival has not yet appeared. Neither has the presence of the CCR resulted in a greater passion for the pursuit of true holiness and separation from the godless world, especially in the West. If anything, contemporary Catholics are opting for a sort of ‘Catholicism Lite’, to use George Weigel’s happy turn of phrase, and are increasingly adopting a hand in hand with the world type of religion which makes little or no demand upon them in terms of renunciation of questionable worldly pleasures. If any group are likely to spearhead spiritual revival within the Holy Mother Church, then it is those traditional groups who recognize that the entire course of this life is a state of probation, and that it is only by an earnest seeking after holiness that men will ever enjoy the beatific vision of God in Christ - “Strive for peace with all men, and for the holiness without which no one will see the Lord” (Heb. 12: 14).

Mankind, dear friend, requires a Church that will demonstrate that it is focused upon eternal verities and realities, not sensational showy manifestations. Individual Catholics must face up to the challenge of the call to sanctity and separation from the world and resolutely refuse to become distracted and demoralized by its ungodly influences. It is religion of this stamp that will usher in world-wide spiritual revival and sit up and make the world take notice, not a religion based upon emotional experiences and a shallow happy-clappy type of frivolty.

God bless.

Warmest good wishes,

Portrait

Pax
 
Dear grannymh,

Cordial greetings and a very good day. Thankyou for your response.

If, dear friend, the CCR is a genuine movement of God in our times then it ought surely to be enthusiastically embraced by all the faithful as it will greatly enrich their spiritual lives.
When reading this sentence, one needs to keep in mind that the Holy Spirit, as the Primary Giver, is not limited in any way regarding the who? what? when? where? why? of His gifts.

So, let us ask the what? What is the Catholic Charismatic Renewal? Yes, it can be considered a “movement”. But, let us go deeper and ask *what * is this movement? This movement is the Gift of a Pentecostal Renewal just like what its name [Renewal] implies.:doh2:

And yes, the power of the Holy Spirit to give the gift of a Pentecostal Renewal is substantiated in Chapter 14 of the Gospel of John. Futhermore, following in the footsteps of the First Pentecost, the Gift of a Pentecostal Renewal is meant for the Mystical Body of Christ, the Catholic Church.

It is a tad foolish to think that the Holy Spirit is limited by time and space when it comes to His personal love for all of us.

This is from post 40, first sentence.
If, dear friend, the CCR is a genuine movement of God in our times then it ought surely to be enthusiastically embraced by all the faithful as it will greatly enrich their spiritual lives.
Some common sense should be enough to show that the Holy Spirit’s Gift of a Pentecostal Renewal is not depended on being “enthusiastically embraced by all the faithful as it will greatly enrich their spiritual lives.”
 
Dear grannymh,

Hello again and thankyou for your response above.

The CCR, which emerged on the scene in 1967, owes it origin to Protestant Fundamentalism, which in turn had become deeply influenced by the hippy-culture of those rebellious times.
I know about Pentecostalism in the early 1900’s. So I am very interested in your Protestant Fundamentalism issue. Would you be so kind as to provide the sources of this information so I can further study the history of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal. Also, you do have my curiosity about the influence of the hippy-culture of those rebellious times. What is it that you are referring to?

Thank you for honoring my requests.

In the meantime,
would it be o.k. if I substituted “checking out the Pentecostal experience” in place of “owes its origin to Protestant Fundamentalism…” In 1967, there were people who saw a difference between “Pentecostalism” and mainline Protestant denominations. What have you discovered in this regard?

Those familiar with the beginning of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal are well aware of the “seeking” information from other religious peoples, including checking out the Pentecostalism experience. The public concerns of Bishops were front and center. Good thing.

Those familiar with those early years know that both Protestant and Pentecostal teachings were laid on the table along with Catholic teachings. It is here, that the charismatic renewal became truly Catholic within the Catholic Church.

In other words, the difference between Protestant/Pentecostal experiences and the Catholic Charismatic Renewal is the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass along with the seven Sacraments of grace throughout one’s entire life.
 
