Catholic tongues advice

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dutch_H
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
To understand the differences between Pentecostalism which refers to the First Pentecost described in Acts, the Pentecostal churches which are also known as the “third force” in Christianity, and Protestantism, one should skip the “cherry picking” and start with the beginning of the Link.
brendancase.com/uploads/Key_to_the_Charismatic_Renewal.pdf
Dear grannymh,

Cordial greetings and a very good day.

The genuiness of the original Pentecostal outpouring, dear friend, is not question, the issue is whether modern Pentecostalism, in its Catholic and Protestant manifestions, is an authentic movement initiated by the Holy Spirit in our times.

Specifically, dear friend, we were focusing on the back history of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal and so what happened in Pittburgh in February 1967 is highly relevant with respect to the birth of the movement and its undoubtedly Protestant influences. Moreover, that it was a similar outpouring to the original Pentecostal effusion is an opinion that does not stand up to scrutiny and is based more upon wishful thinking from sincere but sincerely wrong and misguided individuals. It was probably fuelled by an immature dislike of clericalism and the perceived aridity of traditional Catholic worship, an attitude which chimed with the then popular hippy-culture which had a strong aversion to anything that even had a whiff of conventionality and tradition. Let remember, they were young students and so it is not unlikely that they would have absorbed some of the spirit of that age - I refer to that “whole generation with a new explanation” nonsense and the discarding of allegedly outmoded conventions etc.

God bless.

Warmest good wishes,

Portrait

Pax
 
Dearly beloved friends,

Cordial greetings and a very good day. This will be my final post in the current thread as I am of the opinion that our topic has been thoroughly discussed now. Thankyou grannymh for a jolly charitable discussion, given our controversial subject matter, and for engaging in debate without rancour. Thankyou also to Mickey for your supportive and informative (name removed by moderator)ut, dear brother.

To end on a positive note, I think we can all covet the zeal of our Charismatic Catholic brethren, they are undoubtedly zealous and their religion is clearly very meaningful to them. Never could they be accused of a nominalism, that is for sure. Some here may be interested to learn that my first contact with the religion of Christ was actually through Protestant Pentecostalism (Elim) and I owe my conversion to our Lord to the simple and earnest witness of a lay Pentecostal chap, who told me the ‘old, old story’ and then ‘led me to Christ’, as they are wont to term it. Those times, many years ago now, were very precious to me and I do remember singing those rousing ditties at the meetings and listening to long - yes very long sermons. There is no doubt whatsoever, dear friends, I felt extremely close to our Blessed Saviour at that time and was very earnest in my nascent faith. However, to cut a long story short, I soon came to have serious misgivings respecting Pentecostal practices and remember feeling very uncomfortable around tongues speaking. Moreover, it seemed that many within the church were extremely worldly and showed very little zeal for the pursuit of holiness, notwithstanding that they allegedly ‘moved in the gifts’ of the Holy Spirit. This was puzzling to a new convert who had recently parted company with his entire rock/pop music collection, which was not an easy thing to do as it was quite sizeable, and who was generally striving very hard, though failing many times, not to be conformed to the godless world, from which had been saved from (cf. Rom 12: 1-2). Many of them did not appear interested in trying to live up to the arduous requirements of the Christian religion and often spoke flippantly about Puritan or ‘super spiritual types’ who thought that they were better than others. It did not take this young convert to see that this did not square with the holy religion of Christ, which was very much about striving to enter in a the straight gate and avoiding worldliness and an unspiritual outlook.

At length, I was led to leave the Elim Pentecostal Church and join a Baptist Church, which although it was not Pentecostal was quite liberal. Eventuallly, I became a member of the Church of England (Anglican) and joined and Evangelical parish, where the vicar was in the Reformed tradition. For many years I embraced this Protestant Reformed tradition, until I finally became convinced of Baptismal Regeneration and other Catholic teachings, after reading ‘High Church’ books. After 25 years in the Anglican communion, the last few years as a High Churchman, I entered, along with my dear wife, the one Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church of Christ in 2009. However, even as a Catholic I have seen no compelling reasons to revise my stance on Pentecostalism, be it the Protestant or Catholic variety and I have spent a considerable amount of time researching the issue, especially the CCR.

