Catholic tongues advice

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dutch_H
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Dear grannymh,

Cordial greetings and a very good day. Thankyou for the above reponse.

There was, dear sister, a sort of Catholic appropriation of Fundamentalist Pentecostalism when in the ecumenical frenzy of the late 60’s, students at Pittsburgh’s Duquesne University began exposing themselves to Protestant Pentecostal influences because of spiritual aridity. Apparently they were envious of the ‘changed lives’ among many Protestant friends and decided to pray for a similar experience. An unsupervised weekend retreat in 1967 proved to be the key to their answer. Various people approached various Protestant ministers, laity and prayer groups and all received “the Baptism of the Spirit” after having heretical hands laid upon them. Those viewing this thread should note the Protestant roots of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal movement.
Note to Readers:
Post 39 by Itwin has an excellent explanation on Pentecostalism.
forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=9791433&postcount=39

May I remind you, Portrait, that I have replied to your description of the early days of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal in posts 26, 27, 33, 34, 43, 44, 47, and 48.

And yes, the phrase “checking out the Pentecostal experience” is the correct description for the first year of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal. Was this right or wrong? One is certainly entitled to evaluate the situation. In any case, the Holy Spirit survived.

For those interested in the early days of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal,
here is a valuable link.
brendancase.com/uploads/Key_to_the_Charismatic_Renewal.pdf
 
At the Duquesne retreat, the Catholics who attended it were overcome with the Spirit and they ended up in the chapel where they were all drawn to our Lord in the Blessed Sacrament. That unforgettable and powerful experience was the true beginning of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal!

This was not mentioned in Portrait’s description. Instead it was stated that heretics brought these Catholics in to the renewal.
 
Thank you for bringing this up. What are your Scripture references?

Up front, I will declare that my question is like a trick question which those who understand “Tongues” will recognize. Still, I have the right to ask for references.

Please note that the situation that you are describing is separate from the two gifts which employ Tongues. Nonetheless, people are interested in it which accounts for the different opinions as to whether or not that situation is biblical.

Therefore,
if anyone has the references for this gift, please post them. I do not want this to turn into a debate. I simply recognize that there are plenty of people who know Scripture better than I do.
Dear grannymh,

Hello again and thankyou for your above response. May I also thankyou, dear friend, for your polite replies in this discussion, especially given the jolly contentious nature of our topic.

The authentic ‘tongues’ of the N.T. was never gibberish or ecstatic utterances. Exactly the same word (glossa) is used in the Greek text of I Corinthians 14 as in the account of the initial Pentecostal outpouring of Acts 2, where the hearers from diverse regions indisputably heard a variety genuine earthly languages spoken.

In verses 10 and 11 of First Corinthians 14 St. Paul makes reference to the multitude of different languages, each which has a clear and distinct meaning. Most conclusively of all, his citation from the Book of Isaiah in verse 21 takes us to the period in Israel’s history when the people of God heard what seemed to them the gibberish of the Assyrian language , but which was nevertheless authentic speech. This is seen as a parallel with the uncomprehending listener who hears a man speaking in ‘tongues’, which may sound like gibberish, but is in fact genuine speech, an earthly language of some description. Thus the manifestation of tongues at Corinth is synonymous with what occured on the Day of Pentecost.

The tongues of the N.T. then, dear friend, were unkown human languages (such as, for example, Latin or French) and not some supernatural heavenly language, as Pentecostalists are wont to assert. The appeal that is usually made to I Corinthians 13: 1 - “If I speak in the tongues of men and of angels” - to support the theory that the glossolalia of the N.T. may have been supernatural speech cannot be sustained. In First Corinthians 13, which shows that the Christian Way is pre-eminently the way of love, St. Paul is making use of hyperbole for rhetorical purposes and using exaggerated statements that should not be taken literally. He is merely saying that without love even the most impressive display of religious emotion is of no value.

Incontrovertably, dear friend, the ‘tongues’ of the N.T. were known earthly dialects and not some strange supernatural language which men, under the influence of the Spirit, spoke or sang in.

God bless.

Warmest good wishes,

Portrait

Pax
 
At the Duquesne retreat, the Catholics who attended it were overcome with the Spirit and they ended up in the chapel where they were all drawn to our Lord in the Blessed Sacrament. That unforgettable and powerful experience was the true beginning of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal!