When reading this sentence, one needs to keep in mind that the Holy Spirit, as the Primary Giver, is not limited in any way regarding the who? what? when? where? why? of His gifts.

So, let us ask the what? What is the Catholic Charismatic Renewal? Yes, it can be considered a “movement”. But, let us go deeper and ask *what * is this movement? This movement is the Gift of a Pentecostal Renewal just like what its name [Renewal] implies.:doh2:

And yes, the power of the Holy Spirit to give the gift of a Pentecostal Renewal is substantiated in Chapter 14 of the Gospel of John. Futhermore, following in the footsteps of the First Pentecost, the Gift of a Pentecostal Renewal is meant for the Mystical Body of Christ, the Catholic Church.

It is a tad foolish to think that the Holy Spirit is limited by time and space when it comes to His personal love for all of us.

This is from post 40, first sentence.

Some common sense should be enough to show that the Holy Spirit’s Gift of a Pentecostal Renewal is not depended on being “enthusiastically embraced by all the faithful as it will greatly enrich their spiritual lives.”
Dear grannymh,

Cordial greetings and thankyou again for your reply to my post.

Of course, dear friend, the Holy Spirit is sovereign and can impart gifts to whom he will, assuming of course that those gifts are still being imparted. However, my point was that if the CCR movement is of divine origin, then clearly the faithful ought to be actively involved with it, as it will necessarily be an immense blessing to them, whatever the gift God chooses to impart to them or when he chooses to impart it. Nevertheless, what needs to be determined is whether it really is in truth a genuine movement of God in our times. For reasons I have explained in my previous posts, the evidence is decidedly against it being authentic. From a doctrinal standpoint the entire movement is in fundamental error inasmuch as it asserts that the “signs of an apostle” are the property of the Church today. The ‘sign gifts’ were necessary at the *first *proclamation of the Gospel, since it needed to be authenticated in the pagan world where there were ‘lord’s many’. However, dear friend, this state of affairs would obviously not persist indefinetley and with the passing of the Apostles the gifts, which were inseparably linked with the Apostles, would pass with them. The Christian religion only needed to be established once in the world and so the analogy of a building holds good; once an edifice has been erected, the scafolding is removed, having served its purpose. The extraordinary “signs of an apostle” were very much needed in the beginning when the Church was in its infancy - little like a jolly good firework display to get the show on the road.

As a matter of fact there is good biblical support for this position, for we are told by the writer to the Hebrews who, just prior to the sacking of Jerusalem (AD 70),* looked back* to the early days of Christianity and said: “How shall we escape if we neglect such a great salvation? It was declared at first by the Lord, and was attested to us by those that heard him, while God, also bore witness by signs and wonders and various miracles and gifts of the Holy Spirit, distributed according to his own will” (Heb. 2: 3,4, added emphasis mine). Please observe, dear friend, the past tense of the writer, which is no mere literary device but the straightforward prose of a man looking back to the distant past when the charismata was a normal feature of Church life. At the time of his writing this situation no longer obtained because the exrtraordinary sign gifts had more or less petered out. The problem with all Pentecostal groupings, Catholic or Protestant variety, is that they insist on making the narrative portions of the Book of Acts normative for Church life today. Incontrovertibly this is bad theology because it treats of Sacred Scripture in a Fundamentalist fashion and disregards the purpose and historical context in which the gifts of the Holy Spirit were given.

If, dear friend, the phenomena that we witness today in the modern CCR movement is not the authentic charismata of the New Testament, then surely we must admit the possibility that sinister dark forces may be at work in all Pentecostal groupings of our times. Simply because today’s manifestations resemble the manifestations of the N.T. that does not ipso facto mean that they are the manifestations mentioned of the N.T. Indeed, it is sheer folly to assume that they cannot be deceptions of the Devil and this is why men must needs “test the spirits to see whether they are of God” (I John 4: 1) and “test everything” (I Thess. 5: 21).

God bless and goodbye for now.