With all the good will that I can muster, I cannot accept that the CCR is a vital work of the Holy Spirit in our times. The extraordinary gifts were imparted to fledgling Church in the early days of Christianity for the confirmation of faith and in answer to the divine origin of the religion of Christ. Their end being accomplished they were gradually withdrawn and eventually petered out. There is nothing really odd about this, for once and edifice has been errected the scafolding is removed, since the building no longer requires support - think of the extraordinary gifts, dear friends, in much the same way. They were as it were the initial fireworks to launch the newly established Church, which needed to be accredited and authenticated by by miraculous phenomena in those very early times in the pagan world (see Heb. 2: 3,4, which verifies this).

One of the most glaringly dangerous underlying assumptions of the CCR, dear friends, is that today’s manifestations which resemble the charismata of the N.T. are indeed the genuine charismata of the N.T., simply by virtue of this resemblance. Then you have yet another assumption that the Holy Spirit is the author of this modern phenomena, simply by virtue of the fact that He was the the author of the genuine charismata in the early days of Christianity. To their own peril the CCR completely discounts even the possibility that these extraordinary manifestations (which Catholic charismatics are seeking to make normal), could be the result of satanic deception. Given that the Devil transforms himself into an angel of light, is this really so beyond the realms of possibility? He does not mind men praying in the short term if he is more likely to take them to eternal Hell in the end.

As for the wide support and approval of the CCR by the Popes and Bishops, I have already treated of this, dear friends, earlier in this thread. However, let me repeat, support and approval does not equate with official pronouncements of the Magisterium. We are not at liberty to elevate personal endorsements of high-ranking officials into official approbation. Moreover, Charismatics, in common with liberal Catholics, have a tendency to ascribe creeping infallibilty to u**nofficial papal pronouncements that support their position.

Blessing be upon you all, dear friends, and may you have an enjoyable and relaxing weekend.

Warmest good wishes,

Portrait

Pax:tiphat:
 
Dear Grannymh,

Thank you for all of your hard efforts in this thread; it is sincerely appreciated. If one were to “test the Spirits,” it is clear which poster is demonstrating the Spirit’s fruits here. Your posts don’t require the syrupy greeting and warmest good wishes to make your message more palatable.

Wisdom indicates that we leave the naysayers to their own braying. Clearly, the Church has spoken, yet they remain free to attack Her guidance.
Not only that, but this morning I recognized an old-fashioned scare tactic that basically implies that ordinary folk lack the know-how of free will because intelligence is on the low side.

I need to go back in memory to the time when I attended the Catholic Life in the Spirit Seminar. I know I went to it to learn with no strings attached.

I am trying to figure out my reaction if someone had said to me – " I have seen CCR services where people are waving their arms, falling down in convulsions, and swaying to popular music as the priest speaks gibberish. It is not recognizable as any type of Liturgical service."
:eek:

How would I question the truth of that statement? ? ? ?
 
Your posts don’t require the syrupy greeting and warmest good wishes to make your message more palatable.
Portrait is one of the most kind, charitable, knowledgeable posters on this forum. How sad that you feel it is necessary to denigrate his greeting in order to somehow demonize his motives. For shame! 😦
 
40.png
grannymh:
I doubt if this is an original thought, but I believe that prayer tongues is dependent on a deep relationship with the Holy Spirit.

