Challenge from a Skeptic re: Miracles

  • Thread starter Thread starter PRmerger
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Im sorry JN Cherie, I didn’t realize that was you, and I believe you, faith is absolutly necessary. But is the skeptic saying that it is no longer necessary once proof is provided?
The skeptics won’t be clear, except that they are skeptical of any evidence that isn’t in today’s scientific articles, accepted by today’s skeptical scientists…who believe nothing even if the truth slapps them in the face. If it doesn’t back up what they choose to believe…or disbelieve…according to their own agenda, it is given no credit. And anything that they cannot prove is against their agenda. That is what I have come to understand about the scientists that the skeptics on this thread are in need of acceptance from.

Their point and denial has no place in the truth.

As I believe, without approval from the scientists of today’s world, that Christ Jesus rose from the dead and ascended into heaven after dying on the Cross to take upon Himself the punishment for my sins…I believe that the stigmata of Christ on Padre Pio is truth.
I believe because I know Christ Jesus personally.
And I pray that they, too, will come to know Him personally.
 
there is no reason for the argument as the Vatican does not need to use what “you” consider objective evidence.

It does if it wants to be taken seriously by non-Catholics.
Jesus N Cherie;4046849:
Many of today’s “academic evidence scientistis” do not believe in what is right in front of them if it disproves what they want to be the truth.
Thats quite the naked assertion. Care to provide some evidence?
They are not interested in the truth, only interested in appearing correct in order to keep those of you who follow faithfully.
Absolutely correct. This is why your computer is faith powered am I right?:rolleyes:
This doesn’t mean it is any less true. It is a matter of faith for the faithful. And it is backed up by scientific and medical evidence done by many who were not Catholic.

No scientific peer-revied journals were published, ergo it is not scientific.
Jesus N Cherie;4046849:
As I said, the Catholic Church is not stupid, and it had to be proven by those who would be very skeptical before being accepted as truth. The fact is, skeptic medical doctors and scientific researchers could not explain it. It is an accepted miracle, as are many others.
The Hindu drinking statues are also accepted by many people. Neither however, are accepted by the academic community, so they are both only miracles in the eyes of believers.
Something that bleeds often, without a wound is not medically or scientifically possible. And there are no scars.
Not to sound cheeky, but have you never heard of a period?😃
Just because you have not yet been shown the pictures (as if that would make you accept it) of Padre Pio’s hands when they were not bleeding, does not make it any less true.
Yep, pictures mean everything. I guess David Blaine really can conjure magic then eh?:rolleyes:
Although you may not have started the thread, you argued for the OP. And after realizing that it would take time and much research to find the evidence for you, I realized that if you were in need of it, I could point you in the correct direction…and you could do the research yourself.

Odd. When you requested that I evidenced my claims, I did.
Jesus N Cherie;4046849:
I have better things to do with my time than do the research for you. I have no need of the research myself, since I have no problem believing the truth…which is that miracles are indeed true…example of Padre Pio.
So you’re being lazy? Why even bother to pretend to have a discussion if your going to be intellectually lazy?:confused:

PS. To quote specific paragraphs, you need to
NAME etc etc. then end with [ /quote:
, for every paragraph.
 
My apologese. I got confused as you keep saying this.

There was nothing that I said to give that impression, as I kept saying how important faith is.

Objective evidence tends to render faith in something meaningless as it now becomes demonstrable.

For ex. If I told you I could jump 30 feet into the air, but only on certain days and in private. You could only take my word on faith.

If I jumped 30 feet in the air in front of a crowd of people and it was confirmed by scientists that its no trick, then objective evidence exists and no faith is required as I can simply show the person the evidence.
So what you are saying is that faith is unimportant. I totally disagree. If you do not believe unless there is scientific evidence of something, it takes no faith. You reject it. If you recieved the evidence of Padre Pio, evidence that could not explain the stigmata, you would still not believe it. But then you couldn’t argue the point either. And I believe that this is the reason why you do not do the research. It is the life of a skeptic to want to continue to deny the truth, even in the face of true evidence. Faith would still be required in order to believe, because it seems to be too unbelievable to accept. Which is why I doubt that the skeptics would accept it.
 
