Could you REALLY convince me?

  • Thread starter Thread starter M31
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It seems that you want to not believe in God. And if there is a God, you want to blame him for the troubles in your life. I’m sorry. You can’t blame God for the terrible things in life. Rain falls on the good and the bad. Bad things will happen to the christian and the atheist. Suffering is used to help bring us closer to Christ who brutally died on the cross and it helps us to show that we are commited to him in the good and the bad. How selfish is it if we who say that we love him turn on him in any sign of trouble. Suffering helps us to show God that our love is true love. Would you want a spouse who will ditch you at the first sign of financial trouble? So, God, who wants to be even closer than us than spouses, would want someone who will stay with him throughout everything.
It may seem that way but I dont want it to.

Look, I’m trying to find truth…in-your-face truth and sometimes the only way to do that is ask questions, be skeptical, even tick-off the Christian (not intentionally though), and to test everything!

For example, I was introduced to metaphysics last year by a friend. I was skeptical. But I thought I try it. My friend got interesting "results"but I didn’t. I told myself maybe I’m doing something wrong. I later got better “results”…or did I? it wasn’t until I gave up and told my friend it’s not true. I was right.

I can now conclude that metaphysics is nothing but “wishful thinking with fake answers” if that made sense. If metaphysics were real and truth, I’d be a happier person. Hey, at least I tried. Testing is what it is. Again, skeptical.

I was told it’s healthy to be skeptical and question everything.

Now with God, I’m not sure. Either God exists or he doesn’t. I was toldeither you hate God for letting you exist in this dumb world, OR, you hate humanity for making-up God in their puny minds and what they say is false. You decide!

So it must be one or the other. Cant be both.

Now I’m left with a hard choice: either God exists and doesn’t care, OR, humanity made him up with interesting “traits” (loving, kind, gentle, just, etc.) that are not shown on this planet.

Both can be viewed as true or false…BUT both cannot be true. Contradictions are pathetic and possible lies.

Now can you see where I’m REALLY coming from?

As far as I observed, we live in an indifferent universe and that is NOT my pessimistic opinion.

It’s what I observe.
 
So if God is powerful, he could eliminate all atheists, right? He’s powerful enough to convert me to a Catholic in 5 minutes if he wanted to, right? If he’s really powerful, why all the contradictions in religions?

Just how powerful is God?
Those questions of yours are so familiar to me. I wasn’t an atheist but kinda - whatever. God won’t make you convert. Why would He? You have free will. You will make your own personal choices. But, if you are really, really lucky, you will feel God’s grace. It is awesome and I thank God every single day that He made me Catholic. (Easter vigil 2008)

But, don’t forget Pascal’s wager. ask.com/wiki/Pascal’s_Wager

Pascal’s Wager (or Pascal’s Gambit) is a suggestion posed by the French philosopher, mathematician, and physicist Blaise Pascal that even if the existence of God cannot be determined through reason, a rational person should wager as though God exists, because living life accordingly has everything to gain, and nothing to lose. Pascal formulated his suggestion uniquely on the God of Jesus Christ as implied by the greater context of his Pensées, a posthumously published collection of notes made by Pascal in his last years as he worked on a treatise on Christian apologetics. The Wager was set out in note 233 of this work.
Following his argument establishing the Wager, Pascal addressed the possibility that some people may not be willing to sincerely believe in God even after acknowledging the enormous benefit of betting in favor of God’s existence. In this case, he advises them to live as though they had faith, which may subvert their irrational passions and lead them to genuine belief.

These also might interest you.

conversiondiary.com/2008/01/from-atheism-to-christianity-conversion.html

conversiondiary.com/2007/10/why-im-catholic.html

These are posts written by Jennifer Fulwiler who was an atheist her entire life. She didn’t lose her faith, she never had one. She was raised as an atheist.

There used to be a link to her original blog when she first started her search. But I haven’t found it.

I hope you find these at least thought-provoking.
 
Perhaps you should visit with a priest about the troubles in your life for which you blame God.
 
The type of world that you are asking for God has created and it’s called heaven. God created this world on earth too but as a poster mentioned above Adam and Eve’s sin ruined it.

The way that we can know that God exists is by looking at Jesus Christ and on purely philosophical grounds we can know by looking at St. Thomas’ proofs. God is not the just the best but the ONLY explanation for 1. Existence 2. Efficiency 3. Contigency 4. Value 5. Design that exist throughout the universe
 
conversiondiary.com/2008/01/from-atheism-to-christianity-conversion.html

conversiondiary.com/2007/10/why-im-catholic.html

These are posts written by Jennifer Fulwiler who was an atheist her entire life. She didn’t lose her faith, she never had one. She was raised as an atheist.