“This whole phenomenon [of speaking in tongues] is very obscure, but the obscurity is produced by our ignorance of the facts referred to and by their cessation, being such then as used to occur** but now no longer take place.** And why do they not happen now? Why look now, the cause too of the obscurity hath produced us again another question: namely, why did they then happen, and now do so no more”? St John Chrysostom

In the earliest times, “the Holy Ghost fell upon them that believed: and they spake with tongues”, which they had not learned, “as the Spirit gave them utterance”. These were signs adapted to the time. For there behooved to be that betokening of the Holy Spirit in all tongues, to shew that the Gospel of God was to run through all tongues over the whole earth. That thing was done for a betokening, and it passed away. In the laying on of hands now, that persons may receive the Holy Ghost, do we look that they should speak with tongues? Or when he laid the hand on infants, did each one of you look to see whether they would speak with tongues, and, when he saw that they did not speak with tongues, was any of you so strong-minded as to say, These have not received the Holy Ghost; for, had they received, they would speak with tongues as was the case in those times? If then the witness of the presence of the Holy Ghost be not given through these miracles, by what is it given, by what does one get to know that he has received the Holy Ghost? Let him question his own heart. If he love his brother, the Spirit of God dwelleth in him.
St Augustine of Hippo
 
Not only that, but this morning I recognized an old-fashioned scare tactic that basically implies that ordinary folk lack the know-how of free will because intelligence is on the low side.
If you think that scare tactics are being used to to subtley accuse people of being ignorant and/or stupid, then that is very very sad and mistaken. Forgive me if that is the impression you have gleaned. I will now follow Portrait’s lead and bow out of this thread.

Good day all!
:tiphat:
 
Dearly beloved friends,

Cordial greetings and a very good day. This will be my final post in the current thread as I am of the opinion that our topic has been thoroughly discussed now. Thankyou grannymh for a jolly charitable discussion, given our controversial subject matter, and for engaging in debate without rancour. Thankyou also to Mickey for your supportive and informative (name removed by moderator)ut, dear brother.
I do hope that you and our gentle readers will read post 51.
forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=9794391&postcount=51

Portrait, your love of Catholicism has never been doubted.

Your conversion story is precious but not singular since in my area, there has been the observation that Pentecostalism meaning the study of Acts and St. Paul has brought people into the Catholic Church. Thank you Holy Spirit for guiding Portrait.

What is up for discernment are the sources of opposing CCR information.

It is important to know what is valid and what is not. It is very important to look at the time frame of the information. For example, statements from a well-known respected theologian (currently being proposed for sainthood) contain a critical evaluation of the first years of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal. His concerns were valid for the time frame. What our current people do not know is that those concerns have been addressed and resolved.

This theologian’s insight and that of others were crucial at the time CCR was stated. The first years of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal needed guidance from the Catholic individuals responsible for guarding the Faith. This process of sorting out the issues is part of the Holy Spirit’s [charismatic] Gift of Discernment listed by St. Paul and which has existed through the centuries to this very moment. Source: 1 Corinthians 12: 10, discernment of spirits. This gift enables a person or group to know the source of an inspiration or action. Did it come from the Holy Spirit, a person’s human spirit, or from the evil spirit? Those responsible for guarding the Catholic Deposit of Faith reported …

As early as 1969, only two years after the Renewal started, the U.S. Bishops investigated the fledgling movement and the Committee on Doctrine wrote that “theologically the movement has legitimate reasons of existence. It has a strong biblical basis. It would be difficult to inhibit the working of the Spirit which manifested itself so abundantly in the early Church.”

Subsequent statements in 1975, 1984 and 1997 have been equally affirming.

The 1984 Statement, A Pastoral Statement on the Catholic Charismatic Renewal, concluded with these words:
We wish those in the charismatic renewal to know that we make our own the view of Yves Congar: “The charismatic renewal is a grace for the Church.” We assure those in the charismatic renewal of the support they enjoy from the bishops of the United States, and we encourage them in their efforts to renew the life of the Church. (39)
The Statement also says:
Echoing the words of Pope John Paul II, we commend the charismatic renewal to the priests of the United States: “The priest, for his part, cannot exercise his service on behalf of the renewal unless and until he adopts a welcoming attitude toward it, based on the desire he shares with every Christian by baptism to grow in the gifts of the Holy Spirit” (May 7, 1981). The priest’s responsibility to give pastoral guidance remains, even though an individual priest may not be a participant in the renewal. (37)
Source: nsc-chariscenter.org/AboutCCR/

A key statement is “efforts to renew the life of the Church.” This means the Sacramental life of the Catholic Church. This means lay participation by following the mission statement of th parish. This means bringing one’s children to the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass.