It does if it wants to be taken seriously by non-Catholics.

It is the loss of those who do not believe. It affects me not at all, except in my prayers for them.

Thats quite the naked assertion. Care to provide some evidence?

Evolution.

Absolutely correct. This is why your computer is faith powered am I right?:rolleyes:

My computer is not faith powered. How does that fit into the argument you present?

No scientific peer-revied journals were published, ergo it is not scientific.

Have you checked every single scientific journal since 1960 published everywhere in the world? Would medical journals do?
And explain to me why they would publish something on a valid miracle. It is not scientific…it is miraculous and spiritual. They talk about science in those journals…not things that cannot be proven with science. Just like they don’t teach miracles in medical school. They spend time teaching about medicine in medical school.


The Hindu drinking statues are also accepted by many people. Neither however, are accepted by the academic community, so they are both only miracles in the eyes of believers.

Have their been as many tests done on those fountains as there have been on the stigmata of Padre Pio? Oh, wait. You haven’t done the research on Padre Pio to possibly have the knowledge to answer that?

Not to sound cheeky, but have you never heard of a period?😃

Why? What you quoted was grammatically correct.

Yep, pictures mean everything. I guess David Blaine really can conjure magic then eh?:rolleyes:

Never heard of him. I know that any power that does not come from God is evil.

Odd. When you requested that I evidenced my claims, I did.

I looked on the website you provided. That gave neither dates, nor interviews with the afflicted in a way that was explained at all. It was a jumble of words, and not making much sense. I couldn’t tell who the person was talking about, when it happened, or where the person was. A general location of Europe would not be sufficient, but that is what they might as well have said. They gave no evidence at all. And if that kind of evidence is all you need, simply because it may have been found in one of your journals, then you should have no problem believing about the miracles of Padre Pio. The Church did a very medical and scientific profile of all that was involved with Padre Pio. You just have to do the research.

So you’re being lazy? Why even bother to pretend to have a discussion if your going to be intellectually lazy?:confused:

I am not the one who needs the proof. If there was something I wanted to know about, why should I attack other’s beliefs in order to get them to do my research for me? I am not the one being lazy. It would help you to understand exactly where the evidence came from, and how it was proven correct if you do the research. We have already told you where to go in order to find the evidence YOU seek.

PS. To quote specific paragraphs, you need to
NAME etc etc. then end with [ /quote:
, for every paragraph.
 
Sometimes they are fictional accounts. Sometimes it is natural phenomena… and sometimes they are hoaxes.

Actually, things that have been proved, I have no problem with.

**They aren’t. What it is more credible when someone looks at the experience of many people without bias to success.

Let’s say I pray to Zeus, and my hypoglycemia goes away. I conclude that it is because I prayed to Zeus. You can’t conclude it isn’t just based on the fact that Zeus hasn’t blessed you.

However, if you get 1,000,000 million people who have illnesses to pray to Zeus, and the number that gets better is consistent with chance, then you have good reason to think that Zeus had nothing to do with my cure.**
This is an excellent point.

Just because something “miraculous” occurs, even if you can prove beyond all doubt that there is no scientific explanation, you’re still left having to prove who/what was responsible for this miracle. Faith, which is mentioned a lot in this thread, is an essential part of this question. If I pray to Isis and what I pray for comes to pass, then I can say that my faith in Isis was a prime motivator. IOW, other religions have miracles too and they credit their god(s). So, even if miracles do happen, there is no way to prove (other than faith, which I just covered) that is was necessarily your “God” that was responsible. 🤷
 
This is an excellent point.