There used to be a link to her original blog when she first started her search. But I haven’t found it.

I hope you find these at least thought-provoking.
Her original blog was The Reluctant Atheist and can be found here: thereluctantatheist.blogspot.com/
 
So if God is powerful, he could eliminate all atheists, right?
What would His reason to do so be?
He’s powerful enough to convert me to a Catholic in 5 minutes if he wanted to, right?
Why would he violate your free will to do so?
If he’s really powerful, why all the contradictions in religions?
Invalid logic. Also there are no contradictions in the teachings of Catholism.
Just how powerful is God?
Omnipotent (All powerful)
 
Now I’m left with a hard choice: either God exists and doesn’t care, OR, humanity made him up with interesting “traits” (loving, kind, gentle, just, etc.) that are not shown on this planet.

Both can be viewed as true or false…BUT both cannot be true. Contradictions are pathetic and possible lies.

Now can you see where I’m REALLY coming from?

As far as I observed, we live in an indifferent universe and that is NOT my pessimistic opinion.

It’s what I observe.
If God was just a projection of our traits, wouldn’t he resemble us better? We wouldn’t make a God contrary to our instincts. Wouldn’t he be a God of noise and signs like humanity wants and like the out-going prophets who would have invented him instead of a God who is in the silence. Wouldn’t he represent a more sex crazed humanity instead of the thou shalt not commit adultery. He would resemble the pagan gods better. He would be like Zeus who viewed humanity as nothing and only came down to Earth to have an affair. So you can not try and pin the Judeo-Christian God as just a projection of humanity.

Once again though, you seem to be deliberately leaving out what we believe to be the truth. That maybe just maybe, this God loves us. That maybe he gave us free will and thats why he doesn’t interfere and in your view, doesn’t care. This universe isn’t perfect. It’s set up to where rain falls on the good and the bad. Our goal is to go through whatever and don’t yell out in anger and turn to the hatred you refer to. You know your life could be a lot worse. You could be paralyzed. You could be deaf, blind, and mute. You could be brain dead. In the words of Job, the Lord has given and the Lord has taken away, may the name of the Lord be praised. The book of Job is specifically there to show that we should not question why suffering comes our way. Because that suffering can make us better if we don’t mope but turn to the Lord. You know excercising is hard. But the pain helps to make you stronger. It is through your hard work and endurance during this that makes you stronger. If you despair and give up then you will get no where. Our suffering does the same thing. It trains our will and our soul to have obedience and trust. Suffering helps. Can you be good at anything without sacrifice and suffering?

You know that the whole goal of all this is for God to become one with us. In the beginning this was a lot easier for us to do, but humanity decided to sin. So, now we need to seek forgiveness and to make up for what we did. We are like a lover who spat in his face. Now we have to come back humbly asking forgiveness doing our best to show we love him. He isn’t a man in the sky, he is like a spouse who wants us to join in the love that He sends out. He wants us to join Him and Christ in the eternal love they share. It is this uncontrollable bliss that God has prepared us for. However, he gives us the choice to love him or hate him. He loves us enough to let us choose. He wouldn’t want to force us into something we wouldn’t want. So, He lets us decide if we indeed love him or hate him, if we accept his offer or if we once again spit in his face.
 
It may seem that way but I dont want it to.

**Look, I’m trying to find truth…in-your-face truth and sometimes the only way to do that is ask questions, be skeptical, even tick-off the Christian (not intentionally though), and to test everything!**Now can you see where I’m REALLY coming from?

As far as I observed, we live in an indifferent universe and that is NOT my pessimistic opinion.

It’s what I observe.
There is a way…if you are willing to. I came across this reading a book. The author was a skeptic till he experienced what he wrote about.

The book is The Rite, by Matt Baglio.
 
I know that! One time I was leaving the bank when it started to hail severely. When I ran to my car, I got hit by those stupid balls of ice and it hurt. But nature didn’t care. It didn’t matter if I got a little hurt or not because nature doesn’t understand the human concept of “suffering”.

So if God created the laws of nature - and since nature doesn’t care - then that must mean God doesn’t care, right? Don’t forget tornadoes!