What is interesting about the last statement is that an individual priest does not have to participate in the Renewal in order to give necessary pastoral guidance. Charismatic Prayer groups are to act in obedience to the Pastor.

Please note.

It is up to the people involved in the Catholic Charismatic Renewal to carry out the proper Catholic elements in the above statement. It is a Catholic person’s responsibility to report any abuse or deviation from Catholic teaching to the pastor and/or renewal liaison to the diocese and/or the appropriate vicar for spiritual organizations and/or the bishop.
 
Mickey,

It is good for you to ponder that a number of people do not take kindly to overtures that violate personal space, unless a relationship is well established or invited. To assume a position of intimacy using endearing terms such as this is highly offensive. St. Teresa of Avila taught this to her sisters, forbidding them to use such expressions.

In one single post earlier, I found seven repetitions of “dear friend” when we are nothing of the sort. It is something to take under one’s wing. Nothing wrong with cordiality, but this goes overboard. I trust you understand that it does not question his motives.
 
In one single post earlier, I found seven repetitions of “dear friend” when we are nothing of the sort.
Love thy neighbor.
Nothing wrong with cordiality, but this goes overboard.
Referring to a fellow Christian as “a dear friend” seven times…or seventy times seven…is not “going overboard.”
I trust you understand that it does not question his motives.
I 'll give you the benefit of the doubt.

…and now this was truly my last post. 😃
 
If you think that scare tactics are being used to to subtley accuse people of being ignorant and/or stupid, then that is very very sad and mistaken. Forgive me if that is the impression you have gleaned. I will now follow Portrait’s lead and bow out of this thread.

Good day all!
:tiphat:
May I refer readers
to the original post in order to understand what I was saying.

*** Post 82
"Not only that, but this morning I recognized an old-fashioned scare tactic that basically implies that ordinary folk lack the know-how of free will because intelligence is on the low side.

I need to go back in memory to the time when I attended the Catholic Life in the Spirit Seminar. I know I went to it to learn with no strings attached.
.
I am trying to figure out my reaction if someone had said to me – " I have seen CCR services where people are waving their arms, falling down in convulsions, and swaying to popular music as the priest speaks gibberish. It is not recognizable as any type of Liturgical service."
:eek:

How would I question the truth of that statement? ? ? ? "

I am looking at possible implications and possible reactions to a popular statement.
Never did any direct accusing. I did share that **I **wonder how I would react **if **someone said to me… Perhaps one can consider that I am accusing myself. And that is o.k. with me.

As for intelligence being on the low side, this is due to the fact that some, not all, people do not take the needed time to research questions of faith, such as how one makes use of free will. Free will involves both knowing and understanding what is involved, *both *good *and *bad.

As for scare tactics… Some old examples. You can’t be a champion if you eat such and such. Are you dumb enough to jump off a bridge? My simple proposition is that we need to shift to a more beneficial reaction to popular opposition statements regarding the Catholic Charismatic renewal. Examples of a wise reaction. I trust my ability to read the ingredients on a package. or Of course, I am able to make informed decisions.

When it comes to the know-how of a free will choice regarding elements of any kind of a charismatic program, using one’s intelligence properly is a key issue. This is one of the reasons that it is recommended that people attend the Catholic Life in the Spirit seminar.

Regarding the Catholic Charismatic Renewal, it is important to question the truth of statements coming from both sides of the table.

As I said in post 51, “My focus is on the readers, CAF members and guests. What is it that they need to know so that they can properly understand the Catholic Charismatic Renewal?”

To that I now add that from reading hundreds of posts, what people need to understand is prayer tongues.
 
I called 1-888-633-3446 and they showed me how to be sure of going to heaven!!!
Amen!!!
1-888-needhim!!!
 
Hello all.

I am seeking some advice. I have been a Catholic for some time now after converting from Calvinist Anglicanism.

