Climate Change News 2

  • Thread starter Thread starter Theo520
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
But are you OK with it when the majority and the elected official doesn’t agree with you?
That is the challenge for all.

Recently Trump has reversed the course of the prior elected official
 
That is the State of California we are talking about,right?
I understand you withdrew from the Paris agreement,if this is what you mean, that doesn’t mean that you are abandoning optimization of resources and care for the environment. Something US has always been quite a good example of.
Our provinces,also make decisions for the common good and care of resources.( Well…sometimes…).

I am fine with our decision we are pulling foward together as we can with much effort cause now we have to fasten seat belts here,and this administration here inherited much trouble,and empty arks.
Yes,they have my support,flawed and all.

Did I live in a flat or downtown, I would have a set of regulations when building.
As this is a farm/ranch outside CABA,Bs As,our province and municipality have a set of regulations that adapt to this sort of environment.

And I do not see any strange issue there or contradiction either.
None. Just maybe political small letters that I may not grasp.
( Theo,I am a bit disperse today in various activities. If this isn t what you were asking,sorry. Just ask again later,no worries…)
 
Last edited:
I understand you withdrew from the Paris agreement,if this is what you mean, that doesn’t mean that you are abandoning optimization of resources and care for the environment. Something US has always been quite a good example of.
I was thinking of the Paris Accord, not California. It can be very smart for a rural location to harness wind/solar, as you are.

I also agree that we should continue to care for the environment regardless of views on catastrophic global warming projections. Carbon fuels should be burned efficiently and cleanly whenever used
 
Agree,now off to pick up my brother who is undergoing surgery and needs the best choffer in town 😁…Have a great day!
 
But are you OK with it when the majority and the elected official doesn’t agree with you?
That is the challenge for all.
That is part of what it means to be in a society. Not everyone agrees. But we don’t all stamp our feet and hold our breath until we get our way. We do our best to influence that group decision, and then if at all possible, go along with it, even if we are not “OK with it.”
 
That is part of what it means to be in a society. Not everyone agrees. But we don’t all stamp our feet and hold our breath until we get our way.
No, instead we initiate frivolous law suits against the administration, like the state of CA has done 🙂
It’s the equivalent of holding your breath and stamping your feet
 
Last edited:
What I learnt through those who know best( not me…),
is that for alternative energy to have a real impact environmentally,has to be extended,not individual only.
To my dismay…cause I thought our small contributions counted … Not that they don t but it isn t enough.
In this sense,what Leaf is saying about authority makes sense . Someone chosen by the people has to coordinate efforts.
Coordinated? That is an interesting euphemism for dictated.
Alternative energy will work when it is economically feasible, and user convenient. When that happens, the market will work to encourage individuals to make that choice. When government forces things, we get Solyndra.
One may agree or not with the chosen direction,but it is elected authorities.
The question is should the authorities have such powers, to dictate to consumers what choices they make between legal products or services. That smacks more of an abuse of authority.
Personally,we are slowly replacing stuff by solar panels. Bills here have skyrocketed as well for gas and electricity,and we may start small and see how the hybrid works.
We have wind powered water for us and cattle,but this how it is here in the countryside. Not in town.
Want to speed it up? Encourage people to invest in private industries that provide these kinds of products, making them efficient, user friendly, cost effective compared to other sources of energy, and watch the market take over.

.
 
Last edited:
It is polítical, I see it now…
I can also see you do not now my country nor enjoy listening about it.
And third,and I am very glad for you honestly,you have no idea what to be " dictated" is.
No worries. I enjoy participating every now and then here,but not to be used for your political.ping pong. This was a climate change thread,JonNC.
 
Last edited:
It is polítical, I see it now…
I can also see you do not now my country nor enjoy listening about it.
I don’t recall mentioning your country. I don’t even know what country it is. So, enlighten me.
And third,and I am very glad for you honestly,you have no idea what to be " dictated" is.
No worries. I enjoy participating every now and then here,but not to be used for your political.ping pong.
Wait a minute. You posted to me first. There was no ping pong here. I simply responded to what you wrote. How is that using you for political ping pong?
This was a climate change thread,JonNC.
Climate change is a political issue, much more so than it is a scientific issue.
 
Climate change is a political issue, much more so than it is a scientific issue.
If this is how it is seen,and not about people,environment, sharing resources and life in this earth, then we have misunderstandings.
And if mine was one, I apologize.
It isn t a political issue as from the people,the books,the authorities,the representatives from alternative energy resources,local and foreign and authors I have had the pleasure to listen to and/ or meet.
Sometimes we happen to be blessed almost by chance and unmerited.
It is all right,no problem. No big deal. I had a tiring day yesterday and maybe I just reacted too much.
 