So why would God’s laws of nature hurt humanity?
Did someone/thing MAKE you run to your car? Where you already on route, when out of the clear blue sky these golf balls came hurling at your head? Was there zero shelter for you to seek? No one opened their car door, and yelled for you to jump in? No other doorway to step into? Or did you choose to venture out in bad weather? Did you choose to be there? Or did God make you? How do you know that a tiny little child hadn’t JUST MADE it into his house before the storm started. Or that a funeral was not allowed to finish, casket lowered and people back in their cars before this storm. There’s really A LOT going on in the world. Does it have to be about YOU all the time? and YOUR good experiences? Obviously, this did not kill you. Now, I’m not sure why we have to have golf ball sized hail… But it’s got to rain, we have to have sun, and nightfall. We couldn’t grow food without these conditions… etc.

It’s funny you mention golf ball sized hail. I can think of 2 stories involving this stuff. 1) was my mother as a teen. She was staying with her father in a huge house. That had a LONG driveway. Her school bus dropped her at the end of the drive way, and sure as heck, that kind of hail came pummeling down. She held her books over her head, and ran like a mad woman. All the while her step mother screaming from the front door for her to RUUUUUNNNNN! She was bruised a bit. But to this day… she’s always kind of WOW, you should have seen it. Those things are AMAZING. You’ve never seen anything like it. Like she witnessed something incredible and breathtaking. She smiles when she tells that story. And story #2) My DH’s grandfather lived in OK. They get those huge storms… They had one a few years back so big, that many roofs had to be repaired. Almost seemed to build the community a bit. Everyone out talking to each other. Did you get hit bad enough to need repair? Helping each other. But you know what he did? He went out and collected a pie tin full of those hail balls. And he put them in the freezer. We went to visit shortly thereafter. And he pulled them out for our boys to see. Who knows if they will ever see that kind of hail in their lifetime. I’m 40 have never witnessed it. Been through some HUGE earthquakes however. Our kids went nutz! They were so impressed. And this will forever be their last time with their great grandfather. As he has since passed. And that was their last time with him. Their last 30 minutes in fact. So, you see. Your pain the face… our forever memory with someone we loved dearly…

I’m not an expert on tornadoes. But I’m going to GUESS that tornadoes, say in “tornadoe alley”… where happening WAY before people decided to build there. Who MADE people build where tornadoes are known to happen?

Would you choose the base of an active volcano to build your home? Why not? If you choose to do so anyway, whose fault is it when the top blows and you die? Yours? Or God’s.

Why on earth would a country like Japan, for example, that has been shaking for as long as anyone can remember build nuclear power plants, probably ON TOP of known fault lines, and THEN not keep them up to code. It’s not a matter of IF a big enough quake will come along it’s WHEN?

Free will! Free Will! Free Will! I have free will, and you have free will… Now some other guy with free will can really mess up your life, when he decides to freely pull out a gun and shoot you in the head. It may be that you’re done on this earth by God’s clock, and you go home. It could be that many of us will learn from hearing about some guy shot in the head, leaving behind a wife and children. And our hearts go out to her and the children. We learn to be better people through your tragedy? Maybe??? Or maybe God has other plans for you, and he guides a bullet through your brain in a way that allows you to live. It could happen. Not likely. SOOOOOO Not likely that most would call that a “miracle”. We hear of people surviving things that scientifically they should not have…

I think God has a plan for each of us. I suspect it’s the way that each actor in a play is important, including the people you never see behind the scenes… We each have a role to fill. Big or small. Your life and existance matters to someone, somehow. Whether you realize it or not. Whether the entire world realizes it, or it’s just your mother, or wife. Or some guy you happened to smile at while passing by. The question seems to lie in the fact that sometimes we don’t have a clue why we’re here or what we’re doing about it.

I personally have experienced things that can not be explained. That quite honestly, to NOT believe in God brings me to the impossability of the things I’ve experienced.

I’ve read of things that can NOT be explained otherwise. Padre Pio’s story is amazing. Google stories about him and military bombers. Their stories are INSANE without the reality of God.

We as human’s seem to be designed to question. It’s good that you have questions, and that you keep tossing out more questions. It’s a clear indicator that we do not have ALL the answers. NO ONE does. I think that God is so huge, that we’ve developed entire careers out of the chase for knowledge of Him. I think many think we’re too smart to think that’s the REAL chase… So we call these people scientists, and such. We are all in search of some truth. We’d like to hold it in our hand. I just think God is way to big for that…
 
What would His reason to do so be?

Why would he violate your free will to do so?