To make a long story short (I’ll try). I befriended a Pentecostal friend and we were speaking about Tongues. He put the argument up to me and I studied. His arguments were all Biblical and to me did not seem anti Catholic.

He offered for me to join in him prayer. I did last week. Nothing heretical (correct me if I am wrong please) I believe as we just prayed to God then started praising him.

I was very skeptical at first having not known any Catholics who spoke in tongues. As we continued praying something remarkable happened. Both my hands down to my elbows had an awesome feeling of energy running through. Similar to pins and needles but much more intense. (I have never had any circulation problems in the past or since for those thinking it) I then started to pray in tongues automatically. I was thinking what to say in my mind praising God but it came out something foreign.

It lasted about 5 minutes and I felt the overwhelming love of God. I also had no temptation for some time afterwards along with a new comprehension of scripture and a yearning for it.

As the days went on I started to feel down as I had searched and searched in the past and came to Catholicism, yet I wasn’t seeing the practice of what I experienced in all the parishes I had been too. I did find some joy when I realised there is a Catholic charismatic movement.

I believe the Holy Spirit came into me in full that evening. The experience and feeling was like nothing I have ever had.

My question is, why don’t the majority of Catholics practice this and why isn’t it more known? My Pentecostal friend of course disputes the claims of our Great True Church and sadly some of those thoughts have entered into my head after this experience. If I saw much of the parish doing this I would feel better but I feel many are missing out. If Our Great Church is really the true Church of Christ then why isn’t the outpouring of the Holy Spirit more prevalent. It is possible that I experienced something unique and not meant for the masses? That the Holy Spirit gives difference graces to different members of the Body of Christ?

My Pentecostal friend claims every baptised member can receive the same gifts as I did.

In saying this I am not leaving Catholicism as I am being rational about it and remember my years of study and prayer that lead me to here. I feel at home within Catholicism. I am just a little confused and having a few of my beliefs challenged.

In saying this, is there a Catholic Charismatic movement in Sydney Australia? I would like to meet up with them? I can’t seem to find one.

Thank you for your time.

Peace in Christ.

God Bless.
Somewhere on this post I believe I read that the gift of tongues and praying with tongues are distinct. I have never heard that there was such as thing as praying with tongues that was distinct from the gift of tongues. And I’m not saying that there might not be such a phenomenon as praying with tongues.
According to catholic theology, the gift of tongues from the Holy Spirit is an extraordinary gift. It is not given to all and when it is given it is always given for the benefit of others. You can read this in scripture from St Paul. The charismatic gifts of the Holy Spirit such as tongues, prophecy, healing, etc. are given by the Holy Spirit when he wills and to whom he wills. Whereas the seven gifts of the Holy Spirit are given to every baptized person as well as again in confession if we need to be restored to the life of grace.
If we ask ourselves why isn’t the outpouring of the charismatic gifts of the Holy Spirit more prevalent today, we would need to ask the Holy Spirit for the reason. The charismatic gifts are not necessary for our sanctification.
However, prayer is necessary for our sanctification. Two great witnesses, among many, to a life of prayer in the catholic tradition are St Teresa of Avila and St John of the Cross, both doctors of the church and masters of the interior life and the art of prayer. However, there is no mention of a form of prayer in their writings such as praying with tongues that is distinct from the gift of tongues. Maybe this could answer your question as to why dont the majority of catholics practice this praying with tongues and why isn’t it more known.
I suspect that what you experienced, if indeed it was some kind of gift from God, if it was not the gift of tongues, some kind of form of prayer. And I’m not saying that you truly didn’t experience something from God.
In the CCC #2699, it says “The Lord leads all persons by paths and in ways pleasing to him, and each person responds according to his heart’s resolve and the personal expressions of his prayer”.
As I believe somebody mentioned somewhere in this thread, it would be wise to speak to a good spiritual director about your experiences.
I would just like to leave you with the thought that the rosary of our Lady is an excellent prayer and we can certainly trust her to lead us along the right paths.