Warmest good wishes,

Portrait

Pax
 
As for glossolalia or tongues speaking, dear friend, this gift was given to enable the Gospel to be preached to everyone in attendance regardless of his language.
Thank you for bringing this up. What are your Scripture references?

Up front, I will declare that my question is like a trick question which those who understand “Tongues” will recognize. Still, I have the right to ask for references.

Please note that the situation that you are describing is separate from the two gifts which employ Tongues. Nonetheless, people are interested in it which accounts for the different opinions as to whether or not that situation is biblical.

Therefore,
if anyone has the references for this gift, please post them. I do not want this to turn into a debate. I simply recognize that there are plenty of people who know Scripture better than I do.
 
Dear grannymh,

Cordial greetings and thankyou again for your reply to my post.

Of course, dear friend, the Holy Spirit is sovereign and can impart gifts to whom he will, assuming of course that those gifts are still being imparted. However, my point was that **if **the CCR movement is of divine origin, then clearly the faithful ought to be actively involved with it, …
Please accept my sincere apology. I am totally hung up on the false assumption of if. I marked it in bold. The following reference to the faithful presents the false assumption that somehow the faithful determines if the gift of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal is from the real, true Holy Spirit.

Perhaps this will help. Are you aware of the Holy Spirit Gift of Discernment which is part of the administrative gifts given to the leaders in the Catholic Church? This gift has been in effect since chapter 15, the book of Acts. The easiest way to trace this gift through the centuries is to read the footnotes in the Catechism of the Catholic Church, Second Edition.
 
Nevertheless, what needs to be determined is whether it really is in truth a genuine movement of God in our times. For reasons I have explained in my previous posts, the evidence is decidedly against it being authentic.
I addressed your evidence in posts 26, 27, 33, 34, 43, and 44.

There is no need for me to address this additional statement. “The problem with all Pentecostal groupings, Catholic or Protestant variety, is that they insist on making the narrative portions of the Book of Acts normative for Church life today.” because the Catholic Charismatic Renewal in general is based on different Scripture. However, in Acts there are some passages which are important in the Catholic Charismatic Renewal. Since the citations, chapter, verses, were not presented, there is no need for me to address the comment about Book of Acts. Since Acts has 28 chapters, specific citations are essential when alluding to evidence.
 
Grannymh, I think you are doing a great job, bending over backwards to help this person, but from what I’ve seen elsewhere on CAF, it is a losing battle and waste of your effort. He’ll never budge a single point.

I found on the Bishops’ site (USCCB) this list of other movements in the Church.
“Some examples of contemporary ecclesial movements that exist to greater or lesser extent in the United States are CCR, Cursillo, Christian Life communities, Christian Family Movement, Movimiento Familiar Cristiano, Focolare, Neocatechumenal Way, Marriage Encounter, Communion and Liberation, and L’Arche.”
So we see that among many spiritual movements, CCR is a choice available to the faithful, who follow the call of the Holy Spirit. I think it is wonderful that there is so much diversity.

There are 5 pages listed from the search word “charismatic” on their website. I noted this one on the first page.

MANDATE AND GOALS FOR THE COMMITTEE

The committee assists the bishops of the Latin Church, both collectively and individually, in fulfilling their roles as priests and leaders of the worshiping community, especially with the translation of liturgical text and the development of guidelines for the celebration of the Mass and the sacraments. The committee addresses in a particular way prayer and worship within culturally diverse communities.
This mandate includes the following areas of responsibility: For the Latin Church, liturgical practice within the United States, translation and adaptation of liturgical texts, sacred music, charismatic renewal, and national shrines.
This Divine Worship Committee at USCCB oversees, therefore, the CCR. It is also noteworthy that most major dioceses and archdioceses in the US (and elsewhere) have internal liason offices for the CCR. If this movement was not authentic, there would be no such assistance to the faithful by either the USCCB or the many diocesan offices.

It is extremely disturbing to me that Portrait continues to post his antipathies in many threads here at CAF. He seems to put his opinions above the authority of the Church, and has never once shown anything of substance to back them up.