Invalid logic. Also there are no contradictions in the teachings of Catholism.

Omnipotent (All powerful)
Free will. Free will.

That’s the #1 thing in religion. That’s what it all comes down to. Judaism and Christianity talk about it a lot.

Well, God must hate atheists since they dont believe in him. Didnt Jesus say that those who dont believe will be condemned to hell? I’ll admit, that’s not love.

Maybe that’s one of the reasons why I can’t accept this kind of “God”.
 
If God was just a projection of our traits, wouldn’t he resemble us better? We wouldn’t make a God contrary to our instincts. Wouldn’t he be a God of noise and signs like humanity wants and like the out-going prophets who would have invented him instead of a God who is in the silence. Wouldn’t he represent a more sex crazed humanity instead of the thou shalt not commit adultery. He would resemble the pagan gods better. He would be like Zeus who viewed humanity as nothing and only came down to Earth to have an affair. So you can not try and pin the Judeo-Christian God as just a projection of humanity.

Once again though, you seem to be deliberately leaving out what we believe to be the truth. That maybe just maybe, this God loves us. That maybe he gave us free will and thats why he doesn’t interfere and in your view, doesn’t care. This universe isn’t perfect. It’s set up to where rain falls on the good and the bad. Our goal is to go through whatever and don’t yell out in anger and turn to the hatred you refer to. You know your life could be a lot worse. You could be paralyzed. You could be deaf, blind, and mute. You could be brain dead. In the words of Job, the Lord has given and the Lord has taken away, may the name of the Lord be praised. The book of Job is specifically there to show that we should not question why suffering comes our way. Because that suffering can make us better if we don’t mope but turn to the Lord. You know excercising is hard. But the pain helps to make you stronger. It is through your hard work and endurance during this that makes you stronger. If you despair and give up then you will get no where. Our suffering does the same thing. It trains our will and our soul to have obedience and trust. Suffering helps. Can you be good at anything without sacrifice and suffering?

You know that the whole goal of all this is for God to become one with us. In the beginning this was a lot easier for us to do, but humanity decided to sin. So, now we need to seek forgiveness and to make up for what we did. We are like a lover who spat in his face. Now we have to come back humbly asking forgiveness doing our best to show we love him. He isn’t a man in the sky, he is like a spouse who wants us to join in the love that He sends out. He wants us to join Him and Christ in the eternal love they share. It is this uncontrollable bliss that God has prepared us for. However, he gives us the choice to love him or hate him. He loves us enough to let us choose. He wouldn’t want to force us into something we wouldn’t want. So, He lets us decide if we indeed love him or hate him, if we accept his offer or if we once again spit in his face.
Again, how can God be love when he threatens folks will burn in hell?

I dont know about you but I take threats as people who hates. A terrorist that threatens to blow up people is viewed as hate, a threat to do this, do that, etc. it’s nothing to be joking about either.

So when God threats, a red flag goes up.

I view threats as evil.

Did you know I hate evil? I try to stay away from it.
:eek:
 
I didn’t read all of the posts so please forgive me if I have repeated something someone else already stated. Also I would like to add that the following are my personal beliefs and not necessarily the Catholic Church’s teachings. I am still learning myself so basically I am saying any error in the following is my own.

First of all, why do I believe? You’ll think I nuts. But because I have seen the difference. I have been atheist and agnostic and deeply religious. I have seen the difference in my attitude when I attend Church. I also have seen the difference in how people have acted around me and just plain random situations. I believe everyone that truly believes God has a miracle or an answer prayer that they can’t fully explain but it seems awfully suspicious that it had been fulfilled after we asked God for help. Of course, we don’t generally talk about it because other people will say it is random luck or some such thing and while we acknowledge it could be random luck…we just don’t believe that is the answer.

Why does evil exist? Now this is where I differ from most Catholics and Christians. I don’t believe evil is the opposite of God. I believe evil exist so we can become stronger people and can become what God intends us. Is it fair? Nope! But so what…if it makes us the best people we can be so much the better!

God didn’t create us so he could create the perfect society. He created us to love.

I’ll give you the same challenge I gave a good agnostic friend of mine. Attend Mass for a year. Read everything you can about the Church and her teachings because I promise you you do not know enough. (I don’t know enough and I was raised in the Church and I am an avid reader) If after a year you don’t find anything that makes you want to learn more…then at least you can say you gave it a fair shake. But you really won’t get an answer from listening to our stories…you have to sit in the pew and find your own story.
 