God Bless, Rich
 
Somewhere on this post I believe I read that the gift of tongues and praying with tongues are distinct. I have never heard that there was such as thing as praying with tongues that was distinct from the gift of tongues. And I’m not saying that there might not be such a phenomenon as praying with tongues.
According to catholic theology, the gift of tongues from the Holy Spirit is an extraordinary gift. It is not given to all and when it is given it is always given for the benefit of others. You can read this in scripture from St Paul. The charismatic gifts of the Holy Spirit such as tongues, prophecy, healing, etc. are given by the Holy Spirit when he wills and to whom he wills. Whereas the seven gifts of the Holy Spirit are given to every baptized person as well as again in confession if we need to be restored to the life of grace.
If we ask ourselves why isn’t the outpouring of the charismatic gifts of the Holy Spirit more prevalent today, we would need to ask the Holy Spirit for the reason. The charismatic gifts are not necessary for our sanctification.
However, prayer is necessary for our sanctification. Two great witnesses, among many, to a life of prayer in the catholic tradition are St Teresa of Avila and St John of the Cross, both doctors of the church and masters of the interior life and the art of prayer. However, there is no mention of a form of prayer in their writings such as praying with tongues that is distinct from the gift of tongues. Maybe this could answer your question as to why dont the majority of catholics practice this praying with tongues and why isn’t it more known.
I suspect that what you experienced, if indeed it was some kind of gift from God, if it was not the gift of tongues, some kind of form of prayer. And I’m not saying that you truly didn’t experience something from God.
In the CCC #2699, it says “The Lord leads all persons by paths and in ways pleasing to him, and each person responds according to his heart’s resolve and the personal expressions of his prayer”.
As I believe somebody mentioned somewhere in this thread, it would be wise to speak to a good spiritual director about your experiences.
I would just like to leave you with the thought that the rosary of our Lady is an excellent prayer and we can certainly trust her to lead us along the right paths.

God Bless, Rich
Thank you. You have given a very good description of the Holy Spirit Gift of Tongues as one of the nine gifts listed by St. Paul, 1 Corinthians, Chapter 12. In 1 Corinthians, Chapter 14, the “rules of order” refer to the practice of this gift. Chapter 14 also contrasts this gift with the common gift of praying in tongues or as St. Paul says, “I will pray with the spirit…” Source: 1Corinthians 14: 13-15. The difficulty is that the words speak and tongue have different meanings. Thus, one has to study the entire context and then some.

In addition to 1Corinthians 14, the religious activity of praying in tongues is referred to in
Acts 2:4; 10:46; and 19:6.

In my parish, some of the people who have gone through the Catholic Life in the Spirit seminar or similar pray the Rosary before daily Holy Sacrifice of the Mass. Whether or not these people also pray in tongues is not important.
 
Wisdom indicates that we leave the naysayers*** to their own braying.*** Clearly, the Church has spoken, yet they remain free to attack Her guidance.
For me, those two sentences sum up the attitude of many members of the Charismatic movement. You let the cat out of the bag, not that i didnalready know. :shrug: Now, youve expressed it in print, so you can`t deny it.

Ironically, some who dislike the speaking in tongues phenomenon might apply the phrase “to their own braying” to that very thing! 🤷
 
For me, those two sentences sum up the attitude of many members of the Charismatic movement. You let the cat out of the bag, not that i didnalready know. :shrug: Now, youve expressed it in print, so you can`t deny it.

Ironically, some who dislike the speaking in tongues phenomenon might apply the phrase “to their own braying” to that very thing! 🤷
:confused: What in the world … ? What cat? Are you suggesting I belong to the CCR? How judgmental. You would be wrong … completely wrong. I am a Secular Carmelite, nothing more, but I do uphold the Church’s teaching that the movement is approved, and I will support anyone who belongs it, since it their lawful right not to be persecuted by those who willfully reject it.
 