We have canonized saints who have been gifted with the extraordinary charisms, even in this century. One of my favorites is St. André Bessette whose gifts of healing were very well known. We know Sr. Briege McKenna and Fr. D’Orio have used this gift extensively for the faithful. The Spirit truly is manifesting them continuously!
 
. From a doctrinal standpoint the entire movement is in fundamental error inasmuch as it asserts that the “signs of an apostle” are the property of the Church today. The ‘sign gifts’ were necessary at the *first *proclamation of the Gospel, since it needed to be authenticated in the pagan world where there were ‘lord’s many’.
Since I am unfamiliar with the term “sign gifts” I Googled it. Here is what I found.
Source is from the first link. The two following links give some background information.

bible.org/article/two-views-sign-gifts-continuity-vs-discontinuity

bible.org/book/about-bibleorg

bible.org/article/doctrinal-statement

From the first link above.

“On any given day of the week, Christians can be found debating with one another over the “sign gifts”–that is, the spiritual gifts of tongues, prophecy, miracles, and healings.”

Question-- While tongues, prophecy, miracles, and healings are listed by St. Paul, why would the other five gifts in his list be omitted? The Catholic Charismatic Renewal teaches all nine gifts also known as the classical list.

From the first link above in reference to the argument for continuity.

“Part of the argument derives its theology from the book of Acts, part of it from the New Testament as a whole.”

Question – Could someone find the “theology” in Acts? I learned Catholic doctrine before opening a bible. Consequently, I am at a loss. I do know that Acts, chapter 10 contains the theology that Catholic Sacramental Baptism is different from the gift of “Tongues” as received by Cornelius from the Holy Spirit. Source. Acts 10: 44-49

Personal observation – In my humble opinion, the issue of continuity verses discontinuity should not be the mutually exclusive or – either this or that.

The Catholic Charismatic Renewal is realistic when it studies St. Paul’s classical list of nine gifts plus the common gift of praying in tongues. The common gift of praying in tongues appears to have died out in the general populace over centuries. Yet, the “sign gifts” of miracles and healings are seen in the lives of the Saints. The three intellectual gifts, The Word of Wisdom, The Word of Knowledge, and the Gift of Discernment, can be inferred from saintly actions.

One more thought. The Catholic Charismatic Renewal teaching regarding the nine gifts listed by St. Paul also follows the corrective measures given by St. Paul in addition to applying modern safeguards for certain gifts.

Here is a Catholic source.
brendancase.com/uploads/Key_to_the_Charismatic_Renewal.pdf
 
Grannymh, I think you are doing a great job, bending over backwards to help this person, but from what I’ve seen elsewhere on CAF, it is a losing battle and waste of your effort. He’ll never budge a single point.
Before I answer you, may I share a tidbit about the Christian Family Movement which was mentioned in your post. When I was growing up, one of the founding couples of the Christian Family Movement gathered a group of parishioners to be one of the first groups to live out the principles of CFM. This group often met in our living room. At times, following the meeting, they would discuss what was beneficial what could be improved in the CFM approach. Some of my own approach to life is due to sitting on the stairs out of sight but within hearing distance.

To return to the comment about a “losing battle.”

I know very well that there are people who will remain firm on opposition to the Catholic Charismatic Renewal. I have read some of the opposition articles and tracts and they are convincing. I also understand how difficult it is for today’s Catholics when it comes to reading St. Paul. Personally, I hope to show that the opposition is based on misunderstandings or lack of knowledge of the truth. Hopefully, the person will eventually “budge” on her or his own. All I can do is to present the position of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal as it is within the Catholic Church.

My focus is on the readers, CAF members and guests. What is it that they need to know so that they can properly understand the Catholic Charismatic Renewal? If someone wishes to reject the Catholic Charismatic Renewal, I want them to first know both sides before making their decision.

There have been times when “opposition” turns into a personal learning experience for me. I don’t know all the answers so when I have to research, the “opposition” becomes beneficial. Regardless of how a discussion turns out, my efforts are never wasted as long as I do my best to charitably give useful information to our curious readers. I hope that others who are involved with the Catholic Charismatic Renewal will continue to do the same.
 