This was not mentioned in Portrait’s description. Instead it was stated that heretics brought these Catholics in to the renewal.
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you for this wonderful reminder of the beginning of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal. Our Lord in the Blessed Sacrament reminds me of the Last Supper where He promised to send the Holy Spirit.
 
Dear grannymh,

Cordial greetings and a very good day. Thankyou for the above reponse.

There was, dear sister, a sort of Catholic appropriation of Fundamentalist Pentecostalism when in the ecumenical frenzy of the late 60’s, students at Pittsburgh’s Duquesne University began exposing themselves to Protestant Pentecostal influences because of spiritual aridity. Apparently they were envious of the ‘changed lives’ among many Protestant friends and decided to pray for a similar experience. An unsupervised weekend retreat in 1967 proved to be the key to their answer. Various people approached various Protestant ministers, laity and prayer groups and all received “the Baptism of the Spirit” after having heretical hands laid upon them. Those viewing this thread should note the Protestant roots of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal movement.

Indeed, dear friend, the importance of this action cannot be oversestimated. These Catholic students submitted themselves to a non-Catholic quasi-sacramental rite - obviously a mockery of the Sacrament of Confirmation - and the emotional high brought about by this convinced them of the holiness of the whole experience. They were now* Catholic* Pentecostalists and their influence soon spread far and wide, first on the college campuses and then to the world at large.

If ever there was a compelling argument for listening to Holy Mother Church, then this is surely it, dear friend. The Church has unceasingly warned the faithful to steer clear of heretical ‘worship’ for almost 2000 years because she knows fully well what the consequences will be, both for the individual and the wider Church. Notwithstanding, the CCR unabashedly admits and even extols its Protestant roots! Alas, this what happens when Catholics who ought to know better “check out a Pentecostal experience”.

Baptizing the pernicious Pentecostal heresy does not ipso facto render it acceptable and holy for Catholics. Unfortunately, dear friend, the CCR movement is a blighted tree bearing poisonous fruit, sown by the Devil among Fundamentalist Protestants and then transplanted into the Catholic Church by some misguided students back in 1967.
Yes. It is quite obvious that the roots of this movement originate in the heretical pentecostalist sect. I have seen CCR services where people are waving their arms, falling down in convulsions, and swaying to popular music as the priest speaks gibberish. It is not recognizable as any type of Liturgical service.

The Catholic Pentecostal movement began when four Catholic lay faculty members of Duquesne University attended a Pentecostal prayer meeting conducted by Episcopalians and Presbyterians in a Pittsburgh suburb in February, 1967. The four Catholic participants asked to have hands laid on them. A prayer group was then established at Notre Dame University. In January, 1971, a Charismatic Renewal Conference netted 4,000 registered participants, one-fourth of whom were priests and nuns.
 
The tongues of the N.T. then, dear friend, were unkown human languages (such as, for example, Latin or French) and not some supernatural heavenly language, as Pentecostalists are wont to assert.
Correct.

For the Orthodox Christians, the “Baptism of the Spirit” is the sacrament of Chrismation. The gifts of the spirit - including the miraculous ability to speak in other languages - are given by God to the Church when it is necessary to the life and well being of the Church. Also the gifts are made manifest in us in proportion to our own perfection. Thus the saints have at times when necessary exhibited the gifts of the Spirit. Those of us who are still not perfected will rarely manifest the “gifts of the spirit” for we ourselves have not yet acquired an abundance of the Holy Spirit. In all, it is more important to acquire the Holy Spirit rather than the “gifts of the Spirit”. The phenomenon of “praying in the Spirit” as it is taught by the pentecostal/charismatics group teach is in fact foreign to the Church, rather “praying in the Spirit” is achieved though the practice of prayer and ascetic labor and is experienced only by those advanced in the faith.

As for the specific gift of “speaking in tongues” or more clearly the ability to speak in other languages which have not been learned, we have seen it in the lives of some of the spiritual elders (startsi or gerondas) but it is always a known language spoken in the context of communicating the grace of God to someone with whom they do not share a common language. And it almost always seems that neither party is aware that such a miracle has occurred. It is not the meaningless emotional babble that some people pass off as an imitation of the real thing. In that way lies deception.
Fr David Moser
 
At the Duquesne retreat, the Catholics who attended it were overcome with the Spirit and they ended up in the chapel where they were all drawn to our Lord in the Blessed Sacrament. That unforgettable and powerful experience was the true beginning of the Catholic Charismatic Renewal!