:confused: What in the world … ? What cat? Are you suggesting I belong to the CCR? How judgmental. You would be wrong … completely wrong. I am a Secular Carmelite, nothing more, but I do uphold the Church’s teaching that the movement is approved, and I will support anyone who belongs it, since it their lawful right not to be persecuted by those who willfully reject it.
Dont you think "...to leave the naysayers to their own braying." is a bit offensive? If you hadnt said that, i wouldn`t have posted.

i wilfully reject the lack-of-self-control acts of many members of the Charismatic movement, the spiritual immaturity (desire for a spiritual high) of many, and the look-down-their-noses-attitude (of many).

The fact that youre not a member of the Charismatic movement doesnt alter the fact that your words in that post reflect the attitude of many of its members. So, with the removal of the second and third sentences, my last post still applies.

Ever thought that the Church`s approval may be partly an attempt to keep it under control? To try to prevent excesses? And excesses do happen. 🤷
 
Acts 2: 1-4 is a marvelous description of the promised Holy Spirit.

“And suddenly there came from the sky a noise like a strong driving wind, and it filled the entire house in which they were.”

Those who meditate on Scripture will find all kinds of inspiration such as the Holy Spirit filling the entire house. Couple the idea of house or church with John 14: 25-26.

“I have told you this while I am with you. The Advocate, the Holy Spirit that the Father will send in My name–He will teach you everything and remind you of all that I told you.”

Follow this with Acts 2: 4.

“And they were all filled with the Holy Spirit and began to speak in different tongues, as the Spirit enabled them to proclaim.”

Here are Mary and the Apostles, wide-eyed as the tongues as of fire parted and came to rest on each one of them. Later, outside with the crowd, Peter reminds them of the prophet Joel. “God says, 'that I will pour out a portion of my spirit upon all flesh…” Acts 2: 14-47.

What did the people in the upper room proclaim? Praise? Thanksgiving? Complete commitment to Jesus the Nazorean? Only the Holy Spirit could enable these “hiding” Apostles to pray with full confidence. As we read in verse 4 above, they began to speak in different tongues, as the Spirit enabled them to proclaim. Outside, a crowd of devout Jews were gathering. Inside, the Apostles were yielding their own voices so that the Holy Spirit could transform their prayers to God.

The above is a prayerful description of the first time, the first Pentecost, that the Holy Spirit gave the gift of Prayer Tongues. The same Gift of Prayer Tongues appears in Chapter 10 of Acts. And this same Gift of Prayer Tongues is available to us ordinary folks.
 
Thank you to the posters who have graciously presented the opposition to the Catholic Charismatic Renewal. It is obvious that now everyone has seen enough information to make up their own minds.
Thank you to all.
**Amen dear sister (you may be a Granny but I’m a GREAT Grandpa, by the grace of God. Again, you’ve struck the nail on the head. I once asked the Lord, “why did you create Satan, Lord, life on earth would be lovely and peaceful without that beast?”. The lord answered, “Because I love you (plural), Ian.:confused: I puzzled over this for years; then a few years later, the Lord said to me (in church!) " I an, the time for softly-softly evangelisation is over: everyone has had 2000 years of Jesus and more of Satan. Tell them its time to choose: Jesus or Satan.” I realized then how scrupulously fair is our Lord: having given us free will, he then created an alternative choice. Jesus or Satan. Right now there seems to be another free-will choice for His beloved people: Charismatic Revival or Tradition. As Grannymh says: everyone has seen enough on this thread to make up their own minds.
BTW Many years ago, out of the blue, the Lord gave me this reading: Ezekiel 33:7 -9: “I have made you a watchman; so hear the Word I speak and give them warning from Me. When I say to the wicked, “O wicked man you will surely die"and you do not speak out to dissuade him from his ways, that wicked man will die for his sin, and I will hold you accountable for his blood. But if you do warn the wicked man to turn from his ways and he does not do so, he will die for his sin, but you will be saved yourself.” I am not the only Charismatic Christian who has been given this task: I wouldn’t be surprised if Grannymh is another. Anyone else?
PS I’ve mentioned this before, but permit me to re-iterate: why has the gift of tongues been the single source of misunderstanding? There are the other gifts, notably the gift of healing: witness to a healing performed by JESUS via the hands of a Born Again Charismatic is proof enough that Jesus is alive and well, living, caring and healing down your street - it doesn’t HAVE to be a church. And when YOU lay hands on an ailing person and personally watch a dramatic healing (as I have done) you will look at your own hands and say “how did I do that?” and then you’ll know the power of Jesus’ love for all.
Then there is driving out of demons, sometimes a disgusting sight to witness: I have seen the possessed crawl like dogs, spew and even defecate before the Name of Jesus ORDERS him bound and kicked out. Which is why the command - in the name of Jesus - must BIND the evil beast and force him to leave quietly. In my first case, the woman was hurled back a dozen feet to end up back to the wall. No she wasn’t hurt, thank you Lord, but I never knew about “BINDING”. Don’t you guys want to heal your loved ones (which should be EVERYONE), but more especially the ones who your tears, sympathy and pity reach out to. When Jesus healed, he often “felt pity” according to the English translation of the NT. In Greek, " he felt in his intestines”: I’ve found Jesus healings most effective when I am forewarned by the Holy Spirit by feeling sympathy deep in my guts.
**