The gift of tongues is always given(gift) to build up the church.

Either for a given person in the church, to strengthen faith and knowledge,
or a group of people in the church
or to impress and bring a group of people into the church, as on Pentecost.

Glossolalia is a form of gift of tongues, giving praise to God in a strange tongue which only the Holy Spirit understands and is not interpreted.

Interpreters are really spiritual translators so what was said can be understood.

There was a situation where I was with a person who was going to die and I was praying the rosary for them by their bedside. At any rate another christian came in and I could see that it bothered them that I was praying the rosary. So they began to speak in a strange muffled tongue walking up and down the room as I was saying the rosary. I don’t think they were intending to offend me but they did it to conteract the effects of praying to Mary. I found this interesting how misinformed things can get.

However I do think they have the right to pray in tongues if they wish and it truely means something to them. For some, tongues may be a good way to build their faith and knowledge as long as it is carried out in the correct way.

I personally don’t feel the need nor desire to pray that way, but others who do, they should use this gift of the Holy Spirit.

Maybe the problem comes in where those who pray conventional prayers or those who pray in tongues, think to pray one way excludes the other way.

Just a thought.
 
If, dear friend, the CCR is a genuine movement of God in our times then it ought surely to be enthusiastically embraced by all the faithful as it will greatly enrich their spiritual lives. Thus assuming it was genuine, it would be sheer folly and, indeed, disobedience to “choose” not to be a part of it. However, the key issue to be decided is whether or not it is a genuine movement of God’s Spirit and not some counterfeit phenomena, possibly inspired by Satanic activity.

**Please read Matthew 12:22 to 37, where, after a miraculous healing, Jesus answers the Pharisees whose words are echoed by Portrait: “it is only by Beelzebub, the prince of demons, that this fellow drives out demons.” Jesus utters a most fearful warning: …“anyone who speaks against the Holy Spirit will not be forgiven, either in this age or the age to come”.
**

“Whereas even now the Holy Ghost is received, yet no one speaks in the tongues of all nations, because the Church herself already speaks in the languages of all nations: since whoever is not in the Church, receives not the Holy Ghost”.

Of course, the converse is true: "whoever does not receive the Holy Spirit cannot be in the church, eg Cornelius. Which is why Jesus spoke of the “signs of the BELIEVER”😉 BTW they are not “signs of an apostle” but ANYONE who believes in Jesus and puts HIM above father, mother, wife, home, church. To those who fear this total trust in Jesus (what’s He gonna make me do?), we Charismatics will tell you Jesus and the Holy Spirit bind you closer to all your earthly people and principalities. He is LOVE: the hate-filled powers of darkness He reveals to us through discernment so that we can nullify the evil one’s nefarious activities (however subtle) IN THE NAME OF JESUS.
BTW, Portrait: can you say “Jesus is Lord”?
😛

God bless.

Warmest good wishes,

Portrait

Pax
I notice you call people “dear friend” and end “with warmest good wishes”. Charismatics call each other “brother” and sister" (although our sisters insist they are the “Sons of God” so that they don’t miss out). We end with “In the love of Jesus, who binds us to Him”. We are also noted as a peculiar people who hug one another and share the kiss of peace.
BTW, Pax (true peace) is a fruit of the Holy Spirit.:D.
The lord defined peace for me by giving me Psalm 91: 7&8:
“A thousand may fall at your side,
Ten thousand at your right hand,
But it will come near you.
You will only observe with your eyes
and see the punishment of the wicked.”
I saw it then as an INNER peace, no matter what nonsense is going on around you. “Do not let your hearts be troubled, for I AM with you!”
 