This was not mentioned in Portrait’s description. Instead it was stated that heretics brought these Catholics in to the renewal.
Dear Dorothy,

Cordial greetings and a very good day.

As the link provided by grannymh at the end of #60 states, dear friend, those student Catholics were led to pray with a Protestant Pentecostal group in Pittsburgh. At length they requested to be prayed with (by Protestant Pentecostals) for the ‘Baptism of the Spirit’, a distinctly Protestant theory and mockery of the Sacrament of confirmation.

It admits of no doubt, dear friend, that the Catholic Charismatic Renewal owes its origin to the influence of heretical Pentecostalism and it can never sever this connection.

God bless.

Warmest good wishes,

Portrait

Pax
 
No matter how one looks at this or that event in history – the fact remains that the Catholic Charismatic Renewal is based on the teachings of St. Paul.

Being reminded about the power of the Holy Spirit in 1967 has me in awe.
Those who attended the retreat must have been courageous beyond belief.
On the other hand, these people must have been very, very humble.

And yes, there have been extremes in the Catholic Charismatic Renewal. Apparently, in my town a whole group left the Church. Yet – the fact remains that both the Catholic Church and the Holy Spirit are still around. And yes, the CCR Life in the Spirit Seminar is still bringing Catholics back to the Church through the Sacrament of Reconciliation.
 
It admits of no doubt, dear friend, that the Catholic Charismatic Renewal owes its origin to the influence of heretical Pentecostalism and it can never sever this connection.
Yes. And I have one other observation. The charismatic movement reveals emotional outbursts such as gibberish tongues, tingling limbs, laughing/convulsions, hand waving, etc. If you were to relate this to one of the Fathers of the Church…I believe he would tell you that it is demonic in origin or delusional at least. The Eastern Fathers have a word for it…it’s called prelest.
 
St John Chrysostom regarded the whole phenomenon of ‘speaking in tongues’ as not only something that was not practiced in his own day, but was even obscure:

“This whole phenomenon [of speaking in tongues] is very obscure, but the obscurity is produced by our ignorance of the facts referred to and by their cessation, being such then as used to occur but now no longer take place. And why do they not happen now? Why look now, the cause too of the obscurity hath produced us again another question: namely, why did they then happen, and now do so no more”?
 
Yes. It is quite obvious that the roots of this movement originate in the heretical pentecostalist sect. I have seen CCR services where people are waving their arms, falling down in convulsions, and swaying to popular music as the priest speaks gibberish. It is not recognizable as any type of Liturgical service.

The Catholic Pentecostal movement began when four Catholic lay faculty members of Duquesne University attended a Pentecostal prayer meeting conducted by Episcopalians and Presbyterians in a Pittsburgh suburb in February, 1967. The four Catholic participants asked to have hands laid on them. A prayer group was then established at Notre Dame University. In January, 1971, a Charismatic Renewal Conference netted 4,000 registered participants, one-fourth of whom were priests and nuns.
Dear Mickey,

Cordial greetings and a very good day. Thankyou for your splendid (name removed by moderator)ut into the current discussion.

Indeed, Charistmatic style services are frequently irreverent and would never have been tolerated within the Church prior to the 1960’s. Did not St. Paul say as regards divine worship, “Let all things be done decently and in order”.

We are not obligated, dear friend, to accept the claims of Pentecostalism (the Protestant or Catholic variety) uncritically and St. Paul exhorts us to “test everything; hold fast what is good” (I Thess 5: 21). Pentecostalism is an ecclesial movement of interdenominational congregations, which are wont to gather in sports arenas and other large venues to be thrilled and emotionally ‘lifted’ by raucous music and the ministry of ‘anointed’ preachers, many of whom are Protestant clerics. The entire Pentecostal movement is, as with other Pentecostal groupings in the past, founded on a clearly heterodox pneumatological conception of the Church, which regards the institution of the Catholic Church as but a visible manifestation, however admirable, of a pre-existent pan-denominational “union of the Holy Spirit” with objective heretics.