Perhaps you should visit with a priest about the troubles in your life for which you blame God.
I did not see any blaming of any God, let alone yours that was the root or cause of the reason for seeking here. Did you?
 
I’ll start off with some Aquinas theology:
The First Way: Argument from Motion
Our senses prove that some things are in motion.
Things move when potential motion becomes actual motion.
Only an actual motion can convert a potential motion into an actual motion.
Nothing can be at once in both actuality and potentiality in the same respect (i.e., if both actual and potential, it is actual in one respect and potential in another).
Therefore nothing can move itself.
Therefore each thing in motion is moved by something else.
The sequence of motion cannot extend ad infinitum.
Therefore it is necessary to arrive at a first mover, put in motion by no other; and this everyone understands to be God.

The Second Way: Argument from Efficient Causes
We perceive a series of efficient causes of things in the world.
Nothing exists prior to itself.
Therefore nothing is the efficient cause of itself.
If a previous efficient cause does not exist, neither does the thing that results.
Therefore if the first thing in a series does not exist, nothing in the series exists.
The series of efficient causes cannot extend ad infinitum into the past, for then there would be no things existing now.
Therefore it is necessary to admit a first efficient cause, to which everyone gives the name of God.

The Third Way: Argument from Possibility and Necessity (Reductio argument)
We find in nature things that are possible to be and not to be, that come into being and go out of being i.e., contingent beings.
Assume that every being is a contingent being.
For each contingent being, there is a time it does not exist.
Therefore it is impossible for these always to exist.
Therefore there could have been a time when no things existed.
Therefore at that time there would have been nothing to bring the currently existing contingent beings into existence.
Therefore, nothing would be in existence now.
We have reached an absurd result from assuming that every being is a contingent being.
Therefore not every being is a contingent being.
Therefore some being exists of its own necessity, and does not receive its existence from another being, but rather causes them. This all men speak of as God.

The Fourth Way: Argument from Gradation of Being
There is a gradation to be found in things: some are better or worse than others.
Predications of degree require reference to the “uttermost” case (e.g., a thing is said to be hotter according as it more nearly resembles that which is hottest).
The maximum in any genus is the cause of all in that genus.
Therefore there must also be something which is to all beings the cause of their being, goodness, and every other perfection; and this we call God.

The Fifth Way: Argument from Design
We see that natural bodies work toward some goal, and do not do so by chance.
Most natural things lack knowledge.
But as an arrow reaches its target because it is directed by an archer, what lacks intelligence achieves goals by being directed by something intelligence.
Therefore some intelligent being exists by whom all natural things are directed to their end; and this being we call God.

And springing from that, things do not exist by necessity. In fact, existence does not “exist” by necessity. It’s an action of the will, by the will, due to motive. This “will-er” is who we call God.
Thank you very much for your post! You provided an excellent language bridge for me to understand the Summa! I hope your day is better than normal for you have made my day better!
 
What’s with the :confused: :confused: ?

I’m asking a question, in plain English, so why can’t you answer it? Forget my randomness…just answer the question please.
Ok. It seems you are looking to God to make or force you into believing Him. Yet, you continue to resist Him. that is why is confusing to me.
 
You know… I think the problem is… You want God to be as YOU define Him.

You can only accept God for your definition… The way you are writing, is that you somehow are more compassionate than God. You have a better idea than God.

Yet, at the same time you say you don’t understand. So how can it be that you can not accept something you don’t understand. If you don’t understand it? How can you form a complete opinion? Do you perfectly understand the theory of realativity? Can you perfectly explain it? So that all can understand? Because I know I can read about it over and over again, and “not get” all the concepts… but that doesn’t mean it’s not real.

I mean, I get, based on what you do understand you don’t like the idea. My kids don’t like the idea they can’t eat ice cream for breakfast lunch and dinner. The fact that I can’t make their life seemingly grand with such a choice seems rather mean. I’m hopefully bringing them into a healthy adulthood. God does the same with us. He’s raising us into a perfected heaven. But we’ve got to mind… and say we’re sorry when we blow it. And try harder next time. Just like we don’t expect perfection from our children. We keep at them.