Just because something “miraculous” occurs, even if you can prove beyond all doubt that there is no scientific explanation, you’re still left having to prove who/what was responsible for this miracle. Faith, which is mentioned a lot in this thread, is an essential part of this question. If I pray to Isis and what I pray for comes to pass, then I can say that my faith in Isis was a prime motivator. IOW, other religions have miracles too and they credit their god(s). So, even if miracles do happen, there is no way to prove (other than faith, which I just covered) that is was necessarily your “God” that was responsible. 🤷
Thanks, I only wish in retrospect that I had taken more time proofreading it before posting. 😛

Despite what some people are claiming, I don’t have a problem with people having faith in God. What I have a problem with is people who say, “I don’t need to prove it because I have faith. But I have proof as well.” If you are going to claim it is a matter of faith, then we have no argument. If you are claiming that you have proof, then you have to prove it.

You can’t say, “I have proof, but I don’t need to prove it to you. You have to show that I am wrong.” Well, you can, just don’t expect to be taken seriously.
 
Thanks, I only wish in retrospect that I had taken more time proofreading it before posting. 😛

Despite what some people are claiming, I don’t have a problem with people having faith in God. What I have a problem with is people who say, “I don’t need to prove it because I have faith. But I have proof as well.” If you are going to claim it is a matter of faith, then we have no argument. If you are claiming that you have proof, then you have to prove it.

You can’t say, “I have proof, but I don’t need to prove it to you. You have to show that I am wrong.” Well, you can, just don’t expect to be taken seriously.
Yes, the idea that because I don’t have faith then I can be convinced through some sort of convoluted logic makes no sense to me. And that I have to somehow demonstrate how my lack of faith is logical from their point of view is nonsensical. Religion is based on faith. Either you have it or you don’t. I also find the suggestion that I’d have faith if I just tried a little harder to be insulting. I’m bipolar and suffer from extreme depression and I liken the above to folks to tell me that I’d feel better if I’d just “cheer up”. It presumes a lot.
 
Objective evidence tends to render faith in something meaningless as it now becomes demonstrable.

For ex. If I told you I could jump 30 feet into the air, but only on certain days and in private. You could only take my word on faith.

If I jumped 30 feet in the air in front of a crowd of people and it was confirmed by scientists that its no trick, then objective evidence exists and no faith is required as I can simply show the person the evidence.
This is a good example. But lets say this…

For years you tell everyone that you can jump 30 feet in the air. Some people believe, some don’t. Then one day you decide to do it once. At this point you jump and tens of people see it and believe you finally. You declare you are going to do it again next week. Hundreds of people show up and witness your second jump and are super excited. They become obsessive and want your autograph and want you to do a private jump for them. After this event you don’t want to show anyone again because you don’t want the publicity, and it might lose its mystery. So you stop and years later you pass away. Now, it was a fact that you had jumped 30 feet, but only a few hundred people had witnessed it, and there were no television crews or handheld cameras or youtube fans there, so there is no evidence in the future. The people that witnessed it all tell their kids and grandkids and it gets passed on and on and on. Now, 400 years after the even, what does anyone have to prove you actually jumped 30 feet in the air?
 
Sideline:

I just wanted to let you know I don’t believe that you are actually an individual that is posting on the forum. I think it’s a hoax. In fact I think everyone beside me on this forum topic is the same person posting to themselves on different accounts to generate a discussion. Can you prove me wrong? I want undeniable proof and I have to see it with my own eyes, I don’t care if 10’s, 100’s, or 1000’s of people claim they have seen you write you and only your posts. Once again, I must see it for myself, with my own eyes.
 
Sideline:

I just wanted to let you know I don’t believe that you are actually an individual that is posting on the forum. I think it’s a hoax. In fact I think everyone beside me on this forum topic is the same person posting to themselves on different accounts to generate a discussion. Can you prove me wrong? I want undeniable proof and I have to see it with my own eyes, I don’t care if 10’s, 100’s, or 1000’s of people claim they have seen you write you and only your posts. Once again, I must see it for myself, with my own eyes.
Make it worth my while, and I’ll give you directions to my apartment.
 