Alas, dear friend, this grotesquerie has penetrated many parts of the Western Catholic Church and has been the occasion of much deep division among the faithful, which surely evinces most plainly that something is very wrong with it.

Thankyou for those additional details of the undeniable Protestant origins of the CCR., from which it can never be disassociated.

God bless.

Warmest good wishes,

Portrait

Pax
 
The entire Pentecostal movement is, as with other Pentecostal groupings in the past, founded on a clearly heterodox pneumatological conception of the Church, which regards the institution of the Catholic Church as but a visible manifestation, however admirable, of a pre-existent pan-denominational “union of the Holy Spirit” with objective heretics.

Alas, dear friend, this grotesquerie has penetrated many parts of the Western Catholic Church and has been the occasion of much deep division among the faithful, which surely evinces most plainly that something is very wrong with it.

Thankyou for those additional details of the undeniable Protestant origins of the CCR., from which it can never be disassociated.
Yes indeed, Portrait. I have not been able to find any evidence that the odd practices which occur in pentecostal services has ever been documented in the early Church. St Paul is certainly not condoning these types of behaviors. The only evidence I can find originates from the heretic Montanus.

“He [Montanus] became possessed of a spirit, and suddenly began to rave in a kind of ecstatic trance, and to babble in a jargon, prophesying in a manner contrary to the custom of the Church which had been handed down by tradition from the earliest times.” (Eusebius, d.c.339)
 
To understand the differences between Pentecostalism which refers to the First Pentecost described in Acts, the Pentecostal churches which are also known as the “third force” in Christianity, and Protestantism, one should skip the “cherry picking” and start with the beginning of the Link.
brendancase.com/uploads/Key_to_the_Charismatic_Renewal.pdf
 
The following book is a thorough study of “Baptism in the Holy Spirit” and the charisms in the early Church. It includes; Tertullian in his Catholic years, Hilary of Poitiers, Basil, Gregory Nazianzus, Cyril of Jerusalem, John Chrysostom, Philoxenus, John of Apamea, Theodoret of Cyrrhus, Severus of Antioch, and Joseph Hzaazya. They represent Latin, Greek, and Syrian cultures, almost the whole of the Mediterranean seaboard.

Christian Initiation and Baptism in the Holy Spirit
Evidence from the First Eight Centuries

ISBN 0-8146-5009-0
by Kilian McDonnell, O.S.B. and George Montague, S.M.
 
It admits of no doubt, dear friend, that the Catholic Charismatic Renewal owes its origin to the influence of heretical Pentecostalism and it can never sever this connection.
😦
 
I think your experience was great! Worship the way in which you find a closeness to Christ. I attend a predominately Af. Am. parish and it a great experience.Not boring like many parishes i’ve attended. The Mass is lively with liturgical dancing and full of the holy spirit.
 
I think your experience was great! Worship the way in which you find a closeness to Christ. I attend a predominately Af. Am. parish and it a great experience.*** Not boring like many parishes i’ve attended.*** !] The Mass is lively with*** liturgical dancing *** [a liturgical abuse] and full of the holy spirit.
Must be a real circus! :eek:
Do you understand what the Mass is?
 
Thank you to the posters who have graciously presented the opposition to the Catholic Charismatic Renewal. It is obvious that now everyone has seen enough information to make up their own minds.
Thank you to all.

Regarding the OP – “Catholic tongues advice”

Posts 52 and 58 contain some interesting comments about Catholic tongues.

forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=9794719&postcount=52

forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=9798863&postcount=58

I doubt if this is an original thought, but I believe that prayer tongues is dependent on a deep relationship with the Holy Spirit. To understand this relationship one needs to meditate on the Catholic Sacrament of Baptism. I remember a presenter asking: “How many of you prayed today for the graces of your Baptism?”

Prayer tongues is not the only way to pray to God. Yet, there is a basic humility to all prayer. To say the words “Our Father” calls us to humility since we are creatures dependent on our Creator.
 
Dear Grannymh,

Thank you for all of your hard efforts in this thread; it is sincerely appreciated. If one were to “test the Spirits,” it is clear which poster is demonstrating the Spirit’s fruits here. Your posts don’t require the syrupy greeting and warmest good wishes to make your message more palatable.

Wisdom indicates that we leave the naysayers to their own braying. Clearly, the Church has spoken, yet they remain free to attack Her guidance.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top