My FIL tells me time and time again he does not want into the heaven I want to go to. His specific reason: Did you know that Ted Bundy asked for forgiveness and it was given to him? I don’t want into a heaven that would let him in. See, he thinks a lot like you. There’s something greater than us, but he can’t figure it’s the God we discuss, because the God we discuss does stupid things… Like let Ted Bundy into heaven. Where as I’m thinking, HOPING… Man, if Ted Bundy can get in… I have a pretty good chance. I just have to work hard…

But further with regards to my FIL’s thought process, I think… Well, was Ted Bundy truly sorry? Only God would know that. The God we Catholics are talking about… would Say, Ted, I know in your heart of hearts you are either 1)not sorry, you’re a big faker, nice show down there…and there is no way to hide that… You may now go to the place you CHOSE by way of your heart and actions… or 2) Ted, I can tell how sorry you are… blah, blah, blah… Come home my child…

Have you ever done something that you are truly sorry for? Something that makes you a little sick to your stomach? Or do you know someone who has? Let’s say a man cheats on his wife. He knows it was stupid, hurtful, and he can’t believe he did such a thing. What are her options? Kicking him to the curb? Or letting him back in, in the hopes that he will not stray again? Giving him a 2nd chance… a 3rd chance a 10th chance? How would you advise your sister on this? How would you advise God? 'Cause he does this you have infinate chances to get it right… He gives you the chance to apologize. You have your entire existance to show God you are worthy of his relationship and love. Would you extend the same to your spouse? Even if she’s a repeat offender? Bringing you diseases? Showing your children she has no respect for you? Are you really so God like? We can try to be. But let’s face it. On earth, we’d call you stupid after so many repeat offenses. We’d call you a door mat.

See, you can’t trick God. God KNOWS what’s in your heart. He knows your true self. He knows you better than YOU do. He knows exactly what you’re going to do from today until the moment you die. He’s not controlling you. He just knows, because he is that much greater than you. Like WE KNOW, for the most part, if it’s going to rain by tomorrow. We can’t control that. But we know… We have enough information to figure that out ahead of time.

We children of the earth, IMO, are like the have nots that can have it all if we choose. If we work hard. If we don’t feel sorry for ourselves when the going gets tough… we can keep plugging along and make it. We’ve seen many people do that.

In a spiritual world, we are shown what we can have (heaven, unconditional love) it all. But we have to follow the rules. We have to earn it so to speak. Just like our own children. We give them as many opportunities as we can afford them. But what do you do with the child who chooses the route of wild life, and drugs and stealing… Do you enable them? Do you give them every opportunity to get better, do better? Do you quit loving them, in the middle of all your pain watching them destroy their lives? Do you keep bringing them into your home, so they can steal from you, endanger lives in the house perhaps? A human is likely to say, enough is enough… God, however reads that person’s heart. God recognizes that person may no longer even be able to make a good decision, and forgives. Or God can see that person is pure hate. Has chosen to hate… has decided that God’s love is not for him/her and therefore chooses to seperate himself from God as well as his human family.

God created angels, in all their perfection straight into heaven. Some decided heaven wasn’t all that it’s cracked up to be… They wanted to be in charge. That’s a choice. They could not appreciate really just how spoiled with love and perfection they were.

You are designed to seek God. That’s why you’re hear. You have an emptiness that you can’t define. IMO an athiest no longer feels that emptiness. In the way a drunk no longer feels their emotional pain. They seek to numb it. Some athiests have chosen this path. They deliberately switched off. Some athiests were raised to be athiests. Like a child born to a drunk. They have no choice in the matter of damage done to them. IMO, this person can still be saved. Many of their choices have been removed from them. HOWEVER, should they search for whatever reason, and come to the truth… as I said earlier. I believe God allows the defense of ignorance. But NOT blatant disregard.
 
God doesn’t threaten anybody with hell. He desires that all people are saved. What He does is respect our free choice to go to Hell, if that is what we choose to do.

Do you think a just God would force someone to love Him against their will?

Again, I really encourage you to read both Mere Christianity and The Problem of Pain… Lewis addresses everything you’ve brought up and so much more.
 
I guess it’s time for my next question.z

Should I post it here or start a new thread?
 
God doesn’t threaten anybody with hell. He desires that all people are saved. What He does is respect our free choice to go to Hell, if that is what we choose to do.

Do you think a just God would force someone to love Him against their will?

Again, I really encourage you to read both Mere Christianity and The Problem of Pain… Lewis addresses everything you’ve brought up and so much more.
So if someone purposely rejects the concept of God, then they go to hell?

I dont understand why you guys would believe in the concept of hell. We already live in hell in a way on this very planet. Why would you want to believe a place even worse is awaiting us?!?

We dont even know for sure if God exists!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top