Finally, to hold that the CCR is a genuine movement of the Holy Spirit requires the faithful to believe that until its emergence in 1967, the Church was impoverished and incomplete since the Gifts had not been fully restored, which is preposterous. This is tantamount to saying that the multitudes of earnest and holy Catholics, including the Saints, were somehow deficient because they did not experience their faith in all its true fulness. However, the vast majority would have found this risible and would have been in total agreement with Baltimore Catechism in believing that the extraordinary gifts were no longer the property of the Church. Were all of these mistaken, dear friend?
Good point, Portrait. 👍
 
However, the key issue to be decided is whether or not it is a genuine movement of God’s Spirit and not some counterfeit phenomena, possibly inspired by Satanic activity.
Indeed!

In 1974, in a scathing criticism of the Charismatic movement, the staunchly orthodox Archbishop Dwyer of the United States said, “We regard it bluntly as one of the most dangerous trends in the Church in our time, closely allied in spirit with other disruptive and divisive movements; threatening grave harm to unity and damage to countless souls.”
 
When I was growing up, my neighbor’s mother was an EXTREMELY devote Catholic that reputedly spoke in tongues. I never heard it myself, but it was well known to the Catholic community she would do so.

Back in the day, I went to some major evangelical events, and people were reputedly speaking in tongues. I could actually recognize some of the languages, such as one of the people near me that started speaking in Hebrew…but I could never verify if these people actually knew the languages beforehand.
 
Finally, to hold that the CCR is a genuine movement of the Holy Spirit requires the faithful to believe that until its emergence in 1967, the Church was impoverished and incomplete since the Gifts had not been fully restored, which is preposterous.
May I respectfully ask what website this requirement of belief came from? Since there is no identification as to who initiated this requirement of belief, it is very difficult to understand it.

In any case, the declaration of this requirement of belief is not part of Catholic theology regarding the Holy Spirit. A good source regarding the Holy Spirit in the 20th - 21st centuries is chapter 14, the Gospel of John.

Since this requirement of belief is probably an urban myth, here is a bit of information coming from those qualified in Catholic theology.

As early as 1969, only two years after the Renewal started, the U.S. Bishops investigated the fledgling movement and the Committee on Doctrine wrote that “theologically the movement has legitimate reasons of existence. It has a strong biblical basis. It would be difficult to inhibit the working of the Spirit which manifested itself so abundantly in the early Church.”

Source: National Service Committee. Catholic Charismatic Renewal
nsc-chariscenter.org/AboutCCR/

The difference between this statement and that requirement of belief is that the existence of the movement was examined per se. That requirement of belief does not flow logically from “existence” per se. In other words, the existence of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal per se does not float or sink depending on which direction people are swimming.

Now, it is a well known fact that many Catholics have opposed the existence of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal. That is totally understandable. However, in the spirit of fairness, one should learn what “Pentecostalism” really is within the Catholic Church.

Yes, I know that some will not accept the evaluation of the U.S. Bishops. So be it.
 
The gift of tongues is always given(gift) to build up the church.

Either for a given person in the church, to strengthen faith and knowledge,
or a group of people in the church
or to impress and bring a group of people into the church, as on Pentecost.

Glossolalia is a form of gift of tongues, giving praise to God in a strange tongue which only the Holy Spirit understands and is not interpreted.

Interpreters are really spiritual translators so what was said can be understood.

There was a situation where I was with a person who was going to die and I was praying the rosary for them by their bedside. At any rate another christian came in and I could see that it bothered them that I was praying the rosary. So they began to speak in a strange muffled tongue walking up and down the room as I was saying the rosary. I don’t think they were intending to offend me but they did it to conteract the effects of praying to Mary. I found this interesting how misinformed things can get.

However I do think they have the right to pray in tongues if they wish and it truely means something to them. For some, tongues may be a good way to build their faith and knowledge as long as it is carried out in the correct way.

I personally don’t feel the need nor desire to pray that way, but others who do, they should use this gift of the Holy Spirit.

Maybe the problem comes in where those who pray conventional prayers or those who pray in tongues, think to pray one way excludes the other way.

Just a thought.
This is an excellent thought. Thank you.
“Maybe the problem comes in where those who pray conventional prayers or those who pray in tongues, think to pray one way excludes the other way.”