But see there you go. To obtain this proof of which you and I seek we must travel. In my case of skepticism I’d have to travel to your apartment as you recommend. I then recommend to you, to obtain the proof you seek, you must travel time and place. This is because these things of which we speak happened in the past. Likewise if you died today I would have to travel both time and place to obtain the proof I seek about you. The fact is that from the position I’m currently in (in front of my computer in the present) I cannot obtain proof I need to relieve my skepticism. If this argument of skepticism can be made about anything (as I just demonstrated), how can you hold our beliefs to a torch? In fact I bet there have existed more people who claim to have witnessed definitive proof of a certain miracle than there are people who claim to have witnessed definitive proof that you have only been on your account and everyone else in this forum are indeed real people.

Do you get what I’m saying?
 
(Oh and as a side note: Even if I went to your apartment, how could you actually PROVE to me you haven’t created all these accounts yourself and have only been on the account by the name Sideline?)
 
But see there you go. To obtain this proof of which you and I seek we must travel. In my case of skepticism I’d have to travel to your apartment as you recommend. I then recommend to you, to obtain the proof you seek, you must travel time and place. This is because these things of which we speak happened in the past. Likewise if you died today I would have to travel both time and place to obtain the proof I seek about you. The fact is that from the position I’m currently in (in front of my computer in the present) I cannot obtain proof I need to relieve my skepticism. If this argument of skepticism can be made about anything (as I just demonstrated), how can you hold our beliefs to a torch? In fact I bet there have existed more people who claim to have witnessed definitive proof of a certain miracle than there are people who claim to have witnessed definitive proof that you have only been on your account and everyone else in this forum are indeed real people.

Do you get what I’m saying?
Yeah, I got what you were saying immediately. It’s just not very interesting, and I’m tired of playing silly games with people.

It’s true there are things we take for granted in order to function in the world. We have to take it on faith that Richard III was a real person because we can’t prove it. But I’m not asking you to believe anything supernatural in asking you to take that on faith.

I’m not saying that he walked on water, bilocated, or shot lightening bolts out of his eyes. If I did, it would be incumbent on me to prove to you that those things were possible. If I couldn’t do that, then you shouldn’t believe me.

If you can’t see the difference between what I’m asking you to take on faith, and what you are asking me to take on faith, then go ahead and live in whatever fantasy world gives you comfort. Just don’t expect me to join you there.
 
Basically what I’m saying is that everything is faith because most of the time we can’t prove what we believe. If you believe in the Holocaust, were you actually there, can you prove it first-hand? I get your point and I know you get mine. But what you perhaps haven’t come to a realization of yet, is that you don’t need to be Christian or a theist at all to have faith. Your beliefs, especially of past events, you believe because you have faith in the source that you have heard it from. People believe the Holocaust happened because that’s what their teachers, the media, and everyone else said. They might not have seen it, but they have faith that it actually happened. The only difference between you and I is who is a reputable source. And by the way the Holocaust is completely unrelated, I’m just using that as a large historical event.
 
Yes, the idea that because I don’t have faith then I can be convinced through some sort of convoluted logic makes no sense to me. And that I have to somehow demonstrate how my lack of faith is logical from their point of view is nonsensical. Religion is based on faith. Either you have it or you don’t. I also find the suggestion that I’d have faith if I just tried a little harder to be insulting. I’m bipolar and suffer from extreme depression and I liken the above to folks to tell me that I’d feel better if I’d just “cheer up”. It presumes a lot.
Swan, my heart goes out to you. I am not trying to be condescending, only honest. I am not bipolar, and I cannot claim to know what you must suffer with being so. You told me on another post yesterday or today that this is a main reason why you have lost any faith or belief you once may have had…if I understood your words correctly.
I think it is important to understand something though. The saints have not had perfect lives. Each individual has his own things in life that the devil will use to destroy the true faith of Christ Jesus. That is not to downplay what you have to deal with in being bipolar. I say this to bring you hope in Christ. You are not alone, though I imagine that at times you feel that way. God has not abandoned you, though once again I imagine at times you feel like He has.
I have agreed with the fact that no amount of evidence will suffice to make someone believe if they lack faith. No one on the believers side has even implied this. It is one of a few reasons why I will not do the research requested of we believers.
I will continue to pray for you, that a seed may be planted by what you read on CAF by true believers. I pray that you, and the others who do not believe will come to faith in Christ Jesus.
And whether you believe or understand it or not, Jesus created, loves and wants you. He is thinking about and longing for you every millisecond of your existance. He died for love of you. And you are so dear to His Heart that He willingly died for you. Had you been the only one alive on earth, the only one to be saved, He would have suffered His extreme passion and death for you, because that is how much He loves and wants to be with you for all eternity. You are beautifully and wonderfully made…even with your being bipolar. I pray that you try again to pray that He will make Himself known to you. I pray that you will pray for the faith it takes to believe in Him. He is waiting for you.