I doubt if this is an original thought, but I believe that prayer tongues is dependent on a deep relationship with the Holy Spirit. To understand this relationship one needs to meditate on the Catholic Sacrament of Baptism. I remember a presenter asking: “How many of you prayed today for the graces of your Baptism?”
In my case I humbly asked Jesus to take over my sin-filled life. He did and then led me to an infilling of the Holy Spirit. It was through the Holy Spirit that I was given the grace of a deep relationship with the Father, Jesus AND the Holy Spirit. For some time I wondered Who to approach to for specific prayers. One day, on a high returning from Communion, I suddenly KNEW that the Father, Jesus and the Holy Spirit are one and the same God and it doesn’t really matter to whom one directs one prayers. But then tongues gets rid of any problem: tongues is a personal hot-line to God. Period.

Prayer tongues is not the only way to pray to God. Yet, there is a basic humility to all prayer. To say the words “Our Father” calls us to humility since we are creatures dependent on our Creator.
Tongues will lead you to that deeper relationship with God and pretty soon you find yourself TALKING in English or any language you choose to God. A comfortable personal chat as with a close friend or, indeed FATHER. Prayer becomes an unburdening to the ultimate Spiritual Confessor, the Holy Spirit Hisself!😉
 
I am a Secular Carmelite, nothing more, but I do uphold the Church’s teaching that the movement is approved, and I will support anyone who belongs it, since it their lawful right not to be persecuted by those who willfully reject it.
Would you do me a favor? I would like to know a few basic facts about Secular Carmelites. About when did the Carmelite Order begin? And why does it currently draw people. I could look this up but I would prefer a brief firsthand experience of their spirituality way of life.

Brief is the operative word because I do not want to go off topic. Yet, I see a relationship between them and the Catholic Charismatic Renewal. There is a unity of purpose in that both emphasize giving one’s life to God.

I have been doing some research and came across interesting ideas regarding movements per se. Usually a movement arises from a specific founder or a close knit group. It is humanly explainable in terms of historical, sociological, spiritual factors. While we do not normally think of Saints as founders of “movements” yet, they impacted past and present history.

Are you aware of the statement – God raised up Saints? As I explore the meaning of God raised up Saints, I am beginning to see a positive response to those who favor the cessation theory of the First Pentecost in that the “charismatic” gifts were only meant for Apostolic times.

John 14: 18. “I will not leave you orphans;”

To understand a “Renewal” one has to be aware of the history between the original Pentecost and the Second Pentecost which is the “agent” of the renewal. For example, how did the Carmelites add to the riches of Catholicism?

That history between two Pentecosts is filled with mystics. Mystics totally yield themselves to our Triune God. With the contemporary renewal of praying in tongues, we can choose to yield our speech mechanisms to the Holy Spirit. This is one of many ways, we can yield to our Creator. Not all of us are a “Francis” or a “Faustina”. But all of us can choose some way to yield to God. Secular Carmelites are an example of yielding to God.

John 14: 15. “If you love me, you will keep my commandments.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top