I agree that this is a problem probably because people are so used to the “mutually exclusive or” meaning either this *or *that. We need to look at prayer with a both this and that attitude.

I would like to name the gift you described as
“Glossolalia is a form of gift of tongues, giving praise to God in a strange tongue which only the Holy Spirit understands and is not interpreted.”

This is the gift known as praying in tongues or prayer tongues.
We often think of it as a language, our own personal language. I would add to your comment that not only does the Holy Spirit understand the sounds we make, He is the one Who is using our lips, tongue, larynx, our very own speech mechanism to form those sounds. This is because we give Him the right to do so. The terminology is that we yield to the Holy Spirit. We set aside our rational powers of memory or intellect and literally let the Holy Spirit take over. We are in control of this religious activity. We can start and stop. We can be vocal or silent.

When I was involved in a charismatic prayer group, there would be a set time on the agenda for praying to God in prayer tongues. Personally, I found myself *both *yielding to the Holy Spirit *and *then a bit later return to English. Yielding to the Holy Spirit in prayer is a lot better than road rage.
 
I know about Pentecostalism in the early 1900’s. So I am very interested in your Protestant Fundamentalism issue. Would you be so kind as to provide the sources of this information so I can further study the history of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal. Also, you do have my curiosity about the influence of the hippy-culture of those rebellious times. What is it that you are referring to?

Thank you for honoring my requests.

In the meantime,
would it be o.k. if I substituted “checking out the Pentecostal experience” in place of “owes its origin to Protestant Fundamentalism…” In 1967, there were people who saw a difference between “Pentecostalism” and mainline Protestant denominations. What have you discovered in this regard?

Those familiar with the beginning of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal are well aware of the “seeking” information from other religious peoples, including checking out the Pentecostalism experience. The public concerns of Bishops were front and center. Good thing.

Those familiar with those early years know that both Protestant and Pentecostal teachings were laid on the table along with Catholic teachings. It is here, that the charismatic renewal became truly Catholic within the Catholic Church.

In other words, the difference between Protestant/Pentecostal experiences and the Catholic Charismatic Renewal is the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass along with the seven Sacraments of grace throughout one’s entire life.
Dear grannymh,

Cordial greetings and a very good day. Thankyou for the above reponse.

There was, dear sister, a sort of Catholic appropriation of Fundamentalist Pentecostalism when in the ecumenical frenzy of the late 60’s, students at Pittsburgh’s Duquesne University began exposing themselves to Protestant Pentecostal influences because of spiritual aridity. Apparently they were envious of the ‘changed lives’ among many Protestant friends and decided to pray for a similar experience. An unsupervised weekend retreat in 1967 proved to be the key to their answer. Various people approached various Protestant ministers, laity and prayer groups and all received “the Baptism of the Spirit” after having heretical hands laid upon them. Those viewing this thread should note the Protestant roots of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal movement.

Indeed, dear friend, the importance of this action cannot be oversestimated. These Catholic students submitted themselves to a non-Catholic quasi-sacramental rite - obviously a mockery of the Sacrament of Confirmation - and the emotional high brought about by this convinced them of the holiness of the whole experience. They were now* Catholic* Pentecostalists and their influence soon spread far and wide, first on the college campuses and then to the world at large.

If ever there was a compelling argument for listening to Holy Mother Church, then this is surely it, dear friend. The Church has unceasingly warned the faithful to steer clear of heretical ‘worship’ for almost 2000 years because she knows fully well what the consequences will be, both for the individual and the wider Church. Notwithstanding, the CCR unabashedly admits and even extols its Protestant roots! Alas, this what happens when Catholics who ought to know better “check out a Pentecostal experience”.

Baptizing the pernicious Pentecostal heresy does not ipso facto render it acceptable and holy for Catholics. Unfortunately, dear friend, the CCR movement is a blighted tree bearing poisonous fruit, sown by the Devil among Fundamentalist Protestants and then transplanted into the Catholic Church by some misguided students back in 1967.

God bless.

Warmest good wishes,

Portrait

Pax
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top