As He is certainly waiting hopefully for all those who are not walking with Him. Come home. We are waiting to welcome you.
 
Basically what I’m saying is that everything is faith because most of the time we can’t prove what we believe. If you believe in the Holocaust, were you actually there, can you prove it first-hand? I get your point and I know you get mine. But what you perhaps haven’t come to a realization of yet, is that you don’t need to be Christian or a theist at all to have faith. Your beliefs, especially of past events, you believe because you have faith in the source that you have heard it from. People believe the Holocaust happened because that’s what their teachers, the media, and everyone else said. They might not have seen it, but they have faith that it actually happened. The only difference between you and I is who is a reputable source. And by the way the Holocaust is completely unrelated, I’m just using that as a large historical event.
If you re-read my post you’ll see I’ve explained the problem with this already.
 
It’s true there are things we take for granted in order to function in the world.
Yes! Exactly! Skeptics take for granted that you can only be certain of what science has proved. Except science hasn’t proved that.

As Peter Kreeft says: Skeptics are exactly like the fundamentalist Christians who claim “sola scriptura”, except their claim is “sola scientia”. Yet sola scriptura isn’t found in the Bible, and sola scientia can’t be proven either! :whacky:
 
Yes! Exactly! Skeptics take for granted that you can only be certain of what science has proved. Except science hasn’t proved that.

As Peter Kreeft says: Skeptics are exactly like the fundamentalist Christians who claim “sola scriptura”, except their claim is “sola scientia”. Yet sola scriptura isn’t found in the Bible, and sola scientia can’t be proven either! :whacky:
Haha very true, good analogy…
 
Yes! Exactly! Skeptics take for granted that you can only be certain of what science has proved. Except science hasn’t proved that.

As Peter Kreeft says: Skeptics are exactly like the fundamentalist Christians who claim “sola scriptura”, except their claim is “sola scientia”. Yet sola scriptura isn’t found in the Bible, and sola scientia can’t be proven either! :whacky:
Actually, using the scientific method we can demonstrate exactly what science claims. We can demonstrate that it is the most effective method for discovering the truth.

Try any other method you would like, and then go about it methodically in a scientific method. You will find that science works. Try it the next time you are sick. Pray to God to find out why you are sick at the same time as going to the doctor. Then see which one gives you the correct diagnosis first.

Try it several times, or better yet, put a large sampling of people into two different groups. One will pray for a diagnosis, the other will try scientifically tested western medicine. See which one works better.

You see, science can back up it’s claims. That’s why it is popular. Scientists don’t claim to know everything. The only difference is they don’t claim to know what they can’t possibly know… at least good ones don’t.
 
We don’t pray for God to give us a diagnosis? We pray for His healing. And remember, your on a Catholic forum, not some crazy evangelist one. We believe in going to doctors and all and that we, as children of God, have the utmost responsibility to preserve and protect out bodies (gifts of God) as we mortally can.

Also remember that in being Catholics we believe, unlike most Protestant sects, in faith AND reason. The laws of science and of God must not conflict each other - this we know (for obvious, logical reasons). Therefore we must, in our faith, take into account everything which science has proved or theorized to a likely extent. This is most evidently seen in the Catholic Church’s acceptance of the possibility of evolution and clarifying that it wouldn’t contradict anything about our faith.

The scientific method has its uses, but they’re limited. It provides no answers to those bigger questions in life.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top