Last edited:
If this is how it is seen,and not about people,environment, sharing resources and life in this earth, then we have misunderstandings.
I care about all of these, as well. It is one planet, and we need to take care of it. As I said, I think there is great potential in the use of solar power.
Natural gas has been a phenomenal part of our energy mix, as it is clean burning and plentiful.
But solar power is not developed enough to bring third world countries up out of poverty. That still takes fossil fuels, including oil, gas, and coal.
If we care about people, those sources of emery are still critical, and will be for the foreseeable future.
It isn t a political issue as from the people,the books,the authorities,the representatives from alternative energy resources,local and foreign and authors I have had the pleasure to listen to and/ or meet.
Good. I take it they are not talking about carbon offsets, the Paris Accord, and the like, since those are political.
It is all right,no problem. No big deal. I had a tiring day yesterday and maybe I just reacted too much.
No problem.

Jon
 
If this is how it is seen,and not about people,environment, sharing resources and life in this earth, then we have misunderstandings.
In the US, the environmental movement seems to be focused 100% on stopping the use of carbon fuels. And if you disagree with that, you are a ‘science denier’. This all or nothing approach is confrontational and takes the focus off all the other things we could be doing to improve the environment.
 
Last edited:
40.png
graciew:
If this is how it is seen,and not about people,environment, sharing resources and life in this earth, then we have misunderstandings.
In the US the environmental movement seems to be focused 100% on stopping the use of carbon fuels. And if you disagree with that, you are a ‘science denier’. This all or nothing approach is confrontational and takes the focus off all the other things we could be doing to improve the environment.
This is a gross mischaracterization of the environmental movement (actually, movements), and as such a straw man argument.
 
This is a gross mischaracterization of the environmental movement (actually, movements), and as such a straw man argument.
No it’s not.
You are in denial if you don’t see what I said to represent the mainstream media push on environmentalism.

I’m not talking about individual environmentalists toiling away in obscurity, in their area of expertise.
 
40.png
LeafByNiggle:
This is a gross mischaracterization of the environmental movement (actually, movements), and as such a straw man argument.
No it’s not.
You are in denial if you don’t see what I said to represent the mainstream media push on environmentalism.

I’m not talking about individual environmentalists toiling away in obscurity, in their area of expertise.
Neither am I. I am talking about very public movements - for clean water in Flint, MI and elsewhere. For preserving the Everglades in Florida. For recycling materials. For protecting endangered species. For preventing the spread of invasive species. For keeping poisonous discharge out of our waterways. For preserving natural areas and habitat. Just look at this list of environmental organizations and their areas of concern. You will see that most of their areas of concern are quite specific and do not focus only on stopping the use of carbon fuels, which only a part of the environmental movement.
 
Last edited:
Flint wasn’t about the environmental movement, it was about politics and local inept governance of their utilities.

Here are some book reviews where the authors seem to concur with my point, that the focus on carbon is sucking the oxygen out of the room about other environmental issues.

Authors take the environmental movement to task | Earthbeat | National Catholic Reporter
Only one of these authors says anything like what you said, and even he only said (according to the review):

“in its exclusive focus on carbon and climate change”

which is not as strong as your claim. In general, these are authors who chose to write about something other than stopping carbon fuels, which is more supportive of my point than yours, as it shows that there is a lot going on in environmentalism besides stopping carbon fuels.
 
Read the reviews again

Berry: To the global climate change movement, he recommends turning its focus away from big marches and policy work and look instead toward “good work.”

Kingsnorth: Like Berry, Kingsnorth worries that in its exclusive focus on carbon and climate change, the environmental movement has lost its way.

Simpson isn’t specific, but stresses a shift away from policy and science towards spiritual. So two out of three are explicit in concurring with what I said. The third is vague, from the review.
 
Read the reviews again

Berry: To the global climate change movement, he recommends turning its focus away from big marches and policy work and look instead toward “good work.”

Kingsnorth: Like Berry, Kingsnorth worries that in its exclusive focus on carbon and climate change, the environmental movement has lost its way.

Simpson isn’t specific, but stresses a shift away from policy and science towards spiritual. So two out of three are explicit in concurring with what I said. The third is vague, from the review.
“Big marches and policy work” is not the same thing as “100% focused on stopping carbon fuels”. So only one out of three explicitly mentions excessive emphasis on carbon. And depending on the reviewer’s accuracy, I’m not sure the author would put it in quite that way either.

Wouldn’t you consider lowering your “100%” assessment to something like “70%”? That might be more in keeping with my impression of which aspects of environmentalism are in the news these days. (Not all climate change stories are about stopping carbon fuels.)
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top